Clue?

Previously

Dear Rarity, Dear Rainbow Dash, Dear Pinkie Pie, Dear Fluttershy

You have been invited to Everfree Mansion at 20:00. Don’t be late.

“Derpy, what else did the person say to you? Or what happened when you got here?” Rainbow Dash asked.

“They said lock the door.”

“We're locked in, help! Help us!” Rarity shouted.

“He said I will die!” Derpy shouted and with that a bullet came though the lounge door and hit Derpy right in the chest. Derpy flew across the room and lay on the opposite side of the room.

“They’re going to kill us all” Rarity said looking at the remaining ponies.

Chapter 2 – The Mansion

“What do we do now?” Rainbow Dash shouted.

“I saw we just wait. There has to be an explanation to this.” Fluttershy said looking at the group. The group all looked back at her.

“You could say that Fluttershy, but we are all locked in a mansion with Derpy dead right in front of us. You could be the killer wanting us to be here.” Rarity said stepping back one step at a time. “You cannot trust anyone here.” She said taking a big jump backwards this time.

“Yeah, you're right Rarity it could be you.” Rainbow Dash said

“Stop it, stop it. We don't know who it is, but it is best if we try and think logically and try and work this out.” Pinkie Pie said. She looked around the entrance of the mansion. “Most of the time there are two other ponies with us, there is Applejack and Twilight. As they are not here they must be pulling some sort of joke on us.” Pinkie Pie questioned. Looking at the group.

“So it must be them then.” Rainbow Dash said “Come on girls, come out while you still can, otherwise I will be getting you and you won't know what hit ya.”

“Rainbow, they are not going to come out any time soon. It will be best if instead of them getting us, we get them. So we find them, think about it, they have to be in the mansion somewhere.” Rarity replied.

“Fine then as there are four of us we will split into groups of two, that way we can cover half of the mansion each.”

“That’s a great idea Fluttershy, right then I will go with Pinkie and you can go with Rarity.” Rainbow Dash said.

“But what will we do about Derpy? Her body is right there.” Rarity replied.

“Don’t worry she is faking it, if she is still there when we get back then we should be worried.” Rainbow Dash said. “Now girls, run as fast as you can Rainbow is coming to get you.” With that, Rainbow Dash flew off though the mansion.

“Wait for me Rainbow!” said Pinkie Pie, hopping along behind her.

“So where do we go then Fluttershy? But be aware, there is a killer on the loose.” Rarity said, winking at Fluttershy.

“What! I did not do it, why would I bring you all up here to kill you all. You are my friends, not my enemies.” Fluttershy said while walking slowly though the double doors leading to the lounge. “Oh look Rarity, there is a bullet hole in this door.” Fluttershy said, stoking the bullet hole.

“This must be where the killer was standing when he… Or she pulled the trigger. But what I still don’t understand is why Derpy got shot.” Rarity said, looking at her body though the bullet hole. “Look, the killer must still be in this room as think about it, the only way out is this door here. “ Rarity pointed at the door behind them.

“Well Rarity, they might have climbed out of the window then ran around the mansion and climbed into another window in another room.” Fluttershy said as she ran over to the window while Rarity was looking around the lounge. “Ok forget that theory, the window is still locked so they couldn’t have climbed out of it.” She walked over to the fireplace and leaned back on a candlestick. Just as she did the whole fireplace revolved and there was a loud.

BANG…

“Fluttershy! Fluttershy!” Rarity screamed. “Where are you!” she ran around the room knocking over all of the furniture in her way.
Upstairs, in one of the bedrooms, Rainbow Dash was hiding under the bed.

“Dashie! why are you hiding under the bed?” Pinkie Pie questioned nudging her head under the bed where Rainbow Dash was.

“I heard a Bang. I knew it was one of them downstairs, it has to be.” Rainbow Dash said as she crawled back out from under the bed.

“It was nothing Dashie, if one of them was a killer, then the one who was not the killer will be dead, but then the one who is the killer will be walking up them stairs now to get us and kill us.” Pinkie Pie said.

“Pinkie, you lost me after the word killer. You're right, it was most likely nothing maybe a tree scraping along the window sill.” Rainbow Dash said, shaking.

“I think the worst thing is that we are all fighting. You never know it may not be one of us at all.” Pinkie Pie said.

“You're right on that one Pinkie. I’m going to go and explore the bathroom. You wait there, I will be back in a tick.” Rainbow dash said as she flew quite quickly out of the room.
Pinkie Pie explored the bedroom, she looked under the bed, in the wardrobe and out of the window that was locked and bolted.

“Ok Rainbow, I have done this room, I’m coming in to help you. You better be decent.” Pinkie let out a small laugh. “You get that Rainbow decent as you are in the bathroom?” Pinkie pushed open the door. “Rainbow are you there?” She nudged open the door and no one was in the bathroom. “She probably check this room, she’s got to be upstairs.” Pinkie Pie ran along the corridor pushing all of the doors she could see. But they were all locked. Pinkie walked slowly down the stairs looking around at everything she could see, just when she walked into Rarity.

“Aghhhh!” They both screamed.

“Oh hey Rarity, you haven’t seen Rainbow have you?” Pinkie Pie said, blinking at her repeatedly.

“I was just about to ask you the same thing, Fluttershy has gone missing too.” replied Rarity. “I have a feeling, this is it friend, we are about to die.” They both hugged each other while shaking in their hooves.

“Hang on, what is that over there?” Rarity questioned. “It looks like Derpy’s body has a note on it.” They walked over to Derpy’s body and Pinkie Pie snatched the note off the body.

Dear House Guests
You now know what is going on here. But what you don’t know is why you are here. You are all here as you all have a secret about the people you are with, and that little secret of yours is oh so bad to your friends. Let’s just say it may make you want to kill each other. Good luck in trying to find me in the mansion you never will.
From the best Killer in the world

P.S Look up at the balcony!

They both looked up and saw a shadow of a pony, then came a muffled but loud voice.

“WHAT ONE OF YOUR FRIENDS DO YOU LOVE THE MOST” The pony shouted.

“Well I think Rainbow she is the best.” Pinkie Pie said.

“No we love Fluttershy the best.” Rarity replied.

“MAKE UP YOUR MINDS.” Said the voice.

“We can’t.” Shouted Pinkie Pie

“THEN THINK.” The voice got even angrier then it was the last time. “WHAT IF I GIVE YOU BACK YOUR FRIENDS THEN, THEN YOU CAN THINK!” there was a pause. Then a door to the basement unlocked and out came Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy. They ran over to Rarity and Pinkie Pie and hugged them. “YOU HAVE ONE HOUR TO THINK, WHAT ONE OF YOU SHOULD DIE. OTHERWISE I WILL STRIKE AGAIN AND MAKE IT MORE OF A PAIN FOR YOU TO WATCH.” The voice said, all of the doors locked one by one, and a clock started to tick.

They all looked at each other, each of them knowing one of them was involved in the killings. They had to use this time carefully. Otherwise it could result in all of them being killed off one by one. They had to pick the right pony to kill…

TO BE CONTINUED… IN CHAPTER 3 – THE LONGEST HOUR