Resolve! Let's Challenging: Six Versus One!

You look up at the sky, and take in the beautiful environment of your surroundings. Clearly, this day could not be any better. The skies were clear, free from any cloud cover, and the morning air was pristine, making it very easy to breathe. It was truly a beautiful day indeed.

And speaking of beauty, there was also quite a bit of it to be found in the mare that happened to be walking along next to you. When it came to mares, you were definitely quite fond of the one at your side, which happened to be the lemon-coloured pegasus that everypony knew as Fluttershy. In your eyes, she was most well known for her gentle demeanour, kind mannerisms, and shy behaviour that was compensated for by a plot that was nothing short of legendary.

...Scratch that last part. Anyway, the two of you had been walking alongside each other for a while, but conversation between you and her had been sparse. So, to remedy this, you attempt to speak with her once again.

“We're almost there, Fluttershy,” you say to her.

“Oh, yes, we are,” she replies in that tone you love so much. “I can see the library's front door from here. Oh, I bet Twilight will be so happy to get these books back!”

“I bet she will...” you trail off, realising that neither of you have anything interesting to say. Oh well.

A few seconds later, the two of you reach the library's entrance. Just as your hoof reaches for the doorknob, Fluttershy says something to you.

“Um... Thanks for coming with me. I... Never mind.”

“Oh, it's no problem, Fluttershy,” you answer as you open the door and look inside. “In fact, I–WHAAAA?!”

The sight before your eyes is an odd one indeed. There are five other mares in the room; one pegasus, two unicorns, two earths, all of which you can identify as Fluttershy's closest friends. All of them are readying various instruments ranging from whipped cream to hoofcuffs to Celestia knows what else. You then hear Fluttershy's normally meek voice sound out from behind you.

“Oh, gosh! That was today? I totally forgot!”

The rainbow-maned Rainbow Dash responds by saying, “Don't you worry, Fluttershy. I've got you covered!” before using her mouth to fling a strap-on in Fluttershy's general direction. She then looks angrily towards you. “As for you, blue...”

You look around and realise that you are the only other blue pony in the room, with your coat being a navy colour as opposed to Rainbow's cyan.

Rainbow Dash continues, “Now that you've found out about our secret, I can't let you leave without a challenge...”

Immediately, Pinkie Pie starts bouncing on the spot as she addresses Dash's statement. “Ooh, ooh! Are you gonna do what would we did to the last one?” she asks excitedly.

“Shh! Quiet, Pinkie. You'll ruin the surprise!” Rainbow whispers. Returning to her normal tone, she then speaks to you. “Anyway, accept my challenge, and I might let you leave unharmed. Refuse, and I'll have to punish you!”

As a fellow pegasus, you knew that Rainbow Dash was known for having quite a wild side, and that her clutches were indeed a very dangerous place to be, so any chance to escape them was an opportunity that should definitely be taken.

“...Okay. Fine, Rainbow Dash. What's the challenge?” you ask her, hoping desperately for a break.

“Heh heh heh...” She laughs menacingly as she reaches into her saddle bag, making you shiver in fear. The tension reaches a climax as her head comes out of the bag, revealing the item that she retrieved: another strap-on! Her vast experience with the apparatus in question allows her to don it quickly, and then comes the moment of truth as she announces, “I challenge you...” She then pauses for dramatic effect, drawing out your apprehension. “...to Aerial Penis Fencing!”

Everypony in the room gasps, and a few comment.

Rarity, unsurprisingly, is a bit uneasy. “P-Penis Fencing?” she cries out.

Fluttershy then jumps to your defence. “Um... For the record, I don't mind if he–”

She is then cut off by Twilight, who appears to oppose Dash's idea. “Is this really necessary?” she asks. “Because honestly, I don't see a point in all of this. I mean, we could just let him go, since your challenge was a bit, you know, random?”

“No, Twilight,” Dash counters. “These meetings were your idea. You said you wanted to experiment and try new things, and it doesn't get much more new than random!”

“Well, Rainbow, I–”

“Enough!” You interrupt them before it scales into a full argument. “As strange as it is, Rainbow Dash, I accept your challenge!”

“Hoo!” Applejack calls out from a slight distance. “Looks like we've got some fightin' spirit in this one!”

Turning your attention back to Dash, it appears that she has just lunged towards you.

“Ahh!” you scream as you fall over backwards. Apparently, Rainbow Dash had just tackled you to the ground.

“Now...” she says as her eyes look downward. “Let's see your weapon.” She taps a hoof to her chin as she looks you over. You can't help but feel embarrassed. “Hmm... It's decent, but not good enough. What do you think, Pinkie Pie?”

Pinkie then rushes over to your position to get a good look for herself. “I think she's right,” she says, causing you to feel shameful about your inadequacy. “But don't worry,” she continues, “'cos I can fix this baby up real good for you!”

Just what could she mean by that, you think to yourself, as you spot her reaching for your equipment. When contact is made, your body twitches in reaction.

