Triple Trouble Tripled

by SmileandSoar

Some Kind of Nightmare Night Fright

Previous ChapterNext Chapter

Day 58 - Scott Scottson - Principal's Office

I came in to find the room empty. Big surprise. But wait, Guy isn't here. And neither is Richard. Or any of our pony friends. Oh shit. Did they find my Vodka stash? I didn't drink as much because of what happened the first time I drank on campus. Or maybe Rarity had found out that I was the one who ruined her weekend hair drier.

I was in the Principal's office, at Celestia's request, wracking my brain for reasons why she might want to see just me. What had I done in the past month or so? I had been trying to keep a low profile; Rarity and Applejack were at me almost non-stop. And whenever they did take a break from me, they started going after each other instead. At first, I actually enjoyed watching two girls fuck each other. But it got annoying really fast. It's been almost impossible to focus on anything, especially something related to school. To get past that, I had been hanging with Guy and Pinkie in room 32 a lot to get out of my own room; yeah. even Pinkie Pie was easier to focus around than my roommates. Rainbow Dash was never around much when I was there, and Guy didn't want to talk about it whenever I brought that up. Huh. Oh, wait, getting of track here. What was going on?

After a few more minutes of panicking, the principal finally came in, late as usual. At least I thought it was Celestia, but when she walked around into my view, I saw someone completely different. She seemed a bit shorter, her hair definitely wasn’t the same color; this one had black hair with some very dark blue streaks running through it. It seemed to be sparkling a little bit as well. That’s a bit, odd? I don’t even know anymore. Her boobs seemed a bit smaller, but I think there are some wraps around her chest, her ass put Rarity to shame. And her dress just screamed stars, the fabric a blue that was almost black and random specks of white and yellow, blue and red.

"Hello, Scott." She said in a voice that seemed both gentle, yet commanding.

"Um... hi...." I said, confused. "Do I know you?" The woman sighed.

"That pesky sister of mine really should take more effort to make sure I get introduced." She said. "I am SPANK U's Dean, and-"

"Wait, what?"

"I am SPANK U's Dean."

"Holy shit, this school's name is SPANK U?" That had never crossed my mind before.

"Yes. Is this a problem?"

"No, no. Carry on."

"As I was saying, I am also the principal's younger sister and-"

"Oh my god! So you're Luna?" I put in again. Luna was Celestia's sister, after all.

"Yes," she muttered, sounding like she was starting to get annoyed. "Now, if I could just finish my introduction, then maybe-"

"Oh, okay. I'm sorry, I'm kind of a big dick. I'll back up a little and let you finish." I said to let her know I was offering her the floor. For whatever reason, me trying to be polite caused Luna to yell out in frustration. She left the room for a few seconds, then came back in with a perfectly straight face.

"Scott, please don't say anything else until I'm done." She started to talk a little, so I had nothing to do other than look around and try to listen. At one point she turned around, and I noticed that the back of her dress was decorated with a giant crescent moon. It was really quite marvelous, and it almost seemed to glow like the real one in the night sky.

"That's a really nice moon." I couldn't help blurting it out. Again, she gave a frustrated moan.

"Is there anything I can do to make you shut the fuck up and listen?" Well, I hadn't expected that, but...

"Well, now that you mention it..."

About 20 minutes later, I was on my way back to my dorm with my prize. Luna had said something about wanting to meet all the students working on the project, and I was the one she was meeting. As I had walked out, I heard something about hoping the other two weren't as retarded. And that was how I met the school Dean. Not important. What was important was the three bottles of Reyka Vodka. Good thing the Dean was a pony. Otherwise I totally wouldn't have gotten away with getting alcohol out of her. Now I just had to make it back to my room and get this stuff hidden away befor-oh my god whatthefuck? Opening the door, I walked in on Applejack in a Scarecrow costume. Wasn't expecting that.

"Well, Ho-wdy, Scott." She said. Probably one of the normal greetings I've gotten.

"Um... hey. What's up with the outfit?" I thought she was going to explode after that.

"You mean that Rarity done tricked me? I knew this seemed ridiculous!"

"Wait, what?"

"Rarity said y'all put on crazy costumes on October 31st. That little bi-"

"Oh, you mean Halloween?" It had slipped my mind because of my prize. "That's right, Rarity didn't lie."

"Oh. Okay. Then I'll be all right wearing this to Richard's hoe-down?" I looked at the clock. 10:00. I had been wondering why the Principal (or as it were the Dean) had wanted a night meeting, but the fact that it was Luna explained that. Richard's party started in an hour and a half. Ugh. So didn't feel like going.

"Yeah, you'll be fine."

"Great. So what're you goin' as?"

"Eh, I don't think I'm gonna go." She wanted to say something, but I was tired and wanted to sleep. I went to my room and sat down on my bed. I was about to put my stash away, but then I decided one drink couldn't possibly hurt...

