Luna greeted her sister's Student at the front gates to the castle. She'd not seen him since her reintroduction back into society. As such, she could not contain herself.

"Princess Luna, I-Oof!" Dusk was knocked to the ground in an unceremonious fashion. Luna dove for the poor unicorn and managed to harpoon him to the ground.

"Dusk!" she exclaimed, failing to hide her excitement. Dusk was winded and thus appeared unconscious. "OH NO, WE KILLED HIM! DO NOT GO TOWARDS THE LIGHT DUSK SHINE, STAY WITH US!" she began to yell at the peak of her voice, shaking him madly. Dusk could say nothing as his lungs struggled to work under the force of the tackle as well as the constant movement they were suffering. His face turned blue as his head was shaken free of blood. With what little sense of reasoning he had left, he reached a hand to Luna and rested it on her outstretched arm, making her stop her assault.

"Oh, you're alive! Thank goodness. I don't know what I would have done if you'd died." she began to cry into his shirt. Dusk could only manage a groan, which was what he'd been aiming at. He was annoyed.

--Half an hour later--

"Princess, while I appreciate your enthusiasm towards my visit, I'm actually here to see Princess Celestia. I have a rather personal matter I need to discuss with her." Dusk said as he brushed himself off.

"A pity, we would have very much liked to have spent some time with thee. Unfortunately, your visit has been in vain, Dusk Shine. Our sister is not presently in Equestria, she is away negotiating a potential break in the treaty between two rival nations. We do not know when she will be back." said the princess.

"Shit!" Dusk blurted out, throwing his head forward to look ahead. Luna ignored his verbal indecency and continued on as if he'd said nothing.

"Perhaps we could be of some assistance, things could not have changed so much in a thousand years." she offered.

"You'd think so. But I'm afraid that only your sister can help, and no offense, Princess, but she's been at this a lot longer and she'd undoubtedly have the advice I need." he argued.

"Sometimes a fresh but outdated perspective is what's needed, Dusk Shine. The Old ways are always the best ways, tradition breeds happiness." she countered. Her words drove Dusk to surrender to her.

"It's a rather private matter, can we talk about it somewhere secluded?" he asked. Luna nodded and led him to the Throne room. Guards were stationed at strategic points around the room, but were dismissed by the lunar princess.

"Now, what is your trouble, Dusk Shine?" the alicorn asked, taking a seat at her throne. Dusk stood before her, looking for the right words.

"It's a matter of... romantic interest." he began, earning the perked ear of his admirer.

"Oh? And who is this pony you've taken a fancy to? she asked, beginning to look for the slightest hint that she was the subject of his romantic feelings.

"That's the problem, Princess. I don't know." he replied. Luna was slightly confused by his choice of words.

"Some elaboration is required, my friend." she said.

"Well... Over the past few months, I've been developing my friendships with those in Ponyville, and I consider the other Hosts of the Elements of Harmony to be the best friends I ever had, sans Barb of course, she's like a sister to me." he began.

"Yes, and where are you going with this friendship talk, Dusk Shine?" she asked.

"Last night, after Rainbow Dash won the young flyers competition that you and Princess Celestia attended, I visited her home to congratulate her personally."

"Yes, you were her coach prior to the event, if I'm not mistaken. Go on." she said.

"Well, I didn't factor in her past history with others and as I mentioned how proud I was of her, we... entered into a physical relationship." he concluded.

Luna's ears dropped like anchors. "Oh... I see." she said, looking and sounding greatly disappointed. "So you're i-in love with R-r-rainbow Dash then?" she asked. At this point it was just going to be torture for the heart-broken princess.

"That's just it; I don't know. For whatever reason, I don't feel more strongly about her than I do the others. And I was wondering if it was possible for one to be in love with multiple ponies." he said Luna's eyes began to water and she didn't bother hiding them.

"Princess, is something wrong?" Dusk enquired, finally noticing his friend's pain. Luna clutched at her heart with one hand, and cupped her mouth with the other. As Dusk went to kneel down before the Princess to see if he was alright, she threw herself at him, trapping him in her arms and quieting him with her lips. Dusk was stunned as Princess Luna poured her passion towards him into the kiss. He had to admit, it felt nice. An Alicorn's lips were so different to a Pegasus'. Dash's had been rough and unwavering, just like her personality. Luna's however brought on the sense of true love and devotion. Her lips were soft, but powerful, just like her.

As Dusk closed his eyes to allow the sudden invasion of privacy, an image flashed in his mind that brought him back to reality. He quickly pushed the Princess back, startling her into letting him go. While Luna was hurt and dumbstruck, her eyes widened at the taller figure standing right behind her love.

"S-sister..." Luna let out, her veins going cold at the extremely angry look displayed on the Solar Princess' usually expressionless face.

"Dusk, your auditorium, immediately." Celestia said with absolutely bone-chilling and ball-shrivelling calmness. Dusk complied, though not for the reasons Luna would have had she been asked to go somewhere.

--A minute later--

Celestia closed the door behind her and locked it, sealing Dusk and herself in the student's old room/study.

