Starlight Glimmer's Punishment

Applejack

Starlight Glimmer yawned as she awoke. She sat up in bed and cricked her neck. She was still getting used to having such a nice bed, even though she'd been sleeping in it for a week. She yawned again and cleared her eyes. The clock next to her said it was four in the morning. It was still dark outside.

Starlight sighed loudly. Today was her appointment with Applejack, which meant getting up at the crack of dawn to do farm chores and barn chores and apple chores. Aside from chores, she wasn’t sure exactly what the country mare had in store for her. Her eyes drifted to the box on the end table next to her bed.

The collar. Starlight's mind went back to that night the week before, when Twilight had first brought her into the arrangement that now dominated her life. It was all disguised as a form of punishment for Starlight's misdeeds. Starlight smiled. It was so much more than that, though. Her heart raced as she remembered Twilight taking her, the feeling of Twilight's flesh on her tongue, and the unforgettable feeling of being rutted like a common whorse. It thrilled Starlight to no end.

Since that night, she'd painfully been waiting for the next appointment. Her night with Twilight had awoken something inside of Starlight. Not just the thirst for friendship, although that was a part of it, but a lust she had never experienced before. She had always been so focused, so passionate about her cause, that sex had never entered into her mind. In one night, Twilight Sparkle had shown her there was so much more than just her cause, and now it was all she could think about.

Starlight lowered a hoof, sliding it down towards her nether regions. She'd spent nearly every night and almost every morning this whole week like this, and yet every time she'd made herself cum it never held a candle to the pleasure she'd experienced with Twilight. Her hoof found purchase in the folds of her pussy and she began to rub furiously.

Starlight moaned as she spread apart her lips with magic. She thought about Twilight's pussy, wondering when the next time would be that she would be able to experience it again. She bucked her hips, grinding hard into her hoof as her orgasm built up. She was close, so very close....

*KNOCK KNOCK KNOCK*

Starlight froze as she heard the knock at her front door. She cursed under her breath. Applejack had said she was coming to pick her up to take her to the farm. The knock came again. Starlight groaned. She'd been so close, she almost thought about finishing and then going to meet with AJ, but the mood had been ruined. She shuffled off of the bed and after a quick scrub with a towel, she made her way downstairs. As she left she stuffed the collar, safe in its little box, into her bags.

“Coming!” she called out as she reached the door. She pulled it open to reveal a smiling orange earth mare.

“Howdy, Starlight,” Applejack said cheerily. “Sleep well?”

Starlight glared. “Well enough. I had no idea ‘morning’ was this early. Nearly slept in. How are you so chipper?”

“Years of practice. Come on, let's get going to the farm. Got lots to do today, sugarcube,” Applejack replied with a grin.

Starlight nodded and fell into step beside Applejack. As they made their way through the town, Starlight noticed that they were the only ones really out and about.

“Most ponies aren't up this early,” Applejack said, almost as if she'd read Starlight's mind. “Only ponies that rise and shine before the sun are the farmers, like my family. Even then, it takes forever to get Apple Bloom out of bed to go to school.”

“Apple Bloom?” Starlight asked. She wasn't overtly familiar with Twilight's – correction her new friends and their family. Most of the past week had been spent getting in the swing of things in town and learning where everything was.

“My little sister. You'll meet her later on. Her and the Crusaders are headed out for a campin' trip today with their school,” Applejack replied.

Starlight nodded again. As they walked, the dirt road beneath their hooves gave way to green grass. The two mares crested a hill and stopped. Sweet Apple Acres spread out before them. Starlight gazed in awe at the farm. A massive red barn towered next to the house, and beyond that rows upon rows of apple trees sat, an impossible green in the early morning sun.

“Wow,” she muttered under her breath. She let out a low whistle.

“I know, right?” Applejack said. “There's many pretty things in this world but there ain't nothin' quite like Sweet Apple Acres.”

“I agree. It's spectacular, Applejack,” Starlight said.

“Come on. We got a lot of work to do today. We should get started,” Applejack said, trotting down the hill towards the farm.

Starlight followed behind, taking in the sights and smells of the farm as she went. She had nearly forgotten that AJ had interrupted her private time. Almost, at least. Her loins still burned for release. She couldn't take her mind off of what the country mare could possibly have in store for her. One thing was for sure, a little hard work would be good for a change.

* * *

“Alright, we’ve got the little chores done, now for the main event. Applebucking! Now, you're gonna plant your front hooves real solid like,” Applejack explained. “Once you've done that, lift your back legs and kick. It's just that easy.”

Starlight nodded. Her muscles ached from the hard labor of the day. She'd resigned herself to not using her magic in order to better understand her new friend and what she was capable of. In short, she hurt. A lot. It didn't help either that she was sweating profusely.

