Equestria Girls: Case Closed 2, The Big Leagues

by Israel Yabuki

A Welcome Home Present To Remember Part 1

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

Thanks to a little police escort with the help of detective Steel Bars, the girls were able to reach the Canterlot Hospital. They all parked their cars in seperate parking places. They all got out of their cars and locked them before they rushed over to the entrance of the hospital and walked into the waiting room. Detective Steel Bars also went inside with the others, concerned for his partner's condition. He walked up to the front desk and asked if Seth Brooks was available to visit. She said that the patient was still undergoing surgery. Steel Bars thanked her and sat over at in the waiting room.

"Steel? Is Seth going to be alright? He's not hurt too badly, is he?" Sonata asks, worried.

"I'm not too sure myself, Ms. Dusk. But I can tell you and the others that Seth is a very strong, young man. He's endured pain far worse than even a simple gunshot to the arm." Steel says.

"That reckless bastard!" Rainbow said, gritting her teeth, holding back the tears. "Just what the hell was he thinking, taking a bullet like that without using his head?!"

"He didn't have a choice, Rainbow! There was limited ways to get the jump on that bastard who shot at us! I would have probably done the same thing he just did! You guys would've done the same thing, too!" Sunset retorted.

"Oh, we can't lose Seth! Not after all the times he's made us smile and laugh! Just the thought about losing him makes my heart ache so much that I just wanna...*sniff*" Pinkie said before she sobbed quietly into the palm of her hands.

"Ms. Pie, like I said before, Seth's endured hardships far worse than a gunshot to his shoulder. He wouldn't want you girls to be sobbing over a simple flesh wound. He knows it would break your hearts as much as it would break his." Steel reassures.

"The girls all looked at each other and then in one of the two hallways to see which room he was in, but the hallways lead to a horizontal hallway with not just rooms, but elevators leading up to the upper floors. All the girls took their seats and just stared off into space, either looking down or up.

This was one of the first times that their boyfriend had ever been struck by a bullet. Other times when he was shot at, he'd always be as calm and cautious as he usually was, even when he was backed into a corner. But because of the circumstances with being targeted at their own house left him with two options that ultimately put him in a life-threatening situation.

15 minutes later, Steel Bars walked up to the front desk and asked if Seth Brooks was available to visit. This time, she got confirmation that the operation was a success and his visiting hours have now just started. She told Steel where Seth's resting room was and Steel thanked her and told the girls that Seth was making a full recovery and where he was. The girls walked down the hall on their right and headed straight to the elevator and pushed the button. The doors opened and they all walked inside, pushing the button to the 2nd floor. Steel Bars took a seperate elevator to the 2nd floor.

On the way up there, Derpy got a little curious with the girl. "So, I noticed how close you all seem to act around him. It's almost like you're all dating him or something." she said. The other girls didn't even try to hide that fact and Sunset whispered into Derpy's ear.

"Well, we first found him lying on the sidewalk about 6 months ago. He was hurt and unconcious so we took him in just so we could help him find a nice home. But because of some... "unexpected events," we couldn't just let him leave, not since he started his own business as a young detective at our house. To top it off..."

"Don't tell me, he got under your skirts. Ugh, I should've known he was just like the rest." Derpy whispered, disappoineted.

"Actually, no. We mostly forced ourselves on him. But he didn't stop us, he just went along with it." Sunset explains more.

"If he enjoyed it, I see no reason to speak to that man ever again." Derpy gave Sunset a slight glare. Thinking this is getting them nowhere, Aria decides to cut in.

"Look just because we get into his pants for some alone time, doesn't mean he's our pimp. If he was, he'd already have been thrown out of the house months ago. But Seth is still living with us, and do you know why?" Aria asks. Derpy shook her head left and right. "That's because he works his ass off to keep this damn city safe from criminals. Crime rates have dropped by 40% since he started his business and over the past 6 months, Canterlot City's been 65% more peaceful. If I may recall, he did save your little girl, Dinky." Aria whispered.

"The point is, he cares about the people he saves, even at the cost of his own life and he also cares about us when we have our bad days every now and then. The only reason why is because he lost his parents. His mother was executed fer killin' his dad. He was heartbroken when he saw his own dad die in front of his own eyes that day. Ah even share his pain because Ah lost mah parents a long time ago when Ah was just a young gal." AJ explains.

