Pinkamena and Cheese Sandwich

Sweetie Belle and Apple Bloom had overheard Cheese when he had addressed Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo. They jumped out of their seats and galloped over to Scootaloo.

“Scootaloo!” Sweetie Belle cried through tears. “We missed you so much!!” Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle both attacked Scootaloo with hugs.

Scootaloo hugged them back with tears in her eyes. “I missed you guys too.” Rainbow Dash and Cheese smiled at each other as they watched the reunion of the cutie mark crusaders.

“I figured it was safe for her to live in Ponyville again.” Rainbow Dash said. “Since…. Well, you know.”

Cheese nodded, “Yeah, I bet they’re all happy that they’re together again. You girls all missed each other didn’t you?” Cheese asked them.

The girls all nodded and hugged each other tighter.

Cheese laughed slightly. “How about I get you a milkshake on the house, Scootaloo?”

“That would be-” Scootaloo coughed and Sweetie Belle and Apple Bloom loosened their grips on her. “That would be great, thank you so much.” She said going to sit at the table with her two BFFFs (Best Filly Friends Forever).

“It was really sweet of you to bring Scootaloo back to live in Ponyville with her two best friends.” Cheese said to Rainbow Dash as he prepared Scootaloo’s milkshake.

“Yeah, but there is one really big problem.” Rainbow Dash said, frowning.

“What is it?”

“I can’t have her live with me anymore, she hates living with me. She says I’m hiding her from her life. But, if she doesn’t live with me, then she has nowhere to live. She told me she could live with Sweetie Belle or Apple Bloom, but she doesn’t know that both Rarity and Applejack are dead.”

“That is a problem. Just a second.” Cheese took the finished milkshake to Scootaloo and walked back to the counter to continue his conversation with Rainbow Dash.

“I kind of thought she could live wherever the girls are living now, do you know who’s keeping them?” Rainbow Dash asked.

“Well….” Cheese started.

Pinkie came hopping back down the stairs. The first thing she noticed was that Scootaloo had joined Sweetie Belle and Apple Bloom. She stopped, stared at them for a moment and then walked over to Cheese and Rainbow Dash.

“I see that Scootaloo is back.” Pinkie said, smiling at Rainbow Dash.

“Yeah, I figured she would be safe now. All she needs is a place to live.”

“Cheese and I would be happy to let her live here with the other girls.” Pinkie Pie said, smiling happily. Cheese noticed that this obviously hadn’t been part of her master plan, but it was a huge asset.

“Thank you so much, Pinkie.” Rainbow Dash said. “I really care about Scootaloo, she’s like a little sister to me, and I want her to be happy.”

“We promise to take good- no great- care of her.” Pinkie said.

“Oh, would you like anything for the road?” Cheese asked.

“No, but thank you, again. It was nice seeing you again, bye.” Rainbow said as she flew away.

Pinkie and Cheese both said goodbye and then looked at each other. “Well. This is going to be difficult, but a huge improvement to the plan.” Pinkie said.

“Yeah, raising four fillies, I don’t think anypony has ever had to deal with that before, mostly because it’s biologically impossible to give birth to four ponies that are around the same age, but also because it’s a huge challenge.”

“Cheerilee seems to handle them all fairly well at the school house, maybe we could get her to help us take care of them some time.” Cheese suggested.

“Or we could just scare the girls into listening to us, after all, we are serial killers.” Pinkie said.

“I don’t think Scootaloo even knows about all that, Pinkie.” Cheese said.

“I’m sure the girls will tell her if Rainbow Dash didn’t already.”

“And if they don’t?”

“Then we’ll just have to show her.” Pinkie said. “We’ll have to show her tonight when we harvest more ingredients.”

“What if she tries to get away?” Cheese asked.

“Then we’ll tie her up right across from whoever it is that we’re killing and force her to watch. We can even put a bucket in front of her in case she throws up. We can do the same with the other girls, if they refuse to help.” Pinkie said, unaware that they were still in the shop, with customers coming and going.

“We’ll talk about this later.” Cheese said as he took the order of the next person in line.

Later that night, Pinkie would draw the name of their victim and she would bring the girls into the basement and force them all to watch. She would even let them help if they wanted to.