In the Dark

by Autumn_Wind

Rating: everyone
Tags: Adventure
Length: 2390

A new colt is stealing away Sweetie Belle's friends. What is he hiding? Sweetie Belle wants answers

After a new colt named shows up at school, the Cutie Mark Crusaders find that he too is a blank flank. They invite him to join as an official member. Sweetie Belle then finds him slowly stealing away Applebloom and Scootaloo. What secrets could he be hiding? Are the Cutie Mark Crusaders' friendships on the line? Sweetie Belle demands answers. Following them closely, she must find out what's really going on between the mysterious colt and her friends.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2012-12-05 01:40:50 UTC

The Search

It was one of those mornings. The kind Sweetie Belle hated. Her mom forgot to get her favorite cereal from the store. Sweetie Belle was forced to eat waffles, which she had to make because both her parents were busy doing boring adult things. She was glad there was one frozen waffle in her freezer, but even that came out of the toaster nearly blackened. The orange juice was on the highest shelf in the fridge and being the small filly that she was, she couldn't reach it. "Just my luck," she said aloud. After some quick thinking, she grabbed a chair and climbed on it. With a sigh, she poured her orange juice into a glass, and sat down to an empty table. Unsurprisingly, her waffle was a crunchy, tasteless thing. She barely managed to choke it down. Quickly, Sweetie Belle packed her saddlebag and left for school. It was the thing she looked forward to most.

The path to school was laden with mud due to last night's rain. Sweetie Belle trotted along it deep in thought, just as she always was when walking to school.

When she arrived at school, she was surprised to find a new student among the so many already familiar faces. But there was something odd about him. Sweetie Belle searched for the colt's cutie mark, but was surprised to find it blank. She was excited at the thought that The Cutie Mark Crusaders, would soon have a new member. Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon were already teasing him about his blank flank. "Sweetie Belle," said Applebloom. "Heard anything bout' the new blank flank?"

"Nope," mumbled a distracted Sweetie Belle. Sweetie Belle was too focused on the colt's reaction to the teasing to really pay attention to what her friend had just said. The colt didn't seem bothered by it all that much, but Sweetie Belle could tell he was faking it.

"Hey, where's Scootaloo?" Applebloom asked, just so she could break the awkward silence between them. Turning her head away from the colt, Sweetie Belle could just make out Scootaloo on the cloudy horizon.

"Late as always," she joked, with a small grin on her face. The moment after she spoke, it was time to head into class.

"I would like to introduce our new student!" Ms. Cheerilee announced. The brown colt slowly walked to the front of the class. "His name is Cocoa Cake." Nobody gave the usual applause. The Cutie Mark Crusaders found themselves clapping for Cocoa Cake alone. A slightly disappointed Ms. Cheerilee suddenly said "Okay then class. Time to get on with our day."

Sweetie Belle couldn't help but notice how sad Cocoa Cake looked. All alone, in a place so foreign to him. She thought about what it would be like if that ever happened to her. She had always wanted to explore new places, but her home would always be here in Ponyville, where her parents, her friends, and of course, her sister lived.

Her thoughts were interrupted by the school bell, signaling that it was time to go home for the day. She hadn't paid any attention at all. "What was the homework again?" she asked Applebloom.

"We don't have any. It's Friday. Remember?" replied Applebloom. Sweetie Belle really wasn't thinking today. At least she had the weekend to look forward to. Did she? Maybe something else slipped her mind and she forgot all about it and,

"Sweetie Belle!" Both Scootaloo and Applebloom yelled at nearly the exact same time.

"Yea?" said a slightly confused Sweetie Belle.

"We were gonna ask Cocoa Cake if he wants to join the Cutie Mark Crusaders," answered Applebloom. "Where is he anyways?" Their search led them far and wide across the land called school. They looked in every corner, every crack even, but they just couldn't find him.

"Looks like we're gonna have to give it up for today," informed Scootaloo.

"Aw man! That really stinks," whimpered Applebloom.

"So, what next?" asked Sweetie Belle. She silently hoped that her friends would say that there was nothing left to do and she would get to go back to her house, but no, that's not what happened at all.

"Just kidding! Calm down Applebloom," began Scootaloo. "We still have to check the rest of Ponyville, more or less." Sweetie Belle was mad that they ignored her question.

"Where do we start?" questioned Applebloom.

"We'll start at Twilight's library, and then check the area around Sweet Apple Acres, Oh yea, we also have to search the more open area around Fluttershy's cottage."

