Five Nights at AJ's: Hidden Lore (Parts 1-3)

The following content is an unofficial and fan-made story written by Loving-Brony, which is based on Five Nights at AJ’s by anappleforgotten, which is a pony crossover of the original franchise Five Nights at Freddy’s © by Scott Cawthon. Many of the characters in this following story are from the show My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic © which belongs to Lauren Faust and Hasbro. And for further more warning, the following story contains lots of violence, scary and creepy content, disturbing content, and content that may be unsuitable for My Little Pony fans and Five Nights at Freddy’s Fans. Reader discretion is advised.

(Again, this is just for a friend of mine, anappleforgotten, If you do not like creepy MLP fanfics, please do not read this then! For real, this part really does contain violence in it! Thanks!)

  Big Macintosh became so terrified of Twilie ripping her animatronic head off, revealing her endoskeleton that he ran straight out of the security room and out of the barn as the main barn door was unlocked for him as an exit out, however, he left the main barn door wide open.

Big Macintosh ran straight towards the Apple Family’s farmhouse as fast as he could. “Applebloom was right!!! They are alive at nighttime!!!” Big Macintosh yelled as he kicked their front door wide open. Applejack and Applebloom woke up and jumped straight out of her bed, galloping towards her big brother. “What in tarnation is goin’ on?!” Applejack yelled out as she and Applebloom ran towards their big brother. None of them bothered to wake up Granny Smith because they know that she will have one of her episodes if they do wake her up.

“See? Ah told y’all that ah was right all along!” Said Applebloom. “Y’all just never listen to meh ‘cause ah’m usually the one who’s right…” Applebloom mumbled. “Where are they, Big Mac?!” Applejack asked Big Macintosh all freaked out, yet she has her fighting spirit going. “In the barn, of course!” Said Big Macintosh. “Well, there’s no time for chattin’… Let’s git ‘em and show ‘em who’s boss!” Said Applejack as she splinted towards the barn. “No, wait… Applejack… She gonna git hurt if she’s not careful…” Said Applebloom to Big Macintosh. “Well, C’mon!” Said Big Macintosh as he grabs Applebloom with his mouth and tosses her on top of his saddle to ride on and began to splint towards the barn.

Big Macintosh, Applejack, and Applebloom ran inside the barn and ran towards the show stage. “What in tarnation? Where are ‘em animatronics?!” Applejack asked out loud as the three of them realized that Apple Fazjack, Twilie, and Flutterica weren’t on the show stage.

“To the security room!” Big Macintosh shouted as he and his sisters ran towards the security room. “Awlrighty! Let’s see were ‘em robotic critters are right now…” Said Applejack as she looked in the Camera Device Tablet. She didn’t find anything anything until she looked at the camera that views the barn entrance. It was Apple Fazjack looking straight up into the camera with those pitch black eyes and tiny white dots as pupils. Apple Fazjack stared into the camera which stare into the three Apple Family siblings’ souls as she began to do an evil smile at them like if she is trying to taunt them. Suddenly, Apple Fazjack gave a dark and demonic laugh, taunting the Apple Family. Then, Apple Fazjack ran and splinted straight out of the barn, which indicated that she has escaped.

“Aww shoot! First, the animatronics have gone missin’, then, that dirty li’l metal machine of meh has escaped the barn now!” Applejack sighed frustrated. “Whoops! Ah accidentally left that door opened!” Said Big Macintosh in shame.  “Ya two stay here! Ah’ll go git that robotic me!” Said Applejack as she splinted out of the barn.

“Ah’m sorry, li’l sis’! We shoulda believed in ya!” Big Macintosh said to Applebloom. “It’s fine, Big Mac! The youngest can’t always be wrong!” Applebloom replied. “Eeyup!” Big Macintosh replied back. “Ah guess y’all need to really start listenin’ to m-“ Said Applebloom, but she got interrupted by her brother. “Shh!” Big Macintosh quickly hushed Applebloom as they began to hear footsteps coming towards them from the right side of the security room. Applebloom and Big Macintosh were completely silent and try not to make a single step nor any sounds with their mouths. They heard the footsteps getting louder and louder, which meant that whatever is coming is going closer and closer to them, when suddenly, the footsteps completely stopped. Applebloom and Big Macintosh looked each thinking that there is something there at the doorway. Big Macintosh put Applebloom down and made hoof signals telling Applebloom not to move nor talk as Big Macintosh quietly and slowly took steps towards the doorway as he slowly reaches for the huge button that was labelled “LIGHT” which is used to turn on the lights around the doorway. Big Macintosh did a very light tap on the button as he slowly pressed it. A bright light flashed outside of the doorway and it revealed Flutterica with her front hooves laying on the right-side window of the security room. Big Macintosh yelled on the top of his lungs, “Run!!!” at Applebloom. Applebloom splinted out the doorway on the left-side. Big Macintosh ran right behind her. “D-D-Don’t… le-leave (ME TO ROT) uh… us now, fillies and colts... Pl-Please stay and (FREE US) pl-play… play some more games… with me… me and my friends… please? (WE NEED YOU ALL TO HELP US)” Said Flutterica.

