Nightmare Night--The Second Cumming

by ShotgunNeko

Rating: mature
Tags: Nightmare Moon, Romance, Sex, Twilight Sparkle, Princess Luna, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic
Length: 3775

Nightmare Moon has cum back to finish with Twilight Sparkle. Oops I meant finish off Twilight Sparkle for good! Will she succeed in her devious plan?

Nightmare Moon has cum back to finish with Twilight Sparkle. Oops I meant finish off Twilight Sparkle for good! Will she succeed in her devious plan?

Nightmare Moon/Twilight Sparkle/Princess Luna
CLOP CLOP CLOP warning! If you don't like clop then run far far away from this fic!

Published 2013-02-12 08:20:01 UTC
Last updated 2013-02-12 08:20:01 UTC

O' cum all ye faithful

A tall, dark and masked mare stood at the entrance to Golden Oaks library. She had one thing and one thing only on her mind.

Break Twilight Sparkle.

Time after time it was the young purple unicorn that had foiled her plans. She had been so close to driving another wedge between Celestia and Luna, and once again bringing the Lunar Princess back to the dark side. So close, and yet so far as long as Twilight Sparkle was around.

Princess Luna had seen something in her sister’s young protégé. Something she liked a lot. Every time Nightmare Moon came calling for Luna, she was foiled by the newfound friendship Luna had with the purple mare.

But not this time.

Nightmare Moon had teleported inside the library, right into Twilight Sparkle’s room. The young mare was resting comfortably on her back, sound asleep.

“How fitting. You look angelic even when you sleep.” The dark mare sneered. “Unfortunately for you Twilight Sparkle, tonight I am going to drag you through your own personal hell.”

Nightmare moon cackled as the light of the moon shone brightly through the bedroom window.

“Princess Luna’s soul is mine, and now it’s YOUR turn to become one with my eternal night.”

Nightmare Moon’s horn glowed deep indigo, as it radiated a large barrier, covering the entire whole of the library. She trotted over to Twilight’s bed, magically removing the sheets.

Twilight began to stir at the sudden loss of warmth, her eyes fluttering open as they adjusted to the darkness.

“Good evening.” Nightmare Moon greeted, venom dripping from her voice.

“WH-What?” Twilight jumped up quickly, surprised to hear another pony in her bedroom.

Before she even had a moment to react she found herself flying through the air, smashing roughly against the wall. Her hooves were held high above her head with magic, powerful magic that she struggled to free herself from.

Nightmare Moon grinned in the darkness. Twilight shuddered. It was an absolutely, malicious and terrible grin. She tried to look away, but the powerful dark magic held her head in place.

“P-Princess Luna?” she called out, hoping Luna would come to her senses.

“Luna? Really my dear, you know that’s not my name. “

Twilight shook her head. It just couldn’t be. How had Nightmare Moon been able to come back? Hadn’t her friendship with Princess Luna been enough?

Nightmare Moon was done playing games. Her horn glowed again and Twilight’s legs were parted. Her mouth went wide and her cheeks reddened as she realized how exposed she was at the moment. Nightmare Moon shot her a deliciously evil grin. She then licked her lips.

“I am going to thoroughly enjoy this.” The dark mare taunted.

Using her magic once again, she threw Twilight onto her bed, face down. The unicorn’s hooves were still restricted but she managed to struggle as her horn also began to glow.

“Ah, you really are quite powerful aren’t you?” Nightmare surmised.

No matter, Nightmare Moon hadn’t been around for a thousand years without learning a few tricks.

She trotted slowly over to Twilight. Another surge of magic spouted from her horn as she once again tied the poor unicorn down. Twilight was helpless as the dark magic rolled over her body. Her back legs were once again spread open widely, and her poor tail was pushed aside. Nightmare angrily slapped Twilight’s flank.

“Do you have any idea what you are in for? Guards! Get over here!”

Twilight felt her head being turned to watch as four large black Lunar Stallions appeared in front of her. The first thing she noticed after realizing how big they were, was that each one of them had a huge erect cock poking from between his legs.

It hit her like a ton of bricks.

“N-No...please...you can’t...I’ve never...” Twilight pleaded.