An hour and a half later, I was loopy as shit. Maybe I shouldn't have had half the bottle. It was a big ass bottle. I was pretty sure I was hallucinating when a scarecrow and some sort of bondage slave came into my room and grabbed my legs and started pulling me away...

...

Day 58 - Guy Newman - Room 32

Wow, it had already been almost two months of college. Damn, how the time goes. Classes were going okay, I guess. The professors were still out to get Richard, so at least that kept things interesting. Some progress had been made in our contraption, but it was still going to be a long road to completion. In its current state, the machine kept sparking sporadically every time we tried to turn it on. Twilight and Richard were doing their best to find any flaws in the machine itself, while I examined the coding to see if anything was miss-programmed and would result in the current flaws. But at the same time, every last piece that snapped into place right just gave us that much more hope that this was actually possible.

It felt like just yesterday all this had been slammed onto me and I had to take in who exactly I was living with. But now it was pretty normal, and the days just slid by as I enjoyed my time with them. Or at least with Pinkie Pie. We did a lot of things together. So far, we had tried mini-golfing, bowling, video gaming (she was amazingly good for having never held a controller before), music making, and a whole bunch of other stuff. I took the knowledge Scott gathered and opted not to try and teach Pinkie how to drive. We got along really well, even if she was a little too over the top sometimes. I had really warmed up to her, which didn't make my love life any easier. Because then there was Rainbow Dash. Two months, and she still avoided me. She took whatever dialogue was necessary for us to work on our project, or cooperate as roommates, but beyond that she didn't say much to me. I would have just guessed she just decided she didn't like me and was embarrassed about the first few days, but every now and again, when we were both in the living room, or the bedroom, I would catch her looking over at me, a deep sadness in her purple eyes, like she wanted to say something, but couldn't bring herself to. And any time I tried to talk to her, she would just mumble some excuse awkwardly and walk away.

To avoid me, she often just left the room. At first, I took no notice and just let her go. But after a while, I got curious and asked Pinkie if she knew where her friend went almost every day. When she didn't, I started slowly tracking her to satisfy my curiosity. I eventually narrowed down to just a few places, and had been checking them the past few days. Today, only one was left. I had no idea if Dash knew I was on to her or not. Of course, I could still be wrong, in which case I would just drop it. I was kind of hoping she would be more willing to talk if she saw how much effort I had put in to find her. Then again, it could just make her angry at me. But I had to know what was on her mind; I just had to. I was so lost in thought that I didn't notice Pinkie enter my room, which was actually really bad considering how much she stood out at the moment.

"Surprise!" She shouted out, causing me to almost fall off the side of the bed in shock. I looked up in a state of a shock, and the setting slowly set in as my heartbeat went back down. I wasn't usually that jumpy. "Oops, sorry I scared you. But I just wanted to say happy Nightmare Night!"

It took a minute to set in, but I eventually made the connections and realized that it was October 31st. I had been so lost in my personal world that I had almost forgot about Halloween. Or, I guess Nightmare Night in this case. Pinkie was already dressed up in her costume. At least, I hoped it was her costume, but I wouldn't put it passed her to wear this get up on a normal day. On her body was a giant box, gift wrapped with a bow on the front. Across her forehead she had on a balloon headband, which had even more balloons sticking out from it. On the back of the box, even more balloons were tied on. And to top it all off, she had a ridiculous pair of red sunglasses and scuba shoes. I just couldn't help but smile at her.

"It's fine, Pinkie. But here we call it Halloween. And I actually almost forgot about it." I replied.

"But... how could you forget about Howlo-wen? There's free candy!"

"Hal-o-ween," I said, emphasizing each syllable to make sure she got it. She repeated it back, and I moved on with the conversation. "I've just been lost in thought lately and haven't had time to think about those kind of things." To my relief, she didn't ask what "those kind of things" were. But unfortunately...

"But Richard wanted us to all come to a party tonight!" Pinkie said, almost whining that I might not go. To be honest, I had forgotten about that, too. I wanted to go, but it would somewhat defeat the purpose if Dash didn't show up. She and I were the only ones who hadn't yet put in an RSVP. We were also the only ones who Hadn't said "yes" on said RSVP. It was about 8:30 on a Thursday night, but we didn't have classes tomorrow, so Richard had wanted to make it a late night party. He was planning on starting it between 11:30 and Midnight. Rainbow had left for her nightly whatever about ten minutes ago, and I had been about to follow her out.

It was already dark outside, and now I would need to get moving if I wanted to be back in time for the party. And if I wasn't back in time, I would just be attracting attention to myself. I guess I had better get going.

"Yeah, the party. Don't worry. I'll be there." I said as I quickly got up, getting ready to head out.

