Starlight Glimmer's Punishment

Twilight

“I realize that what I did was wrong... and I'm willing to accept any punishment that you may have in mind for me,” Starlight said pensively. She grimaced as she lowered her head in front of the Council of Friendship. She waited. The silence was deafening.

“Actually, we were just discussing that,” Twilight finally spoke, piercing the awkward silence. “We've decided that if you're up to it, you can stay here in Ponyville and learn more about the magic of friendship. I will do the best I can to teach you, if you're willing to learn.”

“Do you... do you really mean it?” Starlight said with hope in her voice.

“Of course we do, sugarcube,” Applejack replied.

“Absolutely, darling,” Rarity chimed in.

“I like you already!” Pinkie said with a grin. “You're like Twilight Sparkle! You even have the same naming structure!”

“That being said, we on the council also agree that in addition to your studies you must perform a minor amount of community service, so to speak,” Twilight added. “To help put your actions into proper perspective.”

“Of course!” Starlight exclaimed. “I will not let you down, Princess. I promise.”

“Excellent. I have procured housing for you in town, you should find it to be your liking,” Twilight said, floating out a piece of paper with an address scrawled on it. “Also, your community service will start tonight. Report to the castle at eight o’clock, sharp. Do not be late.”

Starlight grimaced. Twilight's voice had an edge to it she hadn't realized the ‘Princess of Friendship’ could have. Community service at the castle? At night? What did the Princess of Friendship have in store for her? Why would she pick such a random time to begin her punishment? It didn't make sense.

“Yes, Princess,” she decided to say. She couldn't question Twilight's command. She knew deep in her heart that what she had done, what she had tried to do, was wrong and that she deserved a far greater punishment than what she was being given.

“Good. You may go to your home now. We will continue discussing events where we left off,” Twilight said.

Starlight nodded and trotted out of the throne room. She sighed loudly and looked down at the address on the paper. Guess I should go get ready, she thought. Still... the chance to learn about true friendship from the Princess herself? No matter what the punishment is, that's worth it. I have to make good on my promise.

Starlight exited the castle and made her way through town. Everywhere she went the ponies ofthe town waved at her like she was just another pony. They didn't care about what she had been, or what she'd done to gain power. Starlight smiled. It was something she needed greatly.

The housing that Twilight had procured for her was not too far from the castle, and was a moderate looking building by Ponyville standards. The door was unlocked. Starlight grinned. I guess security really isn't a big deal in this town, she thought as she made her way inside.

The home was fully furnished, it appeared. The curtains had a bit of flair to them that Starlight couldn't help but wonder if Twilight's other friends had a hoof in helping decorate. She couldn't image how quickly they had managed to put this together, for her of all ponies!

Sitting on the nightstand next to the front door was an envelope. Starlight lifted it in her magic. It had her name on it. Below it was a simple white box. Starlight opened the envelope and pulled out the letter inside.

Starlight,

Your appointment at the castle is at eight o'clock tonight. Don't forget! Tardiness won't be rewarded.

Also, the box contains an item that you must wear when you attend to your community service. Please do not put it on until you arrive at the castle.

Twilight

Starlight blinked and pulled out the box with her magic. She opened it, revealing a simple black leather band with a charm attached. The charm was a heart and had her cutie mark ornately engraved on its face.

“What is this?” Starlight muttered under breath. “Some sort of identification band? What is she going to have me doing, picking up trash or something?”

Starlight lifted the band out of the box with her magic and looped it around. It appeared to be too big to go around her forelegs. Her eyes widened as she realized that it fit perfectly around her neck. It wasn't just some identification band. It was a collar!

“A collar! What does she think I am, some sort of pet?!” Starlight exclaimed. “I'm going to have to have a word with her about this!”

Starlight slipped off the collar and put back into the box. Fuming, she looked over the letter again for any indication of why Twilight Sparkle would want her to wear something so demeaning. She sighed loudly after the third or fourth time re-reading it. She glanced up at the clock. She had to be at the castle by eight, which was still about four to five hours away.

Starlight's stomach grumbled. “I guess I should get something to eat,” she said.

