The ponies are sent on vacation to Manehattan. At their hotel, a pony has her apple stolen, and an immediate investigation is conducted by the Manehattan Police Force. This story is a copy of the testimonials given by the eight witnesses as recorded by the Manehattan Police Force. To help you guess the culprit:

Everypony has told at least one lie; the lies are not always intentional.
Everypony has stated at least one truth.
The culprit is one of the Mane six.

An entry for the February Write-Off Competition. I wrote to the prompt: "The Mane six go on vacation."

Inspired by the short story "In a Grove" by Ryūnosuke Akutagawa