The Doctor and Derpy are in 1832 Equestria, where they hear a foal's story about a mysterious stallion who appeares to be a ghost. Could it be true?

A closer more accurate retelling of 'A Christmas Carol' by Charels Dickens, in pony form.

This story is based on a theory I have about Hearth's Warming Eve, and how I think it really happened. It is also based on other theories, such as Doctor Wolf's theory that Clover The Clever is Princess Twilight from the future.