The Untold Tales of Ponyville

The Untold Tales of Ponyville
By Legible Audio

Part One: Shaking the Status Quo
Chapter One: Fluttershy’s Secret

Fluttershy stood in front of the Ponyville Library, hoof poised to knock on the door. Except she wasn’t knocking. In fact, she’d been standing in that exact same position for about five minutes now, perfectly petrified. Except for her hoof; that was still nervously shaking.

Come on, she thought, just one teensy little knock, then Twilight will come out and you can finally tell her how you feel.

But it took more than three whole months for you to work up the courage to walk to her house, another voice responded. How could you possibly tell her something so important and unexpected right now?

I’ve come so far, replied the first voice. I can’t just turn around now.

Okay, first of all, you’ve only walked about a mile from your house, the second voice thought dryly, and, secondly, what if she says “no”? Remember how devastated you were when Thunderlane rejected you? You never thought you’d get over him.

Yes, but I know Twilight a lot better than I ever knew him. Plus, who in their right mind could say “no” to a face like this? She smiled inwardly, feeling that her hopeful side had won.

Anyone could, if you didn't get that celery out of your teeth, the negative voice snarked.

Ohmygoodness, she thought before running her tongue over her front, top teeth. Oh no! she exclaimed internally.

See? the pessimistic side thought. You didn’t even prepare yourself properly. You should just turn around and-

No! the optimist shouted back. I’m going to do this. I have to do this! If I never know what Twilight thinks, then I’ll be asking myself “what would she have said?” for the rest of my life. I’m doing this no matter what you or anyone else wants, darn it! With that, she brought her hoof back, and, with all of her might, hit the door with a resounding... light tap.

That was it. She’d done it. Now all she had to do was wait for Twilight to open the door. And wait she did. For over a minute, she stood in front of that door waiting, but Twilight never showed.

“Oh well,” she whispered to herself. She hung her head while starting to turn away. “At least I’ll always have my animal friends...”

Suddenly, the door knob started turning as a purple aura engulfed it. Fluttershy gave a small gasp as her wings fluttered in excitement. She quickly folded them back up, in an attempt to look more relaxed just before the purple unicorn came into view.

“Well hello, Fluttershy,” Twilight said as she greeted her longtime friend.

“Oh, Twilight! So you did hear me knocking after all,” Fluttershy said, trying not to betray too much excitement.

“Uh no, actually. I just saw you standing outside awkwardly a second ago, and wondered if you wanted to come inside.”

“Oh,” Fluttershy disappointedly responded.

There was a moment of silence where Fluttershy looked down at the ground between her forehooves and Twilight’s. Meanwhile, the unicorn stared at her before looking to either side and ending the sudden pause.

“So... Would you like to come in?” Twilight asked, trying to get some sort of response from her friend.

“Oh! Of course!” the pegasus replied as she snapped back to reality. She cantered in, and Twilight closed the door behind her with magic.

Twilight led her friend farther into the main room. “I don’t mean to sound off-putting,” she said, trying to carefully choose her words, “but you just threw me off a little. Normally, ponies just walk into the library during open hours.”

Fluttershy immediately stopped in place and planted a hoof firmly on her forehead.

The negative voice suddenly came back. Great going, Fluttershy, now she thinks you’re stupid. Like I said before, this is just a waste of-

“Though I must say, it’s actually kind of nice knowing you knocked,” the purple mare interrupted her thoughts.

“Really?”

“Yeah. It’s kind of nice being reminded that this is still my place, and that I’m Ponyville’s number one librarian, instead of some mare you go to to check out books.”

Ha! You hear that, Ms. Meanie-Pants? She said that I made her feel important, so just, um, keep away - you know, if you don’t mind - because I, um, don’t need you anymore.

“So, do you want anything? I have some fried asparagus in the kitchen,” Twilight offered.

“Oh yes, please. That would be lovely.” Fluttershy didn’t usually like it when other ponies went out of their way for her, but she was never one to decline the gift of hospitality.

Twilight soon returned with the plate of asparagus and set it down on the table for them to snack on.

“So, why’d you stop on by?” Twilight asked,trying to get the conversation going.

