The Mystery Fluttershy Fan

by The Mystery Fluttershy Fan

Rating: mature
Tags: My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Dark, Romance, Fluttershy, Sex, Human, Sad
Length: 2925

There I was sitting at my computer, there was a topic on Facebook that read. [i]'Your favourite pony shows up at your house, what do?'[/i] I couldn't help but laugh as the real Fluttershy read the question herself and she giggled too.

Fluttershy jumped onto my lap and started watching what I was doing on the computer. I didn't hide anything from her. I just casually browsed my Tumbler, which contained a lot of pony porn, very regularly featuring the pink maned, yellow coated filly sitting on my lap. I did feel a bit uncomfortable about her seeing it after a while and decided to just go to the more innocent pony discussion on Facebook.

There was a topic on there that read. 'Your favourite pony shows up at your house, what do?' I couldn't help but laugh as the real Fluttershy read the question herself and she giggled too at the irony.

"You really are a dream come true Fluttershy, I love you" I say sweetly as I nibble the tip of her pointy ear affectionately.

This is the story of when Fluttershy showed up at my house and all the sexy antics that followed.

The Prequel to WonderFall

Contains:
-Rape
-Bondage
-BDSM
-Torture
-Human x Pony (Fluttershy)

Edited by Setokaiva - Thanks a bunch!
Co-written by Abductkaz

Published 2013-01-08 23:50:01 UTC
Last updated 2013-01-08 23:50:01 UTC

1. Welcome to Earth

Chapter 1 - Welcome to Earth

The rain was getting louder and I groaned in annoyance as I had to turn the volume up on my TV, yet again. I was trying to watch the season finale of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic. I had been sitting there on my red two seater couch all day, having a mare-athon of all season one and two pony episodes. The reason? Because tomorrow night was the premier of season 3. I lived in a city and had been a self proclaimed brony since July 2011. This was shortly after the first season had finished airing and the My Little Pony fandom was starting to grow, but only really online.

I fell in love with the show immediately and the first thing I did after watching the whole first season drunk, was I researched the fandom. Needless to say I was fascinated with it and now over a year later, I have been attending brony meetups in my city nearly every weekend and bronies are now a well known term amongst anyone that is relatively familiar with nerd culture, whether for good or bad reasons.

The storm got even louder, in fact I was starting to get worried that the roof would blow off at this rate. I decided to pause the episode and get some late dinner, It was 9 PM and I hadn't slept since I started season 1. I had been drinking but I ran out of booze a while ago and the buzz was pretty much gone.

Before I got through the door to the kitchen however, I heard a frantic knock at my front door... Actually it sounded more like...

'Clop Clop Clop Clop'

Sigh... I've been watching too much pony, sounds like a pony is knocking at my door. I should really go to sleep soon.

Clop Clop Clop Clop Clop Clop It was even faster this time.

‘I really hope this isn't someone who's going to want to come in and stay the night from the storm,’ I think as I head toward the door. I really, really hate uninvited company. I have a hard enough time socializing at events I deliberately go to, nothing is worse than having to socialize unexpectedly.

Clop Clop Clop Clop Clop Clop Clop

"Alright, Alright, hold on!" I call out. Well now they knew I was here, idiot. I could have pretended I wasn't home, but not any more. With a sigh I opened the door and looked outside and I couldn't see anyone.

"Oh, go get..." I started to yell out angrily at whoever would prank knock during a storm like this, but the sweetest little voice I ever heard interrupted me.

"Um... h-h-hello..." the voice came from right below me.

That's when I looked down and saw the tiny little filly, with a pink mane and yellow coat. She had one of her wings stretched out over her trying to shield herself from the rain. I stood and stared at her in shock.

Pony...

Wings...

Pegasus...

Yellow...

"P-p-please sir can I come in, I-I-I'm so cold..." asked the shivering little pegasus.

My brain was processing things slowly, what I saw in front of me was like one of the optical illusions you can't stop staring at, because your brain is telling you that what you are seeing is impossible.

The words I was searching for finally appeared in my brain and come out my mouth. "Fluttershy?!"

The adorable little pony looked up at me in surprise. "Oh... you know my name?" She asked.

It was indeed Fluttershy, my favourite character from my favourite cartoon. She was quite short, she only came up to my waist, but her body was of course a bit longer.

Fluttershy stood there being very polite and patient for a response from me. Any other pony probably would have barged in and asked permission after. I finally decided to let my brain figure out what was going on after I let her inside and had a close look at her, maybe she was just a talking plushie my friends put out here as a joke. No way it could be the real Fluttershy.

