Chapter 4: An unwanted surprise

An unwanted surprise

Rarity wakes up in her own bed the next morning, unsure of how she got there.

Was it all a dream? Last thing I remember was falling asleep on the couch with Cheerilee.

She gets out of bed still feeling a bit groggy. She walks into the bathroom to freshen up before going downstairs. She stops in her tracks almost instantly from what she sees in front of her.

Roses? How..? Those can't be what I think they are.

She turns the taps on the bathroom sink and lets the water run until it's warm. The mirror above her starts to fog up, so she uses a cloth to wipe most of the buildup off. The reflection she sees in the mirror makes her sigh. It was the roses.

Did I do the right thing? Leaving Twilight like that.

The white mare puts her hooves underneath the water, and then brings them back up to rub her face. She lets out another sigh and turns the taps off.

A very pleasant smell coming from downstairs makes it into Rarity’s snout.

Mmmmm what is that smell, she thinks

Following the scent, she finds herself downstairs in the kitchen to see Cheerilee fixing breakfast.

"How’s my sleepy pony doing this morning" Cheerilee happily asks her

Rarity smiles and begins to speak, "wha.. What happened last night? How did I.. We end up in my bed?"

Cheerilee is still here. Was it real? Here we go with my bad memory again. Not able to remember anything she thinks to herself

"Well, after we had sex, we started to fall asleep. Somepony came to the door, and then you got up and answered it. After opening the door, you nearly scared me half to death when you fainted and fell to the floor."

She walks over to Rarity and hugs her tight. "I then ran over to pick you up, and to see who was at the door. It was your friend that you hang out with, Twilight Sparkle. She looked awfully sad, like something terrible had just happened to her. She handed me roses, and I put them in your bathroom, since that's probably the first place you would go to."

They break the hug, and rarity looks down at the floor - her ears flopped down the sides of her head. She looks up and Cheerilee, and tells her, "Cheerilee. I need to tell you something."

She pulls her over to the couch, and they sit down.

"Remember last week, at the store, when you found me on the bench bawling my eyes out? Well, It was Twilight that I had just separated from and.." Her throat starts to choke up a bit, thinking about the words she is about to say. "Those roses upstairs were from me. I gave them to Twilight when we started to date." Still pretty choked up, she manages to let out a few more words "I hope you don’t think any less of me for not letting you know at first"

Cheerilee brings her hoof up to Rarity, and raises her head, then begins to speak

"As long as you’re happy now. That's all that matters right? After all, you have me now" She smiles at Rarity, trying to cheer her up the best she can.

"Well yes, I'm happy that I'm with you and all, but it’s just.. Twilight was special to me. She was the first mare....pony I had ever been with. I never thought I would ever like a mare, let alone one of my best friends. I really hurt Twilight, and I know we agreed on this, but, I don’t know. Let's just forget it okay?"

Cheerilee nods her head, and kisses Rarity on the cheek. "Breakfast is waiting in the other room. Hope you like eggs and home hay fries"

The two go into the kitchen and begin eating their meals.

"So what’s on your agenda today Cheerilee?" asks Rarity

"Well, I have to go home and mark some papers so I can hand them back to the kids. We could do something before then though if you would like?"

"No, that's alright." Rarity begins "I think I still need to patch things up with Twilight. She's still one of my best friends after all"

They finish up with their food, and bring the dishes over to the sink.

"I will finish up here Cheerilee, I know you have a lot of work to catch up on. Don't want to upset the kids now right" Rarity finishes, winking at the fuchsia pony in front of her.

She chuckles a bit, and walks over to Rarity. "Alright then. I'll see you later then" She kisses her on the lips, and walks out of the shop.

"UGH!!!!!! What am I going to do?!?!?!" Stomping her hooves on the floor "Why did I have to be so stupid and get myself in this kind of mess! What the hay am I going to say to Twilight!"

Twilight. Is she even going to want to be my friend anymore?

She finishes the dishes, and puts them on a rack to dry. She looks into the living room, and the mess from the night before is still there. The pillows are thrown off the couch, and the blanket that was over top of it is nowhere to be seen. She uses her magic to pick up the pillows, and put them back on the couch.

The bed must be a mess as well. Better go clean that up to she thinks.