"What happened, how long did you kiss her for?" Celestia began her interrogation, bearing down on the unfaltering Unicorn.

"Nothing happened, she kissed me, and it only lasted a few seconds before I realised what was going on and shoved her away. Don't worry, Luna's not in any danger. The same cannot be said for my friends." Celestia's eyes went wide as her mind ventured to the worst possible scenario.

"What happened?" she said as calmly as she could.

"I slept with Rainbow Dash." he replied.

"But did you feel anything?" Celestia pressed.

"No, nothing more than what I've been feeling for the others." he replied. Celestia decided to inspect the situation She unbuttoned the first few buttons on Dusk's shirt and inspected his scar. She was horrified.

"What is this?! Where'd this other scar come from?" she demanded.

"From my encounter with Nightmare Moon here in the castle." he replied.

"The seal's been damaged, Dusk... you're returning to your old self." she said matter-of-factly. Dusk sighed and stepped back from the princess, buttoning up his shirt again.

"I don't want to go back. But what's worse is that I want to love my friends." he said, looking his teacher in the eye.

"Dusk, we've all spent the past thirteen years pretending that nothing happened. All that will have been in vain if you return to your old self. Unfortunately, I can't risk performing the seal again. It nearly killed you the last time." she said.

"Princess, the problem isn't if you can perform the seal, it's if I want you to. Like I said before, I want to know what love is like, and I can't do that with the seal. I'm sick of pretending. I feel the slightest semblance of shame every time I tell my sister I love her, because she smiles at me and all I see is pain because she knows it's not true."

Celestia closed her eyes and held her hand to her forehead in frustration. She didn't know what to do.

"Dusk, I'm sorry to say that you'll never know what love feels like. You've got a few years at best." she said with as much solemnity as Dusk had emptiness.

"So you know about that then?"

"Of course I do. I gave the doctors explicit instructions to inform me of any problems with your health after you used the Elements of Harmony. I knew you would absorb the residual magic instead of letting it flow out into the others. Even without emotions, you always wanted to help others and protect them. You'd have made an excellent guard had I not taken you as my student." she replied.

Dusk stood still, mentally mulling over the dust on the floor. The place hadn't been touched since he'd left. Celestia knew that he would have never seen the Auditorium again and she wanted to keep it perfectly preserved from the last time he'd been healthy. This room was to be a tribute.

"And why did you choose me as your student? You knew who I was, what I could become." he asked, looking her in the eyes again to find them watering.

"Isn't it obvious? Like my sister, I fall in love with ponies who possess power. But not just for the sake of having power, but for the potential to use it for great things. I hoped against hope that you would not suffer from the effects of the elements. I hoped that for once you would not be predictable and let the others absorb some of the magic, not all of it, but enough so as it wouldn't kill you. I loved you from the moment I saw you, Dusk... I wanted to bring you to the top alongside me. I'd waited for years, but then the incident happened thirteen years ago, and you became this... a shadow of your former self trapped in this emotionless cage. I'd have dismissed you as my student then and there if I hadn't still seen your potential in your eyes, like looking through the keyhole of a locked door to find you still there inside. I knew you still had a chance... but now, everything's breaking apart. You're breaking free from your cage only to live for a few years." her tears stained the wooden floor beneath her, mingling with the dust. Dusk felt that the tears on the ground resembled the final spark of his true self, and like those tears, he would soon dry up and be no more than a small mark on the world.

"You took too many chances with me. You used a broken tool and made it irreparable. I'm dead because you took a chance when you believed I could defeat Nightmare Moon. And now, instead of planning ahead like you used to with my studies, you killed me." he said without bitterness or melancholy. Celestia had never thought of it that way before. She hadn't considered her role in his death. All that time, she believed he'd just failed to be unpredictable, but the truth of the matter was, she knew better than to pit him up against a superior power and she killed him.

Celestia brought her hand to her mouth and stifled a sob. She fell to her knees and grabbed Dusk's shirt with her free hand. The buttons gave way and the scars were revealed to her again like judging eyes, blaming her for what had happened.

"I'm so sorry, Dusk!" she began to bawl, squeezing her eyes shut as she buried her face into his chest. Dusk looked down at her with neutral eyes. Though the seal was designed to shut off all emotions within Dusk's mind, it never truly worked to its full effect. Always, he would have that small semblance of an emotion, like moving away from your home and not really missing it, but finding yourself thinking fondly of it from time to time. At that moment, though his eyes portrayed nothing but neutrality, he felt that niggling feeling, as if he was both mildly irritated after one of Barb and Trixie's arguments and scared like every pony was that one day, a long time from that moment, they would simply cease to live.

Celestia had repeated her apologies for hours on end, but she was forced to stop as guards outside the locked room began to grow nervous about her prolonged absence. She'd had difficulty projecting her voice convincingly, but the guards bought it nonetheless. Another minute had passed between them with a simple hug from the princess. She was nearly adamant about staying latched to him. Both parties knew there was nothing that could be done about Dusk's situation and that it was only a matter of time before he died.

