Five Nights at AJ's: Hidden Lore (Parts 1-3)

The following content is an unofficial and fan-made story written by Loving-Brony, which is based on Five Nights at AJ’s by AnAppleForgetten, which is a pony crossover of the original franchise Five Nights at Freddy’s © by Scott Cawthon. Many of the characters in this following story are from the show My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic © which belongs to Lauren Faust and Hasbro. And for further more warning, the following story contains violence, scary and creepy content, disturbing content, and content that made be unsuitable for My Little Pony fans and Five Nights at Freddy’s Fans. Reader discretion is advised.

(I know I’m bad at Disclaimers. lol XD)

(Guys and Gals, Mares and Stallions, I know I’m the Loving Brony, and I’m supposed to be loving and all that and not be into the creepy fanfics, but I’m a big fan of Five Nights at Freddy’s/AJ’s too. So, please do not mind this at all, it’s for a friend of mine, if you don’t like creepy MLP fanfics, then please do not read this at all! Please do not hate me for writing this! This is just for a friend of mine, anappleforgotten! WHATEVER! LET’S JUST GET TO THE STORY ALREADY!!!)

The sun was shining very bright as it was apple bucking day today for the Apple family. Applejack came bursting out of her barn as she was jumping in joy that she just had to give a big holler. “Yee-haw! Ah’m glad it’s apple buckin’ day today! Aren’t you, sis?” Applejack asked Applebloom as she looked down at her. “Of course, Sister! Ah always am!” Applebloom hollered as she leaped to the first apple tree in front of them. “Let’s get ‘em apples!” Applejack hollered as she ran along with Applebloom.

Applejack raced towards the apple tree until she hears a familiar but unusual voice that stops her. “Hey Applejack!” Applejack turned around and the pony that the voice came from was one of their old competitors, Flim, standing there with his brother, Flam.

“Wat in tarnation do ya two want from us? Did y’all forget about how our Ponyville folks would rather choose us as far as our Cider than ya both and yer fancy smancy machine and y’all want a rematch or somethin’? Well, it ain’t happin’ wat so ever!” Applejack yelled at Flim and Flam as she saw the huge thing covered up with clothing behind those two. “No! No! Applejack! We just came here to apologize for our foolishness for the Cider Competition we had.” Flam explained. “That’s Right, my dear brother, we’re here to apologize to you, Applejack, for all that!” said Flim. “Aww! It’s awright! Just dun’t try to put us out of business again!” Said Applejack seriously. “Oh, we won’t!” said Flam. “Not at all, my dear Applejack!” said Flim. “Say, wat’s wif the crazy contraction y’all have behind ya?” Applejack asked Flim and Flam. “Oh, this, you ask? That is our gift me and my brother want to give to you for an apology.” Flim explained. “Prepare to be amazed, Applejack! Viola!” Said Flam as he took off the cover of the huge contraction behind them, which reveals a mini show stage with three animatronics on them.

“Wat is it?” asked Applebloom amazed as she walked towards the mini show stage. “Why it’s a miniature show stage that can be installed inside your own barn, dear!” Flim explained. “I’m sure it will be nice and tidy once it is installed in your ba-“said Flam, but he got interrupted by Applebloom. “No! Ah mean, those? Are they real ponies? ‘Cause they look like they are made of metal or somethin’.” Applebloom asked as she pointed at the three animatronics on the show stage. “Oh, why those are the animatronics that go in the show stage.” Flim explained as Flam jumped in with his explanation. “Those animatronics can operate by themselves, move by themselves, and best of all, they can entertain ponies, fillies, colts, any creature in the world by themselves.” Said Flam with joy.

Applejack gazed at the animatronics as she noticed one of them looked familiar to her. “Hey! Why does tat one up front look just like me?” Applejack asked a little unamused. “That is actually not you, dear Applejack… That’s actually… uh… Apple Fazjack!” said Flim. “Really? Ya just had to add that “Faz” between the “Apple” and “jack” in mah name?” Applejack asked as she raised her eyebrow. “Then, who are those other two? They look like two of my friends, Twilight Sparkle and Fluttershy!” said Applejack. “Uh… We’ll just call them Twilie and Flutterica.” Said Flim nervously.