"Are you going some? Ooh, can I come?!" She asked, getting excited.

"Yes, I'm going somewhere, but no, you can't come." Was my answer, but then she started to pout. Sometimes I had to wonder how I fell for her. Or maybe the energy was just part of the charm. "It's a surprise for the party." I said to cheer her back up. "When you get there, let Richard know I may be a little late, k?"

"Mm-k!" She replied, cheering up at the thought of a surprise. And with my excuse cleared, I headed out the door.

Even though it was almost November, it was still pretty nice outside. It was a warm, pleasant evening; not too hot, but just warm enough that I felt good about the temperature. The streets were already pretty much deserted, Halloween being a little different in the City. In apartment buildings rather than houses. And even that depended on where you lived. The streets were still kept lit by the glow from lamps and store signs. The light was nice, but my destination was way past any of the stores. The walk would probably take about 20 minutes. And that left me lots of time on my own to think; and that sure isn't a good thing. My brain has a really bad habit of going straight to the worst case scenario, which really doesn't help when trying to stay calm. What if she hates me and I make her angry? What if she tries to kick me out? What if I already did something and I don't know what and... Yeah, it wasn't a pleasant walk. So I just tried to tune down my brain and think about other things. I was still going strong on the post-game for Pokemon. That had been fun. All the time spent playing games instead of doing homework?

But I couldn't get my mind off of Rainbow Dash. Had to go faster... These thoughts were scarier than any Halloween costume I had seen in my life, but I was finally drawing close to my destination. Truth of the matter was, I was pretty much this nervous any time I was looking for Rainbow, the same "What if" thoughts always plaguing me.

But finally I broke out of the endless stream of buildings. Now it was just sidewalk, leading up a reasonably sized hill, which was still a short walk away. Absolutely nothing was built here, for what reason, I know but don't remember, and the top still had several trees planted and doing fine, despite the location. And that spot up there was my last guess for where my roommate went off to. The walk up to the top seemed to take forever, but I may have been walking slow on purpose, just to avoid having to get up there. But there was only so long I could make the walk take, and I eventually neared the top. In the light of the full moon, I took in the scene. Several trees were planted on the hilltop, and most of their leaves had fallen to the ground, creating a cushion of oranges and reds over-top the green grass. And in the middle of it all was the form of a human, just lying on the ground and starring up at the sky. Rainbow hadn't noticed me yet, and I was curious what she was doing, so I kept my distance and followed her gaze, which led my stare to the sky. It was amazing how beautiful it was up there. Even with the city so nearby, the sky was clear and covered in stars. So many more than I would have expected. Their light shined down with the moon, giving the night a gentle glow. I gasped in awe.

Which scared the shit out of Rainbow Dash. She jumped up, already getting herself into a fighting stance, shouting "Who's there?" I put my hands up in an 'I'm unarmed' gesture, and started to speak, but the movement had scared Rainbow even more, and I felt a punch land straight in my gut. She could actually hit really hard. I felt the air pressed out of my lungs, then I heard Rainbow utter a confused "Guy?" After several seconds of recovery, I was able to speak again.

"Hi there, RD." I said, trying to sound nonchalant.

"What the hell are you doing here?" She demanded, her expression switching from one of surprise to one of annoyance.

I could have responded in a lot of ways. It was a free park. I could have been the asshole that went that way. I could have told her everything right there. But I decided to take a gamble instead. I looked up at the sky and tried changing the topic.

"Beautiful night." I stated, a question dodge even if it was true.

"Yeah, I... wait, no! Answer the question!" She caught on. I gave a little sigh.

"Fine. But answer me a question first." I said, then without waiting for a reply, "What are you doing out here?" So much for the dodge; I'd just have to push it. She gave me an angry glare for several long seconds, then, without saying a word, lowered her gaze to the ground.

"How'd you find me?"

"I've followed your tracks for about a month, and finally found you here." I admitted.

"Why'd you come here?" She asked, still not looking at me.

"Why?" Such a short, simple question, and yet always one of the hardest to answer. "Why? Well, I guess because I was worried about you." I wasn't sure, but I thought I saw her flinch a little.

"You... you were?" She asked slowly.

"Kind of, yeah. You never said much to me or Pinkie, and were always running off on your own. I thought maybe something was wrong or that maybe..." I trailed off, not really wanting to finish. But I could tell Rainbow was waiting for me to. " Or that maybe you hated me." I finished quietly.

"That's not it!" She instantly burst out, then quickly covered her mouth. I gave her a questioning look. "I... um... I actually really like you." She said quietly. "...I was afraid you wouldn't like me." Well that was an interesting idea.

"What made you think that?"

"I was... Well, when you learned where I was from, I thought you might find it weird to like... you know... and I didn't want to face that, so I just started avoiding you."