God, help me. thought Sweetie Belle. She thought searching the school was tiring. By the time they finally came across Cocoa Cake, her legs were aching so bad she could barely stand. She had to fake a smile just so Scootaloo wouldn't bother her about being a wimp.

"Cocoa Cake?" blurted Applebloom.

"What do you want with me this time? I'm awfully tired of being teased today. If you're here to make fun of me just back off. Okay?"

"No, that's not at all what we're here for. You see we're blank flanks too. We're in a club called the Cutie Mark Crusaders." explained Scootaloo

"Mind telling me what the Cutie Mark Crusaders are?" inquired the brown colt.

"It all started when....."

Sweetie Belle just wanted this torture to end. How much more could she take? Now, right at this very moment, she wanted more than anything in the world to go home, relax on the couch, and watch some television. Although it pained her very much, she bared through the story, along with countless interruptions by Cocoa Cake.

".....That is the story of the Cutie Mark Crusaders." Finished Scootaloo.

"So, you interested in joining?" said Applebloom.

"Eh, I guess," Cocoa Cake mumbled awkwardly.

"Alright then, we'll find you again tomorrow, and we'll give you a tour of our clubhouse." cheered Scootaloo, out of breath from the terribly long story she just told.

Another search was all Sweetie Belle needed.

"I'll see you guys later. I've got to go find Rainbow Dash." blurted Scootaloo as she dashed off.

"Yeah, and I've got work to do at Sweet Apple Acres." continued Applebloom.

Ah, finally Sweetie Belle could go back to her house. This wasn't like her though. Why did she want to go home so bad? What was at her house that was so important? She didn't understand at all why she felt this way. "Cocoa Cake?" she began "I just wanted to say, I'm sorry. I feel kind of bad for you. I would never be able to take the pain of being separated from everything I ever knew. You're a lot braver than I am. My name is Sweetie Belle by the way." There was a pause. She didn't even understand why that came out of her mouth.

"Life's just so hard for me," sighed Cocoa Cake. "Anyways, thanks again for inviting me to join the Cutie Mark Crusaders. It really means a lot to me." There was another pause This time, it was a lot more awkward. "I should get going then." added Cocoa Cake.

"I'll see you around, I guess." whispered Sweetie Belle. She walked home feeling sad.

Terrible Day

".....That is the Cutie Mark Crusaders' clubhouse. Well, in a nutshell." finished Scootaloo. Sweetie Belle was just glad that they found Cocoa Cake faster this time around. "What do you say to some ice cream? It's on us."

All four of them briskly trotted down to Sugar Cube Corner. Once there, they all ordered their favorite ice cream. Sweetie Belle was last to choose. "I'll have rainbow sherbet," said Sweetie Belle.

"I'm terribly sorry, but we seem to be all out of that today, as it is very popular among fillies," began Mrs. Cake. "We do have Pineapple Paradise, a blend of pinapples and other wonderful ingredients."

Sweetie Belle hated pineapple. "No thanks." she grumbled. She shared some of Applebloom's Applelicious ice cream, but it wasn't the same. While the Cutie Mark Crusaders were eating their ice cream, they discussed what they were going to try to get their cutie marks in next.

"Well we could try...um...um...Well, what do you guys have?" inquired Scootaloo.

"I got nothing." claimed Cocoa Cake.

"Don't look at me, I don't have anything either," added Applebloom. "Sweetie Belle, you always have the best ideas for this kinda' stuff. What do ya' say we should do?"

Sweetie Belle had to think quickly. "Well, we could try interior decorating," announced Sweetie Belle. "My room isn't looking too great." Sweetie Belle kept in mind that her room would end up looking like a pile of junk after this, but it was worth it if it meant getting her cutie mark.

"What time should we meet there?" inquired Applebloom.

"How does three o'clock sound?" said Sweetie Belle.

"That sounds alright." concluded Scootaloo.

Sweetie Belle waited for her friends to show up. She had even made cookies for them, which was a terrible idea, considering that it left the oven a molten mess of dough. She tried one, but spit it it out after one bite. Hours passed. Where are they? she thought. Finally, the doorbell rang. It wasn't any of the Cutie Mark Crusaders. Instead it was..... Ms. Cheerilee?

"What are you doing here?" asked Sweetie Belle.

"Listen, I need to speak to your mother. It's about your grades."

Ms. Cheerilee walked into the house, and sat down. "Listen, Sweetie, can you give me a moment to speak with Ms. Cheerilee?" said Sweetie Belle's mom, a slight frown on her face.

