Equestria Girls: Case Closed 2, The Big Leagues

by Israel Yabuki

An Apple A Day

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

Applejack and Rainbow Dash were growing a bit bored with playing Super Street Fighters since they're always end up beating each other as well as pause the game sometimes to engage in their own brawl. Now they both decided to put the game aside and watch a few movies on Netflix to help calm them down. They noticed Seth and Sonata coming inside a bit wobbly. Sonata lost her balance and ended up almost falling to the ground before Seth caught her.

"I think you've earned yourself a well deserved nap, Sonata. You want me to carry you to you room?" Seth asked.

"Pwetty pwease?" Sonata asked so adorably. Seth nodded and picked her up bridal style and carried her up the stairs. Sonata wrapped her arms around Seth to keep herself balanced more. "You're so sweet, Sethy-poo." she says, nuzzling her cheek with his.

"And you're cute, Sonata." Seth replied.

"Ugh, can you guys take that mushy talk upstairs?" Rainbow asked. Seth and Sonata laughed before they disappeared upstairs. Seth opened the door to Sonata's bedroom and carried her to her bed. He laid her down gently and covered her up.

"Thank you, sweetie." Sonata said.

"You're welcome, babe." Seth replied. He leaned down and gave her a long and passionate kiss on the lips. She moaned softly and caressed her boyfriend's cheek. After he broke the kiss, Sonata quickly fell asleep, letting out cute snores and started repeating "tacos" in her sleep, which sounded even more adorable to Seth. "Too cute." he said before he left the room. He closed the door slowly so he wouldn't accidentally wake her up. Seth walked downstairs and slumped on the couch with AJ and Rainbow Dash.

"Fucked her good, didn't you, babe?" Rainbow asked with a sly smirk.

"She knows how to drain a guy of his energy. But now she's out like a light." Seth replied.

"Ah can understand that much. How 'boutcha chill and watch Netflix with us?" Applejack asked.

"Sure. What are we watching today?" Seth asked.

"How does Coraline sound?" AJ asked.

"I've never seen the movie, but I have seen the trailers back when I was still a young teenager. The only thing I know about it is the characters with buttons for eyes." Seth say.

"Well, this movie is probably going to scare the hell outta you! It was suppose to be rated PG, yet it scared so many kids worldwide to the point where some had to sleep with the lights on." Rainbow says.

"In that case... let's see if this movie'll scare the fuck out of me, despite its rating." Seth said with a confident smirk.

Rainbow nodded and selected the movie. So far, the start of the movie looked a bit disturbing, but Seth couldn't take his eyes off of the TV screen for a second. Applejack felt a bit disgusted with the whole doll-making scene. She turned to Seth and saw that even he was a bit disgusted with a few of the scenes, but he kept his game face up. She turned back to the TV screen.


About halfway into the movie, Applejack was clinging to Seth warmly. Rainbow Dash and Seth were really becoming on edge with the Other parents in the movie wanting to sew buttons in Coraline's eyes.

"Would ya want to live in that there world instead of this one, sugarcube?" AJ asked Seth.

"Hell no. I'd rather keep my eyes and stay with you and the other girls." Seth said.

"Good answer. She'd probably eat you up... and not in a good way." Rainbow says.

"Oh? What do you mean by that?" Seth asked.

"Just watch and you'll find out." Rainbow replies.

The movie progressed more and more, until it got to the part with the ghost children and how they referred the Other Mother as this creature called "The Beldam." Seth listened very carefully at what the ghost children told Coraline in the movie and became shocked about how the beldam was a child eater.

"Now that's just plain sick." Seth says.

"Ah hear ya, sugarcube." AJ replied.

Just as they were enjoying the movie, Fluttershy walks in and joins AJ, RD and Seth. "What are you all watching?" she asked.

"We're watching Coraline." Rainbow replied.

"It's movie about a young girl who moves into this apartment complex in this secluded area. She doesn't feel to comfortable with her new home, but she then discovers this other world where she has Other Parents with buttons for eyes and turning her bad days into good ones with treasures and treats. But that's only a setup for what's really to come." Seth explains.

"Oh my. Can I watch with you all?" Fluttershy asked.

"Sure, just try not to get scared. It may be PG but it scared the hell out of some children." Seth replied.

"Okay, thanks sweetie." Fluttershy scooted next to Seth and wrapped her arms around his left arm. Everyone's eyes were glued to the set, waiting to see what will happen next.

