Equestria Girls: Case Closed

by Israel Yabuki

Getting Settled In

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

After getting dirty and cleaned up, Adagio brought Seth downstairs with the other girls with Aria following the two close behind. The rest of the girls had agitated looks on their faces all staring at Seth as well as Adagio. The two approached the living room and then out of nowhere, Rainbow Dash punched Seth hard on the face, making his nose bleed and landed on the couch. He grunted as the pain in his ribs had returned once again.

"You dumbass! What the hell were you thinking?" Rainbow said, angered.

"Indeed! You should've known better than to sexually assault an injured man, Adagio. What if you were to damage his ribs beyond belief then he'd end up having to use a wheelchair!" Rarity added.

"No, no, no! I mean, how could you let that bimbo steal your virginity away?" Rainbow said. All the other girls just immediately dropped to the ground with their legs extending upwards and twitching.

"That's not the point here, Rainbow!" Sunset shouted. "Seth still hasn't fully recovered from his injuries! He has to take it easy and you're worried about Adagio stealing a quick shower fuck from him?"

"She did WHAT?!" Pinkie asked shouting. "Why didn't she invite me?"

"PINKIE!!!" The girls shouted.

"What? It would've been nice to experience it."

"Can we please get back to the business at hand? Starting tomorrow, I have to find myself a decent part-time job, since I got reckless and ended up getting her pregnant." Seth said, pointing towards Adagio.

The girls paused and looked at Seth with their jaws hanging open. Except for Sonata and Aria, who started laughing.

"This isn't funny!" Seth said, frustrated.

"Yes it is! Especially since you don't know that humans can't impregnate sirens." Sonata said with a squee.

"What? Sirens?" Seth asked, confused.

"Maybe we should explain it to him in a way that he'll understand." Sunset said.

"Agreed." Twilight added.

Seth sat up slowly, letting the girls explain to him what they were talking about.

"You see, Seth. Just like the girls sitting with you." Sunset says, jestering Aria, Sonata and Adagio, sitting next to him. "I'm not exactly from this place or this world for that matter. Me and the sirens come from a place called Equestria where I'm a magical talking unicorn and those three are sirens. In Equestria, the sirens had the ability to feed off of the negative magical energy of ponies everywhere."

"However, because of a certain big-bearded buffoon, we ended up being banished to this world. We still fed off of negative energy when we were banished here, but we stopped a few years ago." Adagio added. "Now, even though me and the other sirens and Sunset look human, Sunset is still a unicorn in a human's body while me Aria and Sonata are sirens in a human's body. Also, this is an added bonus for you, since sirens and unicorns can't get impregnated by humans, even if we do look human."

"Are you getting any of this?" Sunset asked.

Seth was just speechless after they told him all of this. He gathered his thoughts together and finally spoke.

"Okay, that sounds like something a toddler would come up with, but I'll bite...for now." Seth said. "Now...I'm just gonna..." he cut himself off as his head landed on Sonata's lap and started snoring softly.

"Aww, he's sleepy." Sonata said, rubbing his cheeks softly.

"I think he needs to take a little time to rest up. It is getting late after all." Fluttershy said. "I'm gonna get him a nice and warm blanket so he won't be cold at night." She ran upstairs to her room, along with all the other girls, except for the sirens, as they decided to turn in for the night as well.

Sonata adjusted Seth's body to where he wa lying flat on the couch. She couldn't help but notice that his nose was still bleeding, so she took out a tissue and wiped off the blood from his nose. "There. Nice and clean, little cutie." Sonata said softly.

"Yeah, well don't go hogging him all to yourself. I'm getting dibs on him first thing tomorrow morning." Aria said, slamming her head onto the couch cushion to try to catch some Z's.

"Well, I already had my fun with him, so why not?" Adagio said, getting cozy on the couch as well.

Moments later, Fluttershy came back down with a warm and fuzzy, yellow blanket. She laid it over Seth's sleeping body, but kept his face uncovered so he wouldn't suffocate. Up close, Fluttershy noticed how Seth seemed a bit peaceful and handsome. Especially when he was completely passed out. Without even thinking, she rubbed his warm cheek and gave him a peck on the forehead.

"Sleep tight." Fluttershy said. She headed back upstairs for some well deserved rest while the sirens stayed downstairs and slept right next to their new "playmate."


The next morning, Aria woke up with a yawn and looked down to where Seth was sleeping, only to find that he gone. Aria's eye began to twitch and she clenched her fists.