Applebloom and Big Macintosh splinted through the left-side of the barn, when suddenly, Rainbow Foxy flew out of nowhere and jumped onto Applebloom, trapping her. “Y-Y-Yargh, ye’ maties! R-R-Rulebreakers… will (BE NOTHING BUT SLAUGHTERED CORSPES) be… be… be… walkin’ the plank…” Rainbow Foxy said to Applebloom’s face, as Rainbow Foxy is about ready to bite her face off. “Ahhh!” Applebloom screamed, but suddenly, Big Macintosh grabbed onto Rainbow Foxy and pulled her right off on Applebloom and he threw Rainbow Foxy straight towards the wall. Big Macintosh stand in front of Rainbow Foxy, blocking her view of Applebloom as he quickly turned his head towards Applebloom. “Go! Applebloom! Run!” Big Macintosh shouted at Applebloom as he turned his head back towards Rainbow Foxy and got into a fighting position. Rainbow Foxy got off the wall and looked at Big Macintosh with white glowing pupils in her eyes indicating that she is angry. “Uh, ah, um…” Applebloom got very nervous to run. “Goooooo!!!!!” Big Macintosh shouted at his little sister all seriously like if it was very life-depending. Applebloom jumped off the ground and ran away from the fight scene about to happen.

The field of Sweet Apple Acres, 2:48 am

Applejack was splinted around the field as she was trying to look for her animatronic counterpart. Suddenly, Applejack heard an old mare scream from their farmhouse. “That was Granny Smith! *gasp* Oh no! She better not be in any danger!” Said Applejack to herself as she splinted towards their farmhouse. As she splinted towards the farmhouse, she suddenly heard a long bang coming from their farmhouse as well. “Oh no! That is not good!” Said Applejack, splinting even faster towards their farmhouse.

“Granny Smith!!!” Applejack screamed as she kicked through the front door of their farmhouse. Applejack looked around in every room on the first floor. When she when into the kitchen, she flipped on the light switch and she saw the following words written up on the kitchen wall in blood, “IT’S ME!” Applejack gasped and almost threw up because of what she just saw as she was thinking that it was Granny Smith’s blood. “No… No… Not Granny Smith… No!!!” Applejack screamed terrified. But, Applejack wasn’t quite done looking around their farmhouse. She wanted to look for who was responsible for this tragic mess.

She galloped upstairs when suddenly she heard another familiar scream echoing from upstairs. “Granny Smith?!” Applejack asked loudly as she realized that was Granny Smith screaming, meaning she was still alive. Applejack ran towards Granny Smith’s room as she kicked her bedroom door wide open with her hooves. “Granny Smith!!! Ah’m here to-“ Applejack shouted, but she paused as she looked and realized that Granny Smith was alive and well like if nothing even touched her at all. “Applejack, don’t scare meh like that! Ya coulda gave yer ol’ Granny uh heart attack!” Granny Smith yelled at Applejack. “But… ya… ya were screamin’ like yer in darn trouble and there was blood on the wa- Ahh, forgit ‘bout it! Why in tarnation were ya screamin’ in the first place when ya looked like nothin’ hurt ya?!” Applejack asked Granny Smith in an angry tone. “Well, ah kept callin’ for y’all to bring mah midnight oatmeal that ah usually have every once in uh while. But, y’all never responded, so ah had to scream for y’all to come.” Granny Smith explained. “Ahh, forgit ‘bout yer darn oatmeal… There’s an animatronic out on the loose and we gotta go git that darn thing!” Applejack shouted. “But, ah need it!” Granny Smith talked back. “Well, ya-“ Applejack talked back, but she got interrupted as they both heard heavy footsteps coming from the doorway of Granny Smith’s bedroom. Both Applejack and Granny Smith stayed completely silent as they heard the footsteps getting louder and louder. Suddenly, they both see two glowing purple eyes standing in the darkness behind the doorway.