"But wait. Pinkie told me where you were from on day one. So why did you..." Her face was already red, so I just trailed off and let her respond.

"Um... I could tell you didn't believe her then, so I was okay for the time. But then when I heard you were meeting with the Celestia, I started to worry. And then she told us that you three had figured it out, and... I'm sorry."

I moved forward and wrapped my arms around her. She seemed a little surprised, but didn't object. In fact, she hugged me back.

"It's okay." I whispered gently into her ear. "But next time, just tell me if something is bothering you. I'd like it if you you trusted me; I am your teacher after all." She wrapped me a little tighter into our embrace, her chin now resting on my left shoulder. I heard her chuckle a little.

"All right." Then she laughed to herself "Some tough girl I turned out to be in all this."

"No problem with being a little sensitive." I said. Then I noticed the few tears I could feel running from her cheeks onto mine. All the small details flowed in at once. The tears seemed to be of happiness as we relaxed under a beautiful full moon and starry sky. She was wearing the same sleeveless vest she had been on the day we met, and the fabric was actually quite soft. And above all, we were both enjoying the other's embrace. We stood like that for a moment or two, then Rainbow gave an awkward cough and pulled back a little.

"So. Wanna watch the stars with me?" Did I? Hell, yes. A beautiful night with a beautiful girl. Our hands latched together as we sat down and leaned back, staring up at the sky. Not a single cloud in sight, and the infinite horizon dancing with speckled lights. It kind of surprised me that a seemingly hardened girl like Rainbow could like to relax and stare at the stars, but I could also understand why. We were together under that bright full moon; nothing else mattered for a moment.

"Kind of funny that the full moon would land on Halloween." I said out loud, but not really intending to.

"Halloween?" Rainbow asked. Oh yeah. I hadn't taught her about that yet.

"Halloween. It's our equivalent of your Nightmare Night. You dress up in costumes, eat candy, throw parties, go trick-or-treating, and... Oh crap!" I broke off, pulling out my phone with my other hand, and finding out that it was already 11.

"What?" She questioned, looking a little concerned.

"Throwing parties! I completely forgot about Richard's Halloween Party!" I practically shouted. "He wanted us all to be there, and everyone else was going."

"Oh yeah, he had invited me to that. But I hadn't really planned on going..." She said, getting up, dragging me up with her, "until now anyway."

I got up too, and we started to walk.

"Well, we won't have much of a costume when we get to the party, but at least we'll be there."

"So is the costumes tradition why Pinkie has been dressing up in all that..." Rainbow asked, with me responding:

"Stuff. Yeah. That one sure has a creative side."

"Yeah..." She looked like she wanted to say something more, but she chose not to, so I moved on.

"Anyway, this should be interesting, at the least. Richard wouldn't tell me what exactly we were doing, but he promised it would be a night we wouldn't forget." That was the first time in a while I saw Rainbow Dash smile.

"Let's get going, then!" She said, and took off, dragging me along by our still entwined hands.

...

Day 58 - Richard Dickinsun - Room 8

Another piece here, another bit there…fuck me. This room is going to be perfect whether it wants to be or not! The cake finally finished, the gummy bears are in the fridge…those are going to be funny, even more so if Pinkie gets her hands on those…and wait…where did Flutters and Twilight go? Oh, giggling, guess they are in the bathroom…well I guess neither would tell me what they were dressing up as…guess it is a surprise. Decorations everywhere, now all I need is to set out the snacks, thanks mom for the ideas, and then everything will be ready…all my extra special contributions will be brought out later once everyone has eaten and danced…hmmmm…maybe I can talk them into a round of truth or dare…then again I’ll probably have to do something dumb…or… I shivered, let’s not think about that. Now there is nothing else to do but wait…it was only 11:15…still another 15 minutes before anyone shows up…damnit…and I have nothing to do…maybe I’ll actually go put on my costume…nothing like a good old bathrobe and fuzzy slipper…just going to live out the Hue Hefner life…with this many girls around it is kind of hard not to feel that way anymore… Welp…it’s 11:30…time for people to actually sta…wait…

“Pinkie, when did you get here?” The curly pink-haired girl whose body was a giant box, gift wrapped with a bow on the front, on her forehead she had on a balloon headband, which had even more balloons sticking out from on top of it, and then on the back of the box, even more balloons were tied on, and to top it all off, she had a ridiculous pair of red sunglasses and scuba shoes. “And what are you wearing???”

“Oh hi, Richard!” She bounced around just as much as she could with that ridiculous outfit on, “I got here right at 11:30 just like you said!”

“But…it just turned 11:30…and I didn’t hear the door open or close…”

“I didn’t use the door silly, would have taken too long.”