* * *

Starlight trotted up to the castle doors at five minutes til eight, the box containing the collarclutched tightly to her side. She pushed open the door and walked inside, seeing that Twilight's dragon assistant was waiting for her.

“Oh, Starlight, you're here,” he said. “Twilight is waiting for you upstairs.”

“Thank you... Spike was it?” she said.

“That's right,” he proclaimed proudly. “I'm Twilight's number one assistant.”

“I assume you'll be seeing a lot more of me then in the days to come,” Starlight replied. “I will go see the Princess now. Thank you again.”

“You're welcome. If you two need anything just let me know,” Spike said, wandering off down the hallway.

Starlight grimaced, waiting until Spike was out of sight. She had decided that she would wear the collar, but would ask about it's significance when she saw Twilight. She pulled it out of the box and fastened it around her neck, the charm hanging just low enough that it touched her coat. It was cold, sending a shiver throughout her entire body.

Starlight ignored it and headed towards the stairs. She trotted up for what felt like forever before finding herself in front of an elaborate doorway. She coughed and lifted her hoof, knocking loudly on the door.

“Enter, please,” a voice came from the other side.

Starlight calmly pushed the door open and walked inside. The room was lit by candles, the scent of lavender wafting through the air and into her nostrils. At one side of the room was an old writing desk with a neatly organized set of papers sitting on top of it. At the other end was a lavish bed with golden bed posts and beautiful satin sheets. Starlight's eyes popped out of her skull. This was... Twilight's bedroom!

“Good, you came just in time. Well, you’re here just in time anyway,” an amused Twilight said from within the room. “Come in, Starlight. Come in, and sit.”

Starlight walked deeper into the room, letting the door close behind her. As she walked, her eyes began adjusting to the light and she could see Twilight in the middle of the room. Her eyes nearly departed their sockets once more. She had been ready to argue against this collar, but she hadn't been expecting what she saw.

Twilight had a sharp grin on her face. Her hair had been done up into frizzly little curls, a far cry from her normal straight and narrow mane. A set of narrow glasses set on the bridge of her muzzle, giving her the appearance of a stern older mare. The outfit she was wearing reminded Starlight of a schoolteacher’s, ith the exception of the lacy leggings that she wore on her hind legs. Starlight couldn't see Twilight's cutie mark, it was obscured by the skirt she wore. A glimmer of silver came from the mare's front hooves. It appeared that Twilight was wearing a simple set of horseshoes.

“Twilight...? Is that you...?” Starlight said as she came to rest in front of the other mare. She slumped to her haunches.

“Ah, ah,” Twilight said. “Starlight Glimmer, you are here because your punishment is to perform community service, in addition to your role as my student.”

“I...” Starlight started to say. “I will do...”

“Did I say that you could speak?” Twilight said, interrupting her. “I can see that you have a lot to learn. You will speak only when spoken to. Do you understand me?”

Starlight balked. Surely Twilight didn't actually expect her to abide by such an inane rule! She started to press her point further, but she knew deep down that the reason she had also agreed to be punished like this. She sighed. “Yes.”

“Ooh, that's another thing I should add,” Twilight said. “While you are performing your community service, you will address me as Mistress. Do you understand?”

“Yes... Mistress,” Starlight said. Her face heated as she immediately blushed.

“Good,” Twilight said. “Now then. Stand up please.”

Starlight stood and waited for Twilight's next instruction, but none came. Twilight instead made way her alongside her, brushing her coat slightly. It made Starlight shiver.

“Mmm... yes. Very nice,” Twilight said under her breath. “Starlight, could you lift your tail for me please?”

Starlight's blush deepened to a crimson red. She wants me to do what?! she thought. Her mind raced with a reply. Okay, okay, just calm down... maybe just... do what she asks? I mean, this is certainly a lot less painful than being sent to Tartarus.

“Yes, Mistress,” Starlight choked out as she lifted her tail. She felt the sensation of Twilight watching her squirm. It... it excited her, like she wanted to Twilight to watch. She felt so exposed. She'd never felt like that in her entire life. All that time, she'd been the one in control. She'd been the one guarding herself, and here she was just displaying herself for the world to see.

