Every year, Spike writes a letter to Santa Hooves, with his Hearth's Warming wishlist. But after running into Dinky Hooves on a day of shopping, Spike finds himself asking Santa for only one thing.

Lyra is wearing something strange on her hooves, and Bon Bon notices.

After an exhausting party, Fluttershy falls asleep, and dreams of a reality that she may have forgotten.

Teddy is a crafty pony commissioned to make a mask for Princess Celestia, for the Nightmare Night Masquerade. But the weight of the task is driving him mad, and inspires him to do something terrible.