Derpy was shocked by how much Seth has been through. The fact that she belittled him in front of his own girlfriends, made her feel a bit guilty about it. Then she felt a slight tug on her clothes. She looked down at Dinky all curious.

"Mommy, pwease don't be mad at Seth, he saved my life. He's not a bad guy, he's a good guy." Dinky begged. Derpy picked up Dinky and held her in her arms, nice and gentle.

"I know, sweetie. Mommy just didn't see it before... but now I do."


Meanwhile, in a hospital bed, Seth was hooked up to an I.V and had a guilty look of his own, thinking to himself.

'I can't believe I did that. What kind of an idiot goes out there and gets shot in the process of catching a kidnapper? I know it's in my job description to risk my neck out there, but... I've nearly lost it all. My life, my job, but most importantly, my loved ones. I can already guess what the girls are going to say. Maybe they're just as pissed off at me as I am. I wouldn't blame them either. But, as long as the little girl is safe, it's all that matters to me. Live on, Dinky.'

Seth let out a long sigh and just stared up at the ceiling. He was too preoccupied to notice the nurse walking into the room. She had the same eye and skin color as Rarity, but had pink hair in a bun. She carried a tray with a cup of water and a pill, which was to sooth any kind of pain that might occur since Seth had the bullet removed from his shoulder. The nurse cleared her throat, catching Seth's attention as he looked up to see the nurse with the same guilty expression. The nurse gave him a warm smile as she walked over to him.

"I see you're looking as chipper as ever." she said.

"Hmm? Oh, yeah. I guess." Seth replied, still feeling a bit down.

"Aw, come on. I saw the news just earlier today. You saved a little girl from a greedy babysitter. You should be proud of yourself knowing that she's safe and sound."

"I'm glad she's safe, but I got shot and I was this close to losing concious... for good." Seth said, inching his thumb and index finger to the point where they almost touch.

"There's no need to beat yourself up. Here in Canterlot City, not a lot of people would try something as crazy as taking a bullet for the safety of a little child. Most people these days would try to stay away from the action and keep themselves safe. So be proud knowing that you made all the difference with your heroic deeds. You might only be human, but you've got something that no other person has."

"What would that be?"

"Courage... and a lot of heart." hearing this from the nurse made Seth feel a little better. She then gave Seth the pill and water. Seth took the pill and gulped it down with the entire cup of water.

"Thanks, Ms... umm..." Seth didn't get her name.

"Just call me Red Heart. Oh, and you've got some visitors waiting in the hallway for you. Probably your admirers." Red Heart said.

"Admirers?"

Red Heart didn't respond and instead walked over to the door and opened it, allowing Sunset and her friends to come in, along with Derpy and Dinky Doo. Seth felt a small smile appearing on his face.

"SETH!" the girls shouted, huddling over to him and hugging him.

"You idiot! Just what the hell were you thinking?!" Rainbow asked, glaring at Seth with tear-filled eyes. "I'm all for being gutsy but that was a stupid thing to do! What if he got you in the heart? Or in the the brain? Aren't you ashamed?!"

"I understand that I was reckless. But I didn't know what else to do. Either I got shot in that narrow space near the front door entrance or I could slip past that by jumping off the ledge and surprise attacking Snails? Either way, I did get shot, but only in the shoulder and lived to see another day." Seth explained.

"You still would have died from blood loss!" Rainbow retorted with the same expression.

"Dashie, please! That's enough! Sethy has been through enough already!" Pinkie begged.

"Girls, stop fighting!" Sunset said. She turned her attention back to Seth. "Hey, Seth. We're all very happy for what you did, even if it was a little reckless at first, but you didn't care. You just went and did it. And seeing that you're wounds are healing is more than enough reassurance for us to know you'll be back home with us soon." she leaned in and hugged Seth and gave him a peck on the cheek.

"Thanks, Sunset." Seth replied, all relaxed.

"Hey, there's someone who wants to say "thank you" for everything you've done for her." Twilight says. Seth already knew who it was so he nodded and allowed Derpy and Dinky to get near him. Dinky climbed onto his bed and gave Seth a big hug.

"Tank you, Seth." Dinky said.

"Aww, you're welcome, kiddo. I'm glad you're safe. Now, if you're ever in an emergency situation where anyone at all is trying to hurt you or Derpy, just give me a call and me and the girls will be there to help you." Seth reassures the little girl.