"Yea, sure," muttered Sweetie Belle. She pretended to walk up the stairs. She was interested in what Ms. Cheerilee had to say. Secretly, she hid behind the wall near the door. She could just barely hear what was being said.

"Ma'am, I'm sorry, but the school years coming to an end, and your child is failing this class," confessed Ms. Cheerilee. "Either Sweetie Belle has to repeat the class, or raise her grades up tremendously."

"What? Sweetie Belle never told me she was failing," replied Sweetie Belle's mother.

"Haven't you seen the report cards? Perhaps her papers?"

"I have to say, I've seen neither of those."

"Well, now you have." Mrs. Cheerilee threw down on the table all twenty eight of the weekly tests. Her mom was forced to sort through the pile of failures. "I dug them out of the trash. Looks like someone didn't want you to find their papers. Oh, yea, and here's the report cards." On them were nearly all F's. Sweetie Belle's mother's eyes were watering.

"I just never knew about all this," Sweetie Belle's mother sobbed. Sweetie Belle was nearly crying herself. How could Ms. Cheerilee do this to her? Now her mom knew the truth. That she was a failure. On top of that, none of her friends ever showed up.

"Okay, I should get going then. Please speak to Sweetie Belle about all this," concluded Ms. Cheerillee.

Moments after Ms. Cheerilee shut the door behind her. Sweetie Belle's mother cried. "Mom? What did Ms. Cheerilee say?" asked Sweetie Belle.

"Oh, I think you know very well what she said. WHY DID YOU LIE TO ME!? Please, just tell me why."

"Listen..... Mom, I'm sorry okay? I just never wanted you to think I was a failure. There are a lot of people out there, who already think of me as a fail. It's only because I'm different. Now even my own mother knows deep down, that I'm a failure. I don't even have a cutie ma-" Totally ruining the moment, the phone rang.

"Let me get that," said her mother. "Hello? Oh, it's you Applebloom." There was a pause. "What?! that's terrible. I'll hand Sweetie Belle the phone now." Her mother placed the phone in her hand, still upset at Sweetie Belle.

"SCOOTALOO'S BEEN TERRIBLY HURT!!" wailed Applebloom

"What happened?"

With a softer voice this time, she said, "S---sh---she had a major crash coming over here. She's in the hospital. She broke her leg, and a wing too."

"So that's why you didn't come over?"

"Yea."

"I'm gonna' go visit her right now!" concluded Sweetie Belle.

"I'll see you there." said Applebloom, who then proceeded to hang the phone up.

That sucks. Sweetie Belle told herself. How many things could happen in one day? "Mom, I'm gonna go visit Scootaloo!" she hollered. She sprinted all the way to the hospital. This was no time to go slow.

Nearing the hospital, she could visibly see Scootaloo's orange shape through the window. Sweetie Belle could also see the rest of the Cutie Mark Crusaders. Inside the hospital, she found Applebloom and Cocoa Cake. They were whispering to each other. They paid no attention to Sweetie Belle at all. They were very busy with their conversation.

Sweetie Belle, not wanting to interrupt, waved desperately. "Oh! There you are!" Applebloom exclaimed.

"Actually, I was here five minutes ago," said Sweetie Belle.

"Well, Scootaloo wanted to see you," interupted Cocoa Cake. Cocoa Cake was very unkempt and looked frantic.

Sweetie Belle walked through corridor after corridor until she finally came across Scootaloo. She had her MP3 player on the nightstand, and her headphones were on her head. Upon seeing Sweetie Belle, she paused her music and removed the headphones.

"Finally, you come," Scootaloo said sarcastically. She giggled a little bit.

"How did you crash?" questioned Sweetie Belle.

"Fell over a stump. I totally ate it," Scootaloo was blushing, embarrassed.

After Scootaloo told the whole story, Sweetie Belle was forced to exit the room by a nurse watching over Scootaloo. "Goodbye!" Sweetie Belle waved. The door shut behind her. Applebloom and Cocoa Cake were still siting in the lobby. "So, how long before Scootaloo is better?" asked Sweetie Belle.

"Probably two weeks," responed Cocoa Cake.

"Two weeks? That's a long time."

"I know, it's a long time huh?"

The three remaining Cutie Mark Crusaders walked out together, leaving behind a broken Scootaloo. Applebloom and Cocoa Cake were walking ahead of Sweetie Belle. "Wait for me!" she called out, but by then, they were out of earshot. She had no choice but to walk home alone.

"Mom, I'm back," said Sweetie Belle sadly.

"Now about your grades," said her mother. Oh come on! was all Sweetie Belle said to herself.