“Then how did you…?” It was then I realized the room was getting kind of cold…and that the window was now open…note to self, lock windows. Guess I’ll just close that up. “Well ok then…glad you could make it though.” And she was already gone…

“OOOOOOOH!!! GUMMY BEARS!” Well…this night is going to get started faster than I thought. And now a knock on the door…at least someone remembers how doors work...

“Coming!” God the knocking still hasn’t stopped…someone must be anxious. “STOP KNOCKING!!!” And of course, on the other side of the door stands Rarity, Applejack and dragged behind them a semi-conscious Scott. I can’t help but notice that Rarity decided that less must be more when it comes to costumes in the human world…less meaning basically nothing, I would have seen less of her body if she were wearing a bikini… And Applejack is…just a scarecrow…flannel with some hay sticking out of the sleeves…and short shorts…pretty much her regular clothes plus hay…at least I can’t see 99% of her… Now obviously I would have said something…if it weren’t for the fact that I didn’t think I could physically process anything after seeing an almost entirely nude Rarity…I also didn’t want to end up like Scott who seemed to have a bruise forming on his head and alcohol already in his system. “Well…w-welcome ladies. Pinkie is already here and Twilight and Fluttershy are still getting themselves ready.”

“Well golly! Glad to know we ain’t late. Had a bit of trouble with Scott back there.” Applejack moved past dragging Scott along.

“Yes…I think he wanted to spend yet another day in bed. We told him he was going, seems like we were right. Hmpf.” And with that the barely covered Rarity squeezed past, her breast rubbing against my chest. I exhaled, didn’t even realize I had been holding my breath…guess it must have just been shock…then again the massive boner I have probably didn’t help… Now we are just waiting on Guy and Rainbow Dash…where the heck are they?

I think I just heard something about Pinkie really enjoying Rarity’s costume…I don’t even know how to feel about that. I just can’t help but smile at this point, it’s been a long time since I’ve had friends to hang out with like this. Ooooh! A knock on the door! Opening it revealed not who I thought, but instead I found a girl who I haven’t met before…and she was only in a towel, her hair up in one of those hair…towel…thingies…you know, the one that look kind of like a turban…shit I was too busy staring at her and I think she said something…I really need to stop doing that. “Ummm…could you repeat that?”

“I said keep it down, I haven’t had a good night’s sleep in weeks from all the damn moaning from your room. I have midterms tomorrow and I actually want to do well.” And with that she went to walk away. Suddenly an extremely drunk ball made up of a Pinkie Pie and a Scott flew out of the door, landed on top of the girl and rolled away with her towel. In response I simply closed the door and walked away. Guy will find them eventually…right?

Back inside the room Flutters and Twilight still seemed to be in the bathroom…and Rarity and AJ are making out on the couch…well, time to make some popcorn. After turning the microwave on I finally heard another knock on the door. Hopefully this is finally the other two sane people. To my delight Guy and Dash finally arrived, each one of them supporting their slightly intoxicated friends. “Nice to finally see you guys!” The smile on my face grew even larger.

“Are you missing someone?” Guy said. He and Dash both look like they had had quite a long walk, wonder what they had been up to. I think he noticed the disappointed look I had. “Sorry we aren’t in costume.”

“Yeah, we went for a bit of a walk before coming over here…” Dash chided in. Well, at least they are here. I ushered them past, the second time Scott has been dragged into my room just today. Hope this doesn’t become a regular thing.

“Alright! Now that everyone is here let’s get this party started!!!” Pinkie cheered as she broke out of her drunken stupor. At least someone else is as excited as me. I tossed her the controls for the stereo and she suddenly found some great house party music. I went back towards the kitchen to retrieve the popcorn. Ok, popcorn, bowl…now back out to th- holy shit. Somewhere in my mind I felt the bowl hit my foot as I dropped it…but pretty much all the blood in my body was being siphoned into two areas, my head and my…’head’. Newly emerged from the bathroom I found Fluttershy waiting for me around the corner…she was in a bunny suit…not one of the ones like the Easter Bunny wears…but one of the extremely sexy and tight fitting ones that the Playboy Bunnies wear…ears and all. If I were to die right now…I would actually be happy.

“D-do you like it?” Her voice still as innocent as can be.

“I…I…I…” I can’t form a coherent thought…

“I told Twilight that I should have just dressed up like a butterfly…” She looked down beginning to do that cute little leg thing she always does nowadays… “I guess I’ll just go take it off…” She turned to leave, along with my chances of getting to see her in that the rest of the night. I quickly grabbed her wrist, spun her around and locked her against the wall with my body pressed firmly against hers.

“That is the cutest costume I have ever seen, don’t you dare take it off.” With that I planted a kiss on her neck, her face now fully flushed and released her from the wall.

