Fluttershy's Apple

Far away from Canterlot was a cottage sitting alongside the Everfree Forest. This cottage belonged to the timid yellow Pegasus Fluttershy. She had been planning something all day, and was almost ready as soon as she heard the sound of somepony approaching her cottage. She prepared for the arrival and ran up the stairs to her room.

Applejack arrived at the cottage, where Fluttershy had asked her to come over to help with the many critters she took care of. Looking around, she saw that all the animals seemed fine. She went up to the house and knocked on the door, but got no reply. Being Fluttershy’s friend, it seemed ok to just walk in.

As soon as she opened the door and stepped in, a cage fell over her and trapped her. The cage had a black cloth over it so she couldn’t see anything. She felt something prodding at her hooves and looked down, seeing a floor trying to be moved under her. She was not going to have any of this, so she pulled her hind legs up and prepared for a strong kick.

What she hadn’t expected is that as soon as she had kicked at the bars, she got shocked and knocked to the floor. Who was doing this to her? Did they do the same thing to Fluttershy and force her to ask AJ here? Knowing how Fluttershy was that was probably the case. She was scared at this point, wondering what was going to happen to her.

Her hooves were prodded with the base again, and she reluctantly obliged, stepping onto the floor as it moved under her. She then felt she was being moved across the floor, but to where? Only time would tell.

After what seemed like half an hour, or maybe it was an hour, the cloth was finally removed, revealing a basement area with a small light hanging from the roof. There was also another pony in the room, and she was dressed up in a weird way so Applejack had no idea who this pony was. She was stubborn as always though. “Where’s Fluttershy? Where am ah?”

The pony shrunk back a bit, which made them seem scared. There was only one pony that Applejack knew that would get scared from one loud statement, and she couldn’t believe it. “Fluttershy? What in tarnation? Why did ya put me in a cage?” Fluttershy removed her mask and looked scared again, her voice quiet. “Well, be-because… I…” She couldn’t seem to muster the courage to speak, which was natural for her and everypony knew it.

Applejack sighed and lowered her tone. “Look, if ya just release me we can ferget that this whole thing ever happened, ok sugarcube?” Fluttershy shook her head, and that made Applejack’s eyes got wide, wondering what she was going to do.
Fluttershy pulled something from a bag nearby and walked back to the cage. She opened up a door on the cage and stepped in, then took the rope in her hooves and tied Applejack to the floor of the cage, knocking her out of the cage.

Applejack struggled against the bonds, but the ropes were strong. Fluttershy then stood above the cowpony and laid on top of her, kissing her deeply, trying to push her tongue past AJ’s lips, but this Apple would have none of that and kept her mouth shut tight, which prompted Fluttershy to yank her tail and cause her to gasp, making her mouth open long enough for Fluttershy to push her tongue inside her mouth and begin playing with her tongue, much to Applejack’s displeasure. Applejack was not a filly fooler, and never would be. It was wrong and weird.

After a few minutes, Fluttershy stopped and pulled her mouth away from Applejack’s, panting hard. She rubbed her body against Applejack’s and moaned quietly. Applejack felt no pleasure from this, she only felt weirder and weirder.

Finally Fluttershy got off of her, but not for long as she sat on Applejack’s face and rubbed her soaking pussy against Applejacks face, specifically her mouth. Applejack turned her head to the side, not wanting this, and gathered the courage to speak again. “Fluttershy, look, if ya stop now, ah won’t feel any different about ya. We can still be friends. Doesn’t that sound nice, sugarcube?”

Fluttershy ignored her and used her hooves move Applejack’s head back into place and forced her plot on Applejack’s face, cutting off her air supply. Applejack was surprised and terrified at how forceful Fluttershy was being. Fluttershy of all ponies.

Applejack knew the only way she would now get out this without suffocating was to pleasure the no longer timid yellow Pegasus who was still dressed in a black suit which had numerous holes in it for her tail, her head, her wings, and her holes. She opened her mouth and breathed in the scent of Fluttershy’s arousal, then slowly licked once on her yellow lips. Fluttershy stood up a bit and moaned, allowing Applejack to get some air, which she happily breathed in before she was smothered again.

This went on for a few minutes, and then Applejack began continuously licking at Fluttershy so she wouldn’t be suffocated any longer. Fluttershy humped against Applejack’s tongue and urged her to continue by putting pressure on her chest. She gave in and pushed her tongue inside of Fluttershy and pushing her nose against Fluttershy’s clit, rubbing it slowly by nodding, which also allowed her to thrust her tongue in and out of Fluttershy, which made the animal caretaker squeak cutely.

Applejack wanted this to be over as soon as possible so she could rush home, clean out her mouth, and try to get some sleep to forget this day ever happened. Fluttershy finally came all over Applejack’s face, a bit flowing into her mouth, which she spat out onto the floor.

Fluttershy got off of Applejack and left the cage, closing it behind her and going back over to the bag to grab a few more things. When she came back, she was wearing Applejack’s hat. She strapped a ball gag to her head to keep her quiet, and attached something around her waist. When Applejack’s eyes finally focused to the light again after being under the shadow of Fluttershy’s plot for so long, she saw that Fluttershy had strapped a dildo onto herself, and judging by the expression on her face, it was double sided.

