Fluttershy and Me: Remastered

So as you can clearly tell those two years were pretty fun.  But, the third year of my life in Equestria probably changed everything the most.  I was 26 when it happened.  Once again, it was an ordinary day, but this time, it was a Wednesday (HOLY CRAP A WEEKDAY).  I had just gotten back from helping Twilight move some books around in the library.  She could be such a slob sometimes when she let those books get out of hand.  But, that is what she has Spike for, although he’s kind of lazy too.  Getting off track again, so I digress.

I entered my home and was welcomed by Fluttershy with a hug and a kiss on the cheek.

“You seem rather happy to see me.  What’s up?  Was being without me for those two hours that bad?” I asked her sarcastically.  She giggled and shook her head.

“No, actually, I need to talk to you.  Let’s go in the living room.”

“Sure, but what do you want to talk about?” I asked, but she just kept walking and didn’t answer me.  I was now very curious, and also a little concerned.

“So seriously, what are we talking about?  You know I don’t like having my questions not answered.”  I really did hate that.  People would always never tell me stuff when I was in school.  It drove me nuts.

“Well, I’ve been thinking about some things Matthew.  I’ve been thinking about this for a while now, maybe about a month.  I’ve gone over in my head all the positives and the negatives to this decision, but the positives ultimately outweigh the few negatives I could come up with.”

“What are you talking about Fluttershy?  You aren’t suggesting we take a break, because that would just make my existence in Equestria pointless."

“Oh no, nothing like that.  I would never leave you, and you know that.  In fact, I’ve been thinking about the opposite of that.  I’ve been thinking about something that can further our relationship.”

“I thought we both agreed that us having intercourse in this state was weird, unless we both agreed on doing it.  And you know I don’t like babies that much.  We are not adopting.”

“Matthew, just listen to me, this is important,” she said.  I immediately shut up.

“Matthew, I’ve been thinking that maybe we could ask the Princess a favor.  Oh, why jump around it?  I’ve already asked her if she could do this at all, and she said yes.  I asked her if she could make me… human.”  The moment she said that my eyes grew and my mouth flew open.

“Wait… what?”

“I want to become a human Matthew.  Not just for me, or just for you, but for us.  Matthew you know we can’t get serious about our relationship like this.  You don’t want to become a pony, even though the Princess offered you the chance.  I’ve tried to get you to, but you won’t do it.  Therefore, I’ve decided to become a human.”

“Fluttershy, I can’t let you do that,” I responded, still in total shock of what she had just told me.  It hurt me a little bit to know she wanted to throw away her existence as a pony just for me.  No, she said for us.  But still, it didn’t seem right.  She had already asked the Princess though if she could be changed.  Did she ask if the Princess would do it?  I had to know.  But before I could ask, Fluttershy continued.

“It’s too late for that Matthew.  I’ve already asked the Princess to do this for me.  We are going to Canterlot tomorrow.  There is no changing my mind about this,” she said, answering my question before I could even ask it.

“But Fluttershy, you becoming a human, it’s like taking away a part of you.  I love you as a pony.  We don’t need to be able to have sex for our relationship to keep going.  I thought you knew that,” I said, starting to get a little emotional about the whole situation.

“Matthew, it’s not about having sex or anything like that, it’s about us.  Something about being human tells me that you will love me even more, and that I will therefore love you even more as well.  I want us to be happy.”

“I’m happy with things the way they are.  Hell, I might not love you as much if you become human.  I fell in love with a pony, not a human,” I said, but then realized that it was a little wrong of me to say that.  I didn’t fall in love with her because she was a pony, I fell in love with her because of who she is.  I fell in love with her shyness, her cuteness, her personality, her kindness, I fell in love with her.  That’s what she understood, and I just told her I only loved her because of her being a pony.  She started to cry.

“No, Fluttershy, I’m sorry, I didn’t mean that.  I didn’t fall in love with you just because you’re a pony.  I fell in love with YOU.  That won’t change, no matter what,” I said.  I took a moment to collect myself.  “Are you sure you want this?  Being a human is much different from being a pony, but I’m sure you’ve taken that into account.”  She was crying less now, and she looked at me.