Later on in the movie came the part with the Exploring game and so far, Fluttershy clinged to Seth from a few jumpscares from the movie, letting out a few yelps and whimpers. Seth kept Fluttershy close to his chest. Even he was getting freaked out by the movie and how he could understand why this movie would freak kids out. 'What the hell were the writers thinking when they designed this movie? Is this suppose to be some kind of sick joke to scare kids and mentally scar them? If so, they should be ashamed for making it PG. This movie should've actually been rated PG-13.' Seth thought to himself.

The movie soon reached near the end after escaping the beldam and throwing away the one key. Fluttershy was still clinging tightly to Seth's arm and quivered in fear. "I-I-I-I-Is it over?" Fluttershy asked.

"Yes, Flutter, it's all over. You can look now." Seth reassured. Fluttershy looked and saw the end credits and sighed in relief. "Although, I probably don't feel like watching it again... at least not when you're around. I don't want to scare you too much."

"You're so sweet, Sethy." Flutters replied, nuzzling his cheek, warmly.

"Well, Ah think Ah should go and rest up in mah room. Could ya come with me, Seth?" AJ asked.

"Sure, but, what for?" Seth asked.

"Just trust me. It's a surprise."

"Alright, AJ, I'm coming."

Seth got up from the couch and followed AJ. They headed upstairs and over to her bedroom door. She opened it and revealed a beautiful green checkered bed with apple stickers sewed into it. On her nightstand was a decoration of waxed apples. Obviously, she was really obsessed with apples so much. Applejack closed the door behind the two of them.

"Ya know, Seth. Ah gotta be honest with ya." AJ began as she guided Seth to her bed. But instead of laying down, both of them just sat at the edge, looking at each other. "Ah might actually relate to ya in one small way."

"Why's that?" Seth asked.

"Remember how ya told us all that ya didn't have any parents anymore?"

"Yeah, why?"

"Well, to tell ya the truth, Ah lost mah parents too."

"You what?! How?"

"It happened a long time ago when mah baby sister, Apple Bloom was barely a year old. Mah mom and dad got into a car accident on their way home from the farmers market. The paramedics arrived in time and rushed them to the hospital. Mah Granny Smith drove us to the hospital to check up on them. Ah ran to check up on them and saw that they were pretty banged up. The only thing they said to be before they died was this: We're sorry you had to see us like this. But know that whatever happens to us, just remember that we'll always be proud of you and your brother and sister and watch over you all, no matter what."

"Oh, AJ. I'm so sorry you lost your parents." Seth leaned in and gave her a warm hug.

"Thanks, Seth. Ah really needed that." Applejack sounded like she was getting choked up. Seth looked at AJ and saw that she was producing fresh tears in her eyes.

"AJ, you're crying. And not on the inside. Are you going to be okay?"

"Yes, sugarcube. Ah just need some comfort. Ah feel like Ah'm about to burst into tears!" Applejack sniffled a bit. Seth laid down on her bed and opened up his arms, welcoming her in a warm embrace. She laid down, burying her face in his shoulders. Applejack began to actually sob and shake so much. It's like she had finally broke out of her shell. Seth felt like he was about to cry with her. He could hear AJ muffle out "I want you back, mom!" and "Please come back to me, daddy!" in his shoulders. Seth stroked her hair and rocked her left and right, trying to give her some love and comfort.

"Shhh, just let it all out." Seth said, all choked up. Seth had never seen Applejack cry so much. He was relieved that she could finally get this huge stone off her chest, but he also felt sad that Applejack was heartbroken since she had no parents. After about 7 minutes, Applejack was finally able to calm down and look up at her boyfriend with loving eyes.

"Thank ya so much fer carin'." she said.

"Anytime, anyday. If you want, I can stay here with you for a while."

"Ah'd like that, sugarcube. But, um...do ya think we can...cuddle...naked?"

"Naked?"

"Ah know yer probably not fully recovered from yer time with Sonata, so Ah was wonderin' if we can just cuddle in the newd."

"Sure, AJ. Anything for you."

Seth sat up and removed his shirt and tossed it aside. He grabbed his belt and undid it before he took off his boxer briefs and his pants, along with his socks. Applejack had taken off her shirt, jean skirt and her black bra and panties. She set them all aside, but put her stretson hat on her nightstand and dove under the blankets. Seth got under the blankets with her. The two of them wrapped each other's arms around each other in a warm embrace.

Applejack let out a cute sigh. "Ah don't ever want us to grow apart, sugarcube."

"We never will. That, I can promise you."