Not wanting to desecrate his own tribute and perhaps his future tomb, Dusk took one of the guest bedrooms. Much smaller but by no means miniscule. The lavender stallion just sat in his rocking-chair, absent-mindedly rocking it as he thought about the day's events.

"You know, I wouldn't be surprised if she just said all that to get you to kill yourself sooner." a voice in his mind said. Dusk closed his eyes momentarily. As he opened them again, his room was darker, almost void of anything beyond himself, the chair and the mirror version of him.

"What do you mean?" Dusk asked. The mirror sighed and snickered at Dusk's apparent naïveté.

"Let me rephraze that; I wouldn't be surprised if she just said that to get you to kill us sooner. Sooner meaning before the seal breaks free." he replied. The mirror version of Dusk leaned forward in his seat.

"Who are you?" Dusk asked.

The other one threw himself back in laughter. "What happened? Did you suddenly cast aside your brain when you realised your life was entirely over? I'm you, you idiot! I'm the real you, the real us. The original Dusk Shine. The one that used to sing with our cousin Vinyl Scratch and play soldier with Gleaming Shield. I'm the life that you wanted, that you miss without actually missing it."

"You're a monster."

"I'm a Pony. That's all I am, that's all I've ever been and I would say that's all I ever will be, but in a few years I'll also be a corpse." the true Dusk began laughing his head off.

"You don't seem terribly worried about that technicality." Dusk commented. The true Dusk stopped laughing and looked at his emotionless counterpart.

"There's a reason for that. I like the word you used to describe it. Because that's all it really is, a technicality; easily fixable." he replied.

"Really? And why haven't I been able to come up with a solution?" Dusk asked.

"Because you don't consider the primary element. Don't worry, I can take it from here." the other Dusk said, going to get up from his seat.

"And what makes you think I'll let you take control? The least I can do for Equestria is prevent myself from becoming a monster again, at any cost." Dusk interrupted.

"Tell me, Dusk... what does a foal do when they don't get their own way? They lash out. But I've been with you every step of the way, considering every lesson taught us. What does an adult do when they don't get their own way? That varies. Some let it go, others look for an alternative means of regression. Me, I found out an alternative means last night." he replied, grinning at himself.

"You mean sex?"

"Ding, ding! Give the guy a medal! That's absolutely correct. Sex does two things; tire you out and make you feel great! Well me anyway, not you, you husk."

"So you have what, five potential stress relievers?" Dusk asked.

"Seven." the real one replied.

"Seven?"

"You're forgetting the princesses. Luna is ignorant of the true situation and the way she looks at us, mirrors our movements whenever we walk together, she's dying for a good time. I'm interested to see the difference between thirteen and a thousand years of pent up aggression. I love a good challenge." the real Dusk replied.

"And what about Princess Celestia, she's not so easily swayed, and she despises you." Dusk asked.

"Celestia is broken, just like us. Your words cut deeper than any blade she's been struck with during her reign. You've cut across the scars left by her sister, ironically enough, exactly like Luna did to you."

"Celestia did not create this scar." Dusk argued.

"The physical one, no, but the seal is a wound that has separated us. It's been an unending hell, screaming at the top of my lungs in your mind and never being heard. And you've always felt something, but it's never been enough to get you motivated. Like the brain, I'm the creative side, and I've been severed. Still in there, but unheard and unused. You are the logical left hemisphere Always working, but never having anything resembling fun. You've suffered too, but you just don't know it." he said.

"Then why are you the only one that wants to become whole?"

"You want it too, you just don't realise it. I heard it come from our own mouth. You want to love the girls. But you can't do that without becoming whole with me, and you know it. Ergo, you want me back so you can become me and feel something when you ride those mares into the next town." The real Dusk had leaped off his rocking chair and had thrown his arms around as if to emphasise the emotions that Dusk could potentially have.

"But I wouldn't be me anymore, I'd be you." he said, leaning back in his rocking chair and holding it back. The real Dusk looked at his logical counterpart.

"You'll be you, and I'll be me. We'll be ourselves, but so much more. You remember the emotions we felt as one, don't you want that again?" The emotional Dusk held out his hand and placed it on his chest, beginning to dig into his scar, which surprisingly lacked the one dealt by Nightmare Moon.

Dusk looked at it as if it were the antidote to all his ailments, yet he had nothing left to live for. He tried to be like the Dusk in front of him and just went with his gut feeling. He brought his hand to his own chest and tore at his scar. The two of them began to shine a bright white, their manes catching flame. As the Emotional one drew closer to the logical one, he spoke.

"I'll show you, and the others that I'm not a monster, not anymore."

And with that, Dusk awoke, his eyes still closed. He smelled the air around him and let out a big sigh. When his eyes opened, they were glowing a reddish violet.

"Time for the sexy sciences." he said, clapping his hands together and rubbing them before rising out of his chair.

Luna paced back and forth in her chambers, more confused than when Celestia had told her about the cessation of executions. She felt Dusk return the kiss, but pushed away at the last second, he was almost hers. What had happened? She scratched her head before grabbing one of Dusk's collected bedsheets and ripping into it out of frustration.