Oh, no reason, Fluttershy thought. I just to tell you how I really feel about you.

“Oh, no reason,” she said. “I just stopped by Rarity’s and wanted to see how you were doing.”

“And how’s she doing? I’ve been doing more studying than usual lately, so I haven’t had much of a chance to talk to her for a while.”

You’re beautiful, smart, and really talented. That’s a really rare combination for anypony, mare or stallion.

“Oh, well she’s been a bit busy too, working in a new line of giant hats.”

Twilight chuckled. “Yeah, she certainly has a thing for those.”

I love you. I love you. I love you. Why am I able to say it so many times in my head, yet I can’t say it once out loud?

“So, how’s Spike doing?” Fluttershy inquired about Twilight’s loyal baby dragon friend.

“He’s been well. He’s actually out running a couple of errands, so he’ll be gone awhile.”

I mean, if I told you, then we could be dating. Then I could feel your tender lips pressed softly against mine any time I wanted...

“I see,” she said, as she took a bite of asparagus.

“So, is there anything else that you want to do while you’re here?” Twilight offered.

“We could make sweet love all night long...”

Oh, I don’t know. I guess I could look for something new to read.

Fluttershy looked up at Twilight, whose face seemed to be stuck in a visible mix of shock and confusion. The surprised pony’s mouth moved only to form two words:

“Wait, what?”

It was in that moment that Fluttershy realized what went wrong. Her eyes widened as she quickly brought her hooves to her mouth. Her wings instinctively popped up and a response to her sudden fear. Her mind could only form two words:

Oh shit.

...I mean, oh darn... I mean, oh... my.

They sat there for a short while; the air between them silent, and the asparagus growing colder.

Twilight started to smile. She’d read about this before, but had never actually seen it: a slip in one’s speech caused by loud, persistent thoughts. Observing a psychological phenomenon for the first time was only the first reason she smiled, however. The second was that she just learned that somepony liked her. Granted, it came out in probably the weirdest way possible, but, based on Fluttershy’s sudden, embarrassed reaction, it was obviously unintentional. And who better to say it than Fluttershy? Even though she wasn’t a stallion like her parents would have liked, Twilight really didn’t have a personal preference. Plus, she was the cutest pony that Twilight had ever known, both in mannerisms and looks.

Her smile deepened. “Fluttershy... Do you like me?” she asked, trying to play coy.

The pale-yellow pegasus was quiet for a few moments, making sure that the next thing she said wasn’t anywhere remotely as bad as the last. Once she was certain of herself, the floodgates opened.

“Oh my goodness Twilight I’m so sorry it’s just that um well I didn’t mean- It’s just I um when I- I mean what I meant to say was and I lost track of- that is- but I was- books- and um I um well...” She hung her head with a sigh, knowing that any plans she had of telling Twilight in normal terms were well out the window. “Yes.”

“Wow,” Twilight said as she paid attention to only the last word that Fluttershy spoke, and marveled at her situation. “Sorry, it’s just that nopony has ever told me that they liked me before. I’m really at a loss as to what I’m supposed to do.”

“So,” Fluttershy asked to confirm her suspicions for sure. “You don’t mind that I like you?”

“Oh, of course not, Fluttershy! I mean, I knew you already liked me as a friend, si it’s really not that different... Except it kinda is. But in a good way.”

By this point, Fluttershy’s heart was beating wildly, her face shone bright red, and she was trying with all her might to keep her smile from splitting it in two. It felt like a mix of ecstasy and and something somehow more euphoric was flowing through her veins.

“Oh goodness, I was so afraid that you were going to say ‘no’ that I really didn’t know if I was ever going to tell you. And, if I did, that you would think that I was weird for it and everypony would laugh at me, and I’d be forced to move into the Ever-”

“But it’s okay,” Twilight interrupted her friend, not really sure where she was going. “Because, well, I think I like you too.”

Fireworks went off inside Fluttershy’s stomach. Everything went better than she could have hoped. This was the best day of her life, and only one word could describe the was she felt:

yay.

