Secret Crush

by Trigger_Finger

Night of passion

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

Joe let out a sigh of relief, “Ahha, finally” Joe said as they put the finishing touches on the project. “Well… I hope we do okay, it isn’t all that good” Scootaloo said as she looked over the papers, though they had gotten lots of information and wrote lots of things about Star Swirl it didn’t seem all that well thought through.

“Eh, what’s the worst that could happen?” Joe laughed and Scootaloo raised an eyebrow, “He could fail us” Scootaloo replied and Joe rolled his eyes. “I suppose… who cares, it’s only one assignment” Joe said casually. Scootaloo shook her head and laughed at his relaxed state of mind, just yesterday he’d almost died, then today he worked hard for most of the day then partied and now it was one o’clock in the morning and he acted like everything was perfect.

“Joe I…” Scootaloo trailed off, even though she had made out with him earlier today she couldn’t bring herself to tell Joe how she really felt. “Yeah?” Joe asked, Scootaloo pulled all her courage up, “I love you Joe and I want to be with you forever” Scootaloo blurted out and Joe gave her a rather confused look. “Uhm… okay… I uh don’t know what to say” Joe stuttered. “Joe, do you love me or are my feelings only one way?” Scootaloo asked worriedly, Joe rubbed the back of his head.

“Well uhm this is kind of sudden” Joe said but Scootaloo shuffled over on the couch so she was right beside him and looked into his eyes. “Please Joe… just tell me if you love me or not” Scootaloo pleaded and Joe exhaled deeply, “You’re really putting me on the spot here kid, we’ve only been hanging out for a week and” Joe began but Scootaloo interrupted him. “Joe I’ve loved you ever since ninth grade and ever since I can’t stop thinking about you” Scootaloo informed him, “Uhm really?” Joe asked and Scootaloo nodded. “You never knew, you never noticed my advances?” Scootaloo asked and Joe shook his head. “Sorry kid but usually I only talked to you during dinners at the apple family house or briefly in the hallways” Joe informed her.

“You never caught on to any of my advances?” Scootaloo asked and Joe shook his head. “Well I mean if you consider when we French kissed today an advance then yes I caught on there but…” Joe trailed off. Scootaloo’s hopes were rising, ‘Maybe… just maybe, please Celestia let him say yes’ Scootaloo thought to herself. “Well… you weren’t like any of the other mares who only wanted me so they could be popular as ‘My first’ so I don’t know it’s still a little weird I mean you’re a Pegasus and I’m a human” Joe replied uneasily. “Please Joe… I need to know” she pleaded and Joe let out a large exhale, “Well if I said I didn’t have feelings for you that would be a lie… so I guess yeah I do kind of like you in that way” Joe said and Scootaloo literally lept on him in joy and full on began to kiss him again.

She pushed Joe down onto the couch and got on top of him. “Whoa, hold on… what do you think you’re doing?” Joe asked curiously and Scootaloo looked to him with a shocked look. “Well… I thought you loved me?” Scootaloo asked and Joe nodded hesitantly “Yes but…” Joe trailed off and Scootaloo’s face turned to a saddened look. “But you don’t love me in that way” she said depressingly. “Well it was a little sudden and took me by surprise… but if it’s what you want… then I guess I’ll go along with it” Joe said and shrugged.

“Joe, I don’t want to force you into anything… if you don’t want this it’s okay” Scootaloo said and Joe thought to himself. “Okay… he’s the problem I’m facing, I’ve only hung out with you for like maybe four days and now we’re about to have sex… I think… so that’s where I’m at” Joe informed her. “Joe… whatever you want, I won’t force you to do anything you don’t want to” Scootaloo told him and he nodded. “Well see that’s the thing, I’m uneasy about it but if you want to I’ll take a shot at it” he told her and her wings shot out in excitement.

She began to kiss him again and was about to pull off his shirt when he stopped again. “Is something wrong?” she asked and he nodded, “Two things actually” he informed he and Scootaloo’s mind raced with negative thoughts thinking how he didn’t want her because of her body or maybe because it was too weird.

“Okay one: I don’t want to get my couch messy and two: we’re right in front of the window so any-pony that glances in is gonna get a show” Joe told her and she took her mind off sex for a second and realized he was right, well for the second part anyway, it didn’t really matter where they had sex, they were going to make a mess somewhere.