For the entire time, all Applejack and Seth did was cuddle underneath her blankets. Of course, the feeling of AJ's soft and naked body made Seth's dick harden and grow. Applejack moaned softly with her eyes closed. She could feel his cock getting bigger and felt like she was in the mood for teasing her boyfriend. She grabbed his dick and started jerking it. Seth closed his eyes and moaned softly. Applejack opened up her eyes and gazed at the handsome stud in front of her. She chuckled seductively, pleasuring him silly.

"Hey, sugarcube."

"Yeah, AJ?" Seth moaned.

"Remember how ya dominated and controlled me back in the hotel?"

"Yeah."

"Ah want to know what it's like to be the dominate one."

"Then, by all means, Applejack. Go ahead. This is your time to shine."

"Okay then, you can start by callin' me Mistress AJ."

"Yes, Mistress AJ."

"Good boy." Applejack grabbed Seth by his cheeks with both hands and smashed her lips on his. Her tongue wrestled with his. She gave his ass a hard smack, leaving a massive red mark. He grunted in approval. Applejack pulled away from the kiss and started flicking his nipples with her tongue and sucking on them. Seth felt chills running down his spine. "Ya taste so good, mah slave."

"Thank you, Mistress AJ." Seth moaned.

Applejack chuckled and kept on playing with her boyfriend's nipples until she finally decided to feast on the main course: A special order of long and hard Seth cock. She turned to face his strong, erect shaft and licked her lips. "Touch or lick mah pussy and yer gonna git a healthy dose of cowgirl ass whoopin'." she said, deviously. "But, you can massage mah ass if ya want. In the meantime, Ah've got somethin' special fer you, mah slave!" Applejack grabbed each of her breasts and placed them in between Seth's shaft. Applejack was now beginning to give her boyfriend a tittyfuck. Seth moaned from her soft cushions and her slithering tongue.

Since he didn't want his "Mistress" left out, he gave her cute ass a good massage. AJ moaned in approval, sending vibrations and chills straight down Seth's spine. Applejack couldn't stop feasting on her favorite hot dog. She grew more hungry and more aggressive and began bobbing her head up and down more quickly, sucking at him more furiously.

"M-MISTRESS AJ!" Seth moaned out loud.

"Hmm?" AJ muffled, still sucking his dick.

"If you keep this up, I'm gonna cum!"

She heeded his warning and took his shaft out of her mouth. "Then let's do this right, sugarcube." Applejack grabbed the blankets and threw them over her and Seth to the point where only their upper torsos were exposed. She adjusted her pussy to where she was just above Seth's shaft and lowered herself down, swallowing his cock whole with her vaginal lips. She grinded her hips forward and back and bouncing steadily up and down. Applejack moaned with Seth, gazing down at him with loving eyes.

"That's right, my slave. Give it all to me! Give yer mistress all o' yer cum!" she moaned. Seth was loving Applejack's dominate side more and more as she was riding him so well. Eventually he felt his old "Alpha Male" instincts kick in. But he tried his best to keep himself in control as he promised AJ to let her be the dominate one. Applejack was losing dominate self to the pleasure she felt from her boyfriend's shaft deep inside her pussy. Eventually, she felt climax gushing out of her like a sprinkler. Applejack moaned out loud before she collapsed on Seth's bare chest with no strength left. "Take me, Seth. Yer mistress has lost all her strength. Fuck me like Ah'm yer bitch!" Applejack said to him, still feeling very aroused, panting.

Now she's really in for it. She felt herself facing Seth from the bottom. Seth looked down at her with the look of lust and love. "Why don't I show you a more gentler side of me?" he asked, softly.

"Then do whatcha gotta do and take me like Ah'm yer wife." Applejack pulled Seth down to where their naked bodies were pressed against each other and began making out. Seth kept up a steady thrusting pace. AJ moaned in his mouth. Seth moan in hers, too. The more he pounded AJ, the more the bed started to rock back and forth. "Yes! That's it! Fuck me! Fuck me! Oh yes! Make me yer bitchy wife! Fuck me until Ah can't walk anymore!"

"AJ, the more you talk like that, the more you sound sexier. So, do you want me to really revert back to my "Alpha Male Mode?"

"YES, AH WANT TO GET FUCKED AND CONTROLLED LIKE A BITCH!" she shouted in ecstacy.

"Okay, alright........You asked for it...my cute little BITCH!" Seth picked her up off the bed and turned her around and made her face the wall while he fucked her from behind. He gave it to her hard and fast. AJ moaned loudly. "Look at me!" he said. Applejack looked at her dominate boyfriend with the look of satisfaction on her face. "Open your mouth and pucker up, my lusty babe!" AJ did so and felt her tongue being pinned down by his tongue, making out with her furiously.

