A Dark Night In PonyVille

by AgentSkittles

Rating: everyone
Tags: Adventure, Crossover, Random, Alternate Universe, Comedy
Length: 1291

The CreepyPasta's arrive in PonyVille's outer fields and slowly make their way up to this small Equestrian Town. Jeff is the first to arrive but what happens when his friends come to his aid, meaning more chaos and disharmony?

Ever since " Cupcakes " was created a portal kept opening up on the outskirts of Ponyville. Nobody or pony has discovered them until Ben hooked up a machine to transfer people to different dimensions as long as they had a Creepypasta history. But after Ben sent Jeff to this dimension, the machine got overheated and was sent into overdrive. It broke, and the portal shut trapping Jeff in the world of Equestria.

Published 1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Last updated 2013-03-25 01:29:13 UTC

Chapter 1 ~ The Arrival

The starts shine elegantly over Ponyville, a normal night was all it was. Twilight Sparkle walked through the wooded surrounding of this small Equestrian village. She examined the rough bark amoung the trees as she passed, humming a tune almost as silent as the night. She then stopped, head facing in the direction of rustling leaves. Twilight was no scaredy pony but whatever this was, it was startling. She held her head high as she bravely peeked between the bushes. She saw a bright blue light flashing, almost capable of giving a pony a seizure. As it flashed it made a loud whine, almost like Doctor Who's tardis. But if he was amoung arrival there would be a royal blue telephone booth flashing and appearing, not a glowing portal. Suddenly the aqua blue tint turned blood red, and you could hear a faded scream, as if somepony was falling through this device. Then the portal got wider and a white pony dropped from the hole. He wore a white hoodie that looked as if stained, hopefully ketchup, with red liquid. He had spikey black hair and dark black circles around his eyes. A knife then looked as if thrown from the portal, nearly hitting the pony. He stood and looked back up the portal as if looking up a window. " Ben! Explain to me where I am! " He yelled, to this Ben person. There was a chuckle and then somepony spoke, " Man your in the magical world of My Little Pony! " He sounded drugged. The white pony growled and looked suprised, " I'll come back for you man! " Ben yelled back. The portal closed up with a startling zap and the white pony feel backwards. He wiped his hoodie clean of any dust or dirt and then stood, looking at his pony form, " How do I even hold a knife with these hooves? " He pondered, as he fumbled with the knife in his hoof. " Augh, screw it. " He got up and slowly trotted around, looking carefully at the trees and bushes. Twilight was confused, where did this pony come from? What did he want? Twilight stepped quietly out of the bushes to get a better look at this pony, for all she saw were his eyes, hood, mane, and coat. As she trotted closer she noticed he hadn't shut his eyes at any point in time and that there was a smile carved deeply into his mouth, probably not capable of healing. " Ahh! " Twilight screamed in horror, backing away. He turned around, his actual mouth more into a frown or straight face. Twilight let her instincts take over, and ran. "Come on...Wait!" The colt called as he ran after her, running lopsided for he was still getting used to his pony body. Twilight ran as fast as possible but this new colt was so much more quick and agile. " You're a crazy pony! " Twilight called, trying to increase her speed. Suddenly the bushes by the two rustled and out popped a pink pony, with ballons dotted on her flank and hair like she put her hoof in a light socket. " Did someone say CRAZY? " She asked, with a presumably happy voice. Startled, Twilight came to a hault, letting the white colt ram into her, and knocking both out cold.

When they came to, each had a bag of ice on their heads. They lay in a small room, in a....tree? Quite strange for an equine to life in a home fit for squirrels. Twilight's eyes fluttered opened as she lay on her back, facing her friends. Pinkie pie and Fluttershy stood in front of her, waiting for her to wake. " Oh my gosh! I am sooo glad you're okay! We also found this weird pony on the way so we brought him along! " the pink pony exclaimed tightly wrapping her hooves around the lavender unicorn. Twilight scanned her eyes across the room and landed them on the colt. Up close, he looked like somepony off of the Slenderpony game Lyra made her play. She got up and slowly walked to him, hearing his moans in utter pain. He looked up, and arched what was left of his eyebrows in a sinister glare. " Why'd you run from me? I am new here and you let me run into your buckin' butt! " he exclaimed, flailing his arms in the air. " Wait... how come I can't curse.." he pondered. " Colts your age shouldn't use the language!" Pinkie said, looking a bit upset. " And...umm... who are you? I ummm... hope you don't mind me asking." the light yellow pegasus asked. The white colt's gaze was directed to the shy pony. Her tufts of pink hair covered her face, only revealing her blue eyes. " Oh.. well.. my name's Jeff. " He said, raising his head higher. Pinkie then rushed right in front of Jeff on her hindlegs. " So Jeff, I know everypony and anypony who lives in Ponyville! Why haven't I heard of you? " Pinkie said, as she held a magnifying glass in her hoof like she was interviewer. " I am not from this place, or a pony for that matter! " the 3 ponies looked confused and then they all chuckled except Fluttershy. " B-But you have hooves.. and umm, you look like one. " She pointed out shyly. Jeff snorted and rolled his eyes, " Well duh! I am not supposed to be one though! " Everypony looked confused except for Twilight. A purple glitter formed around her horn and she started to levitate a huge dark green book. It looked old, probably older than the library itself. She flipped through the pages, which probably wasn't the smartest since they could tear easily. " Do you know a myth called Slenderpony? " Twilight asked Jeff, still skimming through the book. " Pssssht! You mean Slenderman? I know him, he is my mentor! " Jeff said, holding back laughter. Twilight looked up from the book in awe. " So you're from the Creepypasta dimension? " She asked, showing the cover of the book to Jeff. ' Creepypasta: Myths, Legends, and Scary stories. '

Jeff read the cover then nodded, " That's it alright. " Twiight looked back and when to section J, then looked through the names. " Jack, Jason, AH! Jeff....the killer? " The ponies looked at the colt and he blushed the shrugged, " What? "

Chapter 2 ~ Camp-outs

Grass rustled in the breeze, it was a windy day but sunny as ever. Applejack, Rarity, Applebloom, Sweetie Belle, Scootaloo, and Rainbowdash slowly walked up the grassy mountain, Sweetie lugging a cart full of luggage with her. " My hooves hurt! Are we there yet? I am tired! I am hungry! " Rarity 'Complained.' " Rarity stop yer' whinnin', I ain't turnin' around because somepony is hungry! " Applejack spat, irritated. That shushed Rarity up. They kept walking up the mountain, for Rainbowdash's case, flying. " I can see our next campsite! Don't you worry. " Scootaloo said comforting Rarity, mainly showing off for Rainbowdash. " Not whining.."  Rarity muttered under her breath, flipping her scarf to a more comfortable position. Little did they know on the other side of the mountain four other ponies wandered cautiously. " Man, I shouldn't have done that. " one small pony said, acting drugged. " Shush, we need to find my student! I don't need any more rucus happening. " A tall slender pony said. " WOOF. " One barked with a creepy tone. Each one looked like a creature from a horror story.