“Well… there’s always your room” Scootaloo offered and Joe shook his head, “Yeah but then there’s the problem of my neighbour, friggin guy always has this light on at night and I never know if he is watching me or if it’s just a light he’s forgotten to turn off” he told her and Scootaloo rolled her eyes, she didn’t even bother asking about the other two rooms because they both had windows that ponies could see through from the road.

“Well there’s always the basement” Scootaloo offered and Joe sighed, “I hate the basement but alright… let’s do it” he replied then chuckled at his response. “What’s so funny?” she asked as they got off the couch and both descended down the stairs, “I said let’s do it, and we’re actually going to do it… never mind it was funnier in my thoughts” he told her and she smirked at his comment, it was kind of funny in an immature way.

Joe opened the door to the basement room, like he had said it was empty minus the bed in the middle of the room. “So uhm… how do you want to do it?” Scootaloo asked and Joe shrugged “However you want” he replied casually. ‘I can’t believe I’m actually going to have sex with Joe’ Scootaloo thought to herself as she laid down on the bed. Joe scratched his head in confusion, ‘Okay think self… you stick it in her right? Yeah sure let’s just go with that’ Joe thought to himself and crawled up on top of Scootaloo’s body, her body was nearly half his size underneath him but it didn’t bother him in the least.

Scootaloo wrapped her forelegs around Joe’s neck and the two began to French kiss again, their tongues fought passionately in their mouths but suddenly Scootaloo pulled back and gasped. Joe was taken back by her gasp “Are you okay?” he asked worriedly since he had never heard a female gasp in pleasure before. She looked to him with needy eyes. “Joe… I’ve waited for this for so long… please I need you inside of me” Scootaloo whispered. “Uhm yeah about that… uhm I don’t actually know what to do” he informed her and she looked at him then thought to herself for a second. “Really?” she asked and he shrugged “Well… I was too young for all this when I was on earth and when I came to Equestria I was never interested in ponies… well once or twice I had funny dreams about Applejack and me but I didn’t like it all that much and when we talked about it she told me it was normal for someone my age, since humans were a little like ponies in Equestria” Joe informed her.

“Well, okay you’re supposed to put your penis into me” Scootaloo informed him and he hit himself in the forehead. “Well yeah I know that but I mean how do you want me to do it, like do you want me to do it in a special way or something?” Joe asked curiously. “Just put it inside of me” Scootaloo whispered and Joe made a ridiculous gesture with his hands where he created a hole with his left hand and slid his right hand’s index finger into the hole. “Like… like that?” Joe said uneasily and Scootaloo laughed at his immaturity, or maybe it was nervousness but either way it was kind of funny. “Yes Joe, just like that” Scootaloo laughed, Joe stopped the immature gesture “Alright” he replied as he pulled off his shirt.

“No Joe… do it slowly” Scootaloo said, wanting to be like one of those crappy romance scenes like from the movies where the stallion takes his shirt off really slowly. “Oh I know what you mean… like this right?” Joe asked as he slowly began to slide his T-shirt over his head, but due to his perspiration from work the shirt was sticky with sweat and was a little tight to his body so it was hard to pull off. Scootaloo sat up and helped him remove his shirt, his chest pressed against her as she helped him and she gasped at the sudden body contact. “Gah I didn’t do it” Joe replied quickly but Scootaloo shook her head and rubbed her cheek up against his chest. “Uhm okay” Joe said uneasily, not quite sure how this all worked and how she was taking pleasure by rubbing up against his chest was beyond him.

Joe was begining to breathe a little heavier and he felt himself feel kind of strange. “What the hell” Joe muttered and Scootaloo looked up to him “What’s wrong?” she asked and he shrugged. “I don’t know, I just feel strange you know… it kind of feels… oh shit” Joe said as he realized that he was heavily aroused, sure he had a boner before but this was different somehow. Scootaloo tipped Joe’s balance and he fell softly onto his back and she got over top of him and pulled off her shirt slowly over her head just like Joe did. Joe felt really strange and he sat up and embraced his bare chest against Scootaloo’s, it was weird because back on earth people boobs were closer to their upper chest but on ponies they were closer to the lower stomach area. Scootaloo felt contempt as Joe held her closely and returned the embrace but soon her pussy became very wet and it she needed satisfaction or she’d lose control of herself.