"Okay." Dinky replied with an adorable smile. Seth's attention then turned to Derpy after she picked her daughter off the bed and set her down on the floor next to her. Derpy turned back to face Seth.

"I was told by the girls as to why you always put yourself through all this. They even told me about your jaded past." Derpy says.

"Did they now?" Seth asked, interested in what his girlfriends told Derpy.

"They told me how they all loved you and how they...slept with you. I had my doubts about you when I heard about that, but then I felt so guilty when they told me about your jaded past and why you're always putting yourself through this. They told me you lost your mother when she killed your father. Can you ever forgive me for thinking badly of you?" Derpy asked.

"What's there to forgive? Anyone who would see a guy dating 10 girls would probably have the same reaction you just did, I mean, it's very rare that you find a guy who treats women like they're his loved ones, especially when he's dating them simultaneously. So to put it simply, of course I forgive you. Just make sure that when you do hire a babysitter, make sure to perform a thorough background check on them before you offer them the job." Seth explains. Derpy nods.

"Well, I suppose I should pay you for saving my daughter." Derpy reached into her purse, but Seth held out his hand to her.

"No no, there's no need. I was off-duty when you called. I only accept payments on weekdays. So since it's a Sunday, it's on the house, you just take Dinky home and be safe, okay?" Seth said. Derpy and the other girls were surprised when Seth didn't charge Derpy. But Derpy later accepted it and just thanked Seth one last time before she carried Dinky out of the room.

"Bye bye, Seth." Dinky said before she and her mother disappeared through the doors. With another family safe from harm, Seth felt satisfied and slumped back into his pillow with a huge sigh of relief.

"Well girls, I say we should let Seth rest up. He'll need all of his strength when he checks out soon." Rarity implies.

"I think so, too. Get well soon, Seth." Fluttershy added before she pecked Seth on the lips. The girls all walked quietly outside of Seth's room, letting their heroic boyfriend catch up on his rest.


2 weeks later, Seth was finally released from the hospital with his arm having fully recovered from its injury. Of course, even though he was released, he had to take time off work in order to be mentally ready. Thankfully, today after his release, the girls managed to fill in for him and took on a few cases for him while the former Sirens looked after him. Today, there were three cases that required the other 7 girls to take on as a team.

Seth was relaxing on the couch, watching a horror movie with Adagio, Aria and Sonata. Sonata kept bouncing up and down all gitty like she was enjoying the movie. Aria laid down with a bowl of popcorn in her arms, unfazed by the movie. Adagio was sitting on Seth's lap and rubbing her butt on his crotch, trying to arouse him.

"Heh, really, babe?" Seth asked with a playful smile.

"What? A girl can't have a little fun with her lover?" Adagio asked playfully.

"Oh, I suppose it is nice. But if this keeps up, I'm gonna go nuts." Seth says.

"Well, if you're gonna go nuts, why not go nuts on all of us?" Aria asked, shaking her rump.

"OOH, ME TOO, ME TOO!!!" Sonata jumps in.

"Oh, come on! Don't start cornering me now." Seth chuckled.

"It's too late, I can already feel you getting hard, babe. So you either have 2 choices: Either one: let us tease you while you do nothing to stop us from doing so, or two: .....fuck us like there's no tomorrow." Adagio said in a sultry tone. She stood up with the other two and they were really pushing Seth's buttons when they all started stripping themselves of their clothes. The only thing they still kept on were their matching dark purple bras and dark purple panties.

"So what'll it be, Seth?" all three sirens said. Seth was really pushed over the edge this time. A devilish grin appeared on his face as he stood up and grabbed the sirens and brought them together and tossed them on the couch before he took his clothes off, minus his boxer briefs, showing off the nice noticable bulge tent in it.

"You're gonna wish you never teased me like this, my lusty siren babes!" Seth replied with a sultry growl.

"Then how about we do... this!" Adagio reached up and pulled Seth onto the couch and pinned him in a laying position. Adagio straddled his lap while Sonata went upstairs for some strange reason. Aria pulled her panties down and straddled on top of Seth's face.