"DAMN YOU!!!!!" Aria shouted. Sonata and Adagio woke up to the sound of Aria's yell.

"Aww come on, I was dreaming of being covered in taco sauce and getting rutted by our new friend." Sonata whined, tired.

"Can't us girls get a moment of peace away from this world's harsh reality?" Adagio asked in a grumpy tone.

"Not when we don't have our new boy toy! He just up and left!" Aria replied.

"Oh, you mean Seth? He's out doing a little job searching. He said something about wanting to be able to earn a decent buck without having to rely on an allowance, even though we don't do that." Pinkie said from the kitchen.

"Oh, goodie!" Sonata exclaimed.

"Great, now I have to wait until he gets back before he and I can "get down to business." Aria said with her arms crossed.


Seth was out in the middle of Canterlot, trying to find out what kind of job he should apply for. He checked all of the office buldings, restaurants, hotels, and even the real estate agencies, but no luck. However, one by one, he always filled in the job applications at the door just in case any positions become available. Next, he was about to try a donut shop across the street, but he was then stopped by a speeding cop car as it sped past him. He managed to get out of the way before it hit him. Then all too quickly, he felt a jolt in his head as parts of his memories started coming back to him. He started remembering the day he once helped the cops catch criminals and the day he completed his DTI course after high school. He wondered if he could lend a little helping hand for the cops every now and then, but then all too quickly, he came up with another brilliant idea.

'THAT'S IT! A detective agency! But not just any kind, I'll start my own! It's genius!' Seth thought to himself. But before he could do that, he went over to where the cops did and walked down the street. He wasn't sure if he'd it in time, but when he turned the corner, he saw that the cops had stopped and were gathered around in the middle of the street. 'What the hell happened there?' Seth headed towards the crime scene to get a better look.

When he got close enough, one of the cops was about to stop him from going any further until

"Seth Brooks? Is that you? I though you were dead when I heard you got jumped!" one of the cops asked.

"Jumped?" Seth asked.

"I'm guessing you don't know what happened. Well, I'll let you in on the details of that later, come with me. We got ourselves a murder case and we might need ya."

"Alright then. Who's the victim?" Seth asked, walking towards the body.

"The victim's name is Timber Spruce, age 23, the poor guy was stabbed multiple times, I count 47 stab wounds. Whoever did this must've had a huge grudge on the poor guy." said the detective.

For some reason, Seth felt like he knew who did it. The only thing he had to do was put the pieces together. He took a closer look at Timber's bloodied dead body and examined the stab wounds on his chest, back and stomach.

"So who was the one that made the call when they discovered the body?" Seth asked.

"It was me." said a female voice. Seth turned to the crowd and saw a pink skin and scarlet red hair. She had tears in her eyes, clearly making Seth know that she was a relative of his.

"I take it you must be one of his relatives, miss?" Seth asked.

"Yes, I'm Gloriosa Daisy, I'm his sister." she replied, wiping her tears.

"I'm sorry for your loss, Gloriosa. Now tell me, did your brother have any enemies that he might've ticked off for any reason at all or someone he had a fondness for?"

"Well, once when we still lived in Camp Everfree, he'd constantly flirt with one of the high school girls. I think her name was Twilight Sparkle, but that was over 3 years ago."

Seth got a strange look on his face. 'Twilight? Wait, if this happened 3 years ago, Twilight would have been 17 and Timber Spruce would have been at least 20. Perhaps I should try to dig in a little further.' Seth thought to himself. "Alright then, was there any other guy who had a crush on this Twilight Sparkle?"

"Just some other student who went by the name of Flash Sentry."

'Flash Sentry?' Seth asked himself in his mind. But then he got an idea 'Wait, what if--' Seth then ran towards Timber Spruce's corpse to see if he could find a particular item. Sure enough, he found something blue underneaath Timber's body. It looked like a miniature sized handle, but before he picked it up, he put on some gloves so he wouldn't tamper with the evidence he pulled it out. Upon closer inspection, Seth finally figured it out. 'THIS IS IT! All the pieces have fallen into place and now it's time to put this case to rest once and for all.' "Detective, I need you to take a look at this." Seth called out.

The detective approached him and grabbed the blue handle of the object.

"Hey, this is a pocket knife! Where'd you find it?" the detective asked.

"I found it underneath the victim's body when I examined him. Also, thanks to that little pocket knife, I know who the murderer is, and I have a hunch that he's in the crowds right now."

"Let me see! That's my friend out there!" said a male voice from a crowd.