Applejack looked at it with worry on her face and looked into Fluttershy’s eyes with a sad expression, hoping she would get the message. Apparently she didn’t as she slowly began pushing it inside of the farmer’s orange cunt lips. The size of the fake penis was too much for Applejack, and she began crying in pain. The gag in her mouth muffled her screams, but it couldn’t hide her tears.

Even though she was going slow, it still hurt immensely. She had had a few stallions over the years, so she wasn’t a virgin and was used to this kind of thing, but normally all the stallions she was with weren’t as endowed as this fake stallion meat pumping in her. It stretched her to her limits, but being a hardworking pony, she was more resilient on the inside than a lot of mares, so she didn’t tear from the stretching.

This was having a large impact on Fluttershy, since she had never felt anything like this before, and it was getting her off quickly. Though she was a virgin, her toys could never go deep enough to pop her cherry since she always cut them down to size with a knife, and stitched them back together to make them shorter. The other end, however, was still the exact same size as it was when she got it, to make it go deeper in the ponies she was having fun with.

Applejack tried to move her legs to get the intruder out of her, but these ropes were tied tightly, and she was unable to escape. She was at the mercy of the most timid pony in all of Equestria, and it was even said in her name. She gave up trying to struggle after realizing how useless it was to fight it, and thought if she could end it quicker, then she would get to go home to her family quicker.

She pushed against the toy to try and make it thrust quicker inside of Fluttershy, and it was working, Fluttershy was making high pitched squeaks at this point, her tongue hanging from her mouth. Applejack pushed against it harder, which pushed it deep in Fluttershy, but due to the double ends, it also went severely deep into her as well. This pushed Fluttershy over the edge again and made her cum all over their crotches.

She panted and fell on top of Applejack, but quickly stood back up and picked something up behind her, pulling the dildo out first, and strapping the object around Applejack’s neck. Applejack wondered what it was but couldn’t see it very clearly.

Applejack heard a click near the object and then she was released, and the ball gag was also taken out of her mouth. She looked at the red marks on her hooves at where the ropes had held her and began massaging the injuries to lessen the pain.

Then she tried to leave, but then she felt a resistance on her neck and felt where her neck was, feeling something like a… No, no this can’t be happening! She pulled frantically at the collar around her neck, unable to see where it clipped on to take it off. She looked at Fluttershy and saw her holding a leash which led to the collar. “Fluttershy, why are ya doin’ this ta me? What do ya want?”

She spoke in her quiet voice still, still scared of the Earth Pony’s strength. “I-I want… You, Applejack… I want you to be my pet…” Applejack’s eyes went wide and she pulled hard, yanking Fluttershy to the floor and making a mad dash for the door, until she felt a shock of electricity and dropped like a rock, falling into the door. The collar around her was a shock collar, and Fluttershy had the remote for it. And Applejack knew that even though she may have been scared of just about anything, when she got a new pet, she wouldn’t let it go for anything in the world, and she was very good at keeping it hers.

This was Applejack’s life now, and she knew it. She would probably never see her family again and she would be a pet from now on. There was no stealing from somepony like Fluttershy. It wasn’t all bad though, since Fluttershy always took good care of her pets and never let any harm come to them, not normally at least. In a way it would be like having a sleep over at her cottage for years, with probably a lot of sexual activities added in with the mix.

Fluttershy was kind though, and actually let Applejack go home, as long as she came by every day after working to pleasure her. Applejack would be unable to take the collar off, and if she almost did, she would get shocked again. If she also didn’t come over, she would get shocked again. Those were the rules that were set in place by Applejack’s new master. Applejack wanted to avoid as much pain as possible, so she regretfully obliged.

When she got back to the farm, her family wondered where she had been, and about the thing around her neck. Being the honest pony she was, she told them about Fluttershy. They were angry about this and were about to take this to the police but Applejack stopped them. Fluttershy wasn’t actually breaking the law, Applejack still had all her rights and was free to go home when she felt like it, but she had to go over to Fluttershy’s cottage every day to pleasure her or she would be shocked. It wasn’t rape if you thought about it, since it could be considered a fetish, and so now Applejack went through the same routine every day.

She started off the day by waking up, combing her mane, and then eating breakfast. She then went on to work either bucking apple trees or selling apples on the market. Whenever ponies saw the collar they knew what it was about, due to the convention they had had a few days ago. After lunch break she would continue until her work day was over, then she would come home, eat dinner, take a shower (thankfully the collar was water proof), and then head to Fluttershy’s cottage. After she was done there, she would head home, take another shower, and then go to bed.

Author's Note

Another chapter completed! Suggested by Greenfang Neverclear. I was actually able to draw this out longer than I thought I could. Like I said in the comments if I do a terrible job with the country accent tell me what I need to correct and I will correct it. Who should my next master and pet couple be? Again it is all up to you, because you want to read something, and I am happy to oblige. There are also too many pony combinations that I could throw together and not enough time to do them all, so that is one of my main reasons I let you all decide the next couples. If you want to suggest an OC, make sure to give a description on their name, personality, behavior, background story, look/picture of OC, all that good stuff. Thanks for reading and see you next time!