Broken Hearts and Diamonds

"Well, hello there."

Flitter stopped breathing in horror as she looked up at the drunk stallion. She was completely exposed as she was had slid down so she was now on her back, her pussy exposed thanks to the crotchless panties. The stallion's dick was already out due to the heavy urge to urinate, but it hardened even more at the sight of the slutty pony in front of him. The stallion looked over to see if his friend was still nearby but the second stallion had wandered off ahead somewhere.

Flitter couldn't help but stare at his cock, and combined with the massive stimulation caused by the gem in her panties her second orgasm was about to hit her. "N-no! Don't look, go away!" she gasped in horror but it was too late. "Nnmmm! Noo..."

Flitter's protests turned into moans as her body shook once more and she came hard. As before her pussy began to squirt and the stream of her fluids hit the stallion's leg.

"Agh! What the?" he shouted in surprise, but he soon realized what was happening. He moved his hoof to her panties and pushed the vibrating gem against her clit even harder.

"No! No! Nooo... gghhhh!" Flitter cried again, her orgasm increasing even more. The stream coming from her pussy had begun to weaken but now it increased as she reached another orgasm almost instantly. The drunk stallion smiled and bent down to taste Flitter's juices directly from her soaked crotch, causing her to lift her hips automatically as his tongue made contact with her slit.

She moaned as he licked her and lapped up her wetness. However, he still needed to pee... badly. Figuring that this little mare must enjoy playing while wet (as she had just squirted all over one of his legs), he placed his forelegs against the wall so his cock was aimed at her chest. Flitter froze as she got a close look at his cock, and she was terrified that he could try to force her to suck his cock. She clamped her mouth shut in hopes that he would back away but he didn't move his hips forward. Instead, something else happened...

Flitter screamed out loud as the stallion began to urinate all over her body, the warm, yellow fluid pouring from the tip of his cock. It started out just hitting her chest and stomach but as the stream gained strength it began to reach her neck and eventually her face. She couldn't move away from his stream due to his legs surrounding her, and she was forced to endure the humiliation of being used like a urinal. The stallion, however, was having the time of his life and finally finished emptying his bladder. Flitter was too shocked to cry and all she was able to do was curl up in a ball. As she did, though, she exposed her plugged ass to him, and he looked down at the piece of rubber sticking out from her butt.

"What the hay... what's that?" he asked. Flitter didn't respond, so he reached out and gently touched the plug with his hoof. Flitter whimpered as he tried pushing it into her, but it wouldn't go in any more, so instead he decided that he should try pulling it out. He gave a slight tug and felt the object begin to slide out of her ass. Flitter gasped as the plug began to be pulled free but she still didn't move from her fetal position, making the drunk stallion think that she wanted him to pull it out. He gently pulled the plug free from her ass and saw that there was still something else inside of her attached to a string. "Huh..." he said cluelessly. His curiosity got the better of him and with one swift yank he pulled the anal toy out of her body in one swift motion.

Flitter's body went rigid as she opened her mouth in a silent scream. The balls had hurt going slowly into her body one at a time, but having all six round balls yanked forcefully from her ass was just too much. Flitter's wings shot open and her limbs straightened out as her mind didn't know whether to feel pleasure, pain or relief. Her body eventually settled on deciding to feel the pain, and she finally found her voice.

"Augghhh! Celestia, it hurts! Aghhh! G-get away from me!" she cried out. Her legs thrashed wildly from the pain, but the stallion thought she was trying to hit him in anger. Coupled with her loud shouts of pain it proved to be enough to scare the stallion off back into the night.

As much fun as Rarity was having watching the show she knew that she had to get Flitter out of the area before somepony came to investigate all the screams and cries from her. She emerged from her hiding place and quickly unlocked the leash from the fence and pulled gently to make Flitter follow her, leaving the anal beads behind. Still sobbing from her violent treatment Flitter allowed herself to be pulled along by the unicorn, and thankfully within a few minutes of walking the two arrived at Flitter's home.

"Is cloudchaser home?" Rarity asked Flitter, noticing that all the windows were dark. Flitter shook her head and Rarity quickly pushed the pegasus inside, headed for the bathroom. Once inside Rarity helped Flitter remove her urine-soaked clothes and got her into the shower. She thought that Flitter would be able to wash herself but soon after putting her inside of it the pegasus collapsed with a loud 'thump'.