“O-oh…I’m…uh…glad you like it.” Inside she looked like she must have been cheering and thanking Twilight. Speaking of Twilight…what was her…oh god… She’s wearing wings…and a horn…and she dyed her skin purple… I attempted to shove my palm through my forehead, the thud resounding around the room. And now she just put on a crown as well…well, I guess it could be worse…well…I mean, I guess Rarity’s is worse…or is it? I don’t even know anymore. FUCK IT! Let’s party.

About three hours of partying and drinking ensued, we even got Twilight to drink a little by this point. She definitely wasn’t happy about all the alcohol and I’m pretty sure she wrote up a drunk complaint slip for the headmaster…oh well, could be worse I guess. I mean, it is only Celestia after all. I guess it is finally time to propose the new game…

“Alright everyone! I have a game for us.” I slammed down a giant game of Twister onto the table. “That’s right, strip Twister time! Each round ends with one person left standing, at the end of the round everyone but the winner has to remove an article of clothing.” In their wasted state, everyone agreed.

“Soooo…..wut yer sayin ish that Rarity wull be out in lik two rountds?” The horribly slurred speech came from none other than our extremely wasted friend Scott…

“Yeah Scott, pretty much.”

“I’ll have the both of you know that I am actually very good at Twister, but nowhere near as good as Pinkie of course.” She apparently can hold her alcohol much better than most of us as well…

“Alright, let’s get gaming!”

A few rounds went by with Pinkie destroying everyone, at this point Rarity was still wearing her shoes…and only her shoes…don’t know why she saved those for last…Applejack still had her underwear…Twilight by far had the most clothes on being that she had so many props she could remove. Flutters was sticking very close to me now that she lost her bra, her embarrassment was obvious. And Rainbow Dash has been close to winning against Pinkie for the first time now that she only had underwear and a sports bra to worry about impeding her movements. Us guys on the other hand…well Scott passed out now, but Guy and I were both going strong with at least boxers still left…I still had slippers as well. And I think Pinkie just threw that round, have to wonder if she was just upset that everyone else was getting to strip and she couldn’t. So off came the entire present box to reveal that she was completely nude underneath…well…I would say it was surprising if it were anyone other than Pinkie. But when it comes to her, nothing is surprising anymore. Guess it’s next round then huh…welp. Let’s do it. Everyone repositioned themselves in a…somewhat organized circle around the mat, Guy spun the placement spinner.

“Left leg red” Everyone found a spot, not bad so far. “Right leg green” Ok…so now we are stretching…still not too bad. Everyone seems a little clustered, but at least Flutters is right here, she is facing towards me, her arms locked around my back in an attempt to hide her breasts from view. Guy was sitting out this round not wanting to lose all of his clothes. Rainbow and Pinkie are in heated competition staring down each other, neither wanting to lose. Applejack and Rarity just seem to be trying to tickle each other into falling… “Right hand yellow” Oh…well crap. Flutters does a back bend pulling me along with her and I place my hand on the yellow space right below hers allowing her to keep ahold of me. Everyone else seems fairly comfortable, but Rarity is starting to giggle from AJ’s tickling assault. “Left hand blue” The moment of truth. Flutters and I again working as a team line up our hands so mine is just one space below hers. The backbend she was doing underneath me was astounding. With only her panties and my boxers still on, and me being slightly inebriated…the boner I had was pressed firmly against her slit…needless to say every little motion put her into a state of euphoric pleasure and me further into a state of ‘let’s finish this fucking party so I can fuck her brains out.’ Now, let’s clear this up, Flutters and I have fooled around, but we haven’t ever actually had sex .

“THERE GOES RARITY!” Guy yells. I look over and see Rarity rolling on the mat, her laughter overtaking her, this caused Pinkie to start laughing and suddenly there was a giant crash as a huge pileup of people formed where everyone else had been seconds before…apparently Scott was uncomfortable and figured this would be a better place to sleep…alrighty then. I think it is time to call this all quits. I stood up, pulling up Fluttershy with me, her arms locked around my waist and her breasts glued to my back.

“Ok everyone, it’s time for everyone to be getting home…” Rarity and AJ rose and began to drag Scott off the game mat…I’m a tad worried about those three…they all look trashed. Rarity is probably the only person other than Pinkie that gave me a run for my money in alcohol consumption. And AJ was the next closest after her. But off they go down the hallway, each with a leg in their hand…whatever, not like they can make him any dumber or anything. Guy and Rainbow were both trying to support/control Pinkie, who outdrank me by a mile. All those gummies took a toll on her, but she was still as energetic as ever…which is duly noted in the fact that I now had 3 broken lamps in my room…gotta get those replaced…ugh. But the funniest part of that group was that Guy was stumbling back and forth, normally he would swear he doesn’t drink. He however didn’t have much of a problem with it after Dash and I spiked his drink with the strongest vodka we could get. He lightened up a lot and probably drank more than Scott, at least he could hold his alcohol better. And finally there was Twilight, she drank from the same cup that Guy had…and boy did she ever show it, she must have fallen asleep sometime around the beginning of the last round…guess I must have missed that. Guess I should take her to her bed…but Flutters is still stuck to me…aaaand now Twilight is throwing up…all over her clothes. Fuck.