No, not the world. For... for Twilight, she thought to herself. For some reason, that didn't bother her. She'd never given much thought to either mares or stallions, but she knew that didn't mind Twilight seeing her like this.

“You are quite lovely, you know that, Starlight?” Twilight said.

“Thank you, Mistress,” Starlight said automatically. She gritted her teeth.

“And so polite,” Twilight replied. “I'll have to take that under consideration in undertaking your punishment.”

“My... my punishment, Mistress?” Starlight asked.

“You were a very naughty pony,” Twilight said, ignoring her question. “You did a lot of very bad things didn't you?”

“I...” Starlight said. She wasn't sure how to respond to that. She had done a lot of bad things, after all. She still couldn't see Twilight. What was she doing? Just watching her? She wanted badly to turn and face her, but she feared that she would be in far worse trouble if she did.

“What did I say about talking? That's a mark off for you, missy,” Twilight said. “Now, where was I? Oh yes. Your punishment. Stay right there, Starlight. Stay very still and look straight ahead. Do you understand me?”

“Yes... yes, Mistress,” Starlight said.

“Mmm... and keep that tail up. I'm quite enjoying the view,” Twilight replied, her voice husky.

Starlight blushed fiercely. She became acutely aware of a fire burning between her legs. She was actually enjoying being treated like this! Starlight felt a wetness on her inner leg. Her mind was racing with adrenaline. She realized she wanted Twilight to see her excitement, but Twilight said nothing to indicate she had noticed. What was Twilight doing? She had told her to hold still, for what?

*THWACK*

Something hard and flat swatted Starlight's flank, sending a wave of pain through her body. Starlight yelped and nearly buckled to the ground.

“Oh dear, I should have warned you that was coming,” Twilight said. “I'm terribly sorry. Are you alright?”

Starlight blinked. Of course I'm not bucking alright, are you serious?! You just hit me with something! she thought.

“Yes... Mistress.”

“Good,” Twilight said. “Because there's more where that came from. You have been a naughty filly Starlight Glimmer, and it's high time you were punished for it.”

*THWACK*

The second strike came on the other side of her flank. Starlight realized that while it hurt, it also felt incredibly good. She was a bad pony, and she deserved to be punished.

*THWACK THWACK THWACK*

Starlight yelped again as the flat of whatever Twilight was using struck her in rapid succession. She breathed in heavily, bracing herself for more. This was the community service she had to serve? Being spanked like a filly who'd broken a rule? The wetness in between her legs grew. She could feel her marehood pulsing. She was enjoying this. Her brain screamed for more.

“I see somepony is enjoying themselves. I can practically smell you from here. Naughty filly. I'll have to give you more strikes for that,” Twilight said.

*THWACK*

Starlight reeled as another strike came. And another, and another. Every time it happened her mind cried out for release. She yelped and writhed as her flanks grew numb. And yet, she loved every minute of it. She deserved this. This was her punishment. She wanted it.

“More... please, Mistress,” she managed to say between breaths.

“Tell me, Starlight. Have you been a bad filly?” Twilight said.

“Yes, Mistress.”

“Say it.”

“I've been a bad filly, Mistress. I've been a very bad filly,” Starlight replied.

“And what happens to bad fillies who break the rules?” Twilight said.

“They get... punished,” Starlight said, breathing heavily. “Please... punish me, I deserve it Mistress.”

*THWACK*

Twilight struck again, much harder than the other strikes. This one felt different, like it had come from Twilight's own hoof instead of an implement of some kind. Starlight buckled, doing her best to stay up. Tears filled her eyes. Her vision was blurred by the pain.

Twilight's hoof came down, again and again. Starlight's tears flowed freely.

“I'm sorry! I'm sorry! I won't do it again! Please!” she shouted.

Twilight stopped. Starlight waited in agony for the next set to come, but they didn't. Instead, Twilight began to caress her flank with some sort of cool gel. Starlight sighed as the stinging died down. The cool gel felt almost as good as the ending of the pain. She reached up and brushed her tears away.

“I believe that's enough punishment for now,” Twilight said softly. “You may have been a bad filly, Starlight, but I believe that you are trying. I know you're sorry.”

