A Hearth's Warming Eve to Remember

by Inthend

Rating: mature
Tags: Rarity, Sex, Twilight Sparkle, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Romance
Length: 2888

Rarity and Twilight have the best Hearth's Warming Eve together.

Rarity and Twilight have the best Hearth's Warming Eve together, if you know what I mean......

(Edited for a friend who keeps changing her name.)

Original can be found here.

Published 2013-04-24 18:50:02 UTC
Last updated 2013-04-24 18:50:02 UTC

A Hearth's Warming Eve to Remember

Twilight sat up as she skimmed through her book on ancient myths and legends. The adolescent dragon at the foot of her bed had once again settled down into a peaceful rest, his purple tail flicking back and forth lazily. The sound of his soft breathing filled the air with a sort of merry ambiance that would every now and then be interrupted by a tiny snore. Twilight peered up as a quick shiver nipped at her hide. The room seemed to grow chilly all of a sudden. Careful not to disturb the little dragon, she stepped over to close the window with a soft click before settling back onto her bed. A warm smile crept across her face as she looked down at her assistant. With a faint glow of purple magic, she pulled his blanket up to his chin when a faint chiming suddenly rang through the library. The clock had just struck nine - it was time to leave. She gently left a kiss on the dragon’s forehead while grabbing her scarf and neatly wrapping it around her neck. The door let out a shrill creak with her exit, causing her to wince and look back at Spike cautiously, but the intrusion hadn’t seemed to bother him. A heavy sigh of relief hung in the air as the unicorn cantered off to Rarity's.

The circular room was alive with an assortment of sewing supplies and multicolored fabrics fluttering about as Rarity carefully organized everything into their respective bins. Everything would be clean and tidy for once. Finally having completed her task, the unicorn gave a triumphant shake of her mane before trotting into Sweetie Belle's room with her head held high. Then the image of the unruly sight burned in her eyes. Her sister’s room was disgusting. Again! Rarity sighed, pulling her hoof down over her face. She had just cleaned it this morning! The little urchin must have made the mess while digging for clothes and what-not in preparation for spending the night at Applebloom’s. The irritation stewed in the back of her mind as she began to clean Sweetie Belle’s room, but it soon vanished with her usual routine and she found herself humming a familiar little tune while she worked. Suddenly a rustling startled her out of her monotonous efforts for a moment. She waited for it again but there was nothing. No noise. Nothing. Rarity shrugged and set to work again. When she had finally finished, she sat back and smiled. Everything was in order. She couldn't wait to see Sweetie Belle's happy face when she saw her clean room.

Rarity trotted out of her sister’s room with an exhausted sigh when she heard the noise again. It was like a faint rustling, only louder this time. But as quickly as it appeared, it was gone again. She dismissed it for the second time and continued on her way to her room. All that shopping and cleaning in preparation for Hearth’s Warming Eve had really put a damper on her body and all she wanted to do right now was lay down and relax. With a pleased groan she climbed into bed and nestled down under the covers. She could feel as Opal jumped onto the bed too, settling down next to her with a rumbling purr. Rarity giggled and patted Opal on the head. The silken white cat responded with another torrent of deep purrs, and soon both of them were asleep.

Rarity woke with a start when a shudder reverberated throughout the entire house in the middle of the night. The rustling was back. Except this time it didn’t go away. The floorboards creaked eerily as the unicorn tentatively hopped out of her bed and slowly searched all around the house. No matter where she looked she couldn’t seem to pinpoint the source of the noise though. The reflection of the clock on the wall suddenly caught her attention. It was only ten o’clock. She hadn't been asleep for very long. With a deep yawn she sleepily strode into the den where her ever-so-pretty tree twinkled from the corner. She, Spike, and Sweetie Belle had put up and decorated the whole thing together. A warm feeling radiated through her every time she was near it. She could also remember putting together each and every present that glistened beneath the tree, with Spike's help of course. Then she saw one she didn't recognize. It was rather large too. Had Spike made this one for her? Her curious hoofsteps echoed through the house as she carefully looked for a tag. The ribbon appeared as if it had been clumsily tied together and the paper was all mashed and crumpled. Rarity reached out with her magic to slowly tear away at the wrappings. If it was from Spike, Celestia only knows what could be in it. She made sure she was a safe distance away when she finally removed the lid. Then she waited expectantly, but nothing happened. With a sigh of relief she cantered up to the box only to have a figure burst out of it right in front of her. Rarity let out an ear-piercing scream and started to dash away when a familiar voice called out to her.

"Wait! Rarity! It's just me! Twilight!"

Rarity stopped and turned around. "Twilight?" she asked.

Sure enough, Twilight sat there in the box with a playful smile spanning her face. The white unicorn walked over to her and frowned.

"Twilight? Why on earth did you scare me like that! You nearly gave me a heart attack!"

"I was only trying to surprise you…" Twilight mumbled half-heartedly.

Rarity gave her friend an understanding hug. "And that you did dearie." she said sighing. "Now how about some tea? I think we could both use some after that."

Twilight nodded and the fashionista trotted off into the kitchen. Twilight glanced about the room and couldn’t help but remark on the tidiness of the place. Everything was so organized and pretty.

