Trapped in Equestria

As they trotted towards Ponyville, the four friends looked at each other.

"Hey Jess?" Josh asked, looking at him. Jesse turned, trotting backwards.

"What's up?" Josh pointed at Jesse's body.

"Why are we all alicorns?" Jesse looked at them and gasped.

"We're all alicorns? I thought it was just me!" Kristy laughed, punching Jesse lightly with her hoof.

"Well in this one fanfic I read it said humans coming to Equestria have to resemble all three races, so they become alicorns." John shrugged awkwardly.

"I don't really care." Josh snorted.

"Of course you don't." They arrived at the village just as it was getting dark. There weren't any ponies outside, so they headed towards the treehouse, hoping Twilight might be able to help them.

KNOCK KNOCK KNOCK

Twilight got up quickly and opened the door.

"Hello?" Josh's wings flared out, and then he shoved them down again. Kristy had to stifle her laughter and Twilight gasped in shock.

"You're all alicorns?! Are you royalty from like Saddle Arabia or somewhere?" Jesse frowned.

"Sadly no. We're humans from another dimension. We're trapped here and we need to get our friend home," Twilight nodded.

"Well normally I'd take you to Princess Celestia, but the train doesn't come back till noon tomorrow. You can stay here if you want." John nodded.

"Thanks." They all crammed into her tree house library.

"So what are all your names?" Twilight said, using her magic to pour them some apple cider. Jesse thought a moment, then grinned.

"The name's Starstream." Twilight bowed a little.

"Nice to meet you!" Josh stepped forward.

"I like to be called Shade." She smiled.

"What a nice name." John shrugged.

"Redwolf." Kristy waved her hoof.

"I'm Katona!" Twilight whuffled and stepped back.

"Katona? That's a strange name. Is that name common in your world?" John furrowed his eyebrows, Josh shook his head, and Jesse glared at Kristy. She nodded.

"Yep. Pretty common for mares like me!" Twilight smiled.

"It sounds cool! Nice to meet you all!" Jesse whispered to Josh.

"She isn't an alicorn yet, so we do know this is before season four, but..." Kristy put her hooves on their muzzles.

"Shh! What if she hears you?!!!!"

Spike stumbled out of his den and looked up at them.

"Huh? Who are you pon-" He stopped, looking at John with starstruck eyes.

"She's beautiful... what's your name?" He asked, hearts forming in his eyes. John mumbled uncomfortably.

"Uhh... Redwolf..." Spike fainted.

Oh gosh. So much for Sparity.