“Yes, Mistress,” Starlight said, panting. “I'm so sorry.”

“I know. That's why you will be rewarded. You're a good little filly. Would you like a reward?” Twilight asked.

Starlight's mind raced. What was Twilight still doing back there? She nodded her head slightly. Her loins ached for it. She wanted it badly “Yes, Mistress. Please reward me. I need it.”

Her answer came in the form of Twilight's hoof. It started gently working its way up her hind quarters before delving along her belly to her teats. Starlight moaned slightly as Twilight's hoof rubbed along her teats, making its way to her engorged pussy.

“Oh yes, you are most certainly a naughty little slut, aren't you?” Twilight said abruptly. “Mmm... You really enjoyed this didn't you?”

The hoof removed itself as quickly as it had arrived. Starlight cried out inside, yearning for it to return. She wanted Twilight to give her the release her body had been craving.

“Relax, Starlight,” Twilight said. “We'll get to that. First things first.”

Twilight stepped back into Starlight's view, almost strutting in front of her. It was the first moment that Starlight had been able to see under the skirt that covered her hindquarters. A pair of frilly lace panties stuck out. Fittingly enough, they were purple.

“Do you like what you see?” Twilight said. Her eyes narrowed as she wrapped her magic around the pair of panties. She slid them down slightly. “I've been waiting all day for this, I'll have you know.”

“You... you have?” Starlight said, her eyes widening.

“Oh yes,” Twilight replied huskily. “I've been positively wet with excitement.”

The panties dropped to the floor around Twilight's legs, and Starlight got a glimpse of her marehood. It was slick and wet as well. Twilight's engorged teats could be seen as she spread her legs and lifted her tail. Seeing them excited Starlight even more.

“You never answered my question,” Twilight said as she removed her glasses. “Do you like what you see?”

“Y-y-yes, Mistress,” Starlight replied. “You're very pretty, Mistress.”

“Thank you, dear,” Twilight said. “I have a problem though. One that you might be able to help me with.”

“Yes?” Starlight said.

Twilight rolled her eyes. “Come here, silly filly. I have an itch that needs scratching.”

“Huh?” Starlight said, cocking her head to the side. “I’m… I’m not following you.”

“Starlight. Have you ever, you know… had sex before?” Twilight asked.

Starlight’s eyes widened and she shook her head. In truth, she’d never really been too interested in other ponies like that. Her ambition and goals to remove cutie marks from history had kind of taken precedence there. The gears in her head started to click as she realized what Twilight wanted.

“Oh, you want me to…” she said.

“Eat me like a cupcake, yes,” Twilight said. She giggled. “I’m sorry, I hadn’t realized you didn’t have much experience with this. Just, take your time. It’ll be fine.”

Starlight nodded, walking up behind Twilight. She placed a hoof on Twilight's flank, hearing the mare moan softly at her touch. She spent some time caressing her flank, noting that the alicorn especially enjoyed having her cutie mark touched. Her hoof turned and made its way up towards Twilight's pulsing pussy. She brushed along the folds of it slightly, feeling Twilight quiver.

“Goddess,” Twilight breathed. “Feels so good.”

“Am I pleasing you, Mistress?” Starlight asked.

“Starlight... do me a favor...” Twilight said huskily. “And I mean this in the nicest way, but... shut up and fuck me.”

Starlight balked for a second, but nodded. She grabbed a hold of Twilight's flanks and brought her muzzle in close. She could feel the heat coming off of the other mare's pussy. Twilight was aching, just as she was. Starlight wished she could feel relief, but she realized that Twilight was in control here. She was first. Cautiously, Starlight extended her tongue and ran it along the folds of Twilight's pussy. Twilight buckled under the sensation.

“Fuck... right there,” Twilight said.

Starlight's tongue worked up and down, parting Twilight's pussy-lips. Her hoof reached out and pulled Twilight's leg out slightly so that she could reach her teats. As her hoof rubbed one of the erect nipples, her tongue began to work up and down faster. She hesitantly moved towards Twilight's clit several times, before taking it in her mouth and sucking hard on it.