"Be sure to drink it all up, lover boy." Aria said before she sat completely on top of him. Seth started eating her out, swirling his tongue around the outside of her vaginal lips and the inside. Seth was hungry for his beautiful sirens and they were hungry for him. Adagio started dry humping through their soaking panties. Aria kept moaning out as she was being eaten out. "Oh, yes! Oh, right there! Drink it all up and don't you dare fucking stop!" Aria moaned.

"Well, aren't you having fun, Aria." Adagio panted. Her hips now moving on their own.

Soon, Sonata made her way downstairs wearing a strap-on . Aria and Adagio notice and looked at it just as hungerly. Sonata ran over to the couch all excited. "So, who wants a taste?" she asked with a squee.

"Give it here, Sonata. I want to savor it." Aria said. Sonata gave Aria a devilish grin and shoved the strap-on down Aria's throat and started thrusting inside, pushing it further down. It was easy for Aria to let it slide down with her throat all relaxed. Her muffled moans became music to Seth's ears.

Adagio got off Seth in order to remove her panties before she grabbed the hem of Seth's boxer briefs and pulled them off, exposing his hard and twitching cock. She straddle his lap once again and began to tease Seth. She began by rubbing her pussy lips back and forth, getting his dick all nice and wet and slipping the tip onto the surface of her vaginal lips. Seth moaned, wanting the torture to end. He still kept on eating Aria out like a hungry wild man.

Aria still muffled her moans as Sonata kept thrusting the strap-on down her throat. "Oh Aria," Sonata said, sing-songy. Aria looked up with an unamused look at Sonata. "After you've cum, you're getting your just desserts." Aria rolled her eyes and continued getting eaten out and sucking on Sonata's strap-on. Aria felt her climax getting closer and closer. Seth plowed his tongue deep into her inner walls, savoring the taste of her sweet juices.

"Aww, what's the matter, Seth? You want me to put it inside me?" Adagio asked. Seth muffled out a moan as he kept eating out Aria and Adagio enjoyed teasing him. "Oh, alright. I suppose I've teased you long enough. Here I come, big boy." Adagio gripped onto Seth's hard, throbbing rod and plunged it deep into her pussy. Adagio arched back and moaned. "Oh, fuck yes!" she shouted. Adagio started grinding and bouncing on Seth so much like she was in heat. Her big breasts bounced up and down with each rise and fall.

Aria couldn't take the pleasure of Seth's tongue anymore so she shot her love juices in Seth's mouth and let out a muffled moan with Sonata still having the strap-on in Aria's mouth. He swallowed it all hungerly until her orgasm died down. Aria slumped back onto the couch, panting for air with her naked body exposed and vulnerable. Sonata had her right where she wanted her.

"Don't think I'm done with you yet, Aria." Sonata said slyly. Without another word, she plunged her strap-on deep into Aria's pussy, letting Aria moan out loud. "You're such a cutie when you're like this, Aria." Sonata said. She thrusted inside Aria hungerly.

"I-I-I swear I... *moan*...I'll get you for this!" Aria barely managed to say before she was now under Sonata's control. Sonata picked up Aria to where she was now sitting on top of Sonata before she continued pounding away.

Seth couldn't help but feel aroused by the two. "Whoa, they're going at it big time!" he said.

"Yes, but right now, you belong to me, honey-bun." Adagio said before she leaned down and started making out with Seth. Her hips moved on their own as her pussy kept on tightening itself around his cock. Each time the tip of Seth's cock kept on touching her womb, like it was kissing it over and over. Seth and Adagio moaned in each other's mouths.

"Wow, Aria. I never knew how tight you were." Sonata boasted before she had her tongue dancing around with Aria's. Aria couldn't stop moaning from her pussy being pounded by Sonata. In fact, this was one side of Sonata that had never been seen by Seth, Adagio or Aria in their entire lives. But they're glad they know now.

Adagio stopped her bouncing and switched her and Seth to where she was laying on her left side and had her right leg up. "Give to me as hard as you can, baby!" she said with a sultry growl. Without another word, Seth started pounding Adagio's pussy hard and fast and had her leg over his left shoulder. He reached for her breasts and started fondling and sucking on her nipples. She moaned out loud with her tongue hanging out and her eyes shot up.

"You like what you're getting, babe?" Seth asked with a devilish grin.

"You know it! *moan* OH...OH YEAH!!! FUCK ME RIGHT IN THE PUSSY!!! OH YES!!!" she moaned. "GIVE IT TO ME HARDER YOU FUCKING HANDSOME DEVIL!!!"

