After Hearts Warming....

by RadRushingPony

Rating: teen
Tags: Dark, Sad
Length: 1473

Based upon a role play, Sorrow Fog didn't get any presents on Heart's Warming, until suddenly...

All of this is based off of a role play I once had on Omegle with a random stranger. Since the role play I had was rather enjoyable, I decided to TRY and make it a fan fiction. The story of this fan fiction is: It's 2 days after Hearts Warming. Sorrow Fog (my OC) did not get a single gift, until he got a visit from somepony he never thought who would visit him. Things start off great at first, but then things turn bad pretty quickly.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2012-12-30 08:28:45 UTC

Is this the end?

I've been waiting for her to stab me. But what is going on? Why isn't she stabbing me? I opened my eyes, only to find her slightly away from me, without the knife and all washed up in tears. There I do it again. I make her sad.

I am very sorry, Sorrow. I never wanted to kill you. I just wanted somepony to give me a new home and give me a roof to live under in. And I thought you would be the perfect pony for that. But it seems that it went badly... I'm very sorry...

Pinkie...you could've just told me that you we're kicked out of Sugar Cube corner. But if I may ask, why we're you kicked out?

Because I killed Rainbow Dash...just like I did it with Twilight...but I think I'll just go elsewhere.

No, wait, Pinkie. You can still stay with me, if you want to.

Really?

Yeah! You could be like a sister to me! I can always take care of you. It can get pretty lonely living in that house all by myself.

She smiled and while her mane was still straight, I didn't mind. I really didn't. It wasn't any evil grin or anything. It kinda looked like Vinyl Scratch's smile from "Epic Wub Time: The musicians of PonyVille".

Thank you so much, Sorrow! I knew I picked the right pony! - she said that while giving me a big hug, while still having tears in her eyes.

No problem. Remember, if there is nothing we can do together, we can always just sit back and relax.

The End.

The unexpected surprise

It's been 2 days after Heats Warming. No one gave a gift to me. While everypony else we're enjoying their presents, I couldn't enjoy anything. I can't be happy. I did not receive a single gift.

Than, after a few hours of complaining, I hear a knock on the door.

Well who could that be? - I ask myself.

I open the door and Pinkie Pie shows up with a big ribbon attached to the top of her mane.

HELLO! - she screamed.

Oh, um...hi, Pinkie Pie. What brings you to my home?

I just came by to give you your gift!

A gift? Strange, I could've sworn no one wanted to give me anything.

Well, um...what's the gift? - I ask very nervously.

It's me, you silly filly!

I got really confused at this point. Pinkie Pie is my gift? Well, that explains that big ribbon on her head, but why would anypony gift Pinkie Pie to me? It's just ridiculous. But still...maybe that's a good thing?

You're my gift? - I ask with so much confusion in my head. - That's quite silly, but okay...

Oh! Oh! We can do so many things together!

Like what?

Like pull pranks on other ponies, bake muffins or cupcakes, play games... - and she keeps rambling on for a few minutes telling what we can do.

Those things sound really fun! So, what do you want to do first?

Um, I don't know! I thought you we're going to pick!

Uh..well...

She named so many things, I forgot half of them! Not knowing which one to pick, I ask nervously:

Maybe...you want to pull pranks like you said?

Hm...how about not? It's only been two days after Hearts Warming, it wouldn't be nice.

She has a point. Everypony is filled with too much cheer, I don't think that's a good idea.

Maybe you want to bake cupcakes?

Yeah! Sure! Just let me... - she cuts off her own sentence, remembering something. - Oh no, I forgot! I left my supplies at Sugar Cube Corner!

We can go get them, it's no biggie, - I try to cheer her up.

It's not worth it, it would take all day! - She has a sad look on her face.

This does not look good at all. I simply must cheer her up, or else...

This doesn't look good.

Pinkie..please...don't be sad! I am sure there is something we can do!

What's the point? There is nothing we can do... - she said that in a sad tone, while her mane is turning straight,

Pinkie...

Just leave me alone! - she began screaming at me with tears in her eyes.

Wow. To think that I could make the element of laughter sad. I feel like a monster now. And all because I couldn't think of anything to do...

I'm sorry, Pinkie... - I said it quietly with a very sad look on my face.

I close the door and give Pinkie the time to calm down. When I go to my own room and lay on my own bed.

I'm a monster...this is all my fault. Why? And how? Why and how did I make her sad? Now I know she won't forgive me...

After those cloudy thoughts, I fall asleep.

Nightmares. Sweet Luna, I hate having nightmares. And out of all of them, this one is the worst. Pinkamena...she's after me. Seeking revenge. With a knife in her hoof, she's running faster than Apple Jack. Is that even possible? In my dreams, anything is possible. Even cows to eat rocks. I'm running down what feels like an endless hallway. She's still chasing me. I can't outrun her at all. She's just too fast!

You're gonna pay for what you did, Sorrow! - Pinkamena screamed at me.

She caught up. Guess this is the end for me. Before she could stab me, I manage to wake myself up from that horrible nightmare.

Wow...what a nightmare...

I hear laughing sounds from all over the house. I don't know who is doing them, but I'll take a guess. Pinkie Pie. She's probably waiting to surprise me or something.

Pinkie! Is that you?

She's not responding to my screams. I better go look around the house. I go to the room where I left Pinkie. She's not there anymore, but rather, I find a note. ,,I'll be back soon.'' Back soon? Did she leave the house?

She's after me.

I don't know when this was written, but probably an hour ago or something. But I keep looking around the house. I can't find her anyway! Finally, I decide to go to the kitchen, but I'm scared. What if she is there waiting for me? I don't know about this. More laughter. It's coming from the kitchen.

Pinkie! Are you in there? - being very nervous, I go in to the kitchen. - Pinkie, what are you doing?!

Blood stains on the counter, three bloody knives, pony guts and a DING! from the oven.

I was making cupcakes! - she then takes a handfull of cupcakes out of the oven. They don't look good. In fact, they look the same as from when I read the horror book "Cupcakes" written by Twilight Sparkle. - Wanna try one?

No thanks, Pinkie. I'm not feeling hungry.

Try one! - she's getting angrier and angrier.

Can I ask? What did you use to make these?!

It's a very special recipe. Twilight helped me make them!

It was clear to me now that she killed Twilight just to bake these. Without hesitation, turned and ran away as far as possible. But she wasn't going to let me go that easily. Of course, she chased after me with the knife she used to kill Twilight.

You can't run, Sorrow! You will feel my pain!

I can't let her catch up to me. I simply can't! But I'll get tired sooner or later. And then I know that she'll strike. I know that she will use the chance and kill me. I know that I'm dead. No turning back now.

I ran for like an hour and eventually, I got tired. Pinkie Pie was right behind me all along. And as I've said before, she's gonna use the chance and kill me.

It's your turn now, Sorrow!

She held the knife right above me, getting ready to stab my heart out. But before that...she asked:

Any last words?!

Yes...there are...Pinkie Pie...I know I made you sad and angry at me, and now I feel bad. I never meant to do it and you think I meant to do it. I honestly didn't! I'm really sorry for everything I did and said to you, Pinkie. But if you still want to, than go ahead and kill me....I'm ready...- after saying that, I close my eyes and tears begin falling from my eyes.