"Sorry, uh... sure, come inside." I invited and stood sideways. She quickly trotted in and lay down on the carpet, still shivering and leaving a trail of water behind her. I watched her closely, no plushie could move that realistically, she was exactly the same colour she was from the show, yet somehow her fur looked more realistic like that of a typical cat and her third dimension was difficult for my eyes to believe. She was without a doubt Fluttershy from My Little Pony if she walked directly out of the TV and immediately became three-dimensional. Unlike I was used to seeing in the show, the light was clearly showing her curves from the shadows cast.

"C-c-can I borrow a towel, or something, p-p-please...?" She shivered.

I walked around to stand in front of her and stared into her huge aqua coloured eyes, no living creature on earth had eyes that big and adorable, evolution probably wouldn't allow it, too impractical. This creature was definitely designed by an artist, that knew how to ever so subtlety make something look as unnaturally cute as possible.

"Sure, I'll go and get one, just wait here, okay?"

My mind was so boggled I started to head into the kitchen, but then suddenly realised I would find towels in the bathroom so I stopped and changed direction.

For the first time since getting inside Fluttershy took a look around, everything looked so strange to her, they all had so many different shades of colours many of which she had never seen before. She had been terrified ever since she somehow ended up in this strange world. All she remembered was trying to help the other pegasi stop an out of control storm above the Everfree Forest, before it reached Ponyville. She was struck by lightning and then next thing she knew she was amongst much darker and scarier clouds. When she flew down she saw lights, buildings and so many strange things she couldn't describe. She flew to the closest house she saw, this one.

Fluttershy started to look around her, it was a neat lounge room and behind her there was a large rectangular box. Odd, there was a pony on it, a unicorn, with a short pink and purple mane and purple eyes. She smiled at this, maybe there were ponies in this world after all, maybe she could just fly back if she went far enough.

Other than maybe Discord, this bipedal creature was the strangest one she had ever seen. She was a bit scared and uneasy around him, but she didn't have any other options until she found a way back home.

I walked back into the lounge room with one of my favourite towels, it was my favourite because it had a pony on it. Pinkie Pie to be precise. I always wondered what would happen if I brought a girlfriend back to my house, that wasn't a brony and she saw my obsessive collection of pony merchandise. I never even considered an actual Friendship is Magic pony seeing my merchandise. I quickly walked up to the little mare, who hadn't moved and threw the towel around her. She had noticed the pony on it and was unsurprisingly curious.

"Um... Do you know this pony?" She asked.

"Ha ha, yeah I know her, in a way..." I replied.

"Oh... Where can I find them, the other ponies?" She persisted.

It seemed evident that this was a Fluttershy, maybe from the past that hadn't met most of her friends yet. I wondered if she would recognize Rainbow Dash, since she knew her as a filly. I started rubbing her coat with the towel getting it wet rather quickly, her fur held on to a lot more water than a human did. My hair was very long for a guy and it would always take ages to dry.

"Well, that is kind of hard to answer..." I start, thinking about the best way to explain.

"Um... You have a picture of a pony over there." She points a hoof to the paused pony episode on the TV.

"Oh that's Twilight Sparkle and that's not a picture, it's part of a video," I explain.

"A video?" Fluttershy cocks her head curiously.

I try to think back to my knowledge of the world Fluttershy comes from and how I could best explain video in a context she would understand. My overly pony obsessed mind quickly remembered the episode Hurricane Fluttershy and how Rainbow Dash showed an old black and white film about making hurricanes to carry water up to Cloudsdale.

"It's like a film, a moving picture" I explain as I pick up the remote control and un-pause the episode. Sure enough Twilight starts talking about her brother, Shining Armor. I quickly stop the episode again, realizing that if Fluttershy sees herself, it could be really hard to explain.

"Oh okay... I've never seen a film in colour before" She comments.

"I guess Equestria only has early film technology" I conclude.

"So this is another land beyond Equestria?" The curious filly asks.

I take the now soaked towel off her leaving her only slightly damp. I could not help it, I give her back a pet. She responded with a surprised little shriek, but did not move. Petting in Ponyville isn't that uncommon, but it's normally only between close friends, but what freaked her out most was the hands, they felt really creepy and alien to her.

"Well... Equestria is very far away," I consider as I continue to pet. How the heck did she get here anyway?

It felt amazing, her fur was so soft and warm. Her hairs were quite short but really fine. It seemed like the over-exaggeration my mind made about how soft a My Little Pony's coat would be was not far off. It was almost as if, she was exactly how I had imagined her, in all the fan art I looked at and all the clopfics I wrote...

This whole situation was strangely familiar...

Fluttershy walked over to my couch and pushed an experimental hoof into it to feel it's cushiony softness.

"May I... um... sit down on here?" her sweet little voice called out, snapping me out of my deep thought,

"Yes, of course you may," I nod and go to join her on the couch. It's pretty high up for her so she actually extends her wings and uses them to aid her in jumping onto the couch. It looked amazing, to see a real live pegasus in action. I sit next to her and I instinctually, like she is a pet start running my hand down her pretty light pink mane and giving her scalp a bit of a scratch.

