The Six Decisions

by DuBrony

Rating: mature
Tags: Slice of Life, Sex, Main 6, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance
Length: 3041

The Mane Six has fallen in love with you, but... which one do you love the most?

[(Another) second-person story... the ending is for YOU to decide!]
After living in Ponyville for the last few months, you’ve caught the attention of 6 beautiful mares. It’s a hard decision, as they all show deep affection for you. You've influenced the choice of spending one night at each of their houses to see how far they'll go to express that love.

Published 2013-02-09 12:40:02 UTC
Last updated 2013-02-15 15:45:01 UTC

The Proposal

A calm breeze gently rubs against your face, slowly bringing you from the dreamworld. You come to, laying in your warm bed.
"What a perfectly good day..."
It's not easy getting up, as your sleeping place seems to want you back in your original position, but you manage to push past that. You look around; it's the same light-wood panels on the walls and dark-wood for the floor and ceiling. The only accessories that diversified it from it's original, empty state, was a poster of your favorite DJ and some safekeepings from home. Outside, the trees slowly swished back and forth, in a melodic pattern. You rub your eyes, starting to feel more awake.
"I should take a shower..." You decide.

After a lovely, warm shower and some waffles for breakfast, you try to think of ways to spend the Saturday without ruining it.
"I wonder if the library's open..?" The thought seems to jump out at you when you notice the book you took out a month ago was sitting in front of you.
"Crap, that was due four days ago!" You realize. After cleaning up your breakfast mess, you drop the book in your knapsack and start out the door towards the local Ponyville library.
"I hope I don't have to pay too much..."

You push open the main door with your hoof, stepping inside. Inside, books lined every wall, every crevice. The wooden floor and walls seem to compliment the setting perfectly. Funny part was, there was nopony else in sight. But you weren't interested in the decor or population... you had other things to attend to.
"Twilight? I, uh, have this book here that I rented and never brought back!" You call out. "How much do I have to pay for four days late?"
From the top of the stairs, a happy purple mare trotted down the stairs.
"Oh, hey there!" She calls out, adding your name.
You feel a blush come on when you look at her soft, flowing hair bounce alongside her. Her smile, in your eyes, couldn't be any more stunning.
"So, you're here to return a book?"
You nod, hoofing the book to her, and she writes down some words on a clipboard and magically sets the book back up on a shelf.
"That'll be 100 bits..." She announces, slowly gliding towards you, "but there are other ways to pay off a debt that large."
Your eyes widen at the remark.

"I-I-Is she... coming on to me..?" Even in your head, your words seem to trip over themselves.
Suddenly, the door behind you bursts open, and a blue blur shoots past you and forms the shape of a pony beside Twilight.
"Hey there, Twi, you got the next Daring Do novel?" "It's Rainbow Dash!" You realize.
"Sure thing, Dashie, I'll get it for you!" Twilight says, adding a hint of impatience in her voice. She trots off to the other side of the library, fiddling with a few other novels.
Rainbow Dash turns to you, and suddenly red spots appear at her sky-blue cheeks. She says your name, stuttering. You smile, and her blush begins to widen.
"I-I... I..."
"Hey there, Rainbow Dash." You remain solid, but you can tell that she really seems to adore you. "Maybe it's my hair..?" You ponder.
"So... I was wondering if... you know, you and me, if we can... oh, I was thinking that we could..." Her words messily spill out, but you knew what she was trying to ask. Before she could finally say what she wanted to say, Twilight comes back with the next Daring Do book.
"Here you go, Dashie!" She cheerily calls out, making her way back to the stuttering mare. Rainbow Dash turns around and slowly takes the book.
"T-t-thanks... T-t-tt-twi..!"
After one last look at you, she darts out of the room as fast as you've even seen her go.

You turn back to Twilight, and you jump when you see her nose almost pressed up against yours.
"Oh... I'm sorry, I didn't mean to startle you..!" She giggles. You smile weakly, and she makes her way back to you again.
You remain speechless as she closes her eyes. "She's not... is she..?"
She completes the kiss, and you close your eyes as well. The moment feels everlasting, and the feeling of true love crashes down on you...

