Sunset Shimmer felt a chill down her spin at the masked woman's words then pushed the hero off of her.

"Seriously? What the hell are you doing here?" She growled, irritated by the fact whoever this was decided it would be a good idea to use something private to her without even asking. A part of her begrudgingly liking how the moonlight reflected off the purple latex. "You guys aren't supposed to be back till New Year's Eve, who are you under the mask anyways?" She demanded, reaching for the mask. Whoever it was under the mask pushed Sunset's hand away, taking a step back.

"Now, now Sunny. It's very rude to remove a ladies mask." Mare-Do-Well teased, unknowingly irritating Sunset Shimmer more.

"This isn't funny!" Sunset hissed. "You think you can do this after reading my Diary? You guys got so pissed when you thought I invaded your trust and then when you found out I was innocent you haven't said one apology." Sunset sighed, biting her lip in fustration. "Why are you doing this? What's the point?" She asked, looking into the unanwsering blue lenses of the hood.

"Because your right." Mare-Do-Well sat down next to Sunset, sitting exactly like Fluttershy when she is about to say something she was uncomfortable with. "Listen Sugarcube, what we did was way uncool, terribly uncoth, and all together superduper mega mean and I know we're all very sorry." It was odd. Whoever this was, they were making sure Sunset Shimmer couldn't pick up on who exactly she was talking to. Sunset realized the reason why Mare-Do-Well waited a week to confront her, she made sure to practice everyone's mannerisms to keep the ex-bad girl on her toes.

"That's why when everyone was asleep I read your Diary again, I came up with this idea. I figured I could surprise you and well, maybe for a late Christmas gift, I could help you play out your fantasy." Mare-Do-Well then held a hand to her mask. "That's why I can't let you know who I am. But I promise! If you want to stop we will, and then I can just... Never talk to you again about this." She said, her voice becoming sadder. Sunset Shimmer took in all the information and began to go through the pros and cons in her head.

Pro: She apologized for how she treated me during 'Anon-A-Miss'. Con: She read my diary...Again. Pro: She did research on what it is exactly I want concerning this fantasy. Con: She snuck in my room. Con: She isn't telling me who she is exactly. Pro: She's trying to bring my fantasy to life. Pro: She wants to do this right. Pro: One of my friends wants to fool around with me!!!~ Keeping her cool outside will cheering internally, Sunset cleared her throat.

"We need to set up a safe word." She said, holding a finger up. "And I...I want you to keep surprising me. I liked that. I also want to know who it is under the mask." She finished, crossing her arms. Mare-Do-Well scratched her chin.

"Just telling seems kinda...anti-climatic, don't you think?" Mare-Do-Well stated, taking off her hat before pointing it at Sunset. "Why don't we make it another game? If you can guess who I am with...Three tries, then you can do whatever you want." She said, although Sunset Shimmer couldn't see it she could swear Mare-Do-Well was smiling underneath her mask.

"And if I can't?" Sunset questioned, wondering where this was going.

"Simple, I let you know who I am later and I still get to play with you." She joked, laying on the bed. Sunset couldn't see into the blue lens at the eyes staring, but she could feel the hunger and it made her wet.

"What about the safe word? Or in this case, safe action." Sunset asked as she then crossed her arms. "Because if we don't get them both figured out, we aren't doing this." She stated matter of factly, emphasizing this by pushing the roll of tape onto Mare-Do-Well's lap.

"Rosebud. If you need to get out or stop at all, you need to shout out Rosebud. If you're gagged though, either tap your heels three times, or knock on something three times." Mare-Do-Well let go of the tape in order to take hold of Sunset Shimmer's hand. "I promise no matter what, I will get you out." She reassured Sunset then stood up. "Now. I'm gonna make a list that I want you to follow tomorrow."

"Wait what? But I thought. Aren't we going to...You know?" Sunset Shimmer lamely asked, looking at her bed then to her nightstand.

"Maybe I should give you a taste." Mare-Do-Well hummed, tugging on Sunset's top. "Strip." She ordered Sunset, taking a seat on Sunset's desk chair for a view on the show to come. Sunset Shimmer does as she's told, beginning with her new light blue top with golden sheer fring to reveal her sky blue bra with a bow between her breast. Sunset's face was flushed with embarrassment as she unbuttoned her blue jeans, allowing them to fall to her ankles as Mare-Do-Well now got to see Sunset Shimmer's black with white stripes panties.

"I-if I knew we'd be doing this, I would have had matching underwear." She said embarrassed, pulling her feet out of the discarded jeans and boots, her pink socks decorated with images of kittens keeping her from feeling the cold touch of the wood.