“Ah can’t see who that is… Let meh git mah glasses” Said Granny Smith loudly. The animatronic standing at the doorway was Twilie as she heard Granny Smith’s voice and jump attacks towards Granny Smith. “Granny Smith, look out!” yelled Applejack as she tackled Granny Smith to safety, causing Twilie to miss her and hit the wall. Applejack grabs Granny Smith and splints towards the doorway to escape. However, Twilie gets up off the ground and teleports in front of Applejack and Granny Smith, blocking the doorway which was their way to escape. “What in tarnation?! She can teleport just like Twilight can!” Said Applejack freaked out. “Th-There’s… no running… in the play-playroom… chil-children… [THERE IS NO ESCAPE] Please… Please walk… so nopony can [SURVIVE] ge-get… h-h-hurt…” Said Twilie. “What did ya just say?!” Applejack asked Twilie because she swear she heard the demonic whispers Twilie said.

Applejack grabbed Granny Smith and place her on Applejack’s back and began to run towards the window to try to jump for it. But, then, Twilie teleported in front of Applejack again. So, Applejack ran back towards the door again to try to escape only faster to try to beat Twilie from teleporting in front of them again to block them. Suddenly, Twilie jump attacks towards the two Apple Family members, but they both dodged Twilie just in the nick of time as Twilie just missed them again and flew and hit Granny Smith’s dresser. The glasses on Granny Smith’s dresser fell down and shattered into pieces. “Mah glasses! Mah new pair of glasses!” Granny Smith screamed as she heard her glasses breaking. “Ohh, ya’ll pay fer ‘em glasses!” Granny Smith said to Twilie angrily as she grabbed her cane and put on a war helmet.

Granny Smith ran towards Twilie as she swings her cane and beats up Twilie with it. Applejack was standing in the background as she couldn’t believe on what she was seeing. “She knew karate when she was young.” Applejack said to herself. Twilie was taking some damage from Granny Smith swinging her cane at her. Suddenly, Twilie gave up as she shut down, unable to move for now.

“Don’t ya ever break mah glasses ever again!” said Granny Smith. “Granny Smith… That was very brave!” Said Applejack. “Yep! Now, let’s git rid of this darn piece of metal!” Granny Smith replied. “I guess… we’ll just git it fixed tomorrow fer the show fer the kids.” Applejack replied as she drags Twilie’s robotic body out of the room.

The Apple Family Barn, 4:57 am

Applebloom was sitting there in the hay, pretending to be dead by keeping her eyes shut, so the animatronics will think she is dead, but really she is still alive. “Ah hope they think ah’m dead.” Applebloom whispered. Suddenly, she could hear heavy footsteps coming towards her. Applebloom shut her eyes again only tighter as she tried her best to stay still as much as possible. As the footsteps got louder and louder, Applebloom began to sweat as she was worried as well. But, then, whoever was coming towards her, grabbed her and picked her up. “Ahhhhhhhhh! Not me! Ah don’t wanna die today!” Applebloom screamed. But, Applebloom opened her eyes and looked to see who it was picking her up as she wasn’t getting hurt by whoever it is. It was Flutterica. However, Flutterica didn’t look like she wanted to harm Applebloom at all. “Please… L-L-Listen… [I DON’T WANT TO HURT YOU] Ch-Children… Be… sure not to… break any rules…” Said Flutterica. “Git off of meh!” Applebloom shouted at Flutterica as Applebloom kicked her in the face. “Ah ain’t gonna listen to ya!” Applebloom shouted at Flutterica as she kicked one of Flutterica’s front legs causing Flutterica to fall down. “Wait… [DON’T LEAVE ME!] uh… you… you forgot… to play… some arcade games… umm… they… can be very… fun…” Said Flutterica. Applebloom just ran away from the yellow, robotic Pegasus, having fear of getting harmed by her.

Applebloom kept splinting until she bumped into somepony familiar. It was Applejack along with Granny Smith and a damaged Twilie. “Sis’… what in tarnation are ya doin’?” Applejack asked her little sister. “That Fluttershy-looking robot picked meh up and it was sure as darn scary! So, ah had to run away from it!” Applebloom explained. “Oh mah gosh! What is with ‘em animatronics?! Tryin’ to kill us or somthin’?!” Applejack sighed. “Eeyup!” Said Big Macitosh as he come out of the darkness of the left hallway with few wounds on his face. “Big Mac, what happened to ya?!” Applejack asked, freaked out. “That blue one tried to kill meh, but ah shut it down before it could.” Big Macintosh explained as he steps backwards and kicks a damaged Rainbow Foxy out of the darkness as well. “Ah guess we’ve got two animatronics to repair tomorrow and one that’s on the loose that we’re goin’ have to search fer, only if it comes back.” Applejack sighed.