The door swings open once again, and an orange mare walks in.
"Hey there, Twi, I was wonderin' if ya got another one of those-"
You turn to see Applejack, her eyes wide, carrying an empty bucket on her rear. You turn to Twilight, who's also staring at the onlooker.
You're the first one to speak. "I... we, uh... this book, I... I..."
Applejack falls over, laughing. Both you and Twilight blush, looking at the laughing mare.
"Why, I seen everythin' now!" She hoots, still bent over giggling. After her fit subsides, she turns to you.
"I've been lookin' for you, sugar cube! I need you to help me out at the orchard tonight, if possible."
Twilight interjects. "Well, I need him to help me, uh... sort books, yes!"
They didn't notice you stepped out of the library.

"Well, that sure escalated quickly..." You think, passing a few stores. More thoughts on how to spend the Saturday seem to echo through your mind.
"Decisions, decisions..." You start your train of thought, unaware of what's in front of you. You yell when you suddenly find yourself face-to-face with a happy, pink pony.
"Hi there!" She cheerily calls out, her grin never faltering.
"H-hey there, Pinkie... how has your day been so far?"
"Oh, this and that..." She looks around, thinking. Almost immediately, her focus snaps back to you. "What about you? Have you gone on any awesome adventures lately? OH! Can I go somewhere awesome with you? Huh? Can I can I can I?" Pretty please with a cherry on top? NO! A SUPER-DUPER ALLEY-OOPER MEGA-AWESOME BIG BRIGHT RED UBER-CHERRY!?"
"Um..." You're not sure how to respond, "I, uh..."
"Oh, can you help me with something, because I'd REEEALLY love it if you could!"
"Sure, what is it you need?"
A different kind of smile seems to grow on her cheeks. "Oh, just a little something..."
She looks at you and a devious manner. "I'm fun in more ways than one, you know..." She gives her signature giggle.
"Pinkie..?" You ask, "what are you doing?"
Suddenly, you hear hoofsteps running behind you. You turn around, and see Rarity dashing towards you, calling your name.
"I need you quick, darling!

You follow Rarity into her beauty shop, confused.
"What the hell has gotten into these ponies?"
She shuts the door behind you, and locks it. "Oh, dearie, you shouldn't be talking to her!"
You cock your head in confusion. "Why not, is there something wrong with her?"
"Oh, no dearie... it's just, I'm sure it'd be in your best interest to spend a lovely day in the hooves of a real lover..."
She trots to you, flashing a very sexy smile. Your previous blush comes back, and the white mare notices it.
"What, you've got nothing to hide..!" She coos, You remain motionless as she rubs her head against your shoulders. "I've been waiting for this for a long time, you..."
"I... I... I, uh..." You stutter, unable to form comprehensible words. "I know I should leave, but I can't help myself..!"

A loud bang on the door shakes the both of you from your stupor.
"Open up, for buck sakes!" You hear Applejack call out.
Several more loud bangs, and the door splits. In pours five multicolored mares.
"What do you think you're doing with HIM?" Twilight asks in a commanding tone.
"Well, ladies, I think you all know what I was going to do..!" Rarity interjects. Suddenly, the whole lot of them break out in a massive yelling fit. Even Fluttershy raises her voice to Rainbow Dash.
"Stop it, please!"
They keep on fighting.
"STOP!"
You finally have their attention. They all give blank stares, as you finally begin.
"Okay, why are all of you fighting over me? Why am I so damn attractive to the six of you?"
They blink; okay, no good response from them.
"Anything?"
Rarity finally spoke up. "Well, I have an idea..."

"...with each of you? For one night?" You repeat her idea. "Well, I guess that sounds fair. I'm going to have a busy week on my hooves, though."
"Don't worry, sugar... I won't tire you out." Applejack remarks, winking.
Twilight shoots a dirty look to her, and turns back to you. "Well then, who's going first?"
Back in the hot seat again. "Um, well... uh, you I guess." You pick at random.
Rarity breaks into a hysterical stutter. "B-b-b-but-!"
"No buts. Twilight goes first, alright?" You tried to make it sound like you didn't want to be in this situation, but you couldn't help it; six sexy mares and you.

