What if the episode, "The Hearth's Warming Club," had a much more tragic ending than the original?

After settling into his new life in heaven with his parents, Spike decides to head to the Heaven's school, but must tangle with old emotional habits.

A version of Spike's Sacrifice if the events of "A Secret Admirer" played out.

An alternate version of Chapter 8 of "A Secret Admirer 3" in which Starlight, Smolder, Ember, Thorax, and bonus fifth member beat up Chrysalis for rubbing Spike's death in their faces one time too many.

After Spike becomes more than friends with the Mane 6, CMC, Gabby Starlight, and Smolder, his harem and he put a system in place where he gets hang out with each member during the day and to have a snuggle session each night with that same member.

The Mane Six, Starlight Glimmer, the CMC, Gabby, and Smolder are all getting multiple love letters and gifts from an anonymous person and they're determind to find out who it is, but they're in for a shock when they finally unmask them.

When the villains seem to have the Mane 6 in their sight and victory is withiin their grasp, Spike makes a decision that turns the tables, but at what cost? More importantly, how will all his close friends deal with it?