Five Nights at AJ's: Hidden Lore (Parts 1-3)

The following content is an unofficial and fan-made story written by Loving-Brony, which is based on Five Nights at AJ’s by AnAppleForgotten, which is a pony crossover of the original franchise Five Nights at Freddy’s © by Scott Cawthon. Many of the characters in this following story are from the show My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic © which belongs to Lauren Faust and Hasbro. And for further more warning, the following story contains violence, scary and creepy content, disturbing content, and content that may be unsuitable for My Little Pony fans and Five Nights at Freddy’s Fans. Reader discretion is advised.

Applebloom really started very frightened to death that she was literally crying out waterfall. “No! Yer not mah real sister!!! Git away from meh!” screamed Applebloom as she dodged Apple Fazjack’s jump attack towards her. Applebloom splinted away from the killer robotic version of her big sister, trying to protect herself. “Git back ‘ere sis’ or yer grounded fer a week!” Apple Fazjack yelled, trying to act like the real Applejack.

Applebloom just ignored Apple Fazjack as she ran as fast as she could away from her. “Yer not mah sister!!! Mah big sister would never hurt meh!” yelled Applebloom as she began to stop splinting, panting, because she ran out of breath to run further more. “Hahahahahaha! Y-Yer [GOING TO DIE] out…. Y-Y-Yer… out of breath, aren’t y-y-ya… aren’t ya matie?!” said a familiar yet intimidating voice. Applebloom started to shake in fear as she looked up. It was Rainbow Foxy flying right above her.

Applebloom gasped, but she stayed still because she was too low on energy to run. “Well, D-D-Don’t ya kn-know [WHO I REALLY AM] the… the rules, lads?! No runnin’ in the Cloud Cove or you’ll be [LOST FOREVER] w-w-walkin’ the plank!!!” said Rainbow Foxy. Applebloom got freaked out too much so began to run again, this time, in pain from being low on breath. But, Rainbow Foxy chased after her and was too fast for her. “R-Rule breakers be walkin’ the plank!!!” yelled Rainbow Foxy as she raised her hook. “Ahhh!” Applebloom screamed as she looked up at Rainbow Foxy’s hook while running.

Rainbow Foxy tried to slash Applebloom’s head with her hook, but instead, she ended up tearing off the bow on Applebloom’s head. Rainbow Foxy got angry because she missed Applebloom. Rainbow Foxy kept turning her head, looking at Applebloom behind her as Rainbow Foxy kept flying very fast until she hit the wall and got knocked out as in deactivated for now.

Applebloom gazed at the deactivated Rainbow Foxy as she became in relief that she missed her. “Phew! That was a close one!” Said Applebloom in relief, but she knew it wasn’t over just yet. “Wat time is it?” Applebloom asked herself quietly as she saw the clock the Apple Family would usually keep in their barn. Applebloom looked at the clock. It was 12:37 am. “Oh No! It’s still a li’l past midnight! My family usually doesn’t wake up until… *gulp* 6:00 am” Applebloom whispered with some tears in her eyes.

“Wh-What’s with the t-t-tears in your ey-ey-eyes, ch-child? Did you get [MURDERED] hurt or s-s-some…. something? He-Here! We’ll take you to see [YOUR DEATH] a doc-oc-oc… doctor.” Said Flutterica as she walks towards Applebloom. “No! Git away from meh!” screamed Applebloom as she had enough energy to run away again. “D-Don’t run in the par-party room! You might [BE FORGOTTEN] tr-trip and fall!” Said Flutterica.

Applebloom kept running away from Flutterica, but suddenly, some force was causing her to be drag back to somepony else. “Wa-wat’s happenin’? Ah can’t move all the sudden!!!” Applebloom screamed freaked out. Suddenly, Applebloom notices it was Twilie using her magic from her horn that’s really an antenna, that’s causing Applebloom to be drag back to her. “Don’t be sc-sc-scared, little filly! Your best unicorn friend Twilie is j-j-just going to [KILL] ta-take… take you back to your parents!” Said Twilie.

Twilie used her magic to take Applebloom to the backstage of the mini-show stage. “Where are ya takin’ meh?!” Applebloom asked Twilie. Suddenly, Twilie stopped moving, but still used her magic on Applebloom, as they still in front of an empty animatronic suit.