"Oh, for the love of..." Rarity moaned. She hesitated for a second before entering the shower with Flitter, lifting the despressed mare back onto her feet. Rarity felt queasy as her mane and tail got wet under the water, and she thought of how long it would take to restyle them both once she got home. Her attention eventually returned to the still crying mare in the shower next to her, and she helped Flitter wash her body of the foul smelling piss covering her body. Flitter let Rarity wash her body as her mind raced in confusion, her train of thought interrupted only when Rarity began washing around her sore anus. Thankfully, Rarity didn't spend much time washing her flank, afraid that doing so was too dirty.

Having washed Flitter clean, Rarity dried them both off and ushered Flitter to her bedroom. Flitter jumped away from Rarity as soon as they entered her room, her eyes filled with fear and betrayal. "R-Rarity... how.. h-how could you l-l-let him do that to me?" she sobbed. "I... you said y-y-you'd be gone for j-just a little bit. I t-t-trusted you."

Rarity smirked and decided that she had carried on her charade long enough. "Well, that's not my fault now, is it?" she said bluntly. "You should know better than to trust a mare when you steal her lover."

"What a-are you..." Flitter began to ask, but Rarity interrupted her.

"You stole Spike from me." she said, bringing her face close to Flitter's. "He was mine first, and you think you can come in and take him away from me? You don't know who you're messing with. If you're smart you'll leave him and never see him again. If you don't, it would be a shame if certain rumors that you enjoy being pissed on started spreading around Ponyville."

Flitter gasped in horror. "You... you wouldn't..."

Rarity put on an innocent smile. "Well, if you don't believe me, you could always ignore my advice and find out the hard way." she said. "Oh, and I would wash those clothes before your sister gets home. They reek of urine." Rarity left Flitter's room, satisfied as she heard Flitter break down crying once more. She left the distraught pegasus alone in the empty house and returned to her own home, confident that Flitter would remain silent about tonight's activities. She spotted her camera on her desk and wished that she had brought it with her tonight to document Flitter's humiliating experience and blackmail her, but as she looked at how many photos she had left she noticed there were only three pictures left.

'Hmm, I could have sworn I had at least twenty photos left on this film.' she said. She shrugged and removed the film, packaging it up and placing it in her mailbox to be developed in the morning.

*bang* *bang* *bang*

"Twi, ya in there, sugarcube?"

Twilight rubbed her eyes and opened the front door, wondering who could be at her home so early. 'Jeez, the sun's not even up yet!' she thought. She was surprised to see almost all of her friends standing there; Fluttershy, Applejack, Rainbow Dash, and Pinkie Pie. "Girls, what's going on?" she asked sleepily.

"Um, we're, uh, we didn't mean to wake you. We can, um, come back later. Sorry..." Fluttershy squeaked, but Rainbow Dash bopped her on the head to shut her up.

"Something weird has been going on!" the rainbow mare said bluntly. "Last night a blinding flash went off in my room and I heard something breaking. It was... just look!"

Rainbow Dash held out her Element of Loyalty, the red thunderbolt shaped gem dulled and cracked. Twilight couldn't believe her eyes; she had never heard of this happening. Not even when Discord corrupted all of them did the Elements break. She watched in horror as all her other friends held out their Elements, showing that theirs too had suffered the same fate.

"What the... how could this happen?" Twilight asked, but none of them knew. Twilight looked around and looked even more concerned. "Where's Rarity?" she asked.

"I dunno, we tried knocking on her door but she didn't answer." Pinkie said. "Ooh! Maybe she's..."

"No, Pinkie, we talked about this already. She ain't planning a party." Applejack said. "Twi, ya must have some idea of what's goin' on here, righ'?"

Twilight shook her head. "I... I don't know, girls. I already have my hooves full with waiting for Spike to wake up." she said sadly. "Why don't you leave your elements here with me and I'll see if I can figure this out. I'll stop by Rarity's on my way to the hospital today and see if her Element of Generosity is like yours."

The other ponies gave Twilight their Elements and let Twilight be, feeling bad for adding yet another burden to her heavy load but it needed to be done. Her friends said goodbye to her before dispersing to go about their busy days, leaving Twilight sighing as she closed her door and went right to work.

She brought the broken Elements up to her room and laid them on her table where she kept her crown. He Element looked normal to her, but upon closer inspection she noticed that the Element of Magic seemed to be faded. She rubbed her eyes and looked again, this time certain that the crown was lacking its usual luster. She sat puzzled by what could be happening, then rushed off to go see Rarity. 'If all the Elements are like this, we're in big trouble.' she thought as she raced through Ponyville.