Rarity Trap: CYOS

Now that you’ve actually sucked it, you realize that Rarity having a cock is not such a big deal. Weird, sure, but you probably shouldn’t have run away screaming. You tell Rarity that, and moments later you’re in a moist hug. Your dick is hard against the inside of your pants, and as interesting and exciting as blowing your marefriend was, it’s even better when your cock crunches into the warmth of her cunt.

You and Rarity fall quickly into a successful relationship, and have lots of (mostly) normal sex. You’re not above a bit of changeling magic in the bedroom, though.