"Sir, this is a crime scene, please step back." one of the cops replied, pushing him back.

Seth turned to the crowd to see a man with blue hair, blue eyes, a black jacket and a white shirt with a sticker of a lightning bolt on a blue shield on it. "Bingo." Seth said to himself. "Hold on there, gentlemen. I need to ask this fellow some questions, let him through if you please, it'll only take a moment." Seth said to the cops.

They did as he was told and let the guy walk towards him.

"So tell me, what's your name?" Seth asked.

"Flash Sentry, but what happened to Timber Spruce?! He was like a pal to me!" Flash replied.

"Well, you should know...considering the fact that..." Seth paused and pointed at Flash. "You're the one who was responsible for the murder of Timber Spruce, Flash Sentry!"

Flash got a puzzled look on his face, but pulled himself together. "Come on, I'd never do a thing like that! Timber was my best friend since the day we met at Camp Everfree. Why would I want to kill him?"

"Simple, there was a certain girl you two had a fondness over and Timber Spruce almost made her his girlfriend."

"I didn't know he was crushing on Twilight!"

"Up until probably recently, I'll bet. So, you arranged to meet him at a bar or something to talk about the good ol' days you had back in high school, but then probably heard Timber Spruce spouting out how he started flirting with Twilight, which then made you so mad that when you left the bar with him, you used your pocket knife and stabbed him multiple times."

"Wait, how do you know I was at a bar?"

"I can smell the faintest scent of alchohol coming from your breath. It was easy to deduce."

"Still, how do you know I killed him? I don't even have a knife or a gun!"

"That's because you dropped it when you fled the scene of the crime that night. Tell me, do you always carry a blue pocket knife with the same sticker that matches your shirt?"

Flash's eyes got widened in shock.

"I thought so. I from what I can tell, your fingerprints are probaby still on there, along with the noticable blood stains from the victim, so tell me, Flash, why commit murder in cold blood?" Seth gave Flash a serious look.

Flash clenched his fists as he spilled the beans. "That son of a bitch! It's true that he almost took Twilight from me. He was drunk off his ass when he told me how he and her almost kissed. He even bragged about how he'd do it again if he had the chance. But that's not the only reason why I was so mad. He practically used me to get some extra cash and never bothered paying me back! It's like he made a living off of making people's lives miserable! I had to get rid of him! HE WAS A TRAITOR! I called him up at the bar because I wanted to find out why he wouldn't pay me back the money he owed me, but the fact that he also wanted to have Twilight all to himself was another reason why he shouldn't even exist anymore."

"How sad. Yet pitiful at the same time. You threw your life away to take the life of someone else's."

The cops then cuffed Flash Sentry and took him to the station. Seth then walked towards Gloriosa and put his hand on her shoulder, making her look at him.

"I'm sorry you lost your brother. It must be heartbreaking."

"Thanks. I just wished he could've found a better way to live than off of other people." Gloriosa replied. Soon, she got down on her knees and weeped in sadness. Her brother wasn't coming back, but she was able to rest easy knowing her brother's killer was.

Seth felt a slight poke on his shoulder and turned around to see that the detective had a small envelope in his hand and gave it to Seth but told him to wait until he was at home to open it. Seth nodded and decided to walk back home since he had already filled out a few job applications and had solved a murder case.

He managed to get back to the penthouse around 11:30. He was aware that he had been out and about for 3 hours. He opened the front door to the living room. "Hey, I'm back." he said, before getting smacked in the face with a frying pan. He span around uncontrollably upon impact until finally he stumbled over and fell.

"Maybe that'll teach you not to run before I've had my fun." Aria said. She grabbed his unconcious body by the legs and carried him off to one of the girls' bedrooms.

Seth woke up with a splitting headache and reached for his head, getting up. The room had blue walls and the bed he was on had blue blankets and sheets with a cloud shooting a rainbow colored lightning bolt from it. When Seth turned to face forward, he realized that he was butt naked, completely exposing his penis, before he covered himself using his hands.

"What the hell is going on here? Why am I naked?" he said to himself.

"Come on, stud, you should know by now." Rainbow said, as she and Aria appeared out of the dark closet, both stripped of their clothes and exposing their gorgeous bodies. They walked towards Seth, giving their hips some added sway.

"Oh dear god, a threesome?!" Seth asked, surprised.

"Bingo." Aria replied. "Since you had your fun with Adagio earlier, I get dibs on you. Now lay down."

