Broken Hearts and Diamonds

"Rarity? Rarity, are you home?"

Rarity was home, but she was hesitant to open her door to see what Twilight wanted. 'That cunt! She... she snitched and told Twilight what I did to her!' she thought, thinking that Flitter had sought help.

'No, calm yourself, Rarity. If she had, Twilight would have brought the guards with her. Maybe Spike is finally awake.' she thought, clearing her mind. She took a deep breath and opened her door and was almost knocked over as Twilight came barging in.

"Rarity, where's your Element of Generosity?" Twilight said, getting straight to the point.

"My Ele... Twilight, what's going on?" Rarity asked, genuinely confused.

"We don't have time, Rarity. Where is it?" the alicorn said, becoming more and more anxious.

"It's... upstairs, in the jewelry box by my bed." Rarity said. In an instant Twilight ran upstairs with Rarity hard on her heels, wondering what was going on. Twilight ran into Rarity's room and opened the box, her heart hopeful that at least one of the powerful Elements had escaped undamaged. However, what she found caused her to stumble back and fall on her flank. Rarity's Element wasn't just cracked, it had also turned black, the normal glimmer now clouded.

"No... they're all... they're all damaged." Twilight said. Rarity saw her Element and was also at a loss for words.

"Twilight, what's going on? What's happening?" Rarity asked.

Twilight shook her head, unsure of what this all meant, how the Elements became corrupt, or if it was even possible to fix them. "I- I don't know. I don't know." Twilight said, feeling absolutely powerless. She picked up the black gem and looked at it closer. "I'm going to have to take this home with me. All the other Elements are damaged also."

"Of... of course, Twilight darling. Whatever you need." Rarity said, secretly relieved that Flitter's name wasn't brought up. The unicorn saw Twilight out, and just as she was going to shut her door she saw a gray streak in the sky headed towards her.

"What the..." was all Rarity was able to say before the blur smashed into the wall of her boutique just feet from her.

"Oopsie." was all the pegasus said as she pried herself from the wall. "Sorry."

This was not the first time the klutzy mail pony had messed up her landing and smashed into a building instead of landing on her hooves. "Derpy, you really must be more careful." Rarity scolded her.

"I'm sorry, it's just that I was so late yesterday I missed my usual pick up time, so I wanted to get an early head start today so I wasn't late twice in a row." Derpy explained. She reached into her mailbag and held out a parcel for Rarity. "Here you go!"

Rarity looked at the return address and was shocked that it was the photos she sent out to be developed just last night. "But... how? I just put these in the mailbox last night!" she exclaimed.

"Oh, well, I picked them up last night but I kinda broke a door when I was dropping it off at the shop." Derpy explained. "The owner had to stay up anyway while his door was being fixed so he worked on these so I didn't have to come by again."

Rarity shook her head; it amazed a lot of ponies that Derpy wasn't in the hospital more often. But they did have to give the klutzy pegasus credit for being so determined and serious about her job. "Um, thank you, good job." Rarity said. Derpy saluted and flew off, more than likely off to cause more unintended chaos for some other pony. Rarity returned to her shop and sat down at her counter, opening the photos and going through them to see what pictures she had to send out. She flipped through the various outfits she had photographed and sorted them according to who she had to send them to, but half way through the pictures her jaw dropped in absolute shock by what she saw,

She found herself staring at a half naked Flitter laying on her couch and covered in streaks of what appeared to be cum, her red dress pulled up around her chest and her panties not hiding anything due to them being soaked. The next picture was an up close shot of her crotch covered by the sheer panties, and the next was of her face with more cum dribbling from her lips. Rarity looked at photo after photo of the unconscious Flitter in her vulnerable, exposed state, and as she finally came to the last few photos she saw that whoever had taken the photos had finally removed her panties and photographed her naked slit, and the very last photo was of proof of her innocence.

It finally dawned on Rarity that Thunderlane must have taken these photos before he was caught by Spike and Twilight. A few more seconds passed before she smiled once she realized that she had exactly what she wanted; leverage against Flitter to make sure she stayed quiet. No, more than just staying quiet... Rarity could make her do whatever she wanted unless she wanted the photos to get spread around Ponyville.