“Bye Guy. Nice job tonight Dash. Can’t believe how good you are with parties Pinkie, next time you host!” They all walked out the door, I locked it up…now…what to do about Twilight...hmmm... “Hey Flutters, head to bed, I'll be in in a few minutes.” After a light peck on her cheek she headed back to our room to get comfy. I started cleaning Twilight's vomit, she seemed to be back in a deep sleep. I lifted her up off the ground and hauled her into her room. Stripped her costume off her…or at least what was left of it. She was wearing a dark purple bra and her panties were lacy and had flower prints…now that I look she has a pretty nice butt…wait I have Flutters waiting in the other room, what am I doing. Wait, fuck, her vomit stained all the way down to her underwear… Better get those off too… I close my eyes and get them off, trying to ignore the fact that the girl in front of me is completely naked…I tucked her into her bed and slowly closed the door. I really hope she doesn’t remember anything of tonight…

“Rich?” I hear a very sweet voice say. “Is everything ok?” I grabbed my cup of vodka off the table on my way back to the room.

“Everything is fine Flutters.” I walked into our room. “Are you ok?”

“I feel a little sleepy…b-but I don’t really want to go to bed yet…” I take a sip to steel my nerves. “Uh…ummm…can I have a sip of that?” I must have looked a little funny because she quickly added, “If that’s ok with you…I don’t want to take your things.”

“It’s nothing like that hun…just, didn’t think you enjoyed the alcohol you drank tonight…” She didn’t really drink anything…she tried a little beer but she didn’t like the taste…but who can blame her it was that little piss colored light beer…ugh. “If you really want to try some…sure.” I handed her the cup, and she was instantly chugging it. That cup was probably enough to fill at least five shots…and she just downed it like it was nothing…damn.

“Woah…! That feels funny…it feels really warm…all the way down to my belly…mmm…”

“F-flutters…are you ok? That was a lot of vodka…you aren’t going to get sick or anything right?” She nodded her head as she crawled out of bed and walked over to me, it struck me that she wasn’t wearing anything, now I’ve seen her naked before…but the mix of alcohol and moonlight streaming in through the open blinds…I don’t know, she just seemed even sexier than usual. She placed her hands on my chest and leaned in to kiss me. I leaned down a little and our lips met, her tongue instantly pounding against my lips seeking refuge in my mouth. Her hands making small circles on my chest, running down to my waist and then to my hips. I went to place my hands around her shoulders, but suddenly she broke off the kiss, dropping out of my immediate field of view. She locked her fingers around my boxers, pulling them straight to the ground, revealing my growing erection, right in front of her face.

“You seem like you are pretty excited Flutters…” She looked up at me and licked her lips…and I almost lost it, I leaned back against my bed to support myself. She began fondling my sack, her mouth making kisses along the side of my cock…she traveled all so slowly up to the head, lightly licking across the head. God I think she is really enjoying this. “Unnnnh…” The moan forced its way out of my mouth as she took my dick into hers. Her tongue was still working along my shaft as she began bobbing her head up and down. I reached down to move her hair away from her face, but as I went to move her hair I felt teeth gently run across my member, apparently she wanted me to just sit back and enjoy it…she began sucking harder, I was nearing the point of no return, I’m sure she could tell, but just before I hit the wall she stopped and stood up. A small amount of pre-cum was stuck by the corner of her mouth. She quickly licked it off and pressed on my chest trying to make me fall onto the bed. I grabbed her hands, and forced them to her side as I lifted her by the waist and placed her on the bed, leaning down I began my own game. I started by kissing her thighs. I quickly found myself out of thigh and instead found a pretty pink slit in front of me. A few quick licks across the entirety of it caused juices to begin flowing out. Not wanting to stain her sheets I started to drink all of them, sucking lightly on her lips as well. I hope she is ready…I forced my tongue between her walls, starting slowly and finally increasing speed. I could feel her body gyrating against my face trying to force me to go faster and deeper…how could I say no. My hands locked around her waist pulling her to me tightly, her legs locked around my head, I couldn’t stop now even if I wanted to. I found a pretty pink button and began licking and sucking at that was well. Her clit throbbed and her juices were flowing at an alarming rate, her blankets were soaked and her legs began tightening even more around my head pushing me deeper, I sped up even more. Suddenly her breathing went completely irregular, a flood of juices forced their way into my mouth, drinking them all and trying to lick up the rest I began pulling my head back as the orgasm worked through the rest of her body. I climbed up onto her bed running my hands along her stomach and up to her breasts. Her nipples were hard and I hadn’t even touched them yet. She finally regained control of her body.