"He didn't really like us. He saw us as everypony else does. We are... still just Nightmare Moon." she whimpered as she sat out on her window looking up at the moon.

"Are you sure that's such a bad thing?" asked the voice of Dusk. Luna would have fallen off the edge had Dusk not surprised her further by wrapping his arms around her. She fell backwards but was stopped by the surprisingly strong arms of the pony she loved. "I always thought Nightmare moon had hips that put your sister to shame. She was smokin' hot. Just as you are, my princess." he added.

"We thought knocking was still customary these days, Dusk Shine." she said with slight anger in her voice.

"And we believed after seeing the way you mauled our bedsheets that you wouldn't let us in." he replied, leaning in to kiss her neck. Luna shuddered at the touch and the sound.

"A-are you mocking our speech Dusk?" she accused.

"If I were, would I be doing this as well?" he asked as he slid a hand over Luna's left breast She gasped at the slightly rough touch of the pony she'd pined over.

"Dusk, what has come over you?!" she demanded, shoving him off. Dusk allowed this and took a few steps back, giving her her space.

"Your... wordless confession earlier today surprised me. Now that I've had time to think about it properly, I came back to make it up to you. I did push you rather hard, after all." Dusk knew exactly what to do. She loved him, but was hurting from the events earlier today. He was offering her a bit of bait and all she needed to do was take it.

Luna looked at the hand outstretched before her and her eyes widened. This was her chance. Without a moment's hesitation, she took his hand and felt herself pulled into his body, encased in both his arms. This was it She wanted this more than anything. She forced herself on him, reaching up to kiss him. Unlike before, he returned the kiss with vigor. She got the sense that he was feeding off of her love like a Changeling. This idea festered in her mind and she shoved him away.

"We knew this was too good to be true! You're a Changeling aren't you?!" she began to scream at him. Dusk raised a brow.

"Nope. I'm a hundred percent myself, Luna. How else would I have known about the encounter before?" he asked.

"That could have been you too! Maybe Dusk never truly came here!"

"If I were a Changeling, would I have pushed you away and denied myself sustenance?" he asked.

"Changelings are crafty, this situation isn't beyond their mental capacity." she replied. Dusk knew he was being tested. Were he a Changeling, he would have been insulted and would have undoubtedly flinched.

"Would you have settled for a Changeling version of me?" he asked.

"What?!"

"Because I don't think even a Changeling could do what I do. I was always unique, I had the potential to be Celestia's equal, and possibly successor. I won't pretend to know all her plans for me, but there must be a reason she even has students. So would a Changeling do me justice, Luna? They'd undoubtedly be able to act better than I could hope to, but would you see through it as easily as you think you saw through me?" Luna was becoming confused. He was helping her confirm her suspicion in one way, but completely diminishing it in another No Changeling could or would do that. They'd deny the very thought of being what they were exactly as the real one would.

"How can you prove to us that you are the real Dusk Shine?" she asked. Dusk grinned at her and snapped his fingers. Everything in the room shuddered like an earthquake had struck in an instant.

"A Changeling can't use magic through their hands. They need their horns, like every other unicorn, even Starswirl the Bearded." he replied.

Luna needed no more convincing. She fell back into his arms and sighed.

"We're sorry... We suppose we just need to get to know you better." she said. Dusk smiled as he held her tightly.

"We've got all night." he replied, turning her to her bed and letting her down gently. She wrapped a hand around the back of his neck and gently slid it along the side, letting it fall to her side. She surrendered completely to him as he lifted her legs up and her night gown fell back onto her stomach, revealing her humorously night themed undergarments.

"I see Celestia took you shopping." he said, addressing the underwear with a finger tracing along the crescent moon just above her clitoris. She blushed as she gasped.

"She also got us a pair of panties with writing on them. We don't get the joke, but she said anypony would laugh if they had the chance to see them." she replied.

"Really? What did they say?"

"On the front, it said: "I'll do anything for love". On the back it said: "But I won't do that"." she replied. Dusk snickered and buried his head into her chest, trying not to laugh so loud as to attract the attention of the guard. "Please explain it to us?" she begged as if she'd just asked him to take her. Dusk smiled as he rose from her bosom and sat beside her.

"It refers to the two Primary means of sexual intercourse. The traditional method known as vaginal, which we're going to do," he said, causing Luna to blush as he mentioned his plans for her. "And the recently accepted but still strange anal sex." he concluded.

Luna seemed confused. "Anal? But the anus isn't a reproductive organ, there'd be no purpose to it." she commented.

"I understand your viewpoint, and never took an interest in it myself. But it's often used as a means to ensure reproduction never occurs, as some ponies do not wish to have offspring." he replied.

"Such a shame. We would give almost anything to be able to reproduce. Sadly, we lost that privilege during our exile to the moon. We'd rather not speak of it." she said. Dusk nodded.

"I understand." he said. Luna turned to him.

