Don't Mess with Fluttershy's Mare

After Starlight had got back to the castle Fluttershy headed over to the stunned Sunburst. While she was so mad that she could hardly hold it in, she knew that she would have to be nice and lull Sunburst into a false sense of security. She stood by him and asked, "Are you ok?"

Sunburst replied, "No. Some bitch unicorn that I wanted to have supper with turned me down and then slammed me into the ground. She claimed that she had plans to have supper with her fiance, who just so happens to be a mare!" He gagged a little and continued, "That is just sick! Mares marrying other mares? That just isn't right."

Fluttershy replied, "Well I don't know what to tell you." She saw that he had several scars and continued, "Why don't you come with me. I can get those scars taken care of for you."

He got up and replied, "Thanks. I would really appreciate it."

He followed Fluttershy to her cottage and saw all the animals in there. He asked, "I take it you really like animals."

Fluttershy replied, "Yes, I do." She pointed her hoof towards a door that led to her basement. She continued, "Enough about me liking animals, let's get you fixed up."

When he got down there he was stunned. He saw chains and hooks hanging from the ceiling. He asked, "What in Equestria is all of this down here?" He suddenly became scared and screamed, "You're not going to heal me are you? You're going to kill me!"

Fluttershy slammed her hoof so hard on his head that she gave him a concussion. She laughed, "Oh, I don't know about that but I don't appreciate you hitting on my fiance and I am not happy that you grabbed her butt."

He gasped, "Wait a minute, you're Starlight's fiance? She's going to marry you?"

Fluttershy grunted, "Yes she is. You have a problem with that."

Despite having a concussion he was still quite coherent. He sneered, "Oh and what if I do?"

Fluttershy laughed, "Oh you'll see."

Fluttershy had grabbed a saw and headed towards him. With him having a concussion he was unable to stop her with his magic and was scared of what she might do. She saw a few sparks coming out of his horn. She laughed, "I know you're not much of a threat right now but this has got to go."

He saw her eyeballing his horn and yelled, "No, please don't take my horn! It's what makes me a unicorn."

Fluttershy laughed, "Oh you poor little baby." She began to saw his horn off causing him to scream in agony. After she finished cutting his horn off she continued, "Well you're not the first unicorn I've done this to so you're nothing special."

He asked, "Wait a minute, you've done this before?"

She pointed at the blood stained walls and replied, "What do you think? Those blood stains didn't magically just show up!"

He shouted, "Well you're not going to be able to keep me down here forever. Somepony will notice I've gone missing and once it is known that you are Starlight's fiance, they'll come here and save me."

While he was shouting Fluttershy had grabbed a syringe and drew up some sedatives. She held it up and replied, "You know, I wouldn't be so sure about that."

She rammed the needle into his neck and injected the sedatives. Within a minute he was out like a light and this is when Fluttershy is able to do what makes her punishments so brutal. She turned a crank and lowered them so she could run hooks through his front hooves and then raised them, causing him to be lifted with them. She then rammed the lower hooks through his hind legs. She began to stretch him by raising the upper hooks further. Finally she had him in the position she wanted. She laughed, "Now I just wait for Starlight to finish her studies and come over here. This could be our first truly bonding experience!"

Several hours had passed and finally Starlight was able to show up for supper. Fluttershy heard a knock on her door and headed up stairs. Rather than kissing as soon as Fluttershy let her in, Fluttershy decided that they should talk a bit. She asked, "Honey, how has your day been?"

Starlight replied, "Well after we parted ways not so good. I had this annoying unicorn bugging me most of the way back to the castle. He kept on asking me to go out with him to supper and he grabbed my flank so I did what any rational thinking mare would do, I slammed him into the ground."

Fluttershy asked, "So who is that pony that did that?"

Starlight replied, "He was a friend of mine when I was a filly. Sunburst is his name."

Fluttershy asked, "Starlight honey, can we wait until later to discuss more things regarding this guy. I have something I need to show you."

Starlight replied, "Sure."

Fluttershy put her wings over Starlight's eyes and led her into the basement. She heard a pony groaning. She asked, "Fluttershy, what is that groaning noise?"

Fluttershy pulled her wings away and yelled, "Surprise!"

Starlight opened her eyes and screamed in shock, "What? What is he doing down here?" She then noticed that she had his hooves secured with hooks and asked, "Wait a minute, is what Twilight told me true? Do you torture and kill ponies that make you mad?"

Fluttershy replied, "Well sometimes, but only the ones that really piss me off and he really pissed me off." She kissed Starlight and continued, "Now you won't have to worry about him stalking you anymore!"

Starlight kissed Fluttershy back and replied, "No, I won't."

Fluttershy began to innocently giggle, "Do you want to help me punish him for grabbing your flank? Do you want to help me punish him for calling me dumb?"

While Starlight had done many things that ponies considered bad, she had never even imagined torturing ponies before. While it felt kind of weird to her, she replied, "Yeah, sure."

Fluttershy batted her eyes at Starlight and said, "This could be such a bonding experience for us! It could make us even closer than we already are!"

Starlight nervously laughed, "It could."

Fluttershy said, "But I think we should wait until he comes to a bit more. I want the sedatives to wear off, I want him to see you helping me punish him."

Starlight replied, "Alright, sounds good."

Fluttershy was thrilled that Starlight wanted to join her in torturing Sunburst. To her it was a sign that Starlight truly did love her and would not allow herself to fall into situations that may not be in the best interests of their relationship while Starlight, despite being surprised Fluttershy was actually like this, realized that this could be a liberating moment for her.