‘Just like Rarity...’ she thought to herself.

Rarity came back a few moments later with two cups of hot apple cinnamon tea which she promptly placed on the table next to the couch. The two mares sat eagerly sipping their tea before Rarity noticed that Twilight was being unusually quiet.

"So, what brings you here?" Rarity asked curiously.

Twilight looked up at her friend’s face. Her gorgeous face. Rarity's question had sliced through her thoughts like a knife and the only thing Twilight could do was regretfully shake her head. Her cheeks grew warm with the realization that she had been staring at her face this entire time.

"Ummm....I just thought I would stop by." Twilight answered, her voice quivering slightly.

"That was not just 'stopping by!'" Rarity exclaimed. "You didn't go through the trouble of wrapping yourself into a present and waiting for me to open it for nothing! There has to be a reason."

Rarity was right. There was a reason. But Twilight didn't feel comfortable saying it out loud. So she just responded with:

"Because you're my best friend."

Rarity raised an eyebrow. "Then why didn't you do it for another pony? Why me?" Rarity asked.

‘Because I love you.’ Twilight thought guiltily.

Rarity edged closer and smiled.

"Is there something you want to tell me?" she asked provocatively.

Twilight felt her face go hot. Should she tell her?

“…”

"You like me don't you?" Rarity pushed with a keen grin.

“…”

"Twilight?" Rarity prodded, her smile growing bigger.

“…”

"Answer me!" Rarity sang.

"Alright! Alright!" Twilight shouted. "I love you Rarity! I love you with all my heart! I have for a while but I haven’t had the guts to tell you! And plus, I never thought a pretty mare like you would ever fall for a book-loving nerd like me!" Twilight's eyes went wide and she clamped her hoof over her mouth.

Rarity's smile was gone. She had tears in her eyes now.

"I know, I know. It's disgusting. I bet you don't even want to be my friend anymore." Twilight started to shy away.

Rarity didn't respond.

"I guess I’ll just lea-" Twilight was cut off by the warm sensation of Rarity’s lips pressed against hers in a passionate kiss.

She was shocked at first, the new experience was bewildering but then she just went with it. She even found herself leaning forward to keep the embrace when Rarity finally broke the kiss and smiled at her.

"I love you too." She whispered quietly.

"Then why were you crying?" Twilight cocked her head to the side.

"Because I had to put you through so much pain. I should have brought it up earlier." Rarity responded.

"It's okay, Rare. That's in the past now." Twilight beamed.

Rarity smiled again and pulled Twilight in for another kiss. This one was longer, and Twilight had to pull away just to get some air.

"Let's take this into my room." Rarity beckoned seductively.

Twilight's eyes went wide and she nodded. The two headed into the bedroom and Rarity threw Twilight onto the bed the instant they stepped inside. The white mare followed her friend’s projection, hopping onto her and kissing her hard. She could feel the unicorn’s tongue grazing across her lips, begging for entrance. Frankly, she was surprised that Twilight even knew about French kissing. Rarity opened her mouth a tiny bit, their lips still locked together, as she let Twilight explore her. The sensation sent shivers down her spine and she returned the favor, slowly sticking her tongue into her friend’s mouth to explore it just the same. She could feel Twilight’s moan rattle through her mouth. The two let their tongues dance a bit before pulling away and gasping for breath. Rarity wasted no time in planting a series kisses all the way down Twilight's neck and chest. Twilight moaned and arched her back as the kisses landed across her tummy. Rarity kept going down until she got to her hind legs. It took surprisingly little effort to pry Twilight's legs open. The white unicorn licked her lips eagerly.

"May I?" Rarity asked politely.

Twilight nodded. Rarity flicked her tongue across the unicorn’s clit, causing her to moan with pleasure. Twilight couldn’t help but grab a nearby pillow and squeeze it hard as her breathing quickly escalated to panting and her moans filled the room. Rarity could feel her friend’s orgasm getting closer and with a sly grin suddenly stopped. The librarian let out a frustrated sigh as Rarity climbed on top of her, straddling her face with her legs. Twilight smiled and nodded, knowing precisely what to do. The white mare slowly lowered herself down onto Twilight's mouth who immediately began eating her out. The unicorn’s tongue shot out into her friend, making her gasp and then moan loudly. Rarity never expected Twilight to be so good. Rarity's pants began to increase to the point that Twilight could feel she was close, so she stopped. The white mare gave an agitated grunt and climbed off Twilight to kiss her again, harder this time. The taste of their bodies mixed and swirled together in their mouths.

Rarity pulled away suddenly to search for something under her bed. A few seconds later she pulled it out and opened it. It was a box - filled with an assortment of different sex toys. Twilight felt the area between her legs quiver.

"A-ha!" Rarity exclaimed pulling out a double-sided dildo.

Twilight's eyes grew bigger by the second as Rarity climbed back onto the bed with the beastly object. Rarity paused at the frightened expression on her friend’s face.

"You're a virgin?" she asked blankly.

"Mmhmm." Twilight said, blushing.