"Yes, you do, don't you? Only you could ever understand us. Celestia told us of your strangeness compared to the other ponies and we feel that we are linked in that sense." she said, leaning forward. Dusk said nothing on the matter. He was certainly strange, of that there was no doubt. And he did desire a link between himself and Luna, but he wanted it to be more than a link, he wanted a web between himself and those he loved, both the princesses and the girls back in Ponyville.

"We love you Dusk Shine." she said, daring to throw it out there for him to catch.

"I love you too, Luna. But I can't love just you alone. Friendship is new to me and I've developed feelings for the others also. I wish I knew what I could do." he said, growing sad as he spoke. Even with emotions he was still half-lying. While he spoke the truth, he wasn't sad about his feelings towards others.

Luna, being the inexperienced romanticist fell for his half-lie and offered him a way out.

"There was once a stallion who came to us with a similar problem. Celestia and I resolved to let him be with those he loved and to marry both with equality in mind. What became of them, we are unsure. It was shortly before our exile. In short, we are willing to... share you with your other loves, on the condition that you do not stray from those five and provided they are willing to do the same as we have." she said. Dusk had won. Luna had granted him the means to be with all of those he wanted, all for the sake of her love for him. He couldn't help but grin as he threw himself upon her.

"I promise, my love." he said with the deep and dark kind of voice that the mares appeared to love, proven by Luna's twitching of the ears and her sudden rolling onto her stomach.

"We have delayed for too long, Dusk... begin when you are ready." she said as if to order him. Dusk clapped his hands together rubbing them.

"With pleasure, your majesty." he said in the same voice. As he positioned himself over her, his face entered the shadows and his eyes turned from the usual amethyst to crimson.

Celestia thought she'd heard something coming from her sister's room. While she was in no mood to entertain a silly tantrum if that was indeed what it was, she couldn't abandon her sibling duty on that reason alone. She threw herself out of her bed, abandoning the tissues she'd been using since she'd retired for the day. The guards stood at attention at either side of her doorway, ready to obey her orders. She ignored them and left them stationed there. She marched with purpose over to the other side of the hallway.

"Guard, has anypony entered this room after my sister?" she asked the Night guard stationed outside the room. The guard saluted the princess.

"No, Princess Though I did hear her throwing what could only be described as a tantrum earlier, but that was close to half an hour ago." he replied. Princess Celestia looked at the door and raised an eyebrow at it as if she were judging Luna over the tantrum. The door failed to give her any sort of answer.

"You're dismissed." she said. The guard saluted once more and left the older Princess to her devices. Celstia calmed herself down in order to face her sister Two unstable Princesses would not help to fix either mood. She took a deep breath and exhaled. As she opened the door, the waft of sexuality assaulted her nose.
"Luna I hope you're not playing with those bedsheets aga- WHAT IN THE NAME OF ALL THAT'S PONY!!!!" she screamed at the top of her lungs as she saw the sight before her. Luna was stark naked with her ass raised in the air while a red-eyed Dusk Shine fucked her silly.

"Oh, bugger!" Dusk let out as he spotted the elder princess, and heard her screaming. Luna took no notice of her older sister as she was enjoying the effect Anal seemed to have on her. "Luna, I forgot to mention, your sister's one of the ponies too, is that alright?" he asked. Luna just continued to moan for a moment before answering.

"That's fine, just don't stop this!" she cried out. Dusk wasn't sure whether to keep going in front of Celestia or disappoint his current partner and stop. So he thought of the first thing that came to mind.

"Celestia, glad you're here, come join us and shut the door, it's cold." he mentally smacked himself after he'd heard what he'd just said.

Celestia was somewhat confused. Why was Dusk having sex with Luna? The smell played havoc with her mind as she had just started her Estrus cycle. Dusk was supposed to be emotionless, he wouldn't actively take action towards Luna... unless.

"Oh shit!" she cried, backing into Luna's cupboard. "You're back, you're Dusk again!" she began to panic. Dusk huffed.

"What gave me away?" he asked, groaning as he plunged deep into Luna's ass. The lunar princess cried out in pleasure as she felt Dusk's juices fill her up. She was on the verge of unconsciousness and had been leaking from her vagina since the beginning. A thousand years had made her extremely randy.

Dusk leaned over Luna and pulled her mane aside to kiss her neck. As he left her on the bed, he approached Celestia. "Was it the eyes? The smile on my face, your sister rolling her eyes to the back of her head as she enjoyed what I believe you've imagined for... quite some time now?" he asked, pinning her to the wall. Celestia was so confused. Between the smell, her urges and the fear that Dusk's return had inspired in her, she didn't know what to do. This just wasn't her day.

"Do you hate me?" she asked. Dusk raised a brow at her, smiling.

"You seriously just asked that question, didn't you? Do I hate you? No, I don't hate you! You've only fucked me over time and time again!" he growled at her. He took some small amount of satisfaction in her sadness, but he had other motives.

"I'm sorry." she whimpered. Dusk relaxed his expression, his eyes changing from red to their usual colour in the light from the doorway.

