Fluttershy has always been sweet and kind to all of Ponyville. She's known the residents for awhile now and they know her. She hadn't had to meet anypony new in a long time. But when a young stallion takes up residence across the street from her, she finds herself once again hiding inside. Usually that's because she's shy. But she feels even more insecure around this stallion. She thinks she's in love. However this new guy has a mission, and what could have have been easy now begins a dagger swinging feud between two stallions, and Fluttershy's first love just might be her last.