Walking into the room, she notices the bed is a mess, with the blankets thrown off, leaving only a sheet.

"Oh, there’s that silly old couch blanket."

She picks it up, and places it by the door.

"That Cheerilee must buck in her sleep with the way she left this bed."

She picks up the blankets for the bed, and fits them back onto to. She fluffs the pillows, and puts them underneath the blankets. The night lamp was still on from the night before, so she turns it off. Out of the corner of her eye, she sees the roses once again.

Those stupid roses. I better throw them out.

She walks over to bathroom, and bites onto the roses picking them up, and then something falls out of them.

Is that..a letter?

She sits down and opens the letter and begins to read it.

Dear beautiful and wonderful Rarity,

I’m writing this letter to you, to apologize for what has happened a few days ago. Spike has already forgotten about what has happened. He convinced himself that he was just seeing things, and that you would never do such a thing. Close one right? Anyways, I know that we agreed upon what we did, but, I think it might have been a little soon. I…We were not thinking straight, and probably made the wrong decision. I still like you very much, and want to be with you. I, I love you. There, I said it. I love Rarity, and I’m not afraid to say it.

Your best friend and lover,

Twilight Sparkle

Rarity drops the letter and begins to cry, unable to stop herself.

What have I done! I'm so stupid. Maybe it was a little fast. But I'm with Cheerilee now, and I really like her. Ugh stupid me! Why did Rainbow Dash have to spike that punch!

Still sobbing a little bit, she gets up, and throws both the letter and the roses into the trash. Rarity looks around the room, and is content with its looks. She remembers the couch blanket, and picks it up. She almost trips walking down the stairs, but catches herself on the railing. With the blanket now on the couch, she forces a fake smile on her face, and walks out the door to begin her day.

It's another nice day out, just like the day she went over to Fluttershy's house to get some medicine for her pet. Bright blue sky, with almost no clouds. She looks around the town, seeing everypony go about their days, carrying on their daily lives. She sees Lyra and BonBon sitting on a bench near the town square fountain, smiling at each other, laughing after each time she sees one of them open their mouths.

She sighs and continues to walk on.

What am I ever going to say to twilight, I don’t want to hur...

Her thought is broken by somepony crashing into her.

"Sorry Rarity, didn’t see you there!" Rainbow Dash says to her

Well THAT voice sounds familiar

"Watch where you’re going next time! Can’t you see a lady is trying to walk here?"

"Where ya headin’? Probably over to Twilight’s huh?" Rainbow asks her

"Well yes, I was going over there to...."

"It's okay you don't need to tell me, we all know. Twilight asked us to come over yesterday because she had something to tell us. She asked us to stay there while she went over to your place to give you something. But before we knew it, she came running home crying her eyes out, and explained to whole thing us."

"Oh, so then you know about.."

"Cheerilee and you? yeah."

"Are you mad at me?" Rarity asks her, feeling a little bit scared

"Me? I'm not the one to judge about what you do. After all, I'm not the only pony that swings that way anymore right?" Nudging Raritys shoulder a bit. "But..."

"But? What’s wrong Dash, is Twilight mad at me?"

"Well, she's not exactly mad at you, but everypony is pretty upset. They’re all at the library still. She asked them to stay the night. I left myself, and decided to get up early as you can see."

Rarity thanks Rainbow Dash for the information, and makes her way over to the library. She sees even more ponies going about their days, happier than ever, without anything to worry about.

Well this isn’t going to go well. Everypony hates me, and it’s all because of our stupid agreement.

She sees Big Mac walking down the same street as her, and they stop to talk.

"Going over to Twilight's huh?"

"Applejack told you?"

"Eeeyup. I won’t hold you up though, carry on."

They exchange goodbyes, and Rarity continues on her way to the Library once again. Upon reaching her destination, she can see her friends through the window, trying to comfort Twilight. She knocks on the door, and Applejack answers it.

"Oh. It's you. Come on in, I suppose."

"Thanks Applejack, I really need to talk to Twilight."

"Well, I don’t know if she's in the best mood to be talking to you right about now. But it will help I guess"

Aj closes the door behind Rarity, and everypony looks at her, except Twilight.