“Joe please… I need it badly” Scootaloo moaned as she slid off her pants, “Oh my god you’re… wet” Joe exclaimed and Scootaloo rolled her eyes, he was so oblivious to the anatomy of females that she just had to laugh. Joe managed to slide his pants of while her was underneath her and his boner stretched out his boxers and it looked more like a tent rather than a pair of boxers. Scootaloo leaned forward and pushed Joe onto his back so that he lying down completely. Scootaloo took a quick moment to soak it all in, she was really about to have sex with Joe, her high school crush that she had always fantasized about. Scootaloo wiggled out of her panties and Joe followed suit by removing his boxers.

Scootaloo’s pussy clenched, she hadn’t even begun and Joe’s mere presence was driving her mad. She lowered herself down onto Joe’s manhood just enough so that its tip touched her entrance and she quivered in the sheer pleasure of it and a gasp escaped her mouth. Joe grunted, the pleasure was different to him and he actually quite enjoyed it.

She rubbed her pussy along the tip of Joe’s cock and he continued to grunt and groan in pleasure as Scootaloo teased both him and herself. “Jesus… that feels pretty damn good” Joe muttered through groans of pleasure. Scootaloo stopped rubbing herself against Joe’s manhood and lined up the tip with her entrance and began to slowly lower herself down onto him. Both Scootaloo and Joe gasped at the sudden burst of pleasure that washed through their bodies as Joe’s penis began to slide into Scootaloo’s wet pussy.

Joe’s penis twitched a little as the pleasure over whelmed him and he shuffled a little to try and slide himself into her a little more quickly but Scootaloo wouldn’t allow it and continued to slide him into her slowly but stopped as Joe’s penis touched her hymen. “Eh… hold on, I know that ponies are smaller than me but does that mean that I can’t go any further?” Joe asked and Scootaloo shook her head. “Joe… I’m a virgin, my hymen is still intact” Scootaloo whispered and Joe looked both ways in confusion. “Uhm… okay so that means…” Joe trailed off and Scootaloo lowered her head down to Joe and kissed him quickly on the mouth. “Joe… you have to take my virginity from me” Scootaloo whispered into his ear. “Well that’s a no brainer… okay explain to me how I take your virginity, I thought it was as easy as putting my penis into your vagina” Joe replied and she nodded. “Yes that’s how it works” she informed him, Joe shrugged “Okay… so aren’t I already inside you?” he asked, a little confused by the whole virgin taking thing.

“Joe… you have to go deeper inside me” Scootaloo whispered to him, Joe looked down and saw that he only had the head of his penis inside of her and figured ‘Guess that was a no-brainer to’. “Alright… so how do we do this?” Joe asked and Scootaloo took a deep breath “Joe you have to be deep inside me” she whispered and let herself slide down further, she felt Joe’s penis head break her hymen. She screamed in pain and Joe shuffled back, “What… what the hell’s going on… oh my god you’re bleeding” Joe stammered as he realized that he had blood on his penis and Scootaloo’s pussy had blood coming from it. “That’s what happens during a mare’s first time, unless I break it another way” Scootaloo whispered in pain.

“Scootaloo are you okay?” Joe asked as he pulled out of her and sat up beside her, she nodded but he could tell it still hurt a little. “I’m sorry Scootaloo I didn’t mean to hurt you” Joe apologized but she shook her hoof as a tear rolled down her face from the pain. Joe wiped the tear away. “I think I have some tissues upstairs… just hold on while I go grab them” Joe said as he got up and went upstairs.

“I know I have some tissues somewhere… ahhaha tissues” Joe chuckled, thinking about the joke where you offer a guy a tissue when he’s masturbating. Joe scratched his head as he tried to remember where the hell he had put the damned tissues. Joe smacked himself in the head as he remembered that he had put the tissues in the cupboards above the sink. As he went to grab the tissues a hoof pulled him down to the ground and Scootaloo got over top of him.

“Scootaloo… are you okay?” Joe asked and she shrugged. “It still hurts a little but Joe… I still want you inside me” Scootaloo moaned. “Okay fine but… let’s not do it in the kitchen… I just couldn’t think about my kitchen floor the same way for at least a week” he suggested. Joe looked to the stove clock and noticed it was 1:28am. ‘Shit we’re only gonna have like four hours before I gotta get ready for school, five hours if I cut my morning short’ Joe thought to himself as Scootaloo pulled him into one of the spare bedrooms.

Scootaloo flopped down onto the bed, pulling Joe down on top of her and the two began to make out again as Scootaloo slid her hooves up and down Joe’s back. For some reason Joe’s cock ached to be back inside Scootaloo’s wet pussy. He grunted as he slid his arms underneath her and shuffled his body a little so that his manhood lined up with her entrance, sort of anyway.

