PonySuck Adventure

A: Accept the mares' offer for a kinky threesome. Maybe that will satisfy the both of them?

[OPTION A SELECTED]

*Pinkie's eyes widen with incredible glee as you nod at the both of them, and Mrs. Cake's own face is covered in a heavy blush, seemingly embarrassed but quite pleased at your answer.*

"Well, why don't you lie down, dear? If this is your first time with a mare... err, two mares... it might be a little much for you."

*Mrs. Cake adopts the same flirtatious tone as Pinkie did before pressing a hoof into your chest and pushing you back lightly. Thankfully your rump cushions your fall, but you can't help feeling just a bit vulnerable as the bakers turn their hungry gaze on your still erect member. Mrs. Cake is the first to take her position, straddling your thighs and pressing her soaking wet marehood right up against your cock.*

*Grinding her hips in small circles elicits soft moans as both of you disregard the difference in species for some much needed relief. In your case, it's so you don't have to leave these mares displeased. In their case, well... you've become their toy for the day, it seems. Pinkie, seeing fit to take her position, trots over to you and slowly eases her plush rump onto your face, humming in a sing-song voice as her furry behind covers your view.*

"Ah ah ah! You get some, you give some. That's the rule!"

*Obviously referring to their prior oral attentions focused on your manhood, Pinkie forcefully shifts your attention to her own slippery nethers for you to satisfy. You feel another throb in your pride as the sight of fresh mare pussy encompasses your sight. The contrast of its dark, equine nether-regions when compared to the bright pink fur on her body is quite noticeable. Reaching up to grasp those balloon-marked flanks, you spread her cheeks to get a better view of her inner folds, the bumps and ridges turning you on as to what could very well be wrapped around your cock in mere moments.*

*Pinkie's tail twitches above you, perhaps a sign of her anticipation of what's to come, but you pay it no mind. Your tongue snakes out as you take an experimental lick at her outer lips, noting the neutral taste of her own precum and just how horny the poor mare is. With you taking your time and working her up, the younger pink mare wiggles atop your face, biting her lip and holding back a moan of her own as she grinds her sex along your attentive, agile muscle.*

"Oooooh, be gentle..."

*While Pinkie Pie seems nervous as she begins to relax her tense body onto you, Mrs. Cake is quite the opposite. Her wide hips you noted earlier force herself against your thick length in an attempt to get a rough performance out of you. The harsh grinding actually seems to lube you up with her excess juices; she aims to make your first time with a mare as easy as can be, as strange as that sounds.  Her own voice coming through breathy moans, Mrs. Cake's sultry voice can still be heard over your ministrations on Pinkie.*

"You just lie back and enjoy it, deary. Just let Cup Cake do all the work~"

*The now known "Cup Cake" presses her hooves into your thighs to steady herself before she gently eases herself onto your stiff rod. Pressing her own need down on top of your erect member, she seats herself atop you all while letting out a pleasantly high-pitched voice. Her body shudders atop you as she feels your girth invade her welcoming heat.*

"A- Aahh, fuck, yes!"

*This is the first time you've ever heard a technicolor pony swear. Then again, this is the first time you've felt the glorious grasp of a mare's vagina around your human flesh as well. My oh my, is it incredible, too. You have a hard time not gasping in surprise at the feeling of hot, wet walls clenching around your hard member and sucking you in as she pulls back up. However, dropping her weight back down on you and impaling herself on your cock is enough to finally get a low, pained groan out of you. Pinkie giggles upon hearing your oversexed voice, her hoof moving to brush along your hair as if encouraging you.*

"F- Feels good, huh? Yeah, come on! Show us what you can do!"

*Pinkie's voice gradually becomes more confident as the mare continues her face ride with joy. Trying not to fall behind, you dart your tongue inside her and feel her tense up once more around you. Like jell-o, her body wiggles out the kinks and she lets out a soft coo of appreciation at your work.*

*Your thoughts on how to please the mare any further are shoved aside by the amazing sensations assaulting your manhood. Cup Cake's honest body gyrates atop you with a sort of carefree elegance; Her experienced lover's dance is being shown exclusively to you. Well, you and your other pink partner in this threesome, that is.*

*Mrs. Cake moans out, seemingly uncaring of whoever might see her. Her hips continue to work, slamming her rump down as her internal muscles flutter and grip at you with each movement, practically screaming for an encore of the load you deposited earlier. Pinkie, meanwhile, lets out a shuddering moan followed by giggles as her tail presses down upon your head, her sex eager to feel more of that teasing tongue. The youthful mare bites her lip, rocking and grinding her pussy against your mouth, body practically demanding that you service her as well.*

"H- Hey, Mrs. Cake... You want him to cum inside you, right?"