“No! No! Let meh go!” screamed Applebloom. “Come on… Come on… boys and g-g-girls! We will be… be here with opened arms [AND EMPTY GRAVES] for you all to rest in [PEACE]!” said Twilie. “No! Ah dun’t wanna die!” Applebloom cried. “Ah said… let me go!!!” Applebloom screamed as she kicked Twilie in the face, causing Twilie’s magic to stop dragging her. “No hit-hitting each other… boys and girls!” Said Twilie loudly. Applebloom splinted as far away as possible from the purple animatronic.

Applebloom stopped at the main door of the barn panting. “Applejack… Please let me out!!!” Applebloom shouted as she banged on the door, but it wasn’t too loud because she was low on energy. Applebloom heard Twilie’s voice echoing behind her, she knew that Twilie was getting closer to her. “Applejack… Please let me out! Please!” Applebloom shouted as she banged on the door again, but nothing happened. “Please… Please… Applejack… Please…” Applebloom cried, banging on the door rapidly. Then, Applebloom was out of energy to shout again. Applebloom was out of energy that she suddenly passed out onto the floor. Twilie finally got to Applebloom, however, Applebloom passed out just in the nick of time that Twilie now thinks she’s dead. “Aww! Ch-Children need to stop [DYING] fighting be-because… th-that’s… how… that’s how… ponies get [KILLED] h-h-hurt…” said Twilie as she walked away from Applebloom’s body.

5:42 am

Applebloom finally woke up from being passed out. “Ugh… well, tat was uh tragic! Wait… why am ah in uh different place now!” Applebloom asked herself as she notices that she was inside one of the stables instead of at the main barn door where she passed out at. “Why am ah here now?” Applebloom asked herself again. She walked towards the stable door, hoping that it would be unlocked and it was as she slowly opened the stable door.

“Wat time is it?” Applebloom asked herself quietly as she turned her head to face the clock. “It’s only 5:43? Ah got 17 minutes left. Darn!” Whispered Applebloom disappointed with the time not being at around 6:00 am.

Suddenly, Applebloom heard footsteps coming towards her, but they sounded more like heavy footsteps like if the pony walking towards her was very large. Applebloom knew it was one of the animatronics because she could their robotic twitching voice echoing through the barn. “C’mere, sis! Let’s… pl-play uh game! ‘Cause… ‘Cause… ah like to play [WITH YOUR DEAD CORPSES] g-g-games…” said Apple Fazjack grinning sinisterly.

“Ah said git away from meh! Yer not mah sister!!!” Applebloom shouted at the killer robotic cowgirl. “Oh, sis’! Even… even if we’re not [ALIVE] rel-related… We’re all… all still uh family at Apple Fazjack’s!” Said Apple Fazjack. “Come… Come join us… we’ll have [TOMBSTONES] a reunion… w-with… with the Apple Fam-Fam-Family…” Said Apple Fazjack. “No! No!!! Yer not a part of the Apple Family and ya never will be!!!” Applebloom shouted. “We are a part of the Apple Family [YA WILL FIND OUT WHEN YER DEAD]!!!” Said Apple Fazjack seriously. “No! Just… go away, ya sick robot!” Applebloom shouted as she splinted away from Apple Fazjack. “No running in mah place [YOU CAN RUN, BUT YOU CAN’T HIDE]!!!” yelled Apple Fazjack.

As Applebloom splinted, she looked at the clock again. It was 5:54 am. “6 minutes left to go.” Applebloom whispered to herself as she kept splinting for her life. Applebloom began to walk a different direction as she saw Flutterica right in front of her. “W-wait… Come… come back, children… um… [I WANT TO HELP YOU] would you… like to pl-play… some more g-g-games?…” said Flutterica like if she was trying to tell Applebloom something, but Applebloom ignored her because she thought Flutterica was going to hurt her as well.