Most ponies couldn't help but admire the architecture and decor of Carousel Boutique as they approached the building, but one pony found the sight of it absolutely terrifying. She froze at the sight of it and wanted to desperately run away, but she swallowed her fear and thought to herself that needed to do this. Trying to imagine that she was braver than she was, she took a deep breath and entered the boutique.

Rarity looked up as the bell chimed when the door opened. "Oh, hello. Welcome to Carousel Boutique."she said to her visitor.

Flitter walked up to the counter and placed a bag on it. "I... brought that outfit from last night. I washed it this morning so it's clean, but I don't know what happened to that... other part." Flitter said nervously. "I... I want you to leave me alone. I don't want to be around you anymore, and I want you to leave Spike alone, too. He deserves better friends than you."

Rarity was secretly impressed that Flitter had mustered up the courage to confront her like this. "Of course, Flitter. I understand." she said innocently.

Flitter was caught off guard. "Y-you... you do?" she asked.

Rarity nodded. "Of course, I've been acting absolutely horrid to you in my jealousy. I know this won't fix anything or change your mind, but I simply must show you something before you go. I think it will make things better."

Flitter thought for a moment before nodding, figuring that Rarity's words held no venom. 'She just wants to show me something, there's no harm in that, right?' she thought as she followed Rarity to the back workroom. Flitter felt a sudden cold sweep over her body as the entered the room where she was drugged and nearly raped, but thankfully Rarity had moved everything around back in their original place. The unicorn motioned for Flitter to sit next to her and brought a photo album over with her magic, levitating it in front of them both.

"I've made a lot of fond memories with Spike. I... I guess I just couldn't accept the fact that he would be spending time with another mare." she said somewhat sadly. "We've been through a lot together. Me, him, the other girls... we defeated Nightmare Moon and Discord, as well as King Sombra. Actually, Spike was the real hero, he managed to retrieve the Crystal Heart and brought it back to its rightful place. He also saved my life and saved me from a pack of Diamond Dog ruffians. So, I guess we have a lot of history together." As she spoke she flipped slowly through the photo album, showing various pictures of her and Spike during their time together.

Flitter thought she was finally understanding how Rarity was feeling, and she began to think that maybe she could actually forgive the unicorn for her jealousy and trickery. As Rarity flipped to the last page and closed the album she turned to Flitter. "I guess... I guess I want to say that I'm sorry for what I've done to you and Spike, and I wanted to give you something that maybe you and him could share." she brought over another photo album, Flitter's name adrorned in glitter on the cover. "I figured you may want to start your own album to preserve your memories."

"Oh wow, thank you Rarity." Flitter said. 'Wow... maybe she has changed. She does seem really sorry.' she thought.

"Take a look inside." Rarity said. Flitter did as she was told and flipped the cover over, and Rarity smirked as she saw Flitter's smile come crashing down in horror.

The photos that Rarity found were posted on the pages inside the album, and Flitter looked in horror as all of them showed off every little detail that all decent ponies tried to keep covered up in public. Since Flitter was frozen in terror, Rarity took it upon herself to flip the pages to show Flitter just how many photos there were of her compromised privacy. Flitter felt like she was going to be sick as she saw photo after photo of herself covered in the sticky white fluid as well as a few of a stallion's cock in her mouth, and the last few photos, especially the one of herself being spread open, caused a few tears to fall down her face.

Rarity put down the album and looked into Flitter's watery eyes. "Don't you think Spike would love seeing these? Or perhaps you could share them with everypony in Ponyville. I know for sure that a few stallions you work with will enjoy them for sure. Maybe they'll ask you to autograph them or pose for some more." she said sadistically.

Flitter felt like she was about to lose her mind. She made a sudden jump for the photo album and grabbed it before Rarity could react, but as she took out three of the pictures and ripped them up Rarity began laughing.

"Go ahead, tear them up! You really think that will do anything? I have the negatives safely hidden somewhere, not to mention I already had more copies made." she said. Flitter dropped the album to the floor and groveled at Rarity's hooves.

"Stop this, please! Why are you doing this to me? What do I have to do to have you leave me alone?" she cried hysterically.

