Rarity Trap: CYOS

You’ve fulfilled the terms of the agreement, and you try to tell Rarity that.

“So...” you say vaguely, too embarrassed to really speak more than that.

“So...” she echoes. After a few moments, she continues. “Well... I guess you really did it. We’ll stop spreading rumors about you as long as you don’t keep telling everyone I’m a trap, and we’ll even try to repair some of the damage we’ve done.” Aloe and Lotus nod in assent.

A few weeks later, when you try to pick up a mare in the park, she considers it instead of rejecting you out of hand, and in the end you make a dinner date at the local Fancy restaurant.