“Fuck... fuck...” Twilight said. Her tongue lolled out the side of her mouth.

Starlight continued her ministrations, feeling Twilight's body shake under the pressure of release. She turned her tongue to Twilight's clit, running it over it hard and rough. She pulled it into her mouth and sucked. Twilight's legs began to buckle.

“I'm so close... keep doing that,” Twilight managed to say.

Starlight grinned widely, a thought crossing her mind. Her horn lit up, grabbing onto the folds of Twilight's pussy with her magic. She spread them apart, revealing the other mare's glistening insides. She worked her magic along her inner walls at the same time as she used her tongue to lap Twilight's clitoris.

“Oh... oh... oh goddess I'm going to cuuuuuuuummm!” Twilight shouted as she began to convulse. Her pussy began to pulse under Starlight's mouth.

Starlight pulled back slightly, her muzzle drenched with Twilight's fluids. Twilight's legs finally gave out, sending her to the floor in a heap. She rolled to one side, her eyes meeting Starlight's. Starlight felt the fire between her legs flare back to life. She narrowed her gaze as she reached in and kissed Twilight. The other mare's eyes widened for a brief second before closing and melting into the kiss. When they pulled apart, both mares were panting heavily.

“Wow...” Twilight said. “That was... that was amazing.”

Starlight beamed. “I'm glad you enjoyed that, Mistresss... but I uh... I was kind of hoping...” Her eyes glanced down between her legs.

“Silly filly,” Twilight giggled. “We're far from done. I have just the thing for you.”

“You... you do?”

“Uh huh,” Twilight said, her horn igniting. “On the bed. Now.”

Starlight nodded, making her way to the bed. She plopped onto it, marvelling at the feel of her coat on the soft satin sheets. She glanced over at Twilight. The other mare was levitating something over to her. Starlight's eyes widened. It was a massive fake stallionhood, attached to a set of straps. Twilight slid it on and fastened it.

“Do you like it? I created this by myself,” Twilight said, the dick swaying between her legs. “If you want, I can teach you the spell.”

Starlight rolled her eyes. Twilight was so adorkable sometimes. Still, she nodded.

“Good. Now, turn around,” Twilight replied.

Starlight nodded again, as she scrambled to present herself. She hoisted her rump in the air and swished her tail out of the way, revealing her engorged marehood to her lover.

Twilight grinned widely as she used her magic to shed the rest of her clothes. They would only get in the way. She positioned herself above Starlight, the fake dick quivering in anticipation. Twilight had designed the device to function exactly like a real stallion's. It would even cum when she wanted it to. She moved forward, laying the blunt head of the dick against Starlight’s sopping pussy and pushing.

Starlight gasped as the stallionhood pressed into her. It's so big! her mind cried out.

“Are you alright?” Twilight asked softly.

Starlight nodded. “Yes... just... wasn't expecting it to be so big. Take it slowly, please?”

“Okay,” Twilight breathed. She pushed forward a tiny bit further, meeting less resistance as she did. Twilight panted as well. Part of the spell transferred all of the feeling from the dick to her brain, making it really feel like it was a true part of her. The pressure of Starlight's inner walls grabbing onto the dick felt amazing.

Starlight's eyes closed as Twilight pressed deeper. Pretty soon, she could feel that the dick was buried in her pussy to the hilt. The feeling of being so full thrilled her.

“I'm going to pull out a bit and start thrusting. Are you still okay?” Twilight said.

“Yes... please... goddess please. Do it,” Starlight replied. “Fuck me, Mistress. Fuck me like the naughty filly I am.”

“Oh, I intend to,” Twilight said. She pulled back, letting the dick slide out just enough. She thrust back in, hearing Starlight gasp again under the force of it.

“Harder...”

Twilight grinned. She slid out and back in quickly, pumping the fake dick into Starlight's pussy. The other mare quivered and shook in between thrusts. Twilight could feel Starlight's inner walls starting to contract. She was so close. Twilight's magic reached out and gave the fake stallionhood a push, the head of it starting to flare.

“Harder... oh goddess, fuck fuck fuck!” Starlight shouted and squealed.