'If Aria was the one who knocked me out, I'd hate to see what she can do next. I might as well do as she says. From what I can tell, she's and Rainbow aren't giving me any choice.' Seth thought to himself. He laid his body back on Rainbow's bed.

Rainbow and Aria crawled onto the bed and straddled over Seth. Rainbow positioned herself over his face while Aria laid in between his legs, breathing hot air on Seth's now erect penis.

"Okay, stud, it's time to eat up. Open that mouth of yours wide." Rainbow said, lowering herself. Seth opened his mouth as wide as he could and began to eat out Rainbow Dash. Aria was enjoying her meal as well. She licked the tip of his dick, swirling her tongue round and round while massaging his balls. The soft velvety touch from Aria was like heaven as Seth moaned in Rainbow's pussy while he was eating her out, swirling his tounge in her deepest part. Rainbow began to move her hips back and forth, making Seth's tongue touch her clit and almost made Rainbow Dash climax. "YES!!! KEEP GOING!!! RIGHT THERE!!!" she shouted.

Aria took Seth's entire dick into her mouth until it reached down her throat. She bobbed her head up and down, trying to milk Seth for all he had in him.

Seth acted on instinct and slapped Rainbow's cute ass hard.

"OOH, I'll get you for that, stud!" Rainbow said, in a sultry tone.

'I don't know how I got mixed up in this, but this feels too good to stop.' Seth thought to himself. He kept moaning from Aria deep throating his cock. Then came an unexpected change in the blowjob Aria was giving him. Seth was still thrusting his tongue deep into Rainbow's pussy and felt Aria squeezing his dick in between her breasts. She continued to suck on him as she started to rub his cock in between her big, soft breasts. 'GOOD GOD! A TITTYFUCK?! What else is there?' Seth screamed in his thoughts. All too quickly, Rainbow Dash moaned so loud and shot her love nectar inside Seth's mouth. Seth had no choice but to swallow it all to not choke. She tasted sweet.

Rainbow Dash lifted herself off of Seth's face, earning a few coughs from him. She then laid down next to him with her right arm wrapped around his neck, giving him the bedroom eyes.

"You stud, you drank all my cum. Come here, so I can give you your reward." Rainbow said. She then pulled Seth towards her and kissed him, thrusting her tongue in his mouth. Seth did the same and their tongues competed in a battle of dominance. Seth's breathing began to quicken as his climax was reaching from Aria tittyfucking him. Finally he shot out his seed deep inside Aria's throat and she swallowed every last drop of him before taking his dick out of her mouth with an audible 'pop.'

"Well done, Seth. You've got quite the endurance. Now for one last thing." Aria said. She laid down on Seth's left hand side. "Stick that monster of a cock inside here." Aria pointed at her dripping pussy, which she had spread wide open with her fingers.

Seth nodded and got on top of her and positioned his dick towards her entrance. "Aria. Before I do this, do you prefer it rough or do you want me to take it easy on you?" Seth asked.

"I say fuck my brains out. Be as brutal as you want!" Aria said in a seductive tone. The moment she said that, a switch inside Seth just flipped and got a devilish grin on his face.

"Then prepare yourself, you sexy hot MESS!" Seth shouted that last part before he slammed his cock deep inside her, making her shout loudly in ecstacy from the feeling. Seth thrusted deep inside her deepest parts, practically making the tip of his dick kiss the entrance to her womb over and over again. Seth grunted and growling like a vicious predator just like before.

"OH FUCK, THAT FEELS GOOD!!! DON'T STOP!!! DON'T!!! YOU!!! DARE!!! FUCKING!!! STOP!!!" Aria shouted.

"Who said I WAS?!" Seth shouted as he leaned towards her and started sucking on her neck, making her moan even more. Aria then wrapped her legs around Seth's waist, making him thrust deeper into her. "You're such a bad girl, Aria! Bad girls must be punished!"

"THEN DO IT!!! PUNISH YOUR BAD GIRL!!!" Aria shouted.

"As you wish!" Seth then turned her to the side facing Rainbow Dash. He kept thrusting and then gave her ass a hard smack.

"OH FUCK YES!!! I'M SUCH A BAD GIRL!!!"

"No shit!" Seth continued his assault, spanking her ass and thrusting deep inside her. He then leaned towards her again and locked lips with Aria, looking deep in her eyes. He could see the look of pleasure in her as she did in him.

"HURRY!!! I'M GONNA CUM AGAIN!!! I WANT IT ALL INSIDE!!!" Aria shouted.