Eventually, he felt his climax coming soon so he lifted one of her legs and thrusted her scissor style. He groped her large, bouncing boobs and massaged them furiously. "Ah...Ah love ya, sugarcube! Ah love ya so much!" AJ moaned.

"And I love you, babe." Seth moaned back. Applejack pulled him in for another long and passionate kiss while she was feeling her pussy being used and violated and she enjoyed every moment of it. Finally, Seth felt his orgasm reach its limit and shot his seed inside AJ, moaning with her in each others mouths.

They still held the kiss, but Seth carried Applejack back to her bed and laid her down with him. He placed the covers over them and kept making out softly for another 5 minutes. AJ then broke the kiss and just grinded her hips on Seth's crotch.

"Sorry if I got carried away, AJ." Seth said.

"It's no worries, sugarcube. Thanks fer makin' me feel like the "Alpha Female." AJ said calmly. "By the way. Ah think Ah'm in the mood fer a quick nap right now, how 'bout you?"

"Sure, I'm pretty tuckered out, to be honest." Seth replied, quietly.

Applejack hummed in agreement and finally dozed off with Seth. Both still covered up in her blankets and cuddled together.


1 hour later, Seth had woken up while his apple lover was still asleep. "Aww, she's so cute." he said quietly to herself. He picked up his clothes and put them on. Once he was fully clothed, he headed outside of the room and closed the door behind him quietly. He made sure not to wake up Applejack. He walked down the stairs and slumped on the couches. What caught his attention was that most of the girls weren't anywhere downstairs, so he searched the 1st floor and found a not on the fridge. He read it:

Hey Seth

The other girls and I left to pick up some pizza. I tried to call and ask you, but I guess you had your cell phone off. Anyways, if you need anything while we're out, just give me a call.

Love, Twilight

"Alright, looks like pizza for dinner. Might as well chill and and maybe play some video games." Seth got the TV remote and turned on the flat screen before grabbing the PS4 controller. He turned on the PS4 and selected GTA 5. He wasn't in the mood for playing online, so he selected Story Mode instead. He never played Story Mode that often because of how he'd prefer online gaming instead. Luckily, he was skilled enough to kick some ass and earned mostly gold and silver on each mission he did.

While he was playing the game, his cell phone rang in his pocket, so he took it out and put it on speaker phone. "Yeah?" he asked, eyes still glued to the set.

"Sethy, why didn't you answer phone earlier? We were trying to call you to see if you had any specific type of pizza you wanted, but it kept going straight to voice mail!" Pinkie said over the phone.

"Sorry about that, Pinkie. Applejack needed a little comfort earlier, so I had to shut off my phone." Seth said.

"I'll bet you comforted her in more ways than one." Pinkie replied, playfully.

"Now's not the time for joking like that. We didn't just have sex, she wanted a little TLC when she told me how she lost her parents. Did you or any of the girls know about this?" Seth asked after he paused the game.

"Actually...yes. But she never shedded a tear when she told us." Pinkie said.

"Well... she did cry. I got to know the real Applejack... the one who finally let loose her true sadness. She's feeling better now, but I don't feel like we should bring it up anymore. It might brake her heart." Seth explains

"Oh...alright. Well, anyways, is there any kind of pizza you want?"

"Just pepperoni is fine." Seth said

"Okie-dokie-lokie! I'll let the girls know right away. Bye bye, Sethy!" Pinkie says loudly before both she and Seth hang up. Seth then unpaused the game and continued dominating each mission one by one evey 3 to 6 minutes. His mind was highly focused on each enemy he faced in the game and every available route he could pass through to get away from the cops. This gave him the upper hand to even think like a criminal just by becoming one in the game.

About 30 minutes later, the front door unlocked and opened up. In walks the girls, half of them carrying a box of pizza and placing the boxes on top of each other on the dining table. Of course, all of the commotion woke up Applejack and she came walking down the stairs, rubbing her eyes all tired.

"Howdy everybody. Do Ah smell pizza?" AJ asks.

"Yes indeed. Care to join us?" Adagio offered.

"Whoa there, Adagio. First, we gotta wash our hands. Nobody touches a slice until we get these hands cleaned up." Sunset says. Everyone groaned and went upstairs with funny pouty faces. One by one, everyone washed their hands and ran back downstairs to get their grub on with the pizza as a great way to finish up their best day off ever.


Author's Note

Sorry for the delay again. It might have been rushed, but I hope you like it.

Next Chapter