Suddenly, all four of the Apple Family members heard a dark and demonic laughter again, only it was echoing through the entrance of the barn. “That’s the same exact laugh mah robotic-self did before escaping the barn!” Said Applejack. “Did she come back or somethin’?” Applebloom asked. “Luckily, ah brought the Camera Tablet Device with meh. Sadly, ah left it on when meh and Applebloom were runnin’ away from that yellow one earlier, which wasted uh lot of power.” Said Big Macintosh. “How much do we have right now?” Applejack asked. “Ah dunno! Ah didn’t look!” Said big Macintosh as he checks. “Aww Shoot! We’re only at 12% battery and it’s currently 5:21 am!” Big Macintosh shouted freaked out. “How is that uh bad thing? We can just keep that thing turn off fer the rest of the night.” Applebloom asked. “Sis’, not only does this device use power, but all the lights in our barn uses the same exact power as well. So, if we run out of power, the whole barn will go dark like if we were to have uh blackout.” Big Macintosh explained.

Big Macintosh quickly checked the cameras to see where Apple Fazjack is currently located. “Ah hope she didn’t cause any trouble while she was outside the barn.” Said Applejack praying as Big Macintosh was searching for her on the cameras. He saw Apple Fazjack when he got to the camera in Stable 2A, as Apple Fazjack was staring straight up at the camera with those pitch-black eyes with tiny white pupils again just like she did earlier. “She’s in Stable 2A right now!” Said Big Macintosh. Applejack looked up towards the signs that label the stables they were nearby and she realizes that they were nearby Stable 2C. “She’s right there!” Said Applejack as she points into the darkness in Stable 2A. “Ah’ll go git her! Y’all just stay here!” Said Applejack as she ran towards Stable 2A.

When Applejack was standing in front of Stable 2A, she saw the stable gate was wide open. “Ah know yer in there!” Applejack shouted into the darkness, hoping that Apple Fazjack could hear her. Applejack slowly walked into the stable as her heart beats begin to go fast, yet she was ready for anything that may happen to her. Applejack took a few steps into the stable, and another few more steps, getting deeper and deeper into the stable. Then, she stopped and paused, waiting for something to happen. But, nothing came at her so far. Applejack was a little too nervous to take one more step, but she knew was doing this for her family and that she can’t let her animatronic-self escape the barn again. She tried and tried to take the final step, but she would stop herself from doing so. But, then, Applejack lightened up and knew she could do it. Applejack took that one last step.

Suddenly, Apple Fazjack comes out of the darkness and jump attacks onto Applejack as she was doing a very loud screech, knocking her down. “Hahahaha! [IT’S ME!]” Apple Fazjack laughed. Luckily, Applejack kicked Apple Fazjack right off her so she can get up again. Both Applejacks got up off the ground and had a short stare-down at each other. “C’mon, sugarcubes… [Let us fight Pony v.s. Metal Pony!] Let’s go have some fun!” Said Applejack Fazjack. The strange thing is unlike a lot of the other animatronics, Apple Fazjack can talk without being all glitchy most of the time, yet she still does do the demonic whispers like the other animatronics do. “Ya wanna have an Apple Smackdown, eh?” Applejack asked in a fighting position. Apple Fazjack nodded and then threw a punch at Applejack. Applejack dodged the punch in time and kicked Apple Fazjack’s back legs to make her lose her balance. Applejack quickly got up off the ground and kicked Apple Fazjack down onto the ground with her hind legs. “Ha! Can’t resist gettin’ hurt by those babies!” Said Applejack looking at her hind legs. Apple Fazjack got up and jumped onto Applejack again and punched her in the face. Applejack punched Apple Fazjack back in her face, causing one of her robotic, glowing eyes to flicker, and Applejack pushed Apple Fazjack right off of her. Apple Fazjack started to flinch and didn’t move while she was standing. Applejack quickly got up and charged towards her animatronic-self with force as she knocks Apple Fazjack right down, which caused Apple Fazjack’s hat to fall off. Applejack got onto Apple Fazjack, about ready to ask her something, but Apple Fazjack quickly hit Applejack in the face using her head, which knocks Applejack backwards. Apple Fazjack fixes her flickering eye very quickly. Then, she splints towards Applejack as she bites Applejack’s left front leg. “Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh!” Applejack screamed in pain as she pushes her animatronic-self off of her with her right front leg. Applejack’s left front leg begins to bleed a little as she heavily breaths in pain.