“Yes, I understand Matthew.  Like I told you, I’ve given this a lot of thought.  If you don’t want me to do this, I can tell Princess Celestia, but please.  I want this, and I think you do too.”  She was right, to a degree.  Her being a human may not be so bad, but I would have to get used to it.  I finally spoke out.

“Alright.  We’ll go to Canterlot and have the Princess turn you into a human.  If it’s really what you want, then I won’t stop you.  I love you no matter what,” I said to her, and she immediately smiled, jumped onto me, and started kissing me.

“Oh thank you Matthew.  I know you won’t regret this.”

“Yeah, I think I know that too.  But hey, don’t you think we should tell the girls.  I mean, they are your best friends.  I think they should know at least.”

“Oh, of course.  I was planning to go talk to them after we were done here.  Do you want to go now?” she asked.  I saw no reason to stay home when we had a big announcement for the others.

“Sure, let’s get them together at the library.  I know Twilight’s home, and I think Rainbow is at Sugarcube Corner with Pinkie.  Hopefully Applejack and Rarity are home as well.”  After I said that, we headed out to gather our friends.

Fluttershy and I gathered the girls in the library.  We told them what Fluttershy was going to do.  Twilight and Rainbow Dash protested, but Fluttershy told them about how this would be a good thing.  She had actually asked the Princess if this would affect her usage of the Element of Kindness.  It wouldn’t.  She would be able to keep her wings and everything.  The girls couldn’t think of anything to argue against her decision.  They all agreed to join us in Canterlot when the next day.  And so we waited for the next day to come.

The train ride to Canterlot was a quiet one.  We all sat on the train quietly, not wanting to talk.  Even Pinkie was silent.  She knew what was going to happen.  Hell, all of the girls knew what was going to happen.  They were going to lose the pony they had come to call their friend.  They would lose her, at least, in physical form.  There was always the option for Fluttershy to be changed back, but not at least for one year.  This was something Celestia had told Fluttershy, that if she was to go through with the change but want to be changed back, Fluttershy would have to wait for one year.  But, Fluttershy seemed pretty sure she wouldn’t want to change back.

We arrived in Canterlot.  It was a sunny day out, which was nice.  We were greeted by a Shining Armor.

“Twily, glad to see you again sis.  Glad to see the rest of you too,” he greeted us.  “The Princess is waiting for you in the castle, we shouldn’t keep her waiting.”  I honestly didn’t mind at the moment.  I wanted to be with the pony Fluttershy for just a while longer, but I wasn’t going to get that.

We arrived at the castle, and Princess Celestia was there waiting for us.

“Hello once again everypony.  Hello to you as well Matthew,” she said.

“Good to see you again Princess,” I said, bowing my head to her.  “So, you’re really going to do this for Fluttershy?  Like, you’re not even going to try to go against her decision?” I asked.  I wasn’t trying to persuade her to not do it, I was just surprised that she actually was willing to do this.  I wanted to know why.

“Matthew, you have shown that you are willing to do anything for Fluttershy, and that is because of the love you share.  Fluttershy has proven to me with this choice that she is also willing to do anything for you, or as she has said, for the both of you.  I see no reason to deny her this change.  But Fluttershy, I will ask one more time.  Are you sure you want to do this?” Celestia asked.

“I’m sure Princess, and nothing will change my mind.”  Fluttershy was so confident about this decision.  I don’t think I had ever seen her be more confident about anything in the time that we had been in our relationship.  She really wanted this.  I couldn’t help but start to tear up a bit.

The Princess nodded to us, and told us to follow her to the main chamber of the castle.  The Princess stood at one end of the room, and Fluttershy stood opposite her.  Our friends stood to the side.  I remained next to Fluttershy.  At least, I would remain there until Celestia did what she was going to do.

I looked at Fluttershy one more time and gave her a smile.  She returned the smile.

“Hey, if something goes wrong, you know I love you, right?” I told her.

“Of course I do, and everything will be fine.  I promise,” she said.  We shared one last kiss before Celestia was ready.  I stood back from Fluttershy.  Celestia charged up her magic.  Her horn started to glow, and after a few more seconds, she released the energy at Fluttershy.