“A whore like you? Really? Never had some thick stallion meat inside of you? Well don’t worry your pretty little head about it.”

Twilight was flipped onto her back, as the Lunar Guards advanced on her, each grabbing a piece of her with their strong hooves. The first guard reached for her chest, roughly beginning to paw at it. A mare’s chest was very sensitive, and it only took moments before two small erect nubs poked through her fur. Twilight wanted to die, as the second stallion leaned in and began licking her now perky nipples. He bit down roughly, causing poor Twilight to cry out.

The purple mare once again tried to struggle, but it was futile as another pair of hooves slid up between her legs, pushing forcefully into her. The third guard began to ram Twilight’s small tight hole with his hoof. Twilight tried to close her legs.

“It...hurts...” she moaned.

The fourth guard hovered over her face as the two that were playing with her sensitive breasts held her down firmly. He let his cock slide out and against her cheek. She shivered as she tried to turn away. But the stallions were having none of it, as her head was held down and the cock was thrust forcefully between her wet lips.

Nightmare Moon watched from the middle of the room. She felt herself oddly aroused as the guard forced Twilight Sparkle to suck him off. The guard between her legs then pushed them as far apart as he could, holding her legs up in the air as the head of his stallionhood poked against her slick entrance. Twilight couldn’t help her arousal; the guards’ hooves were eliciting all sorts of sensations from her body.

“N-No please stop! You’re hurting me.” Twilight could feel tears stream down her cheeks as she knew what was about to happen.

Before the guard could thrust into her, he was stopped by Nightmare Moon.

“Jerk it off onto her body and into her mane.” She commanded. “Just like a common slut. Not even good enough to have a stallion cum inside of you.”

Twilight could feel the stallion’s body shift as he got up off of her and began to beat his cock with his hoof. The other two stallions holding her down then rose up and began to do the same. The last stallion, continued to thrust his pulsing cock in and out of Twilight’s mouth. He held her cheeks as he continued to fuck her face, taking pleasure as she gagged and choked on its length.

Nightmare moon watched as the first guard unleashed a large spurt of cum right into Twilight’s soft belly. The second and third guards, each took turns splattering Twilight’s engorged breasts with their hot sticky cum. The last guard then pulled his vibrating cock from Twilight’s mouth and jerked it once, then again, before splashing her lips, cheek and mane with cum.

Twilight moaned as the cum hit her lips, and involuntarily her tongue slid out to taste the sticky mess. She closed her eyes. It was bitter, but not horrible.

“So you are not only a whore for cock, but also for cum.” Nightmare Moon stated accusingly.

She motioned to her guards.

“Away with you! Your job here is done.”

Nightmare Moon’s horn glowed and the guards began to fade away. Twilight couldn’t believe it. Were they just a figment of magic? But their warmth felt so real. Twilight couldn’t make sense of anything. Her head was spinning. She was an absolute mess, covered in hot sticky seed. Not only that, but her own sex was now dripping with arousal.

Nightmare Moon sniffed the air. The sweet smell of a mare in heat filled her nostrils. Twilight was now hers. The dark mare looked down between her own legs, as she used her magic to grow something extremely large and thick. Oh yes, she had saved the best for last. She was going to make Twilight Sparkle ride her enormously huge dick. From the looks of it, she wouldn’t even have to force her to do it. In fact, an even more sinister idea popped into her head.

Instead of forcing Twilight to take her, she would make the purple mare beg for that cock!

It took Twilight a moment to realize that she was no longer being held down by magic. She immediately shot up, wondering what was going on. Was it all over? Had Nightmare Moon left?

She was shocked to find Nightmare Moon lying beside her in her bed. The dark mare was on her back, with a smug smile on her face as she happily stroked something between her legs.

Between her legs?

Twilight’s eyes made their way down Nightmare’s body until she saw what the dark mare was playing with. Her eyes went wide. She had thought the Lunar Guards had huge members, but they were nothing compared to what poked erect from her tormentor’s legs.

“See something you like?” Nightmare taunted.