“Yes! She is right!” exclaims Pinkie as she prods at you with a hoof. “You know, Dashie's a real champ when it comes to penis fencing!” She then handles you with both of her front hooves. “You can't possibly hope to beat her with this floppy-woppy thing!”

Your member reacts to the sudden attention by beginning to rise.

“Hmm... It's starting to look better now, but it needs something else... Oh!” Pinkie then whips out her tongue and gives you a solid lick, all the way from the base to the tip. “Almost there...” she says, before twirling her tongue around the edge. “...And done! Now go get her, big boy! If you're as good as you taste, then you're sure to come out on top!”

“...Just what have I gotten myself into?” you ask yourself as to fly towards Rainbow Dash, brandishing your newly forged weapon.

“Heh,” Rainbow laughs. “So you can get it up. Okay, so who's judging?”

“Right here!” Twilight says from the floor. “Should I explain the rules to the newcomer?”

“Go right ahead,” you say, because the newcomer is you.

“Okay, then,” begins Twilight. “The rules are simple. Earn a point by making solid contact with the enemy combatant. The first one to fifteen points wins the round. Try to stay in the air and stay erect, so that you won't be at a disadvantage. Got it?”

“...Got it.” You try to put on a brave face, but you feel uneasy as the word 'disadvantage' echoes through your mind. You notice that your genuine, flesh and blood penis is being pitted against Dash's synthetic attachment, and that your skill levels are inferior to hers, in both flight ability and swordsponyship.

Twlight then interrupts your inner musings by starting the match. “Okay, then. Let's get started!” she says. “Both of you move a few paces back...” You comply with the command. “...And now we're ready.”

“Round One... FIGHT!”

Dash then pelvic thrusts her way towards you. In reaction, you fly to the side, allowing your meat to turn her attack aside. A quick lunge forward allows you to land a blow somewhere near the chest area.

“Point for the challenger!” You hear beneath you.

“Challenger?” you protest. “But I'm not the one who–”

“Back to your starting positions!”

Fine.

“...Begin!”

This time, instead of charging straight for you, Dash slowly makes you way towards your position. You mirror her movement, meeting her in the centre. You strike first, aiming for her forelegs, but she moves to parry by flying upside down. Your appendages collide, and you flinch from the unexpected recoil. By the time you recover, you notice that Dash has completed a somersault, and is charging towards you, with her cock pointed straight at your head. Before you can descend to dodge the attack, it connects.

“Point for Rainbow Dash!”

As you head back to the start, you hear some of the banter from the crowd below.

“Ah, yes! There really is nothing like watching two rogues so savagely thrust their genitals into each other!” you hear Rarity say in her distinguished accent. “Am I correct, Fluttershy?”

“...Huh? Oh, yes, Rarity. It's simply wonderful...”

“...Begin!”

Some time later...

“Point for Rainbow Dash!”

You fly back to your corner after losing yet another point to Dash's superior bladework. As for the score of the competition, you had lost count a long time ago. Dash had won the first round with ease, and apparently, the match was best two out of three rounds. Your weapon had been worn down from the repeated strikes, and was starting to hurt quite a bit. There was also almost no time to rest, with there only being a short break in between rounds, so the match was like some sort of endurance test. You weren't sure if you could continue for much longer.

“Begin!”

Both of you fly forward to meet in the centre once again. After hesitating for a split second, you thrust forward, hoping to connect somewhere. To your surprise, Dash had done the exact same, causing your extended penises to tangle with each other. It was as if you had been put in some kind of hold. Then, you notice that Rainbow Dash is staring into your eyes with a sort of seductive look: eyes half closed, and a sexy smile. You gaze back at her, and to your surprise, her lips meet yours in a passionate kiss. She leaves you with some tongue, and strokes your shoulder with her hoof, leaving you in a world of your own. She then rears back, and spins towards you, smacking you across the face with her strap-on.

“Ahh!” you scream, having been caught off guard.

“Heh heh heh...” Dash laughs at you, her sinister move having paid off.

“Point for Rainbow Dash!” Twilight announces. You are surprised, as you had forgotten that she was there. “Rainbow Dash wins Round Two!” You breathe a sigh of relief as you touch back down. Finally, you can rest your phallus. “Now to recap the scores. For Round One, fifteen to two, Dash! For Round Two, fifteen to four, Dash! Rainbow Dash wins the match, two to zero!”

No matter how bad the result, you are glad to see the ridiculous contest finally end.

“Heh...” you say to yourself. “Glad that's finally over.”

“Hold it!” exclaims your victorious opponent. “I said that if you accepted, then I might let you go.”

You gulp in fear.

“The might part depended on whether you won or lost our little match here, and since you lost, I still get to punish you.”

You let out a sigh as you accept your fate. “Okay, then, Rainbow Dash. What is it that you have in mind?”

Rainbow pauses for a moment, looks around at the company, gives a smile and a wink, then says, “You have to service all six of us.”