“You know…this isn’t very fair…” She whispered in my ear.

“What do you mean?”

“I just did…that…but I stopped you short…” You see her logic.

“Yes…?” Still not sure what to do about it.

“Isn’t there anything else we could do?” She asked with a sly twinkle in her eye.

“Well…there is one thing we haven’t done yet.” She gasped with excitement.

“Can we do that?” She asked innocently, her horniness quickly rebuilding. I nodded, we have been together for a while now…it’s alright now…right? I was interrupted by her lips pressing against my neck, a sensation I will never be tired of. I rolled onto my back and pulled her on top of me.

“Now…raise your hips a little.” She complied, and I positioned her pussy right above my dick. “And sit down a little…but not too-“ She sat straight down impaling herself on my cock. She screamed out in pain and collapsed on top of me panting. “fast…”

“This…really hurts…are you…sure this…is right?” She looked up at me, a few tears glistening in her eyes. I quickly kiss her tears away. Her smile returning.

“Yes I’m sure Flutters. You just need to go slower.” I withdrew most of my length before lightly pressing it back in about halfway, a small moan escaping from her mouth.

“Oh…that feels wonderful…” She began leaning back into it further and further, until my entire length began filling her, her tight virgin walls clamping down tightly on me. There was no way I was going to last longer than her, so I began to fondle her breasts, running my fingers in circles around her hard nipples. Another moan escaped before I pressed my mouth against hers, trapping all others to come. Our tongues met as my slow thrusting continued, they danced around one another before I pressed into her mouth exploring each of her teeth and into her cheeks. I felt that now would be a good time… I released her boobs and quickly wrapped my arms around her chest throwing her weight to the side landing myself on top. Her gasp of surprise extended as I began thrusting harder into her. A small trickle of blood appeared out of her and ran along my shaft. A few tears still ran from her eyes but her pleasure greatly overwhelmed her pain. I broke off our kiss allowing her moans to permeate the air. “Rich I…I’m almost there…” I leaned down and began suckling on her beautiful melons. An act that started to push her over the edge for the second time. A huge pressure began to build up in my sack. I knew what that meant, it was soon time to pull out, just a few more thrusts. Just then she hit the wall, her orgasm overflowing, but she also locked her legs around my hips. Her muscles tightened not allowing me to pull away even an inch. Her walls clenched together and seemingly sucked at my swollen cock…there’s no possible way I can stop this…and with that the explosion trigged, filling her with your sticky white semen. A little leaked out onto the blanket, but her face was still in the throngs of pleasure. A small flicker of remorse flashed through my mind before she sat up and kissed me passionately. As she pulled away from our kiss I finally pulled out of her.

“D-did that feel good?” She asked. I couldn’t help but chuckle a little.

“Well…we both finished didn’t we?” She blushed immensely, then wrapped an arm around my chest as I laid down next to her.

“Y-yes…that felt really good…”

“Good to hear.” I kissed her forehead before she rested her head on my chest as well.

“Rich?” I wrapped an arm around her shoulders.

“Yes?” She yawned a little.

“I love you…more than anything…” I twirled her hair in my fingers.

“I love you too Fluttershy…” She closed her eyes and held onto me tighter.

“Please don’t leave me…” I almost started crying… Knowing full well that someday she will have to go back to her world.

“I wouldn’t dream of it…” She couldn’t stop herself from falling asleep…and I couldn’t stop the tears.

I don’t want her to leave…and I know I have to stay here… Or do I?


Author's Note

SmileandSoar - So, by this point, I'm curious who noticed. Anybody that didn't know where we were going to college... you know now. Anyway, life happened, and we've had school work (by we I mean me, cause nobody else does it) and have been putting a lot of focus into our new youtube channel on top of that. This'll still get done, just not quite as fast as the first few chapters. Fucking CDR made his characters total sluts, so now I have to finish it that way. Woot. Oh well. I decided the overall plot of this thing the other day, and this'll definitely be one hell of a ride. And lastly, please address Scott as Scott Mcfucking Scottson. So happy nightmare night, and double trouble from me: I'll be posting a random one-shot later tonight.

Tehheliclopter - As S&S said we have been doing a lot of work on youtube...so sorry about this. We will attempt to update more frequently, but as you can probably tell I'm not the best writer, this one really challenged me...trying to write as though I am a ton of different people at the same time, so I apologize and promise to get better. Any comments or suggestions are welcome. Thanks for reading!

Clop Drop and Roll - I did this guy's part. And probably will for the rest of the story. Yeah, he's not good at this.

Next Chapter