As Applejack is waiting for a friend, she realizes something about herself that had never occurred to her. The event that led up to this realization somehow sets off enough chain reactions to cause every single one of her friends to hate each other.

The mane six are holding a silence contest. Who wins?

The royal sisters have maintained an unsteady relationship since Nightmare Moon was defeated. But when old friends from the moon return, questions on loyalty may bring this inner evil into the world of the living once again.