“So, What do you think about the four animatronics we built for you, dear Applejack?” Flim asked Applejack. “Ah dun’t kno- Wait… FOUR?! There’s only three of ‘em!” said Applejack confused. “Oh, yeah! About the fourth one… uh… she is out of order right now.” Flam explained. “Wat do ya mean?” Applejack asked. “Well, when we were finished building the fourth one and we were testing them out by showing them active in front of a bunch of fillies and colts. However, the fourth one went berserk and bit one of the fillies’ faces off. So, we had to put her out of order and ever since we did, she been falling apart and now she looks disrepaired right now.” Flim explained. “However, we did bring her with us. She’s in that part of the show stage, which is labelled Cloud Cove.” Said Flam as he pulls the curtains of Cloud Cove out to reveal the fourth animatronic.

“What in tarnation?! That one looks like Rainbow Dash… with a pirate hook?” said Applejack puzzled. “Why did you make her look like a pirate?” Applejack asked. “Oh, we thought she was one, is she?” Flim asked. Applejack shook her head. “She doesn’t even act anything like a pirate. Rainbow Dash would definitely not like tis if she saw tis!” Said Applejack. “Oh, well!” said Flam.

“Applejack! Where were you? You miss breakfast with us?” Twilight Sparkle asked as she walked up to Applejack with Rainbow Dash, Rarity, Fluttershy, and Pinkie Pie walked up towards Applejack. “Sorry! Ah was too busy talkin’ to Flim and Flam about…. Wh-whatever these things are!” Applejack explained.

“Why are you guys making a robot that looks like me, carrying a guitar and wearing a bowtie? I wasn't that interested in playing the guitar when I was in Canterlot.” Twilight asked confused.

“Umm... Is... Is that me?” Fluttershy asked freaked out. “A robot version, uh, of me... wearing a bid that says “Let’s Eat!” and... um... I'm holding a cupcake? Th-That's... very nice!” Fluttershy said confused.

“What the hay! I look like a pirate! I’m no pirate! I’m a fast high-flying Pegasus that has a dream of joining the Wonderbolts. You got it all wrong!” Said Rainbow Dash, disapproving of Flim and Flam’s work.

“Ah told ya!” Applejack whispered to Flim and Flam.

“Anyway, Ah dun’t know ‘bout tis! Ah mean, wat’s the point in ‘em?” Applejack asked Flim and Flam. “Well, watch closely, my dear!” Said Flim. “You’ll be amazed!” Said Flam as he winked at Applejack.

Flam pulled out a controller with only one big red button on it that is labelled “Active Animatronics” above it. As soon as Flam presses the big red button. All of the animatronics, except the Rainbow Dash one, stood up and begin to talk like normal ponies would.

“Howdy, Everypony!” said Apple Fazjack with the exact same voice as Applejack only robotic-like and a little distorted. “Hello... um... children!” said Flutterica with the exact same voice as Fluttershy only robotic-like and a little distorted. “Hi, Everypony!” said Twilie with the exact same voice as Twilight Sparkle only robotic-like and a little distorted just like the other animatronics. “Welcome to Apple Fazjack’s! I’m Flutterica! Let’s Eat!” said Flutterica. “And I’m your best unicorn friend, Twilie Sparkle!” Said Twilie. “And everypony knows me, Apple Fazjack!” Said Apple Fazjack.

“Oh dear! They sound very scary!” Fluttershy said all frightened as she flew behind Rainbow Dash. “Fluttershy! Come one! They’re just robots… they won’t hurt you!” Rainbow Dash sighed.

“Hey! Why isn’t there one with me?!” Pinkie Pie asked all disappointed. “We ran out of bits to do you and Rarity, but when we get enough bits again, we will make you and Rarity.” Flim promised.

"Well, I'm actually glad there isn't one of me because I think they look horrible and ugly!" said Rarity thankful.

“Keep in mind, Applejack, usually the animatronics would make eye contact with other ponies around them and they can be a little glitchy with talking. Also, be sure you keep them locked up in your barn at night!” Flam said all serious. “Why?” Applejack asked. Flam just paused for a few seconds trying to say something. “Because… so they do not escape… because if they escape… that can be bad!” Flam explained, but it sounded like he was preventing himself from saying something else important. “Awrighty then!” Applejack nodded.

“Please take care of them!” Said Flim as he and Flam began to walk away. “Okay! We will! Thanks!” Said Applejack.

