Broken Butterfly

Oh dear. It’s time already? Glancing at the clock, my eyes widened in shock and my heart pumped against my chest at a rapid pace. I was late. I quickly trotted down the basement steps until my hooves hit the cold and damp floor.

Smelling rotted flesh brought an odd sensation to my stomach. Searching for the light switch, I slammed my body into something hard. “Oh, I’m sorry.” I knew nopony was there, but it would be rude of me not to apologize for such a mean act. “There.” I clicked the light switch to ‘on.’

Mudded flesh stuck onto the walls, while feathers covered in blood laid on the floor. She must have been quite busy with herself. I trotted to a rusted door in front of me and unlocked it with the key I brought with me. Opening the door, she sat in her usual spot and didn’t move a muscle, as usual. “Hello? I’m here.” I closed the door behind me as I went inside the room. “You there?”

“Please close the door.” A faint and broken voice spoke to me. A yellow pegasus with a pink mane sat alone in the dark, her face turned to the wall, with blue blankets covering her body. Blood could be seen underneath the blankets. “Please close it.”

“Oh, umm... it’s already closed,” I said, smiling. But it was pointless. She wouldn't see me smile, nor would she care. “How are you feeling?”

“I need more!” The mare clawed at my chest, her dirty hooves touching me. “I hunger for more love, I cannot live without it.”

Slowly taking her hoof off me and placing it on her lap. I gave her a gentle smile. “You will get some more, don’t you worry. But first, we need to get you washed up.”

Taking out a sponge from a nearby bucket of water, I began to scrub it around the mare’s body. “My friends don’t know about you yet.” Scrubbing the blood stains on her coat, I dipped the sponge back into the bucket before squeezing out the water back into the bucket.

“They’re… they’re my friends?” she asked, turning her head to look behind me. “I’m Fluttershy, the element of—ah!” A pleasurable moan escaped her mouth as I scrubbed around the base of her damaged wing. “Please fuck me already,” she said through breaths. “Please, I know you want to.”

I shook my head. “No, I don’t.” Scrubbing the last blood stain out of her coat, I placed the sponge back into the bucket and set it aside. I gave her a small smile before getting up from the dirty floor. I trotted to the door, but stopped when the door was opened. “Who are you again?”

“F-Fluttershy.”

“Sure you are.” Closing the door until it was completely shut, a sigh escaped my mouth. Sliding down onto the floor, Angel hopped in front of me and stared at me with his usual frown. “I’m going out again, Angel.” I got up and carried him up upstairs.

I shut the door once I was back inside the living room and placed Angel on the floor. “I hope I have enough.” Reaching into my jacket pockets, I pulled out and counted forty bits in my hooves and put them back. Just enough for what I needed. Putting on the jacket, I went to the door. “I’ll be back, Angel. Just gotta make a quick run.”

I closed the door behind me and began to trot through the rain to go meet her...

Searching for her in the empty streets of Ponyville, the calm noise of the wind rushing and the rain hitting on windshields put me at ease.

I kept my head down to avoid the gazes of other ponies who passed me by. Trotting forward, I bumped into somepony and knocked them down on the ground. I began to panic, my heart racing and my sweat mixing with the rain on my face. I was losing my cool.

“Excuse my clumsiness,” I said, helping up the pony who fell. “Again, I am so sorry.” My heart skipped a beat, leaving me breathless. A mare with a purple mane, light blue eyeliner and three diamonds on her flank. I found her. “I didn’t know that was you, Rarity.”

“Fluttershy, is that you?” Rarity quickly hugged me before breaking away to get a glance at what I was wearing. “Darling, what’s with the getup?” Examining the black leather on the jacket, Rarity scoffed in disgust. “Fluttershy dear, where were you headed?”

“I was going to see you.” A sudden heat had arisen in my cheeks as I tried to hide behind my mane. “Last night was amazing.”

“Actually, I wanted to talk you about that.” Rarity sighed. “I was drunk, you were drunk. Anything that happened last night… wasn’t supposed to happen.”

She wrapped a foreleg around my neck and we started trotting towards my cottage. “I hope that doesn’t ruin our friendship, darling.”

I put on the most sincere fake smile I could muster. Inside me, rage burned inside my soul and my heart shattered into pieces. I felt a lone tear trailed down my cheek, but Rarity didn’t notice because of the rain. “Not at all.”

“How about we go to your cottage and have some tea, hm?” Rarity smiled. “We can have fun little chit chats about stallions and such.”

“That sounds like a plan.” I looked down to where my hoof was stuffed, inside my pocket. Gripping the bits I placed inside in my hoof, I slided them back in and sighed. “But, I’ll make the tea this time.”

“Sure, darling.” Rarity smiled and gave me a friendly nuzzle on the nose. “You do make the best tea.”

Sitting down on the sofa, Rarity took off her raincoat and placed it down on the table. “Your house is a little chilly,” she said with a shudder. “May I ask why?”

I shrugged. “Well, I like to make sure the animals are nice and comfortable.” Going into the kitchen, I opened the cabinets and took out two small white cups. Pouring water into the pot and placing it onto the stove, I turned the burner on to heat the water as I waited. “There we go.”