"Earlier today, you confessed your love to me. I truly despised you until you told me why you did what you did. I realised that like Luna, you just couldn't let me go. So all my hatred just fell off me, much like your tears. So, no, I don't hate you. I love you too. But as I explained to Luna, I love all the mares that have been in my life save immediate family and their girlfriends Even I wouldn't enact upon that kind of love." he said. Celestia only heard him mention that he loved her. All else just faded away.

"You asked me to join you... I'd love to." she said, throwing herself at him. Dusk was prepared. He'd played on both princesses' feelings and had emerged victorious with two out of seven loves under his thumb. Celestia found Luna waiting patiently with a smile on her face.

"You are in for a treat, sister, Dusk Shine is amazing." the dark alicorn commented, earning a stroke of the mentioned Stallion's fingers along her still sensitive sex.

Celestia watched with great jealousy as Dusk seemingly ignored her. She knew he didn't really love her back. How could he after what she'd done.

Her woes were put to rest as she felt a hand gently push her onto her stomach beside Luna who just lay where she was, eager to receive whatever Dusk believed she could take. As Luna gasped from something Celestia failed to see, she in turn whimpered out of jealousy. It was after her outcry that she began to receive more frequent attention. She squirmed with desire as Dusk teased her with the slightest brushing of his fingers against her clitoris. It was agonising! In her Estrus cycle, she was gagging for a good ploughing. Her mind caused her to despise her sister for having him first. After all it was her that had taken him under her wing, her that had desired him and had waited for him to come of age, her that had sacrificed her desires so he could continue living, even if he were to be a shadow of his former self. While Luna only had to wait a few months after being isolated for a millennia, knowing nothing about the stallion that had stolen both their hearts. Did Celestia not deserve to be taken as her sister was?

Once again, as if Dusk had read her mind, she felt a finger slide easily into her dripping folds. She bit the bedsheets, realising too late that they were Dusk's old sheets and reeked of his scent. She went wild. She lifted her bottom into the air, flicking her tail aside. She would offer everything to Dusk then and there. Just please, let him have her!

Celestia was rewarded with the remaining four fingers, venturing further in. As his hand stretched at her folds and her internal walls, she covered her mouth. He wasn't stopping. She threw her arms forward gripping the corners of the mattress. She didn't want to have the guards come in and end the heaven that was Dusk, so she agonisingly refrained from screaming.

"It's okay, my love. The sound barrier I erected would prevent even your royal Canterlot voices from reaching the guards outside. But perhaps I should I remove the barrier make the situation that much more thrilling Cry out and they'll see their Princesses in such a blissfully embarrassing situation." Dusk teased. Celestia and Luna both began to pant at the thought of being watched by their faithful guard.

"I wonder if any of them would join in? Surely most of them have entertained the thought of winning your attention at some point or another. Just imagine it, you two, me and an audience of your servants all enjoying one of Luna's most memorable nights: The night I returned to my old self, The beginning of Celestia's Estrus cycle, and the anniversary of my becoming your student, Princess." Dusk spoke in the irresistible voice that had Luna swooning. Neither of the two mares could take it. Together, they felt a rush of ecstasy and as Dusk timed his final thrust perfectly, the force of their orgasms had them both squirting past his arms. They both screamed in their Royal voices, breaking the mirrors, glasses and windows in the room.

Dusk knew that that wasn't it. It always felt great to have a few more thrusts after they peaked. The sensitivity sent them twitching like they'd been electrified.

Unable to move, Celestia felt Dusk moving her into position. She watched as she was positioned below a spread Luna. Dusk turned her face so she was looking upward.

"What's going on Dusk?" Celestia asked.

"Luna tried something new, I thought you might like to as well. After all, you're all about equality." he replied. The Sun princess heard her sister moan as Celestia was pushed slightly upward. She went to move her head to realise that her horn had been placed in her sister's anus.

"Uh, Dusk, isn't this a little extreme?" she asked. Dusk didn't reply with words. He wet his index finger and quickly jabbed Celestia's anus with it.

"HELLO! THANK YOU FOR COMING!" she called out. Her surprise caused her to move upward, pushing against Luna who moaned in pleasure. Dusk just chuckled. and removed his finger, much to Celestia's chagrin. She was rewarded afterward by a hard and ready cock which wasted no time with niceties. Celestia was shoved upward, her horn being swallowed by her sister's ass. All Celestia did was gag as the pleasure filled her senses. Dusk shifted closer so that he was truly pressing Celestia into her sister who pushed against the bedpost to get more of the horn inside of her.

He cupped one hand over Celestia's left breast while the other pinched and rolled her clitoris between the thumb and index finger.

"OH YES! YES! YES!! FUCK US LIKE THAT!" Celestia began to scream, dropping into Luna's vocabulary. Dusk thrust harder and faster, earning uncontrollable moans from the others. Dusk pulled out from Celestia's ass and went straight to her vagina. He moved the hand that was playing with it to her ass and began to finger it with two fingers. Celestia lost control of her legs and began to push herself upward, practically piercing her sister's bliss filled anus as all three finished at once. As per Dusk's plan, he came inside of Celestia, sending her into blissful happiness as her juices mingled with his. At the same time, she was covered by Luna's cum which had squirted out all over her body A great deal hit the vital areas, namely her face, breast, and abdomen. A few drops landed on Dusk's still thrusting cock and became one with the mingling juices within Celestia.