Groans echo from their lips, but they decide its for the best. After subtle goodbyes, you go back to your house to wash, eat, and whatnot. Besides, you had a long week ahead of you...

Author's Note

Sorry for not making this chapter a 'Mature' chapter, I wanted to safely explain what the rest of the story was about without diving right in to sex and such... you won't be let down, I promise!

Twilight Sparkle

It's finally 8 o'clock... and you're supposed to be somewhere.
"Night one... Twilight Sparkle... hmmm, I wonder how this will turn out..?"
You step out of your house, leaving the comfort of warm air and sufficient light. You make your way to the library, its occupants long-gone... all but one.
"Okay, this is going to be a long night... one out of six." You remind yourself.
The large tree that holds the library suddenly comes into view. It's nothing short of amazing... you've never seen it at night before. You knock, but no answer. Out of the corner of your eye, you spot a little white notecard.
" 'Come right in! -Twilight Sparkle."
The door is louder than anticipated, but you weren't hiding anything. The torchlight on the walls casts a somewhat ominous glow. Every single book seems to be in order, you spot, which means Twilight's previous work is done. Suddenly, from the top of the stairs, comes the dazzling purple beauty.

You gasp; "She looks amazing... did she do something with her hair?"
"Twilight, you look simply..."
Her mane was pulled back in a different style... it looked like heaven. Something about her seemed to shine and yell "I'm beautiful".
"I know, I borrowed some make-up from Rarity, and I've got to say, it seems to be quite the miracle!"
"And why's that?"
"Well, I've got your attention, don't I?"
You and her get a little closer... she giggles.
"What so funny?" You ask.
"I, haha, I never thought I'd be wearing make-up, and in a situation like this..! Look, I'm sorry beforehand if I-"
"Hey..." you pull her from her train of thought, "you look amazing. It's okay..."
Twilight gasps. "You... you really think so..?"
"Of course, you've always looked simply dazzling in my eyes."
A tear falls from her right eye. "Thank you..."
She's gotten considerably closer, and you feel a kiss coming. You close your eyes, and lean in...

Suddenly, a heavy weight leaps on you and you fall over.
"Woah, what the..?"
You look up; Twilight's on top of you.
"What are you doing, Twi?"
"I love you, I really do!"
You can't help but blush. "Wow, I never would've guessed she thought this about me..!"
"Please, be with me!"
"Well, it's only fair that I go with the rest of them too, but who's to say I love any of them more?"
"So then... do you pick me?" She frantically asks.
Idea. "Why don't we go upstairs and discuss this a little more... privately."