Applebloom hid behind a wooden pole, hoping that she wouldn’t be seen by the animatronics. But, Applebloom looked right in front of her she saw that the Rainbow Foxy animatronics laying there around the wall she hit. Rainbow Foxy looked like she was regenerating herself as she began to stand completely straight up ready to attack. Applebloom held her breath so Rainbow Foxy wouldn’t hear her breathing. Rainbow Foxy looked around but didn’t quite notice Applebloom yet. Applebloom couldn’t hold her breathe anymore, so she suddenly, exhale her breath, which made a noise loud enough to get Rainbow Foxy’s attention.

“Ya l-l-l-l-l-l-landlubbers… can’t [GET OUT ALIVE] br-break the rules… in… in… the Cloud Cove… They be walkin’ the plank…” Rainbow Foxy yelled at Applebloom. “Ahhhh!” Applebloom screamed as she bolted away from Rainbow Foxy. And yet, Rainbow Foxy followed her with high speed. “Yer goin’ git the boot, ya landlubber!!!” Yelled Rainbow Foxy as she got even closer to Applebloom.

Applebloom suddenly got trapped at a corner of the barn and she had no other escape. Applebloom turned around as she saw Rainbow Foxy begin to stop flying and walk the ground slowly towards the helpless filly. Applebloom just sat down, shut her eyes with tears going down her face as she knew that this is the end of her life. Rainbow Foxy raised her hooves in the air about ready to grab and murder Applebloom.

Suddenly, right before Rainbow Foxy even touched Applebloom, Applebloom began to hear the Ponyville’s clock tower’s bell ring which echoed from far away, which means it is currently 6:00 am and it’s time for everypony to wake up.

Applebloom gasped in relief, but still had her eyes shut, thinking Rainbow Foxy was still there. Applebloom waited a few seconds, wondering why she hasn’t been attacked yet. She slowly opened her eyes, but then open them wide when she relieved that Rainbow Foxy wasn’t there anymore. “Wh-What?” Applebloom said confused. “Wh-Where did she go?” Applebloom asked herself. Applebloom got up from the floor and splinted towards the show stage. She noticed that Twilie, Flutterica, and Apple Fazjack were standing there in the exact positions as they were before midnight. Then, Applebloom looked at the Cloud Cove and notices that Rainbow Foxy was standing there with the sign saying “Sorry! Out of order!” as it was before midnight. “Wat in tarnation is goin’ on?!” Applebloom asked herself.

Suddenly, Applebloom began to hear knocking on the barn’s main door with a familiar voice that was music to her ears. “Applebloom! Are ya still in there?!” Applejack asked as her voice echoed through the barn door. “Applejack!!!” Applebloom gasped in relief. Big Macintosh unlocked the barn door and opened it. Applebloom came splinting out of the barn with tears of joy as she jumped onto Applejack, hugging her very tight. “Oh, Applejack, I am so glad to see you!” said Applebloom rubbing her cheek against Applejack. “Wat’s the matter, sis?” Applejack asked her little sister confused. “Oh, ya wun’t believe wat happened to meh last night…” Applebloom cried. Applejack, Big Macintosh, and Granny Smith all gazed at Applebloom like if something serious happened to her. “Wat happened?” Applejack asked. “Those… Those robots suddenly came to live and they were scarin’ meh and worse of all, they tried to kill meh!!!” Applebloom cried. The Applejack, Big Macintosh, and Granny Smith all looked at each other and started laughing. “Wh-What? Ah’m serious!” Applebloom cried in a serious tone. “Ya must of had uh very terrifyin’ nightmare, sis!” said Applejack. “No! No! This really happened!” Said Applebloom seriously. “Ah think ya need to stop makin’ stories up! ‘Cause remember that one story ya told us and we believed ya, but ya were just trickin’ us the whole time?” Big Macintosh asked Applebloom. “Big Mac, Ah’m not makin’ this up! Ah promise! ‘em robots tried to attack meh!” Said Applebloom getting a little mad because her siblings don’t believe her. “Ya just might need to eat some breakfast, Applebloom sweetie! That might help ya stop thinkin’ about that nightmare ya had!” Said Granny Smith. Applebloom growled in frustration about ready to yell that she was telling the truth, but she stopped herself in time. “Aw, Okay!” Said Applebloom pouting.

Breakfast time at Apple Family’s Farmhouse, 6:57 am

“Ah’m tellin’ y’all for the last time, ah am tellin’ y’all the truth. Ah’m bein’ honest like ya, Applejack. Ah’m sayin’ that those robots came to live and tried to harm meh!” Applebloom shouted at the Apple Family.