Celestia was white-eyed, as was Luna. Dusk chuckled as the two of them relaxed, unconscious after the pounding. He pulled Celestia free from her sister and placed her down beside the gleeful night princess. With that, he threw the surprisingly unstained blanket over them and kissed each of them with equal passion.

"I promised myself I would prove I wasn't a monster... But it seems being one in the bed is exactly what's needed in order to fulfil the goals required." he whispered, going over to the study counter to write a pair of letters.

Luna yawned as she awoke. Her entire body was sore from a night well spent. The sunlight shone in her eyes as she opened them, but she was surprised to find Celestia just waking up herself.

"Good morning sister, we did not know you were able to raise the sun in your slumber." Luna noted. Celestia blinked a few times and turned around to face her sun.

"I can't. And I didn't wake up until just now." she replied. The two princesses went to rush out of bed but were stopped as they felt something give way between their legs. They stared at each other and threw the covers off to find a pair of identical notes wedged in their marehoods. The two alicorns screamed in fright at first, both going to rip the notes out. After the initial surprise had died down, Luna went for her note and opened it.

Dear girls,

I don't know which of you will wake up first, so I wrote these letters for each of you. I wanted to thank you both again for that amazing night and at the risk of sounding like a pretentious ass, I'll accept your unspoken thanks as you read this. The two princesses scoffed to each other as they read the letter.

I've headed back to Ponyville as I believe I have some unfinished business regarding earning the love of five more mares there as well as continuing my research into the magic of Friendship. And don't worry, as Luna and I agreed, I will not start adding to the pile of mares I fall in love with. Those five and yourselves are the only ones for me, after all, it's been a hellish thirteen years, right Celestia? (Don't cry if you read that part, it's a joke, I still hold nothing against you) I love you both and can't wait to see you again soon. Get the Auditorium ready because I have a few ideas regarding a ruler and a telescope.

Your student, lover and not-a-changeling (Luna),

Dusk Shine.

P.S. I forgot to mention that the last few bedsheets that were sent to Luna were actually Trixie and Barb's so yeah. It's good to be back!

Celestia and Luna's eyes widened as they read the last part. They took one quick glance at the bedsheets and leaped off them.

"EW!" Luna screamed.

"Aw, fuck!" Celestia groaned.

Dusk approached the Apple orchard in time to see Big Macintosh pointing out the remaining half of the field to his sister. Applejack's jaw hit the dirt in surprise and Dusk knew what had happened.

As the mare fainted, Dusk approached, addressing Big Mac.

"Finally gave up, did she?" he asked.

"Eeyup." replied Mac as he prepared to help his sister out.

"Wait, let me do it. I need to speak with her when she wakes up anyway." he said. Big Mack shrugged it off and left Dusk to his own devices.

--some hours later--

Applejack woke up to find the stars glimmering through the loose boards in her family's barn. She'd slept the remainder of the day away. She felt the straw beneath her body and feared the worst. She'd been relieved of her responsibility.

"Oh no!" she said, beginning to sit up. She stopped as she saw the other half of the field's apples in dozens of apple buckets before her. What surprised her the most was how Dusk sat on the edge of one, his head resting on his hand which rested on his knee. He'd been watching her sleep. She hoped to Celestia that she hadn't said anything while she was out.

"You know, you and Rainbow Dash snore exactly the same way. It took me a while to figure out that the sound was her relaxing on a cloud, given the fact that it always came from somewhere different every day. But imagine my surprise when I see you passed out like you'd taken a coconut to the head, and that same sound, albeit with a different tone, comes out of your mouth." he said Applejack couldn't help but blush. She always hated the fact that she snored, but nopony knew that.

"What's yer point?" she asked slightly defensively.

"No point, just making idle conversation; that's what friends do, right?" he asked. Applejack never thought a smile could be frightening, but a smile from Dusk was like seeing a Cheshire grin in the Everfree forest.

"Did you buck all these apples?" she asked. Dusk snapped his fingers and an apple floated into his hand. He took a bite from it and took a few moments to chew it and swallow.

"I picked them. There was a lot of science that went into the process. I made a mental map of where they all were and just pulled with my magic. I may have missed one or two, but they'll just be a little surprise for the CMC tomorrow. They wanted to go forest hunting, but I convinced them to try orchard hunting first, you know, the basics. To answer your question, yes, I did all this for you. I believe that's also what friends do." he said.

"So... we're cool?" she asked. Dusk tossed the apple to her which she caught without thinking. The apple zapped her, one of Dusk's magical charges surging through her body.

"We're cool." he said, smiling again. "But as for the rest of Ponyville... I suggest you board up your room for the next few weeks. Don't worry though, you've still got a couple of days until the mass sickness wears off."