You trot upstairs beside her, the fire between you growing at each step.
"She could be the one..! " You decide, in the heat of the moment.
You and Twilight lay down on her bed, the moon casting a faint glow over the blankets.
"I love you..." you hear her say. She puts a hoof over your shoulder and scoots closer.
A smile crosses her face. She closes her eyes and kisses you on the cheek, ever so slowly. You close your eyes as well, embracing her hold. You tilt your head to meet her lips, occupying yours. Her soft, arousing peck on the cheek turns into a french kiss, and she puts her other hoof on you. You rub her horn; you read before that it was sensitive. She gives a long moan.
"I want you..."
Like before, she leans onto you, with her hair covering the view of the window and her soft underbelly rubbing against yours.
"I need you..."
Twilight sexually licks your neck, slowly savoring the moment. By your back hooves, you can feel a liquid pour past your skin and soak into the blankets.
She really does want you.
On top of you, she begins to rub against your shaft. Your face heats up again.
"Tw-Twilight..!" You exclaim. "I didn't know y-y-you wanted to just, get right into it l-like that-!"
She doesn't reply, but gives a little smile and rubs harder. The sensation is overwhelming, and you give a little breath of pleasure. Twilight stops grinding against your stallionhood and, instead, inserts it inside her. She lets out a long moan, and you can feel her wet insides glide across your skin. The penetration is amazing.
"I love you-!" She yells. You begin to concern whether or not she'll wake up the purple baby dragon you met earlier, but the thought left your mind. Why would she be doing this if she wasn't the only pony here?
Her hooves wrap around your shoulder, and she begins to make out with you. You do the same, guiding the movements the purple mare performs on you. The bed rocks back and forth, but Twilight's horn magic stops it from making any more noise.
Horn...
You begin to lick her horn. She shakes and shivers, her quivering breath barely forming words.
"...yes, more..."
You put the entire horn in your mouth, and her movements fluctuate between hard pushes and soft rubs. She moans and wails in pleasure, heightening the feeling. You let out a moan as well, unable to contain yourself.
Oh, Celestia, this couldn't possibly feel any better than it does right now-! You exclaim inside your head.
Her hair is no longer the sleek, shiny wave you saw before, and the first beads of sweat began to wipe away the make-up. But you didn't care... it was too good.
Her horn seems to get harder the more you suck on it. You can once-more feel that slick liquid pour from her and cover your stallionhood, reinvigorating the feeling down below. You begin to sweat as well, although you aren't the one doing the work. Her wet body grinds and thrusts against you, it was like nothing you've ever experienced before.
NOW it couldn't possibly get any better.
Her panting breath grows weaker at every thrust, and you occupy her mouth with yours once more. After several more pushes, the everlasting feeling erupts from down below. Thrusting becomes a daunting challenge, as the sweet sensation of cumming overwhelms you. A few more quivers, and Twilight collapses on the bed beside you. After a moment to catch your breath, you kiss Twilight beside you, who now has her hoof laying across your side in a cuddling position.
"I love you, Twi..."
"I love you too..." She groggily replies. After a few more seconds, she finishes the sentence with your name and drifts into a deep sleep.
I wonder what she'll dream about..? You deliberate. After about a minute, you finally start to close your eyes too, feeling a sharp wave of fatigue begin to wane your attentiveness. With a final movement, you lay your hoof over her side and rest your nose beside hers.
"Sweet dreams..."

Your eyes open, revealing a blurry outline of Twilight's room. You sit up, looking through the window out into the distant sunrise. It was peaceful, calm, seren-
"Good morning, cutie!"
You jump, turning around. beside the bed next to you, sits two waving plates, floating. Looking at the ground, you can see a laughing Twilight Sparkle.
"Haha, did I scare you?" She asks, getting up.
"No no, It's just... the sunrise looks magnificent. And so do you."
Her hair was brushed in her normal fashion again, and no trace of make-up was seen on her rosy-red cheeks.
"D'awww, thank you!" She exclaims, setting a plate of food beside you.
"Why, this is just... I don't know what to say, Twilight, thank you!" You say, admiring the hospitality.
"Ohh, it's nothing, really. Besides, it's what happened last night that matters..." She breaks into a small snicker.
"What happened last night? Are you hurt or something?" A familiar voice calls out by the door. Sitting up even further, you can see a purple baby dragon looking up at you and Twilight. A long moment of silence pierces the previous warmth of, for lack of a better word, togetherness. Finally, Twilight speaks.
"Well, Spike, last night we had a... sleepover, yeah."
"A sleepover? Aw, man, how come nopony ever invites ME to a sleepover?" The dragon pouts and walks out the door in disgust.
You laugh, and so does she. After twenty more minutes of cuddling and eating, you finally realize.
I have another pony to visit tonight-!

Author's Note

Ah, hell, I just missed Valentine's Day to post! Oh well... after some heavy consideration and collaboration, here is the first of the six. Did I rush, or was it too long? All comments are appreciated (besides spam, I just can't live with it >.< ), so feel free to ask!

P.S.: In case you're wondering, Spike was on royal duty. Just thought I'd make that clear... don't want anypony's (or, in our case, dragon) filly-years getting ruined at such a small age, right?