Big Macintosh couldn’t take it anymore of her little sister complaining about the animatronics. “Okay! That’s it! Ah can’t take it anymore of yer complainin’, Applebloom! But, yet, we’ll give ya uh chance by showin’ us proof that those robots do come to live at night and attack ya!” Big Macintosh shouted as he banged his front hooves on the table. “And how are we goin’ do that, Big Mac?!” Granny Smith asked. “Ah will call the Camera Company to set up cameras and lights all around the inside of our barn.” Big Macintosh explained. “Yeah! We could do that, but one thing, Big Mac… We ain’t got any electricity in our barn period.” Said Applejack. “We could use that power generator that we have in the old shed.” Granny Smith suggested. “We could… but that would give us limited electricity!” Said Applejack. “So… It would be uh lot cheaper to do.” Said Big Macintosh. “Alright!” Applejack sighed. “Yay! Now, Ah git to prove y’all wrong!” Said Applebloom excited. “Hey! Ya better eat yer breakfast, sis… ya got school today!” Said Applejack. “Oh, Alright!” Applebloom groaned.

Class time at Ponyville School, 8:00 am

“Okay, class! So, let’s begin with some reading, shall we?” said Cheerilee. The whole class nodded. “Ah dun’t feel like readin’ today ‘cause ah just can’t stop thinkin’ of wat happened to meh last night.” Applebloom whispered to herself as she shivered. “Applebloom, is everything alright?” Cheerilee asked as she walked up to Applebloom’s desk. “Aw, no… not really!” Applebloom whimpered. “What’s the matter?” Cheerilee asked. “Ah… Ah… Ah was attacked by the new robots at our barn.” Applebloom explained. The whole class except Sweetie Belle, Scootaloo, and Cheerilee all laughed at Applebloom. “Now, now, class! We don’t laugh at other ponies’ tragic stories!” Cheerilee said to the class. “Yeah, ah’m actually tellin’ the tru-“ Said Applebloom, but she got interrupted by Diamond Tiara. “Hey Blank Flank, were you crying like a baby when you got attacked by them?” Diamond Tiara asked making fun of her. “Stop it!” Applebloom shouted. “Did the robots fire lasers at you?” Snibs asked making fun of her as well. Everypony except Applebloom herself, Sweetie Belle, Scootaloo, and Cheerilee were laughing at Applebloom and her story. “Stop making fun of her, what if her story is true and she still needs proof?” Sweetie Belle asked the class angrily. “Yeah, her big sister is known for her honesty, what if Applebloom is being honest?” Scootaloo asked the class angrily. “Fillies, Colts, get along now or I will have to put you all on afterschool detention! Now read your books and be quiet!” Cheerilee shouted at the class because she was disappointed with their actions.

The Cutie Mark Crusader Treehouse, 3:16 pm

“Thank y’all so much for helpin’ meh!” Applebloom said to Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo. “Of course!” Said Sweetie Belle and Scootaloo. “Is it all true, Applebloom?” Scootaloo asked. “Yes, it all happened to meh just last night! Ah was trapped inside the barn all night from midnight to 6 in the morning. Ah couldn’t believe it at first, but it really did happen… ‘em robots just came to live and they wanted to kill meh for no reason.” Applebloom explained. “Like… what did they try to do to you?” Sweetie Belle asked. “Well, the Rainbow Dash lookin’ one tried to stab meh in the head with its hook, the Applejack lookin’ one almost tackled meh, the Twilight lookin’ one tried to stuff meh in some kind of suit or somethin’ and the Fluttershy lookin’ one didn’t do much.” Applebloom explained. “Wow! I knew they were trouble because I think they are scary looking!” Said Sweetie Belle. “Yeah! Same! I knew that there was something up with them!” Said Scootaloo. “Finally, ponies who actually believe me!!!” Applebloom said thankfully. “It’s okay, Applebloom… we’re here for you!” Said Scootaloo. “Yep! We are!” Said Sweetie Belle. “Thank y’all!” Said Applebloom as they group-hugged each other.