Fluttershy started to float up into the air, and Celestia stopped blasting her with her magic.  I could see Fluttershy, up until the point that the light got so bright we all had to cover our eyes.  After the light stopped shining and we could all see, the pony Fluttershy was gone.  In her place was the most beautiful woman I had ever seen.

Fluttershy was just simply beautiful.  Her hair was still pink, she still had her yellow Pegasus wings, and although I probably shouldn’t write it, she did have a nice rack (hey, I’m sure some of you freaks would want to know, or at least try to imagine it, so why don’t I just tell you?).  Looking past all of that, she was pretty tall, but not as tall as me.  I was about six feet tall.  She looked to be about five feet and maybe nine inches tall.  She had a slim body that was just perfect.  When she finally looked up, I saw her face, her beautiful face.  Her eyes were still that beautiful shade of blue.  Her hair wasn’t as long as when she was a pony, but it was still pretty long.  When she smiled at me, my heart melted.  She wasn’t just beautiful, she was adorable.  She gave me one of those smiles that cute anime girls often give.  She started to blush a bit, which just made her even cuter.  I couldn’t stop the tears.

I looked down to her legs when I spotted something.  Rather, I looked to her thighs.  She hadn’t been wearing clothes as a pony, but now, she was wearing some sort of a toga.  Maybe toga isn’t the right word, but it wasn’t full on clothing.  Maybe you could call it a sheet, I don’t know.  I just know that her right thigh was exposed enough that I noticed her Cutie Mark was still there.  Thank God she didn’t lose it.  I smiled back to her after I was done looking at her Cutie Mark.

“Well, what do you think?” she asked us.  I couldn’t speak, but when I finally managed myself to be able to, I spoke.

“You look… amazing.  I can’t believe I thought this would be a bad idea,” I said, chuckling a bit.  Fluttershy joined in on my laughter.  “Remember all those doubts I had about this?” I asked her.

“Well, yes.  What about them?”

“I think they all just died,” I said, which brought about more laughter, not just from the two of us, but also from the other ponies in the room.  But, foolishly, Fluttershy tried to walk over to me.  She lost her balance and fell to the floor.  I quickly rushed over to her.

“Hey, are you alright?  Don’t try to walk yet, you need to learn, as dumb as that sounds.  You won’t be walking on all fours anymore.”

“I’m fine, and I guess I should have thought about that before trying to walk huh?”

“Yeah, probably.  Don’t worry though, I’ll help you learn.  Actually, I’m kind of the only person who can teach you to walk like a human,” I said.  I was the only human in Equestria, so obviously I had to teach her.

I helped her get up and guided her out of the room, catching her when she stumbled along the way.  A question formed in my mind.

“Hey, can you still fly?” I asked.  She looked at me, then looked to her wings.  She unfolded them and tried to fly, and to my relief, she could indeed fly.  She seemed to have to put more effort due to her added weight from being a human.  She fell to the ground again, but I caught her.

We decided it was time to go.  We thanked the Princess for everything.  She explained that if Fluttershy needed help with something, we only needed to ask.  After that, Fluttershy, the girls, and I, all left for Ponyville.  When we arrived, it was pretty late, so everyone decided that we would all get to learn about the new Fluttershy the next day.  The ponies left to their respective homes, and Fluttershy and I headed to our home.

As we got into bed, Fluttershy started to move her limbs around, trying to get acquainted with all the new movements she could do.  She loved moving her fingers around.  She never had them before.  I smiled at her enthusiasm for her new body.  I really did love this new Fluttershy.  No, it wasn’t a new Fluttershy.  Fluttershy had just changed her look.  The Fluttershy I had fallen in love with was still right there in front of me.

As we started to fall asleep, Fluttershy rested her head on my chest, and I held her close.

“You were right Fluttershy.  I do love you even more now.  Thank you,” I said to her.

“I love you too Matthew, even more so now,” she responded.

She was so innocent right then and there.  She looked at me, and I looked back at her.  We shared our first kiss with the both of us as humans.  It was the greatest kiss of my entire life.  I truly did love Fluttershy, and she loved me just the same.  Everything was finally perfect.