Twilight fears become real when she becomes a prisoner to the pirate Nightmare Moon. Will she be able to escape and return home? Most importantly, what secret is Nightmare Moon hiding? Pirate AU/Nightlight

One night while imprisoned, Nightmare Moon decided to write about the events leading up to and her thoughts on her exile in a simple poem. Little did she know, Celestia was doing the same thing in Equestria. These are their stories of pain and loss.