Sugarcube Corners, 6:39 pm

The Mane Six were having dinner at Sugarcube Corners. “And so I finally found my book on Advanced Spells at last, and so I flipped through the book and read and learn a new spell…” said Twilight Sparkle excited as she continued to talk. “When is this egghead gonna stop yappin’ about her books?” Rainbow Dash mumbled. “Okay… that’s very nice, Twilight!” Said Rarity. “Applejack, is everything alright? You’ve been very quiet recently.” Rarity asked Applejack. “Oh… uh… Ah’m fine… That’s all! Umm… Yeah! Hehe!” Said Applejack nervously. “Say, why weren’t you having another one of those shows with your new animatronics tonight?” Pinkie Pie asked. “’Cause were havin’ cameras, lights, and uh security room installed in our barn right now.” Applejack explained. “Why?” Fluttershy asked. “’Cause mah li’l sis’ Applebloom was complainin’ ‘bout ‘em animatronics goin’ crazy and attackin’ her last night and she wants to give us proof that ‘em robots are nothin’ but trouble at midnight.” Applejack explained. “Oh, who’s going to stay up all night to watch the cameras?” Twilight asked. “Big Macintosh said he would just for this night, ‘cause we’re probably goin’ hire uh different pony to take the job as uh night watch pony for our barn later on.” Said Applejack. “Well, ah better git goin’ back to the barn to see how the installation is goin’! See y’all later!” Said Applejack waving good-bye as her friends were waving good-bye back to her.

The Apple Family’s Barn, 11:54 pm

Big Macintosh is sitting inside the new security room that was installed in their barn with camera screens and lights. “Alrighty then! Ah’m goin’ see if our li’l sis’ is right or wrong about ‘em animatronics goin’ wild around midnight.” Said Big Macintosh to himself. “Ah left the main barn door unlocked in case anything bad happens to meh! So, Ah’m ready to go!” Said Big Macintosh.

Suddenly, the phone in the security room rang which made Big Macintosh jump. “Uh phone… in our barn?” Big Macintosh said confused as he picked it up.

“Hello? Hello? Hey, this is the manager of the company that installed the cameras, lights, and the security room inside your barn, and because you ponies were very good customers to us, we decided to also install a phone in your barn as well! How nice, eh? Anyway, I just want to record you a message that if you feel unsafe being in here, please let us know, so we could also install doors for the security room as well. But, this is just a test, correct? Because one of your siblings complained about the animatronics moving around at night, but you didn’t quite believe her. Well, we hate to spend more money installing doors if you can’t find evidence to proof that your sibling is right. But, anyway, just use that laptop in front of you to turn on the cameras, but be sure you don’t keep that laptop on for too long considering that your family uses a power generator which means you have limited electricity, so it’s important to conserve your power throughout the night. Oh, and if you feel like there’s something suspicious at any of the doorways, please be sure to use your lights to see if there’s any standing at your doorways. But, if you feel like you need extra protection, call us tomorrow and we’ll install doors for your security room. Alright? Good Night!” Said the audio message on the phone.

“Alrighty then! Let’s get start!” Said Big Macintosh all pumped up.

Night 2, 12:00 am

Big Macintosh opened up the laptop to view the cameras. “We’re at 99% Battery, eh?” Said Big Macintosh, gazing at the battery percentage.

Big Macintosh looked through the cameras, when suddenly, he viewed the camera that views the show stage and notices that Twilie was missing. “Wat in tarnation? Did somepony break in and stole one of our animatronics or somethin’?” Big Macintosh asked himself.

Big Macintosh quickly searched through the cameras, when suddenly, he got to the cameras that viewed stable 1A. Twilie was standing there, staring right at the camera.

Big Macintosh tilted his head confused. “Why would somepony place her there?” Big Macintosh asked himself. But, then, Big Macintosh began to get startled as he saw the purple animatronic began to make movements. “Wat in tarnation? That can’t be right?! Ah swear that ah turned the off switch on that thing!” Said Big Macintosh, starting to shiver. Twilie got her right front hoof onto her face as she leaned down, then… she began to tear her animatronic head off, revealing her endoskeleton, which terrified Big Macintosh so much, he started to believe in his little sister, Applebloom, that she was right all along.

To be continued…