"I think it's cute. Even with the little socks Fluttershy got you." Mare-Do-Well teased, Sunset Shimmer walking over to her bed, she leaned down to pull out her suitcase filled with toys. It was a small collection of restraints and a few toys, the ratio was truly more of restraints then toys as she opened it. "Well, it seems Christmas came again for me." Mare-Do-Well said as she sauntered over to examine the collection.

"Who are you?" Sunset asked again as Mare-Do-Well pulled out Sunset Shimmer's old leather wrist cuffs. "I mean I know you want me to guess who it is that's Mare-Do-Well and all, but come on. I need at least a little hint." Mare-Do-Well rolled her head to the side and groaned, pulling out a small roll that consisted of the rest of Sunset's microfoam tape.

"Uh, fine! One hint though. My fetish, can involve me being tied up. Also, I think Maiden-Do-Well would be a better name for me here since we're humans." She said teasingly while ripping a piece of tape off the roll. Sunset was about to say something when Maiden-Do-Well stopped her by pressing a strip over Sunset's mouth. "No more questions, otherwise next time you get to see how tasty those little pink socks are." Sunset's new mistress threatened, pointing to her feet for added empathise then raising her hand up. "Now, hands."

"Ymth mmmsthm." Sunset grunted as she did as she was told, giving Maiden-Do-Well her arms. Her mistress took her right arm and locked one of the leather cuffs on her wrist. With her other wrist still naked, she was pushed onto her back while Maiden-Do-Well fed the chain behind her headboard, the free wrist soon finding itself bound to the other.

"There we go. Now, let's play." She teased as her fingers brushed against Sunset's sides. Sunset's mute giggles began to fill the room as her mistress continued her tickle torture, her eyes tearing up while her lungs began to burn. Sunset beat her feet on her bed while Maiden-Do-Well climbed on top of her, straddling her waist as she discovered Sunset Shimmer's most tickelest spot. Sunset Shimmer screamed as Maiden-Do-Well tickled inside her armpits.

"Nmmmhmmhmmhmm! Stmmmph! Plmmmhmmhmms!" Sunset squealed as she tried not using her safe word, her mistress pausing to wipe the tears from her eyes.

"I'm glad you're so happy about the situation dear." Maiden-Do-Well teased as she began to grope Sunset's chest. "My beautiful little slave. I'm looking forward to all the games we'll play." She then let go of the bound girl's breast and opened the nightstand, pulling out a green, pink, and purple dildo. "With all your toys too." She teased as she then placed the toy down, unlocking Sunset's wrist,

"But that's for another time." She stated. She walked over to Sunset Shimmer's jeans and removed her cellphone, putting it on top of the note she wrote for Sunset Shimmer. Satisfied with her actions she walked over to Sunset's bedroom window. "I'll be watching, so be sure to follow my directions to a 'T' cause I'll know if you don't." She teased, blowing a kiss before jumping out the window.

Sunset Shimmer quickly put her toy away as she brought a hand to her gag, she thought about removing it but decided not to, she wanted to enjoy wearing it for a bit longer. She walked over to her desk to read what was on the paper, blushing at the orders she was supposed to follow the next. Her phone soon vibrated, the screen coming to life, showing she had three unread messages.

Yo Sunset, we had a couple issues with family so we came home early. Text me when we can hang out. The first text read from Rainbow Dash. Howdy, Sunset. I had to bring A.B. home early on account she got food poisoning so if you're available we should hang out. the second message read from Applejack. Darling! Terrible news. It seems my father had a misunderstanding with the hotel owner and to make a long story short, Sweetie Belle and I shall return to town in a few hours. Call me when you can dear, I'd love to hear any gossip I might have missed while gone. the last message from Rarity read. Sunset looked at her phone then to the note her mistress wrote, was this how she'd know if Sunset didn't follow the directions? Was it possible the three of them were working with Maiden-Do-Well? What about Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy, were they both truly away, or was one of them home early as well?

"Mmmm~." She moaned as she picked up her clothes from the ground, playing with her breast as she did so, thinking about all of this. Her bedroom door quickly opened before she could even attempt to put on her clothes, Luna with a large blush on her face as she looked from Sunset Shimmer's underware clad body to the cuff on her wrist and the microfoam tape gag over her mouth. "Mmm cmm mmpthm!" Sunset moaned to Luna, trying to cover her body with her clothes in her hands.

Author's Note

Here is chapter two everyone. Now here is the million dollar question, who is it under the hood?

Also the gag talk in order:

Yes mistress

No! Please! Stop! (Just add ha ha's cause she's laughing.)

I can explain!