It's not everyday in Ponyville that a young mare like Scootalo decides to show affection for a baffled colt like Time Turner, especially when you're in your late twenties and a virgin. As he tries to handle her feelings for him he makes a mess of everything, his life included, afraid to ruin hers. Soon a few things get out of hand and there's no turning back, so it's up to him to chose a path ahead that he won't regret.