The morning sun, bright and beautiful, had given way to a sweltering heat in the afternoon. And through it all, Applejack appeared completely unfazed. Sure, she was sweating just as much as Starlight was, but it didn't seem to bother her.

Starlight grimaced, planting her hooves. She lifted her back legs and kicked out as hard as she could. She hit the tree with discombobulated force, feeling it only shake a little bit. She growled under her breath.

“Take it easy, sugarcube,” Applejack said. “You're lettin' your back legs get away with ya. You gotta keep them together. Watch me.” The orange mare walked over to another tree and turned. She planted her hooves and kicked out spectacularly, striking the tree with enough force that several apples fell into the carefully arranged baskets below.

“Showoff,” Starlight huffed. “This is easy to you.”

Applejack sniggered. “It can be to you too, if you just give it a try. It's alright though. We'll give it a shot after lunch. We're both sweatin' so hard, might be a good idea to head over to the pond and cool off a bit.”

Starlight nodded. She fell into step just behind Applejack. As they walked, her mind and her eyes started to wander. She realized that even though they were both drenched in sweat, Applejack seemed to be barely affected by it. She wasn't even breathing hard.

Starlight's eyes drifted down to Applejack's flank. The sheen of sweat highlighted a pont that was very different than Twilight. Twilight was demure, lanky. Applejack was... well, she was toned. Her legs were muscular, but not overly muscular. They were firm and held a lot of power in them. Starlight's eyes tried to pierce past Applejack's tail. She had spent all day casually trying to glimpse behind it, without much luck. The fire between her legs burned hotter. Why hadn't Applejack mentioned the arrangement at all? That was why she was here, right?

Applejack stopped suddenly and Starlight quickly realized she was nearly going to run into her. She stopped before she did, grinning sheepishly.

“Uh, we're here,” Applejack said, pointing with her hoof.

“Oh,” Starlight said, following her motion.

A simple pond sat just beyond the two mares, an apple tree sitting on the far bank. A picnic basket also sat next to the pond. Applejack trotted over to it and pulled out two bottles of apple juice.

“Go on and jump in, I'll join you in a moment,” she said.

Starlight nodded and made her way forward, dipping her hooves in the cool water. She sighed deeply as she waded in. It felt amazing against her sweaty coat. She heard and felt a large splash next to her. Applejack hadn't just waded in, she'd jumped in with wild abandon.

“Sorry about that,” she said. “Feels good, don't it?”

“Mmm hmm,” Starlight hummed as she made her way deeper in. “I could get used to this.”

“Heh. Yeah, sometimes I like to just come down here and take a dip. Really helps clear your mind, you know?” Applejack said.

Starlight nodded. She dipped her head in briefly and sighed loudly. Her eyes found AJ, who was lazily staring back at her.

“So... you like bucking apples?” Applejack said.

Starlight shrugged. “It's fun, I guess. Definitely a lot of hard work.”

“Uh huh. And how'd you like to buck my apples for a change?” Applejack said, her gaze narrowing at Starlight.

“Huh...?” Starlight said.

“Didn't think I forgot did you? You've been staring at my flank all day, just waiting to get a piece, haven't you?” Applejack said.

“I uh...” Starlight said. “Yes. Yes, I have.”

Applejack grinned. “Good. You're gonna enjoy what I have planned then. Let's finish up here and then go to the barn. Somepony should be waiting for us there.”

Starlight's eyes widened. Somepony else? She knew Twilight had mentioned other ponies sometimes got involved in their arrangement. What did Applejack have in store for her?

* * *

“Alright, sugarcube, follow me,” Applejack said as she led Starlight up to the main barn. “You can uh, put that thing on now.”

Starlight blinked. She'd nearly forgotten about the collar. She nodded, and grabbed it from the bags she'd left by the barn. She slipped it on and smiled. “How do I look?”

“Goofy. I never liked the idea of them things, but Twilight was insistent about it,” Applejack said, her smile taking the edge off the comment. “Now, come on. There's somepony I'd like you to meet.”

She pushed open the door to the barn, letting Starlight trot past her. As Starlight's eyes adjusted to the light, she noticed that there were several bales of hay propped together. Sitting next to them was a large red stallion. His eyes drifted to the two mares as they approached.

“Starlight, this is my brother. Big Macintosh. Big Macintosh, this here's Starlight Glimmer,” Applejack said.

Starlight nodded. The name struck a bell. Twilight had said that she had modeled her fake stallionhood after Applejack's brother. This is him? she thought. He certainly is an impressive sight.

“It's a pleasure to meet you,” she said.

“Eyup,” Big Macintosh said.

“Don't say much do you?” Starlight said.

“Nope.”

“Right... so...” Starlight said, glancing at Applejack pensively.

“You're in luck today that Big Mac could show up,” Applejack replied. She cleared her throat and spoke clearly. “Starlight. I want you to go lay on the hay for me please.”