"Nothing to be ashamed of dearie!" Rarity said with a smile. "I'll make sure to go easy on ya!"

Twilight only nodded. Rarity slowly pushed the dildo into herself, letting out a soft moan which made the librarian a little more eager to try it. The fashionista slowly pushed the other end of the dildo into her friend who let out a quiet cry as a few tears slid down her cheeks. Rarity frowned.

"I'm sorry hun. I wish there was an easier way..."

She gave Twilight a few moments to adjust and then began to gently thrust it back and forth, her body automatically pumping with the motion. Twilight also began to thrust, taking it deeper and deeper each time until the two were thrusting and moaning in unison. Suddenly Twilight slammed her hips into the dildo even harder, causing Rarity to absently scream with pleasure. The fashionista almost came right there, but she stopped herself just in time, quickly pulling out the dildo. Twilight sighed as Rarity went back to the box and pulled out a set of two vibrators. Twilight grinned.

"Better to do 69 with." Rarity smirked.

She positioned herself on top of Twilight and began to rub her with it. Twilight returned the favor by sticking her vibrator into her friend and giving her clit a swift series of licks.

"Harder! Please Twilight!" Rarity panted, desperately bucking her hips into the unicorn’s face.

Twilight responded by thrusting the vibrator back and forth into her. Rarity, at the same time, began to rub the librarian harder with her vibrator. The two were locked in an intensifying cycle until the fashionista couldn’t take it anymore.

"Twi! Twi! TWI!" Rarity screamed at the top of her lungs.

Twilight pulled the vibrator out as Rarity smiled and began to thrust the vibrator into her as hard and as fast as she could. She sucked Twilight's clit and then dipped her tongue into her, causing the unicorn to arch her back and moan with the feeling of her climax closing in.

"Rarity, I'm gonna....CUUUUMMMM!" Twilight shrieked.

Rarity opened her mouth and happily lapped up the unicorn’s juices as they squirted everywhere. Twilight was nearly paralyzed with the sensation, her heavy panting filling the air.

"You see? That wasn't so bad was it? Now it's time to clean up...." Rarity said climbing over her and smiling.

"No!" Twilight cried out. "I have to return the favor first."

Rarity giggled and clapped her hooves together. "Oh alright!" She said pushing Twilight out of the way and lying down.

"Fuck me." she snarled playfully.

Twilight nodded and got off the bed to dig through the box for some rope, a gag, a blindfold, and another vibrator. Pulling up a chair and motioning for Rarity to sit, the unicorn quickly tied up her friend and put the blindfold on her after teasingly wagging her ass in her face.

‘How the hell does she know all this?!’ Rarity thought.’ I thought she was only a virgin!’

Twilight started by kissing her passionately. The two let their tongues dance for a bit before pulling away for a gasp of air. That’s when Twilight put the gag on the fashionista and grabbed the vibrator.

"Love you." Twilight said roughly shoving the vibrator into her.

Rarity tried to gasp through the gag but it was no use. She abruptly choked, which somehow heightened her arousal as Twilight sucked on her clit. The unicorn dipped her tongue inside again, giggling as her tongue was being vibrated too. Twilight took her hoof and roughly rubbed Rarity's clit, making her groan loudly. With the other hoof she began to thrust the vibrator in and out of her. Rarity's moans now filled the entire house.

Twilight snickered as she took the gag out of her friend’s mouth.

"Oh Twi! How did you learn all of this?" Rarity groaned, a heavy breath escaping with the relief of the gag being removed.

"Ummm....porn?" Twilight answered blankly.

The fashionista said nothing as Twilight began to thrust harder and harder and faster and faster. Her moans turned into loud pants and squeals. Her whole body trembled.

"Twilight! Twilight! Oh fuck!" she moaned.

"Scream my name." Twilight sneered.

"Twilight!"

"Louder!"

"Twilight!"

"Louder bitch! Make the neighbors know my name!" Twilight yelled.

"Damn it! TWILIIIIIGHT!” Rarity shrieked as loud as she could.

Rarity came, squirting her juices all over Twilight's face and mane. Twilight licked her lips and smiled.

"Yummmm!"

Rarity laughed and panted at the same time.

"Well done, Twilight. You did good. And you learned all that just from watching....porn?" Rarity mused.

"Yup." Twilight giggled.

"Umm, ok. Now please do untie me. This is becoming quite uncomfortable." Rarity motioned at the rope around her hooves.

Twilight untied her, taking the blindfold and gag off before sliding out the vibrator. Rarity got up and wobbled a bit, some of her cum still spilling on the floor.

"Gosh. Well, I'm glad you came over." she said with a smile.

"Anytime." Twilight nodded happily.

"Tomorrow night at your place for round two?"

"For sure." Twilight said grinning devilishly.

Rarity gave her friend a quick peck on the lips.

"I'm glad I have a fillyfriend like you." She said beaming.

"Me too."

Author's Note

This story is originally the idea of OuttaMyMind (or whatever their name is now since they keep changing it) who asked me to redo and post it for them. This was done with full permission and no form of plagiarism is intended. The original can be found at http://www.fimfiction.net/story/72126/a-hearths-warming-eve-to-remember.