Princess Luna's illicit affair with an awkward young unicorn threatens to tear her relationship with her older sister apart. Her feelings for him-- which go all the way back to her days as Nightmare Moon-- remain stronger than ever. Yet the back and forth conflicts eat her up inside, and she can't help thinking that she's making terrible mistake after terrible mistake. Then, the unicorn and the alicorn deal with some shocking and surprising news.

This is a sequel to one of the alternative endings of 'Nightmare Date'. However, I hope that the story can stand up on its own as well. Thanks to Liquid_Rainbows and SilentAuthor for their stories "Under the Moonlight" and "Moon Phased", respectively. They've given me great inspiration. Many thanks as well to Conicer for the great illustration.