They sat, looking into each other’s eyes and smiling from across the table. It was still the very same table upon which the asparagus was placed, the cooled snack that had long left the thoughts of the newly established lovers.

“You know,” Twilight said, “according to a few romantic stories I’ve read, I think the next thing we’re supposed to do kiss to show each other how we feel.”

“But don’t we already know how we feel?” Fluttershy asked.

“Well, yes, I guess.” Twilight tried to reason her emotions. “But all we’ve done so far is tell each other, and actions speak louder than words, so they say. I mean, I think it would be a good way to seal the deal, you know?”

“Twilight, are you nervous?” the pegasus asked. Normally, she was able to tell the subtleties of a pony’s emotions through their actions, but Twilight’s nervousness as this point might be noticed by a pony more like Applejack. Her sentences were formed as she thought, and her eyes were beginning to dart. She figured it was best to settle the issue before things got worse.

“Maybe. Maybe a little.” Twilight averted her gaze out of embarrassment. “Yes.”

Fluttershy’s eyes widened. “Have you ever kissed anypony before?”

“Well, uh...” She looked her friend in the eye. “No.”

Fluttershy was amazed at how quickly the situation had turned around. Just a few moments ago, she was the one who was so nervous and embarrassed, and now it seemed as though they’d swapped places. It was actually kind of exciting. She had never been the more experienced one in a relationship before.

Okay, Fluttershy, she thought, now it’s time to bring out your inner Rainbow Dash; it’s time for you to be the coach.

“Oh, Twilight, it’s really nothing to be worried about.” She got up and started walking toward Twilight.

“But you’re nervous, too,” the purple unicorn pointed out.

“It’s easy,” the yellow pegasus continued, now almost to Twilight. “You just ready your lips, and...”

And then they kissed. Oh, what a kiss to be remembered! It was Fluttershy’s first kiss with the mare she’d been doting on, and Twilight’s first with anypony ever. Their insides mutually melted in a swirl of euphoric emotions.

It only lasted a good five seconds, and mostly resembled a prolonged peck, but neither really seemed to mind. After, they continued to stare into each other’s eyes, both of their thoughts just incomplete blurbs as they tried to find the words to properly represent how they felt.

Twilight liked it. She wanted more. She wanted to know more about it. As per usual, she wanted to examine this phenomenon as thoroughly as possible. She wanted to delve deeper.

“That was... really something,” she remarked after a few seconds.

“Yeah,” her yellow friend replied, quietly admiring her.

“Do you want to do it again?”

“Mm-hmm.” She started to lean it, but stopped as soon as she remembered something. “Er, just a second,” she said as she turned around. After about five seconds, she finally dislodged the piece of celery from her teeth. She turned back towards Twilight, bearing a big ol’ smile that displayed as many teeth as possible.

“Okay,” she said, now more confident than ever.

They both leaned in as their lips softly smooshed together, their brains recreating the same emotions as last time. This time, however, they stayed together for more than five seconds, much more. After a while of just holding it in place, Fluttershy tilted her head to the side and slowly started opening her lips. Twilight quickly followed suit.

It felt good. So good. Everything might have ended there if Twilight didn’t get a curious little thought that suddenly popped into her head. Now, Twilight was naturally a rather curious pony, her nose always in a book, but she was still reserved enough to keep the bolder, stranger, and more impulsive thoughts inside her head. However, this kiss was awakening new sensations, and, next to alcohol, the strongest purveyor of impulse is burning desire. Her thought: Just how good can I make this feel? So she slowly, nervously started bringing her tongue forward, opened her jaw slightly, and slipped it between her teeth until it hit Fluttershy’s.

Mmm, she thought. Tastes like celery.

Fluttershy was surprised by Twilight’s brazen move, but just took it in stride and offered her tongue in return.

Together, their tongues danced in the dark of their mouths, always in supple contact with each other. Fluttershy let out a soft, purring moan as she lifted her forelegs and embraced her partner, pulling her closer.

The kiss must have lasted at least three minutes because when it broke they both gasped for air.

It was so lovely. Warm and moist. Warm and moist... Fluttershy realized that all this excitement caused these two words to also describe a certain other part of her body.