Scootaloo felt Joe’s penis press up against her but it missed her pussy by a few centimeters. Wrapping her hindleg around Joe’s leg she rolled their bodies like Joe had done to her one the lakeside only now they were passionately making love rather than playing around on the edge of the lake. Scootaloo lined herself up with the tip of Joe’s manhood, she lowered herself so that Joe’s penis once again rubbed up against her wet pussy entrance. The pleasure returned to her as she felt it brush up against her and she slid her needy pussy along his shaft, driving herself insane as she did it. He pussy continued to moisten further as she teased both of them. She slid her pussy down so that the tip of Joe’s penis rubbed against her clit and she moaned in pleasure. Joe grunted a bit and his mind only could think of one thing, to get inside of her, she was driving him over the edge.

Finally she calmed herself down and lined up her entrance with Joe’s manhood and slowly slid his cock into her pussy. Inch by inch she allowed Joe’s penis to further penetrate her ever so slowly, his penis stretching her inner vagina walls. The pain still lingered in her groin area but it soon faded as the pleasure over whelmed her. Finally after what seemed like an eternity of pleasure Joe’s full length was inside her, she could feel his entire length and it made her almost go over board and cum right that moment but she held back the orgasm for the moment being, this felt better than any of her fantasies she had about Joe.

“Joe… how does it feel?” Scootaloo asked curiously, wondering if he was in any sort of pain. “Oh god… it’s so tight… oh my god this feels unreal” Joe managed through grunts of pleasure, obviously trying to hold himself back from cumming. They just laid there for a minute and let the pleasure wear down so it would last longer, “Jeeze… never once in my life did I think that I’d ever have sex with a pony” Joe muttered and Scootaloo gave a heart-warming smile. “Are you ready?” Scootaloo asked and Joe took a deep breath and nodded, “Only one way to find out right?” Joe asked and Scootaloo slid her body up until Joe’s penis was no longer in her pussy and as Joe’s cock left her inner depths it clenched, needing his presence back inside.

Scootaloo slid down on Joe’s shaft very slowly and passionately, a moan of pleasure escaping her mouth again as the pleasure returned quickly and attempted to drive her over the edge but she once again held herself back from an orgasm as she continued. Joe couldn’t help but to start grunting as the pleasure began to build up inside him.

Scootaloo continued her slow strides and Joe’s penis slid up and down inside of her pussy, soon her breathing became erratic, her slides became faster as she couldn’t hold herself back. She kept herself sitting up high in cowgirl position as her moans quickly became screams of pure pleasure and her pussy walls squeezed against Joe’s cock and he grunted at the sudden change in pace, but quickly matched her movements as they humped madly on one of his spare beds.

Joe wondered to himself if Scootaloo’s screams woke the neighbours, she was screaming pretty loudly and a concerned citizen might think that a mare is getting chased or raped or something. Scootaloo’s orgasm seemed to make her whole body quiver and she collapsed onto Joe’s chest still humping him slowly and her breathing finally slowed, her pussy walls still squeezed against Joe’s penis but soon the orgasm passed and it unclenched. “Joe… that felt amazing… give me a second to catch my breath” Scootaloo gasped.

Scootaloo caught her breath then began her slow strides again, Joe was trying to hold his own orgasm back but knew that at this rate it was going to end pretty soon, then he remembered that they both had school tomorrow and that it would probably be better if they ended sooner rather than later, but for the moment being he just wanted to buck with her until he blew his load.

At first Joe was a little skeptical about the idea but he soon figured that it didn’t really matter because he loved this mare more than… well he didn’t really know, about the same amount as he loved his parents but in a different way.

Joe felt his pleasure start to reach its peak and he cursed to himself in his thoughts. “Scootaloo… I’m so close” Joe grunted. “Wait… Joe let’s do it together” Scootaloo offered and Joe wrapped his leg around Scootaloo’s hindleg and rolled their bodies over into a missionary position with him on top. Joe started thrusting, his penis reaching her deepest walls and she began to scream again in pleasure as Joe quickly forced her to her peak again.

Scootaloo leaned up and began to furiously make out with Joe as Joe rutted her like a wild bull. Joe’s body began to thrust erratically as he reached his peak, Scootaloo broke away from the kiss, “Joe… I’m so close” Scootaloo screamed and Joe slowed his pace. “What do I do?” Joe asked, curious of what she wanted him to do at this point. “Joe just keep going and cum inside me” Scootaloo replied through gasps of pleasure then the two began to make out again.