Twilight felt her throat go dry and a familiar heat rose up between her legs. She couldn’t help herself, she wanted more than anything to touch it. Nightmare then leaned back, letting go of her dark black cock, placing her hooves behind her head.

“C’mon you dirty little slut. You know you’re dying to get your lips on that cock.”

Twilight grimaced. What had happened to her? She used to be a good girl, but now with Nightmare’s member staring her literally in the face, all she wanted to do was feel it against her skin.

Nightmare reached out and pushed a hoof against Twilight’s head, shoving her down against her groin.

“Suck it.” She hissed, through clenched teeth.

Twilight took a deep breath. Her face was inches from the pulsing cock, she knew how wrong this was, how upset her friends, or even Princess Celestia would be if they knew she willingly allowed herself to be taken by the darkness. Every logical thought in her head was telling her to fight.

“It’s okay my darling Twilight. Give in to your primal urges.”

Twilight closed her eyes and leaned down, slowly she began to lick the tip of Nightmare’s shaft. Nightmare groaned happily. She didn’t know what felt better. The pleasure of Twilight’s lips as they explored her cock, or the power she felt knowing she had broken the great Twilight Sparkle.

Twilight continued to explore, as she reached down and wrapped both of her hooves around her new plaything. Nightmare groaned again.

“Yeah...” Nightmare panted. “Just like that. Use your hooves.”

The sudden encouragement made Twilight begin to feel a bit bolder. She continued to let her tongue dart back and forth over the tip, stopping every so often to swirl it around Nightmare’s large swollen head.

Twilight shivered. She wondered what it would feel like between her legs. She could feel Nightmare entangle a hoof haphazardly into her mane, tugging on it, forcing her back down.

“Suck me harder.” Nightmare demanded. “If I am ever going to get this monster between those pretty little legs of yours, you are going to have to lube me up really well.”

Twilight’s ears perked. Was Nightmare Moon really going to fuck her? And why in the world did she suddenly want to be owned by the dark mare?

Twilight opened her mouth wider and began to take Nightmare’s cock deeper. She alternated from sucking and licking the tip, to bobbing up and down between Nightmare’s strong legs, while her hooves gently continued to massage the shaft.

Nightmare hated to admit it, but Twilight was a pretty good cock sucker. She was really enjoying the thorough blowjob her nemesis was giving her. For somepony who claimed to be a virgin, Twilight Sparkle had skills.

“Are you haven’t done this before?” Nightmare asked, raising an eyebrow.

Twilight just shook her head. It was true. Besides the face fucking she had received earlier, she had never sucked on a cock before.

Nightmare could feel her cock begin to twitch. She pulled lightly on the unicorn’s mane.

“I am going to cum. Keep your mouth open. I want you to swallow every drop. I mean it. If you want a nice hard fucking you better make sure none of my seed drips out of that sexy little mouth of yours.”

Twilight could only nod as she opened her mouth, and within a few seconds she could felt the warmth of Nightmare’s seed coat her lips and tongue. Nightmare moaned loudly, squeezing down on the tip, blowing the rest of her gigantic load into Twilight’s mouth. She obediently licked her lips and swallowed the cum as fast as she could. She then surprised Nightmare as she gently licked the leftover cum from the tip of her cock, making sure no drop was wasted.

Nightmare couldn’t believe it. Had she really turned Twilight Sparkle into a cum loving whore? No, not just any cum loving whore. HER own personal cock sucking, cum loving whore.

Nightmare looked down at the mare between her legs. Twilight was practically dripping sex. She easily flipped the hot mare onto her back, looking down between her legs. Twilight managed another blush, she knew how dirty this was, and yet she just couldn’t stop. She wanted Nightmare inside of her.

No, she NEEDED Nightmare inside of her. She was going to ride that beautiful cock for as long as she could, before making Nightmare cum deep inside of her belly.

As if reading her thoughts, Nightmare’s cock became rock hard once again. She pushed it roughly between Twilight’s legs. She had wanted her to beg, but now she just wanted to fuck her nice and hard while looking into those sexy violet eyes.

