Twilight Sparkle and Rainbow Dash found a note on Fluttershy's door:

I'm upstairs in my bedroom. Come on up, I'm waiting.

They glanced at each other, shrugged, and went in, flying upstairs.

They found Fluttershy splayed out on her back on the bed, her legs spread wide. Her entire belly and--certain parts of her body--were covered in peanut butter, compote, and for some reason, wriggling earthworms and centipedes which were trapped in the sticky peanut butter.

They stared at her, jaws hitting the floor.

Fluttershy looked up and squeaked, her eyes wide and her face red. "Oh! Um. Sorry. I'm expecting a visit from my brother." A pause. "Umm...could you--?"

"NOPE!" Rainbow Dash and Twilight both flew out the window.

Author's Note

Zef challenged me to do a fic using puns based on Flutter Butter's various "flavors". I couldn't come up with anything. So I did this instead.