"As you wish, sexy!" Seth said. He thrusted his dick inside her as hard as he could. Adagio had never been fucked this hard since the day she first took his virginity in the shower when they first met.

Meanwhile, Aria was lost in a world of endless pleasure as Sonata was dominating over the exhausted siren, pounding her strap-on away into Aria's dripping pussy. Sonata pressed her breasts against Aria's and hugged her. She grabbed Aria's face and stared into her eyes with her usual devilish grin. "Enjoying your just desserts you sexy siren whore?" Sonata asked. Aria just nodded as she started panting. "That's my good little siren. Now kiss me again." Aria leaned in and pressed her lips against Sonata for another make-out session.

Aria felt her climax getting close again as she moaned more and more, eager to wanting a break. Sonata could tell Aria was close and she was going to give it to her. Sonata pounded her strap-on harder and faster inside Aria's pussy. Aria wrapped her legs around Sonata and moaned loudly into Sonata's mouth.

"FUCK YES! YES! YES! OH, FUCK I'M GONNA CUM!!!" Adagio shouted.

"ME TOO!" Seth grunted.

"FINISH IT! FINISH IT ALL INSIDE ME, SETH!!! MAKE! ME! YOUR! BITCH!!! OH FUCK YES!!!"

"You got it, Dagi!" Seth grabbed Adagio's waist and thrusted furociously. Adagio couldn't move anymore. She had now lost all feeling in her body and went limp. She was now under Seth's full control. Seth saw how beautiful Adagio looked, even when she's getting rutted like she's Seth's own property. But to Seth, he knew she was much more than that. She was still a woman that he loved as a person and maybe as one of his own future wives. Finally, it was time to let loose the "milk cannon" and he thrusted deep into Adagio's pussy with one big thrust, shooting his seed deep inside until it reached her womb. She moaned loudly and came with Seth. Her juices spilled everywhere on the couch, leaving a highly noticable stain on the cushions.

Aria also let out a loud, shrieking moan when she came all over Sonata's strap-on and all over the cushions. Sonata had made her cum by sucking on Aria's neck. She pulled back and looked at Aria, who was still panting from the aftermath. "Good girl." Sonata said, before she placed a finger under Aria's chin and gave her one last kiss.

"I didn't know you could dominate over someone like Aria. I thought she'd be the one to dominate you." Seth said in surprise.

"There's a lot of things about me that'd surprise you, Sethy!" Sonata said with a cute giggle. Then out of nowhere, Aria had regained her strength and wrapped her arms around Sonata, tightly. Sonata let out a cute yelp.

"It's payback time for turning me into your little sex toy, Sonata!" Aria said, grinning evilly at Sonata. Sonata looked at Aria with a sheepish smile on her face.

"Heh, sorry Aria. I got a little carried away." Sonata replied nervously.

"Too late. Now it's my turn. Seth, take the strap-on off of her and hold her tight. I'm gonna enjoy fucking her" Aria ordered, earning a nod from her boyfriend.

Seth took off the strap-on and handed it to Aria quick enough to hold Sonata tightly in his strong arms. Sonata yelped and looked into Seth's hazel eyes with both nervousness and...arousal. Sonata leaned in to give Seth a kiss and he let her. Now Aria didn't have to worry about hurrying up since Sonata was now occupied. Aria got the strap-on attached to her without much of a fuss. She looked at the two lovebirds making out and cleared her throat. Sonata pulled away from Seth and looked at Aria.

"Seth, turn her around and hold her legs up! I figured you can give it to her in the ass while I work on her pussy. What do ya say, does that sound good to you?" Aria asked with a confident smirk.

"Sure." Seth replied. In a swift motion before Sonata could get away, her picked up Sonata's legs from behind and had her vaginal lips completely exposed and unable to break free. "Shall we begin, Aria?" he asked with a sultry tone.

"Oh yes...we...shall." Aria rubbed her hands together and walked towards Sonata and Seth. Sonata then felt a bit relieved since she figured double-penetration would be nice. She turned to Seth and gave him a reassuring smile and a giggle.

"Don't hold back on me, Sethy." Sonata giggled. Seth nodded.


Author's Note

Sorry for the delay. Here's another chapter. Brony on.

Next Chapter