*Pinkie's question alerts you to the prospect of releasing inside this lonely mare's womb. Considering your situation, there's no real way out of it now. For you, the words cause you to thrust deeper inside her with a more fervent pace, but Cup Cake continues to outdo you in her performance. The words "cum inside" make Mrs. Cake's sex grip that member inside her firmly, the mare crooning with need as she works those matronly hips of hers to milk you for every last drop of your seed. The warmth drives you insane, but the tightness is enough to restrict your blood flow, forcing every little throb and squeeze to be focused on as you feel yourself nearing climax.*

*Mrs Cake's unyielding grasp on your member and plump hips reigning down on you leave you no choice but to relinquish your body's control over the incoming orgasm. Pinkie happily presses her soft pussy right onto your tongue, hungry for your touch as your entire body shivers under the assault of pleasure. Unconsciously, you thrust your hips upwards, pumping the mare full of your creamy jism as she screams out in ecstasy.*

"Ohhhhh, sweet Celestia!"

*Being filled almost to the point of bursting from your hot geyser of semen elicits quite the deep groan from the older mare. Her grinding slows to a stop as her body tries to wring out every last bit and hold it deep inside her, not wanting to waste even the tiniest bit of your gift to her. Slowly, Pinkie rises off of you in a fit of giggles as Cup Cake falls forward and embraces you in a loving kiss. Undoubtedly, it does surprise you, seeing as you didn't really expect such a romantic mare to appreciate you this much so soon. Breaking the kiss and licking the same lips used to fellate you earlier, the rosy-eyed mare nuzzles into your neck as she speaks adoringly.*

"Aww, you really are a sweetheart, aren't you?"

*You aren't sure how to respond to that, but as your bodies disconnect and she lays her swelled rear end off to the side, you feel Pinkie Pie take her place atop your softening member. The feel of a new, fresh pussy sliding along your manhood gets you hard again rather quickly. Upon noticing this, Pinkie smiles giddily at the reaction she gets out of you.*

"Looks like he's got plenty saved up for me, too~"

"Nnn, that's nice, Pinkie. He is going to be here a while though. Don't wear the poor boy out in one day."

*Hearing this, you turn a confused gaze towards Cup Cake even as your expression suffers the pleasurable torment of Pinkie's own hot sex sliding down your length. Mrs. Cake seems amused by your immediate reaction, giggling lightly as she gently cradles your face in her hooves.*

"Oh, you didn't know? Silly dear. It's going to take a lot more than a few loads to satisfy busy mares like us."

*Her matter-of-fact tone combined with her bringing you in for another kiss drives home the fact that she isn't joking. Pinkie Pie begins bouncing along your cock roughly, her moans echoing all throughout Sugarcube Corner as her well-prepared sex clenches down on you just like Mrs. Cake's did for your miracle cure semen.*

"Ooooooh, yeeeeaaah! Maybe a few... Nnh... a few dozen, if you're lucky, nnhn..."

*A sharp panic rushes through your body as you realize what you've agreed upon. They intend to keep you around for who knows how long, keeping them satisfied with your cum in any way they see fit. Pulling back from the kiss, Cup Cake strokes her hoof along your chest before motioning her hoof down her pudgy belly.*

"Don't worry, hun. We'll keep you well-fed... just so long as you do the same for us~"

*Pinkie bursts out laughing as she gets the joke, picking up the pace of her lovemaking as she works your abused member for more and more with each squeeze. All you can do is hold your mouth open in shock, leaving the perfect target for Cup Cake's affection as she presses her lips deep onto yours for another deal-sealing kiss.*

*What started as a simple deal ends up with you on your back, every day, feeding these two baker mares' insatiable appetites. You're too physically exhausted to continue your mission, and resign yourself to keeping them pleased so you can keep seeing their smiling faces as they ride you.*

GAME OVER

*You are dropped back on the hard, flat surface that is the dark void from your dream. Twilight covers her face with her hoof before turning to glare at you.*

"You already had your fun, you know? What made you think having a threesome with two needy mares was a good idea!?"

*You bow your head in shame. You just couldn't resist the temptation. You didn't think you'd be judged so harshly for being a pervert, but, well... Twilight sure seems to think you are, now. Before she can go on, Pinkie Pie interrupts, wearing a fake frown as she addresses you with narrowed eyes.*

"Yeah! Kinky threesomes are not tolerated here, mister!... But I bet I was really good, right~?"

"Pinkie!"

*Twilight scolds Pinkie to calm herself from indulging in your fantasy that you mistakenly allowed to happen. With a deep sigh, the unicorn continues.*

"Look, you got what you wanted and you can move on without pleasing both of them. So, just... go back and try again, alright?"

*Twilight's horn glows brightly as a flash of light goes off in your eyes. In your last conscious thought before being teleported back in time, you briefly wonder how it would have gone if you chose the other mare instead...*

RETRY (Pinkie, Cake)

BACK TO TITLE