Twilight pumped harder and faster, her breathing getting harder and harder as she did. Starlight's pussy began pulsing. Her legs shook and buckled as she cried and squealed into the sheets.

“Oh OH FUCK I'M CUMMING!” Starlight exclaimed.

Twilight released her magic in a final push, the head of the fake cock flaring as Starlight bucked into it, burying the member deep to the hilt. Twilight cried out as she felt Starlight's inner walls contract and lock around the cock as heavy spurts of cum roared from its head. The two mares held the position, each one convulsing into the other. They fell to the side on the bed together.

After a few moments, Twilight wriggled, moving so that the cock slid out. A trail of cum came with it, oozing out of Starlight's pussy and onto the satin sheets. The other mare panted loudly as she turned to face Twilight.

“Your sheets are ruined, Mistress,” she said.

Twilight giggled again. “That's okay. They can be cleaned. Did you enjoy that?”

Starlight nodded in reply.

“Good. I'm glad. I'm sorry for the false pretense. Community service sounded a little bit nicer than what we actually wanted,” Twilight said. “Consider this a good kind of punishment, if you will.”

“Mistress.... Twilight... I did mean what I said. I deserved to be punished for what I did,” Starlight replied. “You have nothing to apologize for.”

“I know you meant it, Starlight. I believe you. But I would be lying if I said I wasn't a little bit apprehensive. But now, now I'm not. You're a good mare,” Twilight said. “Plus, I do admit, you are quite an attractive one at that.”

Starlight smiled. “Thank you. I had feared for the worst. I just have one question... where did you learn all of this?”

“Oh, that's an easy one. My friends and I are very close,” Twilight said. “As you will soon find out for yourself.”

Starlight raised an eyebrow. “What do you mean? Does this have anything to do with this?” she asked, pointing to the collar.

“Sort of. The rules are quite simple. As long as you're a part of the group, you will attend weekly sessions with each one of us in turn. The collar denotes that you are willing to commit to this,” Twilight replied with a chuckle. “In short, don't put on the collar in public. Keep it with you at all times, though. Put it on when instructed, and above all things, enjoy yourself.”

“So wait... you and your friends just... go around and have sex with each other all the time?” Starlight said.

“Not all the time. Sometimes we go around and spread friendship to Equestria. A Princess has to unwind though, you know? It's not always just us, sometimes we bring others in on the fun. This stallionhood? Modeled after Applejack's brother. Still not as impressive as the real thing, but hey, it's a work in progress,” Twilight said. “I did say 'community service' after all.”

“I see,” Starlight said. “So what happens next, Mistress?”

“For starters, you only need to call me that when we're meeting like this. You can just call me Twilight the rest of the time,” Twilight said. “To be honest with you, Starlight. I was apprehensive about trusting you. However, I can see the potential that you have. This was a pretty thinly veiled way of punishing you, if only to make other ponies in the town believe that we have made you see the error of your ways and that you're working off your debt to society.”

Starlight nodded. “Can... can we just stay like this for a while then, Mistress? I don't really feel like getting up. Of course, I'm not sure I could physically manage that for a few days.”

Twilight giggled. Her eyes narrowed at Starlight. “Sure. You know... we could always go again when you're feeling up to it. I would love the chance to let you try this thing out.” She pointed at the fake stallionhood.

Starlight chuckled. “Also, who am I meeting next? I suppose I should get this organized into a schedule somewhere, or face the wrath of my teacher.”

“That would be Applejack. One warning though. Rope burn hurts,” Twilight said with a grin.

Starlight's eyes widened. What have I gotten myself into? she thought.

Author's Note

This little piece was written as part of my "Monthly One-Shot Submissions" thing I'm doing this year. Basically every month, my patrons on Patreon provide me a writing prompt to write, and I pick the best one and go from there.

This was the first one, based on the prompt of "Starlight Glimmer gets punished, instead of forgiven." Granted, I might have skewed things a bit, but the end goal of all of this is to keep my writing technique fresh by forcing myself to write something every month in addition to my ongoing works.

If you like what you've read here, and you want to see more, consider donating to me on Patreon! Then you too can be part of my creative process and help me crank out more content!