That Evening…

The mini-show stage was installed inside the barn and the Apple Family had a show going on with their new animatronics for the fillies and colts.

(All words that’s CAPITIALIZED are the disturbing whispers the animatronics secretly say and the reason why their quotes are messed up is because they’re supposed to be a little glitchy)

“Howdy, Everypony!” said Apple Fazjack. “Hello... um... childeren!” said Flutterica. “Hi, Everypony!” said Twilie. “Welcome to Apple Fazjack’s! I’m Flutterica! Let’s Eat!” said Flutterica. “And I’m your best unicorn friend, Twilie Sparkle!” Said Twilie. “And everypony knows me, Apple Fazjack!” Said Apple Fazjack. “Hey Apple Fazjack, Can you… can you tell me why it is important to KILL… e-eat apples?” Twilie asked Apple Fazjack. “A-a-apples are g-good for you, k-k-kids! You always w-want to eat plenty of PONIES a-a-apples a day because they contain BLOOD Vit-Vitamin C in them.” Said Apple Fazjack. “Of cour- Of course, any kind of PONY fr-fr-fruit is g-g-good for you, Apple Fazjack! RUN AWAY!” said Flutterica. “R-right, Flu-Flu-Flutterica! Be sure you kee- KILL K-k-keep healthy to li-li-DIE live, children.” Said Apple Fazjack. “Alright, fillies and colts, we are going to KILL YOU… take a br-break for now! So, please RUN WHILE YOU STILL CAN en-en-joy your evening!” said Twilie. “Apple Fazjack’s Pizza!!!” the three animatronics shouted with joy.

“Ah do like those ani, uh, ani… whatever they are… but, sometimes, Ah swear, it sounds like they are whisperin’ nasty things, Applejack.” Said Applebloom. “Oh, Applebloom! You’re probably just hearin’ things! Ah think they’re fine!” Said Applejack. “Okay!” said Applebloom, but still a little suspicious on the animatronics.

Applebloom looked up at the animatronics and she noticed that Twilie was staring at her. It was not a normal stare, it was more of a death stare. Applebloom gasped and she looked away from the animatronics. “Was that Twilight-looking one givin’ meh the evil eye or somethin’?” Applebloom whispered to herself. “Nah… Ah dun’t think so… They’re just robots, it’s not like they want to hurt me or someth-“Applebloom paused as she turned around to face the animatronics again and she notices that Flutterica started to give the exact death stare to her as well. Applebloom started to get scared and splinted towards her big sister, Applejack. “Applejack! ‘em robots are starin’ at me!” Said Applebloom, all freaked out. Applejack looked at the animatronics and she saw that they weren’t looking at her. “Oh, Applebloom! Didn’t you hear what Flim and Flam said, they are mend to make eye contact with other ponies.” Said Applejack. “But, they were looking at me with angry looks!” Said Applebloom. “Aww… yer probably just exhausted from doing all that Apple buckin’ we did before we started this show. ‘ere! Lay down on tis hay sack and sleep tight, mah wittle, baby sister!” Said Applejack. “I’m not a baby anymore!!!” Yelled Applebloom as she laid down on the hay sack, frustrated with her big sister.

Applebloom sighed with frustration with her big sister. “Ah just dun’t git why mah sister still thinks Ah’m a baby… Ah’m grown-up now. Ah apple bucked some of the Apple tree by mahself today.” Applebloom complained to herself. “Ah, Forgit ‘bout it. Ah’m just goin’ to git some rest now.” Said Applebloom as she closed her eyes. But, Applebloom opened them back up nervously to see if the animatronics were still staring at her. She turned her head slowly to face the animatronics, all three of the animatronics, Apple Fazjack, Twilie, and Flutterica, were givin’ her death stares. Applebloom gasped as she became really frightened and quickly turned her head the other way, trying to not look at them. “It’s okay, Applebloom… Yer just very tired! It will be all over by tomorrow!” Applebloom whispered to herself as she closed her eyes tightly, but she wondered why everypony else isn’t looking to see what the animatronics were staring at. “Everythin’ will be A-OK by tomorrow!” Applebloom whispered as she fell asleep.