Oh goodness, she thought, I didn’t think that could happen so quickly! Oh, it’s just so overbearing. Should I ask her if she wants to, you know? Obviously, she likes me, and Spike probably still won’t be home for a while, and... I can’t really think of anything else. Well, I’ve come this far.

“So, Twilight, do you feel satisfied?” Fluttershy asked with a tone that sounded surprisingly seductive for a nervous pony. “Or do you want more?”

“Well, I’m definitely...” She trailed off in thought. Wait. I’m not, but if I say “no,” then that could either mean the kiss wasn’t enough to satisfy me, and “more” could mean getting more intense, which I would really like, or it could also mean that she doesn’t think she’s satisfying me, and I’d be telling her that she’s not good enough. And if I say “yes,” then I still don’t know what she’ll think, and I’m supposed to be good at multiple choice!

“You’re definitely what, Twilight?” Fluttershy asked, wondering why her friend was taking so long to finish.

“I definitely think you can kiss well, and that you yourself are a very satisfactory mare,” Twilight said.

“What? ...I’m just asking if you want to, um, do, you know... it?”

“‘Do it?’ Fluttershy, that could mean a lot of... Ohh. You mean have sex?”

Fluttershy nodded.

“Oh. I thought you meant, like, more intense kissing or something. Then yes, I think I’m more than ready.”

“So am I.” Fluttershy smiled and fluttered her eyelashes flirtatiously.

Twilight moved in and kissed Fluttershy, pressing a hoof against her chest, and slowly moving it up and down. Fluttershy suddenly broke off.

“What is it?” Twilight asked, wondering if she’d done something wrong.

“Well, um, don’t you think it would be better if we moved into the bedroom than stay here in the middle of the library where anypony can walk in on us?”

Twilight entertained the thought of how exciting it might be to get caught for a moment, but went against it when she considered how Fluttershy would feel in the situation.

“You’re right. Follow me,” the purple unicorn told her friend with half-lidded eyes.

Twilight led Fluttershy up the stairs. Fluttershy, gazing longingly at her soon to be lover, couldn’t help but catch a glance of Twilight’s hindquarters every time her tail swayed back and forth. The unicorn wasn’t kidding when she said she was more than ready. Her marehood looked so plump and juicy. The Fluttershy noticed the smell it gave off, and it took all of her will to not just pounce her and take her on the stairs.

They quickly arrived in the bedroom, and Fluttershy craned her neck to look at the bed at the top of another, smaller flight of stairs. She’d seen the bed quite a number of times during Twilight’s stay in Ponyville, but she’d never actually wanted to climb into it before, especially with such fervor.

They finally reached it, and Twilight stepped on first, before laying in a pose as seductively as she could manage. Fluttershy jumped and, with a flap of her wings, landed gracefully next to Twilight.

And then they kind of just stayed in place.

“Um,” Twilight started, “does either of us know what we’re supposed to do next?”

“Well,” Fluttershy said wearily, averting her gaze, “I have been with a few ponies before, but all of them were stallions, and they pretty much took control. I really don’t know what to do with another mare.”

“Yeah, in most of the books I’ve read the girl usually starts by taking the stallion’s ‘throbbing mass’ into her mouth. But neither of us has that equipment, and I’m not really sure who the girl in this situation even is.”

“Oh, I guess that would probably be me,” Fluttershy realized.

“Hmm...” Twilight pondered. “Okay, then. I guess that means you go first.” She rolled onto her back, and opened her legs widely. The scent from between the limbs now dispersed well into the air. That was it, Fluttershy couldn’t restrain herself anymore. “So, I guess you should try whatever you think would feel g-AAAH!” She was interrupted by Fluttershy’s tongue as it ran the length of her folds.

Oh Celestia, it was great. Fluttershy began lapping up her juices, and traced her slit all the way up to the clit, but never quite touching it. It was like heaven, as every stroke of the tongue sent a wave of sensation running through her whole body, and the heat in her nethers continued to grow.

It was an amazing new experience for Fluttershy, too. Though she’d never done it before, she had certainly been eaten out, and definitely knew what felt good for her. She seemed to be doing a good job. She also noted that Twi tasted like the smell of old books, and it was delicious.