Without any hesitation or care for Twilight’s well being, she thrust hard between the young mare’s soaked lips. They both moaned simultaneously, as Nightmare filled Twilight up. The dark mare couldn’t believe how tight her young companion was, which made the sensation of her cock sliding in and out even more pleasurable.

Twilight lifted her legs and wrapped them around Nightmare’s waist, causing Nightmare to be pulled deeper inside of the purple unicorn. Twilight clenched her teeth. Nightmare was enormous, and it felt like she was being ripped apart from the inside.

Nightmare noticed Twilight’s discomfort and smiled.

“Too big?” she whispered. “I thought it would be just the right size to fill your tiny virgin hole.”

Twilight whimpered as Nightmare’s hooves dug into her flank. The dark mare began to thrust harder and faster, pumping her hips. Every stroke seemed to open Twilight up just a little more and soon the young mare was taking almost all fourteen inches of Nightmare’s member.

Nightmare leaned in and began to lick Twilight’s tiny pink nipples. Twilight squealed. They were so tender. Nightmare loved the sound of Twilight’s discomfort. She alternated from right to left as she sucked and licked Twilight’s sensitive chest. She continued to watch Twilight squirm, until her sensitive moans became those of pleasure.

Nightmare couldn’t help but think how incredibly beautiful Twilight Sparkle was.

She then pulled out.

Twilight could instantly feel the emptiness inside of her. She looked up. Why had Nightmare stopped?

Nightmare’s face had changed.

Twilight watched as Nightmare rolled onto the bed beside her, removing her helmet.

“Sorry. I just can’t do this. You are just too adorable. Let me make love to you please.”

Twilight flipped over, a huge smile adorning her face as she let her hoof rest on her marefriend’s chest.

“I love it when you say things like that.” She whispered, planting a soft kiss on her former tormentor.

Princess Luna blushed. “I love it when you do things like...well this.” She motioned.

It was Twilight’s turn to blush.

Luna then reached up with booth hooves and held Twilight’s face before leaning up to kiss her slowly. Twilight softly sucked on Luna’s warm tongue as their kissing became faster and more passionate.

Suddenly Twilight felt something poke her in the ribs. She looked down. Luna looked down too. She had forgotten all about the extra equipment she had conjured earlier, becoming lost in Twilight’s sensual kisses.

Twilight smiled lovingly at her marefriend as Luna’s hooves wrapped around her body. The indigo princess lay very still, her erect member protruding proudly once again between her legs. She lifted Twilight’s body up so the unicorn was straddling her waist. Twilight knew exactly how Luna wanted her. She slowly moved her hindquarters downwards, sinking down onto Luna’s cock. Twilight placed her hooves on Luna’s tummy as she closed her eyes, savoring the feeling of being filled up once again. She thrust out her chest, and began to slowly ride up and down Luna’s hard hot length.

Luna watched Twilight intently, keeping her hooves locked around Twilight’s middle. Twilight’s breasts heaved, and her breathing became erratic as she tightened around Luna.

Luna began slowly thrusting upwards, meeting Twilight’s hips. As Twilight slid down, Luna would buck up, rocking her lover slowly, rhythmically. Twilight moaned again and again as Luna’s cock stroked her insides. Her hooves moved from Luna’s tummy, up to the Princess’ breasts, caressing softly.

“Mmm...” was the only sound Luna made, as she thrust every inch of her swollen cock into Twilight.

Twilight could feel that familiar sensation as Luna’s cock twitched and vibrated inside of her. Luna waited for her lover to get off of her and let her finish as they always did when they played these games. Twilight would allow Luna to cum anywhere she wanted on her body. Luna loved turning Twilight onto her tummy and spurting her hot load all over Twilight’s back.

Oddly though, Twilight clamped down harder.

“I’m almost there...” she panted, arching backwards, her hoof finding its way between her legs.

All Luna could do was look on in amazement as Twilight’s hoof circled her small, swollen nub. Suddenly panic gripped Luna. She had never cum inside of Twilight before, and for good reason. It wasn’t that she didn’t want to, because the thought of it made her so incredibly hot. It was because her extra appendage was a product of a dark magic spell, and she had no idea what the magic could do inside of Twilight’s body.

“Twilight...”she tried to protest, but was cut off by Twilight’s loud moaning.