I trotted back into the living room and sat on the sofa positioned on the right side of where Rarity was sitting. “So, Rarity…..”

“Yes, darling?”

I shuffled more into the sofa to get more comfortable. “How was your day?”

Rarity tapped a hoof on her chin as she tried to think of what she did. “Oh! I finished an important line for a special client of mine.” She giggled. “I’ve been at it for days now, and it’s finally paid off.”

“Well, I have this animal who is very needy.” I giggled. My heart began to beat rapidly, and my smile turned into frown. “Rarity, have you ever done something you considered wrong, but cannot escape from it because you done it a lot of times, and then you start to think it’s the right thing to do?”

Rarity silently pondered over the question for a moment. “Well no, but why you ask?” Rarity looked at me with a concerned expression. “Have you done something you considered wrong?”

Yes. “No.” I shook my head. “No, I haven’t.” I felt myself growing more nervous with each passing moment, so I excused myself and trotted into the kitchen to check on the tea. It was boiling hot and ready, so I cut the burner off and poured the steaming water into the cups. “What do you want in your tea, Rarity?”

No response. I was Starting to get worried, so I tried one more time. “Rarity, are you there?” The deadly silence continued to mock me and the cold air making me shiver a little. Trotting back into the living room, the sight I saw made my heart stop. “Rarity, what are you—”

Standing at the basement door, Rarity sniffed the air a bit and scoffed in disgust. “It smells really bad in there, Fluttershy.” She pinched her nose and trotted away from the odd odor. “What have you got in there? It smells awful.” Sitting back down on the sofa, Rarity giggled. “I mean really bad.”

“Probably some animal’s leftovers I have to clean.” I smiled. “Trust me as a friend; you don’t wanna go in there.”

“Why not?” Rarity asked, going back to the door and twisting the knob, almost opening it. “Are you trying to hide something from me?”

Small beads of sweat began to form on my head as I panicked. “The tea is done!” I blurted out.

Backing away from the door, Rarity sat back down on the sofa. “Oooh, I’ve been waiting to taste some of your delicious tea again,” Rarity said, giving me a smile. “Can you be a dear and pour some sugar into mine?”

“Sure, Rarity. Anything for a friend.” I took out a bag of sugar, pouring some into Rarity’s cup and mixing it into the tea. I trotted back into the living room and gave the cup to Rarity while sat down with mine. “It’s really hot, so be careful,” I said with a giggle.

Sipping the tea, Rarity moaned as the sugar attacked her taste buds. “This is some really good tea. A little too hot, though.” Rarity commented, fanning a hoof over her burning tongue. “Thank you for having me here, Fluttershy.”

I gave her a smile before taking another sip of the tea. “It was my pleasure.” My heart suddenly stopped and my world shattered, falling farther into darkness as I realized what I’ve become, and knowing that there was never going back. “Rarity, can I show you something?”

“Sure, Fluttershy.” Setting the tea down, Rarity got up from the couch. “What is it?”

“The basement.” I trotted to the basement door and opened it. “I want to show you something.” Trotting down the steps, I stopped and turned around. “Also, I lied. There’s no animal’s droppings down here.”

“Oh good.” Rarity smiled. She trotted down the steps until her hooves hit the cold and wet floor. “Eeh, Fluttershy dear, why is the floor wet? And why does it smell so bad?” she asked, fanning over her nose. “You said there were no animal’s you-know-what down here.”

“There isn’t.” Unlocking the door, I took a step back and opened it. I turned to look at Rarity who was standing next me with a confused look on her face. “You feeling okay?”

“Ugh...” Losing her balance, Rarity tumbled around a little bit. I could tell she was feeling light-headed. Her heart was beating at a rapid pace and small beads of sweat were streaming down her forehead. “Sorry for me being so clumsy, I’m just feeling a little ill.” She waved a hoof and smiled. “Nothing to worry about.”

Without warning, I rushed in and her lips met. Our tongues wrestled with each other, moans of pleasure filled the air along with a aura from my dripping wet pussy. My hooves wrapped around her body, slowly moving down to her flank and squeezing it ever so tightly.

She shoved her tongue out my mouth and stared at me. Her cheeks burning red and a strong scent of musk was now coming from her marehood. “Fluttershy, I…I—” Pressing her lips back into mine, She pushed me onto the wall and reached a hoof down my lady parts. She rotated her hoof in small circles around my clit, sending a pleasure wave down my spine. “You like that, huh?”

“Yes Rarity... fuck me,” I said through baited breaths. “Please, I know you want to.” Her rubbing became faster and faster, the pleasure making my heart beat a million times faster. I jerked my head back as my love juices squirted onto Rarity’s hoof.

“That… was amazing.”

“You still got me to take care of, Flutter dear.” She softly pressed her lips into mine and we kissed. “You didn’t forget about me did you?” she purred.

I shook my head and smiled. “Rarity, you’re going to come with me inside that room and claim your prize.”

Rarity giggled. “Yes ma’am.” Trotting into the dark room, the smile from my face disappeared. A faint and broken voice that sounded like me spoke to her, sending chills down her spine.

“Please close the door.”