Starlight nodded, trotting over to the hay. She laid down on it, waiting apprehensively for what was about to happen. Applejack grinned and walked over.

“Twilight was right, you're good. Big Mac? Why don't you come on over here and say hello,” she said.

Big Mac lumbered over to the two mares. If he was excited about this, he certainly wasn't showing it. Starlight caught a bare glimpse of his stallionhood, swaying long and loose between his legs. Twilight was right about one thing, the fake just didn't compare. She imagined this stallion rutting her hard over and over, the fire in her legs returning. She spread them on instinct, eliciting a whistle from Applejack.

“You are ready, aren't ya?” she said. She lowered a hoof and started rubbing one of Starlight's exposed teats. “You've just been waiting all day for this.”

“Uh huh... Applejack... I... I want to see your pussy,” Starlight said sheepishly. “I need to see it so bad.”

Applejack chuckled. “All you had to do was ask, sugarcube. And you'll get to, first thing's first though. Big Mac?”

Big Mac nodded and smiled as he reared up just enough for Starlight to get a full view of his cock. It was massive! It was getting harder and stiffer by the second as Starlight watched. Big Mac took a few steps forward, bringing the appendage closer to her face.

“Starlight. This part's real simple. Big Mac here's gonna shove his dick in your mouth. I want you to put on a nice show of it, alright?” Applejack said bluntly. “Understand?”

Starlight's eyes widened and she nodded. She opened her mouth in anticipation. Big Mac obliged the mare's invitation and moved closer, bringing his dick within range of her mouth. Starlight stuck her tongue out and licked the head of it, eliciting a twitch from the stallionhood. She opened her mouth wider and strained to get her lips around his massive flare. It felt amazing. The incredibly masculine smell and taste of the stallion's cock in her mouth made her twinge with delight.

Starlight felt a wet caress between her legs that made her want to cry out in pleasure. Her eyes transferred down to where she saw Applejack on her knees. Her head was buried in her mound, her tongue working on the folds of her pussy. Starlight shuddered and returned her attention to Big Mac. She lifted a hoof and took the length of his dick with it, massaging it down to the base of the shaft where his two large testicles hung, Starlight popped the head of his dick out of her mouth and grinned as she brought her tongue along down the side of his shaft.

Big Mac grunted as her hoof ran over his balls. Starlight grinned.

“Come on BM, stop horsing around,” she heard Applejack say. “Give it to her good.”

Big Mac grunted again and lowered his hooves over Starlight's body so he could angle himself better. Starlight opened her mouth again as the stallion plunged into it. Starlight's eyes widened as the stallion pushed, shoving the length of his dick deeper into her mouth. She wanted to gag, but her mouth was so full of dick that she couldn't physically do it. Big Mac groaned as he pulled back a little and thrusted again. Starlight couldn't speak to moan as Applejack returned her attention to her pussy. She felt the country mare's tongue rolling along her clit, sending waves of pleasure through her body.

Starlight gasped as Big Mac pulled all the way out. His cock was throbbing. He was close. Starlight grabbed the sides of it and forced it back into her mouth. She wanted him to cum. She wanted him to take it in and swallow every drop of it. She pulled off and back, letting the stallion thrust as he pleased. Big Mac grunted and groaned above her. His body tensed as he thrust over and over, fucking her throat raw while Applejack tongue-fucked her pussy below. She wanted to cum too, all over Applejack's muzzle. She wanted it badly.

Big Mac tensed up again and Starlight felt the stallion's dick twitch inside her mouth. He cried out as she felt his orgasm arrive. Heavy spurts of hot and salty cum erupted inside her. What parts of her mouth that weren't filled with dick were swimming in the stallion's seed. Big Mac pulled out, another gush of liquid heat covering Starlight's face. He panted loudly.

Starlight reached out with her tongue and began licking the excess cum off the stallion's head. It tasted wonderful. She licked and sucked at the head while Applejack ramped up down below, bringing Starlight's orgasm to a welcome peak. She shuddered as rolling waves of pleasure rippled up and down her body. She finally laid back and sighed.

“Wow...” she said after a few moments.

“Heh. Liked that, huh?” Applejack said. “We're not done though. You still wanted to see my pussy, right?”

Starlight nodded. Even though she'd came, her pussy still burned with desire. “Let me just clean up first.”

Applejack grinned. “Don't. It's much more fun that way. Come on and stand. Got something even more special for you.”

Starlight pushed herself off the hay shakily. She smiled at Big Mac, who was laying on the hay next to where she'd been. His cock was still rock hard. Applejack pointed over at the nearby rafters. Hanging from them all the way down to the ground was what looked like set of two rope harnesses, made for a pony to step into.

“Go on,” Applejack said.

Starlight made her way to the harness and placed her hooves inside. Applejack tightened the bonds, holding her in place. Applejack went over to the other harness.