“Oh yes yes.....right there....harder...harder.....yes...YESSSSSSSSS!"

As Twilight came, Luna groaned in ecstasy. Hearing and feeling Twilight’s orgasm was too much for her, and it sent her over the edge. She held onto her lover tightly as she pumped string after string of gooey cum into Twilight’s belly. Luna breathed heavily as Twilight’s body slumped down, her hooves finding their way around Luna’s neck. Luna gently pulled out of her marefriend, and pulled Twilight up into the crook of her arm. As Twilight lie there breathless, she could feel Luna’s warm lips on her cheek.

Twilight smiled in the darkness and snuggled up to Luna’s chest. She sighed happily. She always felt so incredibly safe and taken care of when she was in Luna’s strong embrace.

Luna also smiled. She could see Twilight’s body as it rose and fell with every breath she took.

Beautiful.

“I’m sorry I couldn’t finish the role play.” Luna said sheepishly.

Twilight giggled. “Well I suppose I can forgive you. It’s only because you love me so much that your sweet side gets the best of you.”

Luna nodded. “I hope I didn’t disappoint you.”

Twilight laughed out loud. “You know you could never disappoint me. Although I would like a promise that Nightmare Moon will visit me more often.”

Twilight reached down on the floor and picked up Nightmare’s helmet.

“She was really, incredibly sexy.” Twilight gushed, plopping the helmet on Luna’s head.

Luna grinned again. “Even if Nightmare Moon is repelled by your beauty and Princess Luna has to finish the job?”

Twilight’s eyes glazed over. “Oh I just had a wonderful thought. I am assuming those guards that visited us tonight were conjured from magic?”

Luna scoffed. “Do you honestly think I’d allow anypony else to lay a hoof on you? That was some of my finest conjuring. I controlled them as I watched. It was fun to be able to pleasure you in so many different ways.”

Twilight’s grin grew even bigger. “So then, hypothetically you could conjure say, a fake Nightmare Moon?”

Luna wasn’t sure where Twilight was going with this.

“Well of course. I am a master magician after all.” Luna bragged.

Twilight had a nose bleed inducing thought. She imagined being sandwiched between the evil Nightmare Moon and the sweet Princess Luna. She could see herself grinding down on Luna, while Nightmare took her from behind. Feeling her eyes roll to the back of her head as both of her lovers filled her holes with their warmth.

She whispered her vision into Luna’s ear.

Luna couldn’t handle it. “Twilight, you are such a freak.”

“In a good way?”

“In the best way.” Luna pulled Twilight in for another hug.

“All I’m saying is we should try to get in as much kinky sex as possible until our foal is born.”

Luna nodded her head.

Wait...what?

FOAL?

Luna’s head snapped back to her lover.

“What are you talking about?”

Twilight smiled, lifting a hand to her tummy, rubbing it seductively.

“I’m pretty sure you just pumped a truckload of your seed into me. I did some reading. Apparently magic cum is even more potent than that of a regular stallion.”

Luna’s mouth dropped open, but no words came out.

“Gotcha.” Twilight giggled, kissing her poor marefriend’s distraught face.

Luna’s eyes returned to their normal size as she realized her lover was playing with her.

“Well I’m never cumming inside of you again.”

“Aw, c’mon didn’t I feel good? All warm and tight?”

Luna silenced Twilight with a kiss.

“I’m pretty sure you know the answer to that.”

“And I’m pretty sure you can’t say no to me.”

The two mares giggled quietly, exchanging soft kisses, until they both gave in to their exhaustion. Twilight fell asleep in the fetal position, locked tightly against Luna. She happily dreamt about a sexy encounter with Nightmare Moon and her Princess, while Luna dreamt Twilight wasn’t kidding and they really were going to be parents.

OH HELL NO!

The End

Author's Note

Oh gosh! What have I created? Clop!! lol Okay I know I should really be working on "Do You Believe in Magic?" but I suppose when inspiration strikes what can one do? I'm sure this fic will either be loved or hated...meh I had a good time writing it. Now maybe with that out of the way I can get back to my other story ;) Please read and review!