Once you’re able to collect your thought, you rush to inform Princess Celestia of the griffon’s demands. She is also shocked by their one and only request, and for a while she too is speechless. Finally, she tells you that she will be sending another message (this time through magic) pleading for another way to reach a truce to the griffons, but in the meantime you should head back to Ponyville and speak with Twilight. You nod and head back home, planning to return to the small village tomorrow morning.

Your flight home is filled with worry. ‘I can’t send anypony there, especially since I know what they’re going to do to them. But what if Celestia doesn’t find another way? We can’t win a war with the griffons, and now they have an alliance with the dragons.’

You finally arrive home, finding Rainbow waiting for you on your bed once again. You tell her that you have to go to Ponyville again first thing in the morning, and she once again hesitantly agrees to join you. You find it odd that she makes you promise to not leave her alone like you did last time, but you promise her, hoping it makes her more at ease.

The rest of the day is spent preparing for the trip while deep in thought. You don’t think you can go through with deciding one pony’s fate like that, but the threat of war across all of Equestria makes you realize that you don’t have any way out of choosing.

Rainbow Dash senses something is weighing heavily on your mind, but she doesn’t ask, though it’s not like you could tell her if she did. She stays out of your way the rest of the day, and as night falls she heads to the bedroom a little before you do. You figure that talking with Twilight tomorrow should hopefully help your dilemma, so you head for your room and open the door.

You’re shocked by the scene in front of you, not sure what to make of it. Rainbow is on your bed, her legs spread wide open and giving you an unimpeded view of her crotch. Her lower lips are already glistening with her wetness, a hoof busy at work rubbing her clit. She moans loudly, her hips bucking up as she plays with herself. She looks straight at you, her eyes seeming to invite you to have your way with her, and even with those heavy thoughts weighing on your mind still, you walk over to the bed with your cock growing larger from the sight and the smell of her sex in the air.

You walk over to the bed and climb up. Rainbow stops her stimulation and motions for you to lie down. You do as she says, wondering what she could be up to. Your erection stands straight up as you lay back, and Dash crawls up to you, licking her lips. She begins to lick your cock from the base to the tip, strangely taking her time instead of her usual rushed pace. Going lower, she licks at your balls before sliding her tongue back up all the way to the tip, and then swallowing the tip of your cock in her hot mouth. Her tongue dances around the head of your cock as she shallowly bobs her head, teasing you and making you want more.

Just when you don’t think you can take any more Dash draws her head back, leaving the very tip of your cock in her mouth before jerking forward, taking your entire length into her throat in one quick motion. Your head snaps back as the warm sensation engulfs your entire length, almost enough to make you cum right there. She holds her head down, her throat massaging your dick as she gags slightly from the intrusion. She finally begins to slowly lift her head back up, her tongue pressing against the underside of your shaft and pressing up. Once she has the head of your cock back in her mouth, she slowly slides back down, repeating the movements again and again.

She maintains her slow, steady pace, ensuring that you don’t cum too soon. She soon lets your cock fall back free and she resumes licking the entire length of it again. As she moves back lower to lick your balls again, she uses her hoof to gently rub your cock, taking slow, deep strokes as her tongue licks your sack. After a few minutes she then goes back to deep throating your cock, her pace picking up slightly and causes you to feel your orgasm starting to build. Sensing you may be close, Dash stops her blowjob, releasing your cock from her mouth yet again.

“Where do you want to cum?” Dash asks you quietly, slowly stroking your dick to keep you close. It takes a few moments for her question to register in your head, and you finally manage to answer her.

“In… in your pussy.” you respond. Before you can sit up, she climbs on top of you, positioning her wet hole right above your cock.

She lowers herself, letting your cock penetrate her. She doesn’t stop until she takes your whole length in her. She flexes her lower muscles, her pussy squeezing your entire cock in her warm flesh. She feels you tense your body, ready to thrust in and out, but she stops you. “Let me.” she says.

She begins to ride your cock, rising up and pushing back down in a slow but steady rhythm. Though it’s different from her usual quick pace, she manages to still bring immense pleasure to you, her pussy milking your cock with each stroke. The surprise intimacy of tonight’s session seems to add more pleasure, and even at the slow pace you feel your orgasm beginning to build. She once again senses your about to reach your limits, but this time doesn’t stop. She looks down at you, seductively licking her lips. “Cum in me.” she softly whispers.

That’s all you can take. You groan as your cock erupts, your cum shooting deep into the depths of her womb. Dash also begins to moan as she feels your hot seed shooting into her and she continues to ride your cock, wanting the feeling to last as long as possible. A soft ‘POP’ reaches your ears, but you don’t pay it any mind. The gasp of a third pony, however, does finally gain your attention.

Straining your head up, you look past Rainbow still milking your cock and are rendered speechless as you stare at a familiar purple alicorn that somehow has appeared in your bedroom. Twilight stares in your direction in shock also, but her eyes do not meet yours; instead she is focused intently on where you and Rainbow are still connected, your cum dripping out of her pussy. Dash finally turns her head and notices her friend standing there. “Oh, hey Twi.” she says.

Twilight left the room while you and Rainbow ‘cleaned up’. You finish cleaning up first, and you go out to meet Twilight while Rainbow finishes cleaning up the mess you left inside of her. Twilight sits on a chair looking out the window, her face still red from the scene she intruded on.

“Um, hey Twilight. Look, I’m sorry that…” you begin to apologize.