Acting on instinct again, Seth picked up Aria with his dick still inside her. They got off the bed and pinned her against the wall with her legs being held in his arms. He resumed his hard and fast thrusting. Aria then pulled him close to her and kissed him again, both thrusting their tongues inside each other's mouths. Seth felt a familiar tingling below and thrusted with all his might until finally he came, shooting all of his hot seed deep into Aria's womb. She moaned inside Seth's mouth and came as well.

Seth pulled back from Aria and set her down easy.

"This might sound cheesy, but with how you gave me a good time, I love you." Aria pulled him in hard again, but this time for a hug, squeezing her breasts into his chest. Seth hugged her gently.

"Love ya, too." Seth said, softly.

"Okay, okay, hug-festers! It's my turn to have a shot at the stud." Rainbow said, walking over to Seth and gave his ass a hard smack, probably harder than he did with her.

"OOH!!! Getting a little feisty, aren't we?" Seth asked in a sultry tone.

"You know it, stud."

"My name is Seth. Why do you keep calling me stud?"

"Because "stud" sounds 20% cooler."

"Uh, okay, fair enough. Where do you want me to stick this guy." Seth asked, jestering his still erect penis.

"Well, I haven't told this yet, but even though normally I would get pregnant, there's something you should know first. See, back when we left Camp Everfree when we were still in high school, Twilight found something out about the geodes we kept after graduation and that's the fact that the moment we used them, it blocks us from any unwanted or early pregnancies."

"So in other words?"

"I like it doggy style, but don't go so hard. But I do like it fast." Rainbow got on her arms and knees and stuck her ass up to Seth, wiggling it left and right. The sight was so hypnotizing to him and made him get on his own knees on the bed. He spread her ass open with one hand and guided his shaft with the other. He carefully inserted his dick inside her, making her moan.

Seth was able to break through her hymen and reach deep inside her. Rainbow Dash cringed in ecstacy and pain and soon, Seth found blood dripping out of her.

"Shit! Are you alright?" Seth asked in a panic.

"I'm okay. It doesn't hurt. Now show me how much speed you got, big guy!" Rainbow said, reassuringly.

"You got it." Seth replied. Seth was careful not to go too hard, but hard enough and slowly sped up, making Rainbow's moans become even louder than before.

"That feels so good! We...we need to...do this *moan* more often." Rainbow said.

Seth said nothing and kept thrusting inside Rainbow Dash with his speed gradually building up. He even gave Rainbow's ass a few good smacks, leaving red marks on them. The feeling felt too good for them both that Seth then added more force to his fast thrusting and growled once again. His breathing was quickening just like Rainbow's.

"OH, FUCK YES!!! MORE!!! MORE!!! GIVE IT TO ME!!! GIVE IT ALL TO ME!!!" She shouted.

Seth wasn't going to be told twice and kept thrusting with all of his might, enjoying the moment of bliss. Nothing was gonna stop Rainbow Dash and Seth from their trip to Fuck Paradise.

But sadly, like all good things, they must come to an end. With all of his strength, he gripped Rainbow's plump butt in both of his hands and thrusted deep inside her, shooting his seed deep into her. Rainbow and Seth moaned from the top of their lungs.

Finally, Seth's shaft went limp and pulled out of Rainbow while she slumped down on her bed, completely passed out. Seth got off the bed and saw Aria crawling back onto the bed with Rainbow Dash.

"You're gonna sleep with her?" Seth asked.

"Just for a while. You sure gave us a good time. I put your clothes over at the corner there." Aria pointed towards the left hand side of Rainbow's bedroom door.

"Thanks." Seth replied before walking towards the door. He grabbed his clothes and put them back on before exiting the room. But unfortunately, after walking away from the door, he leaned against the wall and slowly slid down, exhausted. "Jeez, those girls are gonna drain the life out of me! I need a quick bite to eat."

He walked down the stairs and towards the kitchen where Sunset and Twilight were playing Monopoly. They turned to face him.

"I'm guessing Aria got you, didn't she?" Sunset asked.

"Yup. Along with Rainbow Dash." Seth replied.

"There's no surprise. How is she?" Twilight asked.

"Clonked out. Our little "private time" tuckered her out. Anyways, girls, I got something to tell you."

"What?" Sunset and Twilight asked.

"I've decided to start my own detective agency."

"WHAT?!" Twilight and Sunset shouted in unison.


Author's Note

And there's another one down. How you all like it. More chapters on the way.

Next Chapter