Joe was about to think ‘am I really about to cum inside her’ but then realized her had just been rutting her for the last little while. Joe’s body began to clench up. Scootaloo moaned inside his mouth as they continued to make out then suddenly she broke away from the passionate kiss and screamed loudly in the pure ecstasy of sexual pleasure. As Joe continued to thrust his penis in her vagina she wrapped her hindlegs around his lower body, she slammed her pussy against his cock as she reached her climax. Her pussy clenched and the sudden clench forced Joe over the edge and he thrust into her deepest depths until he bottomed out then came inside her, his cum filled every inch of her pussy and his cum quickly began to drip out of her pussy. Her pussy continued to squeeze Joe’s penis and tried to milk Joe’s cock for every last drop of cum. Joe continued to hump her at a slower pace, his penis sliding inside her cum filled pussy gave off a squishing sound. He gave a few last thrusts then stopped, panting heavily.

Joe collapsed over top of Scootaloo and they shifted their bodies so that Joe wasn’t completely over top of her. Joe’s penis finally stopped twitching inside her vagina and Scootaloo’s vagina stopped squeezing Joe’s cock. “Joe… that was… amazing” Scootaloo whispered through heavy pants. Joe kissed her lips and the two began to French kiss again but only briefly. “Scootaloo… I love you” Joe whispered into her ear.

Joe soon realized her was still inside her dripping pussy and pulled his cock out of her tight pussy with a ‘shluuuuck’. Her pussy continued to drip cum and clenched a little, wanting the presence of Joe penis back inside but Scootaloo calmed her need, knowing that they probably needed to go to sleep to be rested for school. Cum dripped down her leg and onto the bed sheets. “You know we’ll probably need to get up early to clean up before school?” Joe whispered and she rested her head on his muscular chest and listened to his breathing. “Joe… I love you” Scootaloo whispered and Joe smiled, “I love you too Scoots” he replied and the two quickly passed out.

Outside in a thicket of brush sat Diamond Tiara with a set of binoculars, “You stupid little… ugh… cunt” Tiara gasped, even though she hated Scootaloo for her getting to Joe first she couldn’t help but to masturbate to the sight of Joe having sex, even if it was with Scootaloo. Tiara finally got off and came as she took a deep breath and whispered to herself “I’ll get you… you little bitch” Tiara hissed to herself. A stallion crawled up beside her “If you’re done eavesdropping, can you fuck me like you promised?” the stallion asked and Tiara rolled her eyes as she bent over, presenting her pussy to the stallion and let the stallion mount her, she rested her face on her hoof as the stallion thrusted his penis into her and while the stallion rutted her she watched Joe, imagining that the stallion rutting her was Joe.

“I can get the cock of any guy but he just up and… ohh… just denies me my… ahh… prize” Tiara muttered to herself through moans of pleasure, half of which she just faked to make the big stallion feel better. The stallion began to grunt and she felt his cock flare up inside her. “Ah goddess… I’m coming” the stallion grunted. In a very half assed voice Tiara gasped “Ahh, yess me to… cum inside me, I want you to fill my cunt with your cum” Tiara lied, any stallion with half a brain would know that she was lying and just simply faking her orgasm.

She felt him cum inside her and she thought to herself ‘Light weight’. The stallion panted and leaned over top of Tiara as his cock stopped twitching. “You can pull out now” Tiara muttered, these guys had no care what so ever for being decent and pulling out before they came, now she’d have to wash herself out before school.

She felt his cock slide out of her and cum began to drip out of her pussy, but it didn’t clench for the need of something to fill it, Tiara had been bucked so many times that she was simply loose and it took a lot to pleasure her loose pussy, but she figured that since Joe was bigger than most ponies that he’d easily be able to satisfy her. “Oh baby… that was great” muttered the stallion. Tiara shook her hoof in acknowledgement “Yeah, yeah whatever just don’t leave without me, I need a ride home and don’t feel like walking” Tiara muttered as she looked through the binoculars and watched Joe as he slept. “I’ll get you yet… oh yes, I’ll get you” Tiara whispered in a voice that was borderline insane.


Author's Note

(Shudders) okay, the moment everyone's been waiting for, they finally have sex... and we find out that Tiara really is a slut and don't worry it's not over yet cause I still need to deal with that bitch Tiara and her asshole friends that constantly fuck with Joe and Scootaloo, maybe I should just kill Tiara off... nah, got a better idea

Next Chapter