"Um... c-can you not..." She starts to object looking up at me, but then changes her tone. "Actually, that's nice, nevermind".

"Oh... I'm sorry," I apologize realizing I was probably making her uncomfortable, but I continue since she gave me permission. We both sit there in silence as I go back into deep thought and try to rationalize how I'm in this situation. It must be a dream, I think, but then I don't recall ever knowing I was in a dream until it was over. It would sometimes take me a few moments to realize I'm lying in bed and that I couldn't possibly have been in a shopping center spending my lotto winnings. Or the woman that I was flirting with and had actually put her head on my shoulder was still the one I had never had the courage to say more than two words to me at parties, most of which were pony-themed, it was the only way a anti-social internet nerd like me finally found the courage to go out and socialize, that was why the fandom meant so much to me.

So if it wasn't a dream, then maybe it was like that movie I really enjoyed, it was still sitting there by my TV. Ruby Sparks

Where a author loves his fictional character so much, she suddenly materializes into reality. Could Fluttershy have become real, not the one from the show, but the one from my head canon... The kinky one that loves being fucked roughly and tortured for psychological experiments?

I had written a whole novel length fanfiction about Fluttershy, where a stallion kidnaps and rapes her and tries all kinds of kinky and messed up sex acts on her.

So if this was the Fluttershy materialized from my dreams, then maybe she will come to love being dominated like a slave, just like my fantasies. I start to pet Fluttershy lower to test her limits, I stroke just above her tail and she doesn't seem to object. She just lies down and curls up cutely, she closes her eyes and looks like she's starting to drift off.

She's so damn cute, it should be illegal to be this cute. I run my fingers through her silky smooth tail and I carefully lift it up to take a look at her main prize. A tiny little slit runs a few centimetres down from her anus just below her tail. I stare at both holes longingly and begin to drool. Blood quickly rushes to my penis and almost immediately I already feel a wet patch form in my underwear at the tip of my penis, surprised it look this long actually. I had never really been able to rationalize to myself why, I would feel this way about cartoon ponies, but to the private bits or any other animal. I can normally read clopfics without touching myself and I'll start leaking. This time I did touch myself. I put my hand down my pants and squeezed the tip of my cock, collecting a bit of my precum. I brought it up to my nose and inhaled. If smelled awesome.

I wiped my fingers on my shirt and I attempted to pick Fluttershy up, without changing the adorable curl she was in. I slid my arms each under her front and back legs.

"Mmmm... huh?" She opened her eyes and stood up, wondering what I was doing.

"It's okay Fluttershy, I was just going to take you to a bed.” I consoled, I was trying not to grin to betray my true intentions.

"Oh... okay... I can walk there myself" She said as she hopped off the couch.

"Okay, just follow me" I instructed as I begin to lead her down a long hallway, featuring two doors on each side and one more door at the end of the corridor. ‘I hope she is naive enough to go inside on her own,’ I contemplate. She follows me to the end of the hallway, I get a key out of my pocket and unlock the door with it and slowly open it, watching the little filly carefully; she just sits on her haunches and waits to see what's inside. Right behind the ordinary white door is another one. But this one is made of steel and looks like the entrance to a bank vault.

Fluttershy looks confused more than anything at there being two separate doors to this room. She looks at me curiously waiting for an explanation. I try to think of one as I quickly turn a dial on the door several times to the left and several to the right, stopping at a different number each time. After I enter the combination there is a click and I pull out a handle and then twist it. The heavy door opens to a room so dark, that even from the doorway not much can be seen inside.

"Okay Fluttershy, in you go." I motion to her.

"B-but it's dark in there" She trembles. "I-I'm scared of the dark.”

I consider my options. If I turn the light on for her, she will clearly see that it's a scary room. She may not realise it's a BDSM dungeon, but still. I really couldn't think of any good way to reason for her to go in, so it was time to drop the facade.

"Okay then Fluttershy, I'll take you to a different room." I lie as I walk towards her. As I hoped she waits for me to walk past so she can follow me. Instead I walk straight up to her and grab her mane tightly in my hand.

"Owww!" She squeals. "Stop, that hurts!" Her wings open up and she tries to fly away, but the pain from my hold on her mane quickly makes her stop trying to move away and she instead moves toward me and punches a hoof into my leg. It hurt a little bit more than I expected with how small she was and will probably leave a bruise, but it did nothing to deter me. I grabbed the hoof she hit me with and started to drag her into the darkness. Her wings flapped wildly and put up a surprising amount of resistance.

"This is it Fluttershy, you are mine now!" I shout.

"N-no, nono please, noooooo!!!" She squeaks as her wings get tired and she quickly finds herself surrounded by shadow and then when I close the door, complete pitch black.