Rarity smiled as the numerous thoughts of what she could do ran through her head. She looked out the window and noticed that the sun was setting. "You'll do anything?" she asked. Flitter could only nod, too upset to speak, but it was good enough for Rarity. "Very well. Go and put on the outfit that you just returned and come back here once you have it on." she commanded. Flitter seemed hesitant, but as Rarity held up the photo album Flitter sped from the room and reached into the bag, pulling out the slutty outfit.

Rarity smirked and retrieved her camera, making sure that a fresh roll of film was in place. It took Flitter a while to get the outfit on but she eventually returned to the back room wearing the 'clothes' custom made for her. Rarity noticed that she put her collar on loosely and shook her head. "We can't have that." she said as she manipulated the collar with her magic, forcing it tighter around Flitter's neck. Flitter winced as the collar pinched her skin but remained silent, too scared to make her discomfort known. Rarity looked over the clothes and shrugged. "It will have to do. Come now." she said, picking up the leash and pulling Flitter once again out the door.

Rarity led Flitter down the same route as before but stopped a few buildings away from the night club. To Flitter's horror, Rarity secured the leash around a bench that, while not completely in the open, was exposed enough for any passing pony to see her. "Rarity, what are you..." she began to ask, but a sudden slap across the face shut her up.

"Rule one for tonight, you are not to talk at all. If you do I'll have those photos mailed to every single pony in town as well as spread them across Canterlot and Manehattan." Rarity threatened. "Now don't move, I'll be back."

With a swish of her tail Rarity walked off, leaving Flitter alone. The chained pegasus wasn't sure whether to try and hide behind the bench or to sit down on it and hope nopony noticed her attire. She opted to hide, trying unsuccessfully to hide her exposed body behind the bench. Two ponies did pass by but paid her no attention, whether they were preoccupied or she was hidden in the darkness.

True to her word, Rarity returned after a few minutes. She undid the leash and tugged Flitter forward, walking her down another street and into a secluded alley between two closed stores. Flitter froze as she saw two stallions waiting for them, one of them being the drunk pony that had urinated all over her.

"Woah, she wasn't lying!" the second stallion said. "And neither were you, I guess. Guess I owe you a few beers."

The first stallion smiled, happy that he was able to prove to his friend that there was indeed a slutty mare masturbating behind the club when he went to go relieve himself. Flitter was terrified and wanted to run, but Rarity's strong grip on the leash forced her to stay.

Rarity cleared her throat before speaking. "Like I was saying, I apologize for my pet scaring you like that before, so she's here to apologize."

"Yes, I'm so- Eep!" Flitter cried as Rarity's hoof once again slapped against her face.

"I said no talking!" Rarity yelled at her before turning her attention back to the stallions. "Ahem, my apologies for her rudeness. Anyways, I WAS going to have my pet here show how sorry she is by giving you two a hoof job, but since she can't keep her mouth shut she'll suck your dicks instead."

The faces of the two stallions lit up as Flitter's turned a pale white. Eyeing Flitter, Rarity produced an envelope she was hiding and waggled it in front of her. "Or I can give the pictures to them." she said.

Flitter let out a sad sob as she shook her head, giving in to Rarity's sick game. She knelt down and opened her mouth, waiting for one of the stallions to begin using her but nothing happened. Rarity laughed at her inexperience. "Stupid filly, you have to suck them yourself. They're not going to do all the work for you."

Off to the side the two stallions bickered about who would get to go first. Claiming that if it weren't for him, the first stallion won, and he gladly sat down and exposed his awaiting member to Flitter. She gulped at the size of it, trying to figure out how she was expected to fit it all in her mouth. Rarity yanked at her leash, forcing her towards it, and as she got closer she smelt the stallion's strong, masculine smell. Soon her face was merely inches from the throbbing erection, and she daintily opened her mouth and barely licked the middle of his shaft.

Rarity laughed again. "I guess I have to show you how it's done properly." she said. She grabbed Flitter by the mane and lifted her head directly above the equine cock. Flitter gasped in pain and surprise, wanting to scream no but Rarity's next sentence shut her up;

"If you talk, I'll let them take your virginity."