“N-no, I’m sorry! I shouldn’t have teleported here without telling you first!” Twilight interrupted. “I just, I just didn’t think I would end up in your bedroom…”

Her face grows redder, as does yours. She coughs softly, then continues. “So, uh, is that how you two usually do it? Does it, you know, help her at all?” Twilight asks, appearing somewhat curious about the matter.

“Um, well, I think it does.” you reply. “I really don’t know how much it helps, but every night she comes in and, well, wants to do it. I tried to stop it at first, but she got extremely depressed.”

“Well, she seems to like you, and you’re treating her really well. I think she’s in good hooves.” Twilight confirms, giving you a smile. You smile back, but in your head a pang of guilt strikes your gut as you remember your first time with Dash, her protests not reaching your ears as lust had overtaken you.

“Yeah. Uh, thanks.” you manage to reply. “So, what brings you all the way here? We were going to Ponyville tomorrow.”

Twilight took on a more serious tone. “Princess Celestia informed me that you met with the griffon’s earlier today, and that they gave you a list of demands. Somehow the Elements of Harmony are involved, and the Princess said that you would be coming to talk to me tomorrow. I figured it would be easier if I came to you instead by teleporting to your home.” she explained.

You nod, confirming that what she has said so far is accurate.

“So, what did he demand?” Twilight asked.

You decide to be forward and explain what Captain Ray demanded. Twilight’s eyes grew in shock and horror as she heard your story. When you finally finish, she is speechless for a few moments.

“How... but they can’t… you can’t…” Twilight stutters, unable to find any words. She takes a few deep breaths and finally speaks. “Have you thought about who you’d choose?”

You nod. “Yeah, it’s been on my mind all day, and I know that there’s no way I can choose anypony to suffer that fate. Look how they treated Rainbow, even if they did a fraction of what they did to her to somepony else. I… I know that this will mean war with them, but I just can’t choose any of you.”

“I understand.” Twilight said. “I knew that it would be too much for anypony to choose a single pony for something this big. That’s another reason I came to see you, I knew there was no way you could bear this burden alone. That’s why I’m willing to go, so you don’t have to choose.”

“What?” you say in shock. You can’t believe your ears; Equestria’s newest princess is willing to submit herself to a fate that even she knows will both mentally and physically break her. “You can’t go! You know what they’ll do to you. Just look what they did to Rainbow Dash.”

“I know. Trust me, I know.” Twilight said, looking down in despair. “But I can’t let any of my friends or anypony else in Equestria suffer when I know I can prevent it. It’s my duty as a princess to make sacrifices to protect others.”

You shake your head. “I’m sorry, Twilight, but I won’t give your name to Captain Ray. I’ve already decided what I have to do, or at least what I have to try to do.”

“And what do you plan on doing?” Twilight asks.

You tell her your plan, and she tries to immediately talk you out of your crazy, possibly suicidal idea. You don’t let her talk you out of your plan, though, telling her that nothing can change your mind. Before Twilight can try to talk you out of it again, Rainbow enters the room, once again cuddling up to you despite Twilight being there. Twilight sees how your hardened, determined stare easily gives way to a gentle, concerned look.

“Just… just be careful.” Twilight says, giving in. Dash looks at you with a confused look, but you assure her that things are fine. “It’s okay, Rainbow. Twilight is going to stay the night and bring you back to Ponyville tomorrow for a few days. I have to go do something and won’t be back for a while.”

You can see that Dash has a worried look in her eyes, but she holds her tongue and nods in agreement. You show Twilight to the spare bedroom next to yours, it only being used by Dash for a few hours before she came to your room instead. You bid Twilight goodnight and head to your own room, finding Dash once again already in your bed, waiting for you once again. While you still remain a little horny, you bury your desires and climb into bed next to her, wrapping your hooves around her body and draw her close to you. Before she can say or ask anything, you pull her into a kiss, and though she freezes up you don’t stop, your lips stay pressed against hers. She finally kisses you back, her tongue meeting yours. What seems like an eternity passes before you reluctantly break the kiss, and you can see the quizzical look on her face as you draw back. Her face calms as you stroke the back of her neck, and soon she closes her eyes and falls asleep. Once you’re sure she’s asleep you lean close to her and speak softly.

“Rainbow Dash, I’m sorry. What I did that night to you… after we got out from that lake, I shouldn’t have done that. If I didn’t do that to you, maybe all of this would have never occurred. I caused you to go through so much, to bear so much pain. But I’m not going to subject your friends to the same fate. I’m going to make things right. I’m going to make them pay. I don’t know if I’ll see you again. I don’t know if I’ll make it out alive. But no matter what happens, I want you to know something. I should have said this long ago, and I’m not sure if it means anything now. But I have to say it. I love you, Rainbow Dash. I love you, and I’m sorry.”

You kiss her once more and lie down and close your eyes. Sleep overcomes you, your body knowing it’s going to need every bit of strength in the next day or two. You hold Dash in your sleep as usual, expecting yet another night of terrors for your lover. However, for the first time in who knows how long, Dash doesn’t dream at all.

Author's Note

wtf is this? A whole chapter of happy consensual sex? It buuuurrrrnnnnnnnnnnsssssssssss!

Yeah, another short chapter, but work has sucked me dry of any free time. The next chapter will probably be it for this story. There WILL be another story made once I finish this one taking place in the same timeline/universe, this time expanding to other ponies.

Oh, and before anyone jumps to any conclusions about how they think this is going to end, I highly suggest you hold your comments until the last chapter rolls out... you'll be surprised.