“Yer goin’ pay fer what ya have done at mah farm!” Applejack shouted at Apple Fazjack angrily. “[HA! AH’VE DONE NOTHIN’ BUT ENTERTAIN CHILDREN FER Y’ALL!]” Apple Fazjack replied. “Yer goin’ git it! Ya almost killed mah li’l sis’!” Applejack replied. “This is mah barn! Mah farm! Mah family! Mah rules! And yer not goin’ ruin anythin’ ‘bout it!” Applejack shouted at her animatronic-self. “We are a part of the Apple Family.” Apple Fazjack replied. “No, ya ain’t! None of our family members would kill each other unlike you!” Applejack replied angrily as she splinted towards the metal monster of herself and punched her jaw right off, which knocked Apple Fazjack to the ground and shut her off.

“At least ah was bein’ honest as usual. Ah never give up too easily and Yer not a part of our family.” Applejack said to Apple Fazjack’s damaged body. Applejack walked away from her animatronic-self, when suddenly, the whole barn went completely dark, which meant that they just ran completely out of power. The only light that they had was the moonlight shining through the windows of the barn.

Suddenly, Applejack turned around to face Apple Fazjack as Apple Fazjack started to work again and her eyes started to glow very bright as she gets up off the ground and goes berserk as she charges towards Applejack in huge anger, knocking her down again. “[YER NOT THE ONLY PONY THAT DOESN’T GIVE UP EASILY AND NOW YER GOIN’ TO DIE!]” Said Apple Fazjack fiercely as she punches Applejack in the face repeatedly.

Suddenly, Applebloom comes out of the darkness and tackles Apple Fazjack off of Applejack. “Don’t mess with mah sister!” Applebloom shouted. Applebloom tried her best to hold onto Apple Fazjack so that she wouldn’t attack Applejack again. Applejack got up from the ground as she feels her nose bleeding. “Applebloom! No!” Applejack yelled at her sister, worried that she was going to get hurt as well. Suddenly, Apple Fazjack had enough strength that she grabbed Applebloom and threw her into the wall, putting her into a coma.

Apple Fazjack looked at Applejack one more time with a death stare in her glowing eyes. She suddenly charged towards Applejack for the last time, only this time, the charge looked very deadly like it was going to be an instant kill for Applejack. Applejack just closed her eyes, accepting her death.

Suddenly, right before Apple Fazjack even touched Applejack, Applejack began to hear the Ponyville’s clock tower’s bell ring which echoed from far away, which means it is currently 6:00 am and it’s time for everypony to wake up.

Applejack whispered to herself, “It’s 6 o’ clock!” She was somewhat relieved of hearing the bell ringing. She opened her eyes and realized that Apple Fazjack wasn’t there anymore. “What in tarnation?!” Said Applejack confused. Applejack looked at the show stage and realized that all animatronics were standing there at their normal position like if they never moved nor got damaged because they looked like they have been repaired already. “How is that possible?” Applejack asked herself out loud. Applejack turned around and saw that Applebloom is really in a coma. “Applebloom!” Applejack screamed as she ran towards her poor little sister. “No! Not you!” Applejack cried as she began to get tears in her eyes. “We must take ya to uh hospital!” Said Applejack as she picked her sister up and carried her out of the barn.

Applejack passed by Big Macintosh and Granny Smith as she saw that they were wounded as well. “So, what are we goin’ do now?” Granny Smith asked the Apple Family. “We take ourselves to the hospital first, then we go hire a security guard to make sure ‘em animatronics aren’t goin’ cause any more trouble in our farm, then we call Flim and Flam ‘bout these animatronics and why they want to harm us ‘cause this could be some trap they’re both puttin’ on us.” Said Applejack. “And we’re goin’ install doors in the security room and regenerate the power for the next night.” Big Macintosh added in. “Well, somethin’ fishy and strange is goin’ on here and ah don’t like it, but yet, that’s what we will have to figure out ourselves ‘cause this might be some mystery we’ll have to solve.” Said Applejack as the four Apple Family members walked their way towards the hospital as they we’re limping and wounded, so it’s hard for them to walk there.

To be continued…