11:49 PM…

“Whoo-wee! Ah am beat right now! Today was a long day!” Said Applejack. “Eeyup!” Big Macintosh agreed. “Where’s Applebloom? Ah haven’t seen her since 6 o’ clock.” Granny Smith asked. “She’s right there… sleeping like a baby!” Said Applejack pointing at Applebloom sleeping at the hay sack. “Should we wake her up?” Granny Smith asked. “Hmm… Nah!” Said Applejack. “Eenope!” Said Big Macintosh. “Let her sleep there for the night! She’ll be just fine! ‘Cause ah hate to wake her up and we have a hard time gitting her back to sleep.” Said Applejack. “Eeyup!” Said Big Macintosh agreeing. “C’mon now! Let’s head back to our farmhouse and git some shut-eye!” Said Applejack as she walked Granny Smith out of the barn. “Oh, and Big Mac, Please lock up the barn. Flim and Flam told us it’s important to lock up the ani… er… whatever they are called again, do not escape the barn. Lock it from the inside and the outside, so nopony gits in and out!” Said Applejack walked back to the farmhouse. “Eeyup!” Said Big Macintosh as he locked up the barn doors.

Night 1, 12:00 AM

Applebloom was deep asleep right now until she heard some noises that woke her up. “What in tarnation was that?” Applebloom whispered as she stood up out of her sleep. “It’s so dark in here!” Said Applebloom a little frightened as she walked around, looking for where the noises came from. “Wait!” Applebloom gasped as she turned around to face the animatronics. All three of the animatronics were standing there still and they weren’t staring at her this time. “Phew! Ah thought it was ‘em fer a sec!” Applebloom whispered in relief.

“Wait a sec!” Applebloom whispered standing still as she noticed the Cloud Cove’s curtains were wide open. “What in tarnation?” Said Applebloom as she splinted towards the Cloud Cove. She jumped up on the stage and looked inside. “What the?!” Applebloom gasped as she noticed that Rainbow Foxy wasn't there. “Wh-where’s the Rainbow Dash one?! It’s supposed to be right here!” Said Applebloom freaked out.

The out of order sign suddenly caught her attention, however, the sign didn’t say “Sorry! Out of Order!” instead it said “It’s me!” “It’s me?!” Said Applebloom puzzled. “Ha! That’s right! It’s me!” Rainbow Foxy’s robotic and distorted voice echoed through the barn. Applebloom’s heart rate began to raise as soon as she heard that voice. “Who’s there?” Applebloom asked loudly. “You landlubber! You’ll be walkin’ the plank!” Rainbow Foxy’s voice echoed through the barn again, but Applebloom couldn’t find her anywhere in her sight.

“What in tarnation is goin’ on? Ah’m outta here!” said Applebloom as she splinted towards the barn doors. Applebloom grabbed onto the doors, but they didn’t even budge a bit because they are so locked and sealed tightly. “Oh no! Ah can’t git out!” Applebloom screamed. “Hello, everypony! Wel-welcome to Apple Fazjack’s Pizza! Are you… Are you ready to DIE ha-have some fun?” Twilie asked as she wasn’t on the stage anymore and she was nowhere in sight. “Hello... um... children! Come… Come… Come have some… some pizza with me and my DEAD fri-friends, Twilie and Apple Fazjack. There’s plenty of delicious PONIES… delicious pizza here!” Said Flutterica as she wasn’t on the stage anymore and she was nowhere in sight as well.

“Has the world gone crazy all the sudden?!” Applebloom screamed in terror. “Applejack! Applejack! Help me! Please let me out!” Applebloom screamed as she started to cry.

“Ah’m-a-comin’ fer ya, Applebloom!” said a familiar voice. “Applejack?! Yer inside the barn?! Oh, thank goodness! Ah’m right here!” Applebloom shouted in relief that her big sister is here for her, as she splinted towards where she heard her big sister’s voice.

Applebloom looked around for Applejack, but she was nowhere to be found. “Where are you, Applejack?!” Applebloom shouted.

“Right here!” Applejack’s voice echoed, but it sounded a little awkward.

“Where? Ah still dun’t see ya!” Applebloom shouted nervously.

“No! Ah’m right…… Here!!!” Applejack shouted, popping out in front of Applebloom, which scared her. But, sadly, it wasn’t the Applejack, Applebloom wanted. It was Apple Fazjack, standing right in front of Applebloom, with a wide open mouth and her eyes were pitch black with tiny white pupils…

To be continued...