"Oh no!" she said, hanging her head. Dusk just chuckled, unnerving Applejack for the second time in under a minute.

"Don't worry. I'll make them see reason. After all, the pros outweigh the cons when it comes to you." he said. Applejack blushed red and she wished now more than ever that she had her Stetson with her.

"W-where's mah hat?" she asked, stuttering slightly.

"At home, being washed. You wore it and yourself out Looked more like a hood when I picked it up." he replied.

"Thank ya, Dusk... for everything. And Ah'm sorry for what Ah said to ya yesterday, Ah didn't mean it." she said.

"You meant every word, Applejack. You're the host of the Element of Honesty, you always speak your heart."

"And look where that got me." she argued.

"It got you some shut-eye, the orchard is next to empty, and you have somepony standing before you who wants to be your friend. So tell me honestly, how do you feel about me?" he said.
Applejack looked up at him and stared into his Amethyst eyes. She knew exactly how she felt, but she couldn't put it into words. She tried for the closest thing to it and found what she was looking for. With a deep breath, she looked him straight in the eye and...

"Ah dunno how to say how ah feel about ya." she replied. Dusk smiled again and approached her. He touched her ever so gently. Applejack felt a jolt of magic around the area he'd touched her and blushed as he pushed her back down into the hay.

"Well let's find out How far will you let me go? And don't worry, I'll stop when you want me to... if you want me to." he said, kneeling down before her. Applejack lost control of her breathing.

"Woah now, this ain't some cruel joke or nothin' is it? Cause if it is, then well played... ah won't upset ya again, sugarcube alright?" she asked, growing nervous. She caught her breath as he leaned forward and kissed the base of her neck. Her eyes turned to discs as she felt him exploring her upper body. She was uncomfortable before, but she tried to relax afterward with little difficulty, her body wouldn't stop shivering. Dusk had moved from her neck to her navel. She tried to pull her stomach in, but that didn't stop him. She gasped as she felt his tongue push against her belly button.

"Y-yer serious then? Ya wanna do this... a-a-after what Ah said yesterday?" she asked. Dusk stopped his teasing of her body and met Applejack's flustered face.

"I have to say before I go any further..." he told her the situation regarding his love for her and the others. Applejack listened intently.

"But I'm more worried about upsetting you, Applejack. While I've explained the situation to you, I know that you're very traditional when it comes to family and relationships." he said. Applejack took a moment to process everything she'd been told.

"Well that's true. But Ah also believe that for the right pony, Ah'd share him if he was in that kinda situation. Don't worry about me Sugarcube Just please, finish what ya started." she said, leaning back into the hay. Dusk smiled and brushed his hands along Applejack's bare torso, stopping just below where her short flannelette shirt started. He dragged his hands back down once before brushing them up again, This time, he curled his fingers under the fabric and pushed forward, getting a firm grip on her breasts. Applejack gasped as she felt him touch her. She'd only ever experienced sex once before and it was horrible, but she wasn't dissuaded. Dusk's movements and intensity with which he grabbed her was different in every aspect to her first time. Dusk was gentler, more sensual, more passionate.

"Ah love ya, Dusk." Applejack moaned without thinking. She covered her mouth and looked at him. All she saw was him smiling at her.

"I love you too, AJ." he replied as he slid his hands down to her legs. He got a firm grip on her jeans and began to pull them down. Applejack lay back and let him have his way with her. She experienced his fingers and their expert skill. This was not his first time. That was okay; experience bred more pleasure.

"Ah can't stand it, Dusk... hurry up and buck me like an apple tree." she begged, her breathing becoming erratic. Dusk chuckled and reached over to grab an apple.

"I like a good challenge." he said, drawing her attention to the apple. AJ smiled and spread her legs to allow him access. Dusk managed to insert the apple with ease, but it was still visible.

"It's taken up most of the room. Ah can't fit much more in, Dusk." she told him, Dusk leaned over and kissed Applejack, distracting her as he suddenly pushed against the apple. Applejack threw her head back and gasped loudly as the apple was pushed to the very back. She moaned as her partner began thrusting, smacking the hard apple against her cervix.

"A little more Dusk, Ah'm almost there!" she said to him. Dusk grinned and thrust harder, pounding against the apple. It began to break under the tightening walls of AJ's marehood and the battering pressure of Dusk's cock. It wasn't long before the two found pleasure in Apple bucking barnyard style. The apple gave way, giving both parties a sense of achievement. The apple was cold, but the semen from Dusk was hot and sticky. The combination of both sent her through the roof.

"YEE~HAW!!!" she cried out fortunately, Dusk had the sense to erect a sound barrier around the barn like he had with Luna's room.

"God, I love Earth ponies!" Dusk exclaimed, keeping his spent cock inside of AJ as he leaned down and tongued her.

"Ya'll cum again now, ya hear?" Applejack asked as they broke the kiss.

Author's Note

Oh god, as I began writing the sex scene between Dusk and Luna, the South Park song; 'Uncle Fucker' came up. lol!

Okay, so this is the sex chapter, because it's one part emotion and two parts fucking. So happy fapping, my friends!