"Hello girls. How is everypony doing" she begins to speak

"What are you doing here" Pinkie says to her "Can’t you see what you have done to poor Twilight"

Twilight is sitting down; she looks like a complete wreck. Her mane is all over the place, and she has pretty big bags under her eyes.

"Pinkie, I know, and I'm sorry to the both of you, sorry to all of you."

"Sorry won’t cut it missy!" Pinkie cuts in

"I know sorry is nowhere close to cutting it. But... I got your letter Twilight."

Twilight looks up at Rarity, and she can tell that she is deeply sorry about everything, just from the way she looks. Everything Twilight could want in a pony is right in front of her. What was once hers, gone.

"I really meant everything I said in that letter you know." Twilight says, raising her voice a bit, bringing tears to her eyes. "Every bit of it. It's true. I love you! But once I saw Cheerilee....Everything changed. I.. Hated you."

She hates me.

"I know there’s nothing I can say to change your mind or anything. But..." Rarity starts to say

"Oh just stop saying sorry. You don’t even mean it" Applejack cuts in. "We all know about you and that whore Cheerilee"

"You take that back! Don't say anything bad about her, or even bring her in on this. It's not her fault!" Rarity snaps back, becoming a little short tempered.

"Yeah? Then whose fault is it then huh? The mare in the moon?"

"Applejack..don’t." Rarity tells her.

"Don't what? Can’t face the truth! Maybe you’re the whore! Not even a week later, and you’re already screwing another mare!"

"Applejack.. please. stop!"

"Oh ho ho, I'm not done with you. You have no idea what you have done to Twilight. She loves you, you know that? She truly loves you with all her heart. and what do you do? You express your love by sleeping with another pony!"

"Stop it, now!" Twilight cuts in on the argument. "We did agree on the breakup.."

"Oh come on Twilight. We all know you didn’t really mean that. You were just scared and didn’t know what to do."

Did we really mean it?

"You see Aj, it’s noponies fault then. Twilight even said" Rarity cuts back in

"Stop trying to make this seem less than it is. Just accept what’s going on, and don't try to get out of this. It’s YOUR problem now!"

Rarity is unable to handle everything that is going on, and screams at the top of her lungs, losing almost all control of what she is going to say.

"I HAVE HAD ENOUGH WITH YOU APPLEJACK. THIS IS BETWEEN TWILIGHT AND I. YOU HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS, AND I WILL NEVER BE ABLE TO FORGIVE YOU FOR WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT CHEERILEE. YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHAT IS GOING ON, OR WHAT I FEEL! YOU DONT THINK I FEEL TO HUH? SO JUST BUTT OUT AND LEAVE ME ALONE!"

She runs towards the door, and opens it.

"GOODBYE!"

She runs out, slamming the door behind her. Still crying at the top of her lungs, running through the town, trying to find Cheerilee, and tell her what has just happened.

The first place she looks is the school, but the lights are off, and she isn’t there. The next place she must be at is her house. Rarity starts to run towards Cheerilee’s house, and sees that the lights are on.

She barges into the house, still sobbing pretty heavily, startling Cheerilee pretty bad, sending papers all over the place.

"Rarity? What’s wrong, why are you crying?!"

Rarity tries to tell her what’s wrong, but only gibberish is coming out of her mouth.

"I..Twilights..Applejack..Mad..Yelling..." She falls over and starts to cry even harder.

"Come on now, let's go over to the couch and tell me what’s wrong. I hate it when I see you cry."

Hate. Twilight hates me. My..my friends hate me

"So tell me," handing Rarity a tissue, "What happened."

"Well, After cleaning up the house this morning after you left, I went upstairs to throw out the roses, but a letter came out." She settles down a bit, and stops the tears, but is still choked up. "I opened it, and inside was Twilight admitting that she loved me and that she was wrong about the breakup"

Rarity can feel Cheerilee's hooves rubbing her back, which makes her feel a bit better, and continues to tell her what happened.

"After that I went over to Twilight to apologize, but Applejack went at it, and started yelling at me. She even said a few bad things about you and that’s when I lost it. I started to yell back, and before I knew it, I was running all over town looking for you"

"It's okay my dear, your here now. I got you." Cheerilee says, comforting her. "You.. you don’t feel the same way about her..do you?"

"Well, I don’t know. I mean, I don’t love her, but, I can’t shake the feeling that maybe she was right about the break up."