“BM, little help here,” she said.

Big Mac lumbered off of the hay bales and made his way to the two mares. He fastened Applejack up so that she was facing away from Starlight.

Starlight's eyes widened as Applejack swished her tail to the side, revealing what she'd been spending all day trying to get a glimpse at. Applejack's pussy was engorged and puffy, but it was a magnificent sight. Her eyes drifted to her teats. While Twilight's had been petite, Applejack's were much larger and pronounced. Applejack positioned herself so that Starlight could reach her.

“Like what you see, sugarcube?” she breathed heavily.

“You're beautiful, Applejack,” Starlight replied.

“Well, get to it then,” Applejack said. “Ain't got all day. Still got apple-buckin' to do.”

Starlight rolled her eyes. All business, it seemed. She reached out with her tongue and buried herself in Applejack's pussy, eliciting a yelp from the orange mare. She pushed aside her folds with her tongue and slipped it in and out. Applejack moaned as she worked. Starlight felt the burning between her legs again as she slobbered all over Applejack's pussy.

“Oh...” Applejack moaned.

Starlight continued flicking her tongue up and down AJ's marehood before spreading the pussy to find her clitoris. She tongued the nub up and down a few times, hearing Applejack cry out in pleasure. She pulled the nub into her mouth and started sucking hard on it. Applejack groaned and grunted as she tried to move, but neither mare could move their legs.

Starlight felt two hooves on her rump. She released her hold on Applejack's clitoris for a second and glanced back. Big Mac was behind her, his cock twinging for more. She grinned.

“Mmm... you want more don't you? Go on then, fuck me,” she said.

Big Mac nodded, pulling himself up to mount Starlight from behind. Starlight gasped as his cock plunged into her pussy. She took him easily, already well lubricated from Applejack's ministrations from earlier. The stallion pushed hard, burying himself to the balls into her mound.

Starlight moaned and returned to AJ. She reached out once more and brought the mare's clit into her mouth. She sucked on it as she felt Big Mac pull out and thrust again. Her legs burned as he fucked her over and over while she sucked on Applejack's clit. The orange mare groaned loudly as she tried to buck into Starlight's tongue.

“So close, keep going...” she called out.

Starlight's tongue kept working over AJ's clit, and the other mare's body tensed up as she brought it back into her mouth and sucked. She could barely feel the stallion cock thrusting into her pussy, her legs had gone numb from the pleasure. She could hear Big Mac grunting though, working his way towards another orgasm.

Applejack grunted and tensed up again as her body started to quake and shudder. Starlight held her hold on the mare's clit as her orgasm rippled through her. Applejack sighed and cried out in pleasure as she held firm.

“Oh... oh... OHH....” she shouted. “Yes... yes... yes!”

Applejack's legs buckled, but she held solid as her pussy contracted, spraying Starlight's muzzle and face with her fluids. Starlight happily lapped up the juice from her pussy as AJ huffed loudly.

“You almost done back there, BM? Come on up here and finish it off,” she heard AJ say.

Big Mac grunted, pulling his dick out of Starlight's swollen pussy. He walked over to AJ and Starlight, releasing both from the harness. Starlight huffed as AJ tapped her on the shoulder.

“Big Mac's looking like he needs to release another load. Let's help him out, shall we?” she said with a wink.

“But.. he's your...” Starlight started to say.

“I know. And I wouldn't normally do this, but he never gets this lucky to have two mares on their knees for him. It's fine, right BM?” Applejack replied.

“Eyup.”

Starlight grinned. “Okay then.”

She watched as Big Mac reared up again. She nearly lunged at the stallion's throbbing cock, licking up from the base along his shaft. Applejack was there too, licking up at the same time on the other side. The two mares worked up and down the cock, coaxing the stallion closer and closer to a finish.

Big Mac groaned as he reached that finish. Starlight and Applejack pulled back as heavy spurts of cum burst forth from the stallion's cock, covering both mare's faces in the sticky stuff. Starlight opened her mouth, catching the last spurt and swallowing. Big Mac lowered himself and buckled to the ground, clearly tired from the workout.

“Man, he was really pent up,” Applejack said with a grin. She had cum caked on every part of her face and in her hair. “We're gonna need a shower before we get back to work.”

“Mmm... we could take one together,” Starlight said.

Applejack grinned again, wider this time. “You know, Starlight? I like you. Let's do just that, and after we're done in the shower, you can show me how you buck apples for real this time. Deal?”

Starlight smiled softly. This arrangement was going to take some getting used to, but she was certainly enjoying her “punishment.” Twilight was right though, these ponies were her friends now too. It was nice to know they were willing to accept her like they had Twilight. She reached out and hoof-bumped AJ.

“Deal.”

Author's Note

Like what you've read here? Want to support my work? Check out my Patreon!