After a while, Twilight couldn’t contain herself anymore and let out a long moan of pure pleasure. Fluttershy smiled just knowing that she could make a mare love her with her tongue alone. As Twilight continued to moan afterward, Fluttershy couldn’t help but reach low with her right forehoof and touch her sopping pussy just to relieve some of the pressure.

She had been avoiding Twilight’s little pleasure button so far because she didn’t want to overwhelm her, but now that her moans started sounding like a cry for more, she lifted her tongue off of the lips and gave a quick flick to Twilight’s most sensitive of areas. She screamed in both surprise and sudden pleasure. Fluttershy continued, knowing that the cry was not out of pain, and, even if it were, she wouldn’t stop because she knew that both the pain would eventually subside, and she was simply enjoying it too much.

“Oh goddesses, Fluttershy, keep doing it!” Twilight began to scream. “Oh, yes! Keep it up! I think I’m going to- I’m going to... cum?”

Fluttershy had backed off as Twilight declared her closeness.

“Fluttershy, no! Please get back down there. I need you to finish up; I was right there!” Twi tried to persuade her friend.

Fluttershy lifted her head up, and shook it. Twilight saw that her little yellow muzzle was covered with her own shimmering juices, and for some reason that stopped making her think of her as cute, and instead she now saw her as beautiful.

“I don’t think that it would be very nice of me to let you, um, climax so quickly, especially without having tried out something that’s supposed to feel even better.” She winked and Twi smiled.

Well, I wanted to know how good it could feel, the unicorn thought, and I’m damn glad I’m about to find out.

Fluttershy lay down and situated herself on her back with her honeypot facing Twilight. “Okay, I read in a book about something called scissoring, and, when two fillies do it, it’s supposed to be the most pleasurable thing they can do with each other,” she said, working her legs in conjunction with Twi’s.

“What kind of book is that?”

“Oh, I don’t think you’ll find anything like it in the public library.” Fluttershy finished setting up. “All right. Now this might feel a little strange, I don’t really know.”

She pulled Twilight closer, and, only a few minutes after they first locked lips, their others sets were as well. They reveled in that first moment, each knowing that however good she felt, the other felt just the same.

“Now what?” Twi asked, excited for what came next.

“Okay, I remember reading that we shouldn’t buck each other... with our hips, I mean. We’re already... bucking. Um, what we’re supposed to do is kind of move them back and forth and rub. Like this.” She moved her hips around and rubbed Twilight’s pussy with her own, slathering it with a new mix of both of their love juices and Fluttershy’s saliva. Twilight gave a sharp, staggered intake of breath with her wide eyes looking unfocused at the ceiling, while Fluttershy closed her eyes, bit her lip, and whimpered.

For what may have been an eternity of bliss and passion, they rubbed each other with themselves as they slowly rose to their peaks, feeling free to moan, whimper, and scream as much and as loudly as they wanted. They were oblivious to the outside world; the only thing each cared about was herself and her lover.

“Oh Celestia, Fluttershy! This is amazing! Rub faster, rub- Ohh, yes! You’re amazing Fluttershy!”

“Twilight? Twilight, I- I love you!”

“I love you, too.”

It was those very four words that boosted Fluttershy over the edge.

“Oh, Twilight! I’m cumming!”

And it was those words that tossed Twi over the brink.

“So am I!”

They braced themselves as their orgasms hit them like a wave. They screamed as their pelvises convulsed uncontrollably, and their pussy juices flowed freely. Every contracting spasm was as intense as it was euphoric. Fluttershy could do nothing to stop herself.

“Oh, fuck! Fuuuck! Fuck me! Fuck, yes! Fuuuu...”

The climaxes had soon resolved themselves, and they lay intertwined, exhausted, and fully satisfied. Eventually, Fluttershy found the energy to crawl over to Twilight’s orientation, laying her head on the pillow after kissing her partner on the brow.

“Mmm, Fluttershy?” Twi asked, relaxation evident in her voice.

“Yes, Twilight Sparkle?”

“Let’s do this again, sometime. I think I liked it.”