"Oh?" Cheerilee looks a little surprised from what she had just said to her.

"No, no no no! Don’t get me wrong here, I really like you, and don't want that to change. I want to be with you every day, and never leave your arms. It’s just.."

"It's okay Twilight. I know what you mean. She was very special to you, and understands how you feel." She leans over kisses Rarity on the lips, caressing them slowly.

These lips. I love these lips. Everything about her.. I just love!

"You know." Rarity says, almost completely done sobbing "You always find a way to cheer me up with your lips."

Cheerilee giggles a bit, and begins to speak "I could cheer you more by kissing your other lips if you like" Winking at her.

"Oh Cheerilee!" She says, lunging herself towards her fillyfriend, landing a kiss on her lips as they fall into the couch.

Cheerilee begins her regular routine by kissing Rarity's neck, leaving little wet spots in her fur.

"I think it’s my turn to do you this time Cheerilee" Rarity says seductively, winking and licking her lips.

Rarity begins to slowly kiss her, moving her tongue into the mares mouth, shoving it down her through more and more each time they kiss. She brings her hoof in between Cheerilee’s hind legs, and beings to rub her clit.

Cheerilee reacts instantaneously by letting out a loud moan

"mmmm. That feels sooo good!"

Rarity rubs slowly, and then goes faster, watching the fuchsia mare moan each time she speeds up.

She stops kissing Cheerilee on the lips, and slowly moves down her neck, doing the very same thing that she does to her. As Rarity is kissing all around her neck, she buries her snout into Cheerilee's mane, and smells it.

Oh my goodness. What is that smell? It’s so amazing!

"Hehe, that tickles" Cheerilee peeps out between each moan. "Rarity.. you’re wet. I can feel you dripping all over my fur."

"Your mane smells amazing! What do kind of shampoo do you use?" Rarity asks

Cheerilee doesn’t reply, and just smiles at her, using her hoof pushing Rarity's head down towards her wet pussy.

She gets the hint, and takes control once again, by starting to kiss her belly. As she moves down, she slaps Cheerilee's rump with her free hoof, and she lets out a little squeal.

"Did you like that?" Rarity asks

"Harder."

"What" Rarity says confused

"HARDER!"

"Ohhh!"

Rarity slaps her again and again, increasing the force a little bit each time, without trying to hit her to hard so that it doesn’t hurt.

"Rarity. I want you...ugh...to go down on me....oh my god....NOW!"

She agrees without a second thought, and begins to rub her snout into Cheerilee’s hot, wet pussy.

Cheerilee lets out a loud moan, slamming her hooves on the floor.

She is licking all over, looking for the that magic button that makes Cheerilee go crazy, while at the same time, rubbing her very own hot and wet pussy.

Cheerilee uses one of her hooves to direct Rarity to the right spot, and when she hits it, her back arches immediately from the pleasure.

"Right there.. ugh.. Right there, don’t stop!"

Rarity begins to lick even harder, trying to make her cum faster.

"Rarity! I think..I think I’m coming!!! ooooooooohhhhhhhhhh!"

She stops rubbing herself, and uses that hoof to rub Cheerilee as she is still licking to add to the pleasure.

The doorbell rings. But neither of them notices.

Rarity gives one final push, and can feel Cheerilee tense up

"AHHH! I’m coming!!!!!!!!!!!!" Cheerilee arches her back, and slams her hoof on the floor, knocking more papers over.

"How was that?"

"That was just amazing. Thank you" Cheerilee says "Oh, sorry."

She wipes Rarity's snout off, and kisses her on the cheek.

"What was that?" Rarity asks

"Oh, it was nothing to worry about."

The doorbell rings again.

"Who could that be?"

Cheerilee gets up and answers the door. It’s Applejack.

"Why you all sweaty...?" Applejack asks her.

Rarity gets up, and walks over to the door as well.

"Who is it?" She looks around Cheerilee, and sees that it’s Applejack.

"Applejack?!"

"Rarity?! What in the hay!!!"

Applejack is frozen, knowing what had just happened. Even after their recent encounter. She is shocked that this... would happen again so quickly..

"I can’t believe you Rarity.."

Applejack leaves it at that, and starts to walk away.

"Applejack...Wait!!!!"