Starlight Glimmer's Predicament

Chapter One: P-P-Pregnant?!

Starlight Glimmer positioned herself, a wry grin on her face. She breathed out and glanced lovingly down at the pony beneath her.

“Ready?”

“Mmmhhmm.”

“Alright.”

Starlight thrust forward, eliciting a gasp and a coo from Twilight as her magical cock penetrated the princess's purple puffy pussy. She grunted and buried herself to the hilt, feeling Twilight squirm beneath her.

“You okay down there?”

“Uh huh... keep going. It feels fantastic.”

Starlight nodded, sliding back, feeling her slick member withdraw. Twilight's pussy clenched hard around it, not wanting to let it go. It got its wish as Starlight thrust again, and again, and again.

Twilight groaned loudly as Starlight fucked her. Starlight ate it up. Twilight loved being fucked like this, face down and powerless. For all her wanting to be in control, she gave it all up in the bedroom. She wanted to be dominated, to be on the receiving end of every little piece of their sexual relationship.

Starlight loved it. She secretly desired control, so it worked out that Twilight let her have it. Ever since she and Twilight had embarked on this journey together, she'd been the happiest she'd ever been in her entire life.

Starlight grunted as she felt her cock flare. She was nearing climax, a feeling she'd gotten intimately familiar with since this all began. She had often been the one using this spell, instead of it being used against her. She didn't mind. She loved the feeling of being in control of her lover's every whim. She thrust harder, feeling Twilight shake and squeal until she was ready to let go.

Starlight howled as she came, hot sticky gobs of cum pouring from her cock into Twilight's gaping pussy. Twilight slumped down into the bed, twitching in the aftershocks of her pleasure. She rolled over and gazed dreamily at Starlight.

“I love it when you do that, you know that right?” she said, leaning in for a kiss as Starlight flopped on the bed next to her.

“I know,” Starlight said with a grin. Her horn glowed softly, dispersing the magic that held her extra appendage intact. It disappeared with a blink of light.

“I don't know how I got so lucky, finding you,” Twilight mused. “You really are the best. I love you, Starlight Glimmer.”

Starlight smiled softly. “I love you too, you big goof. When did you get so sappy?”

“I dunno. It just felt right to say,” Twilight replied. Her eyes widened. “Why? Was it the wrong thing to say? Did I just mess up?”

“Twilight, relax. It's fine. I feel the same way,” Starlight said, chuckling. She laid there for several long moments, reveling in her partner's love before Twilight spoke again.

“Starlight?”

“Yeah?”

“Am I... you know... good in bed compared to the others?”

“I'm not sure what you mean. All of our friends are different in their own way,” Starlight replied. “But that's not what you want to hear, is it?”

“I... I guess not. I just... I wanted to know if what we do, what we have is special,” Twilight said. “I'm not... I dunno, I'm not complaining about our open relationship. I'm kind of the one who started it after all.”

Starlight sighed and turned her lover's head towards her, gazing into her magenta eyes. “Twilight Sparkle. You are a silly emotional filly, and I love you heart and soul. Now stop being so sappy. Let's just lie here and enjoy this, alright?”

“You're right, you're right. I'm just being overly emotional. The last couple of days have been like that,” Twilight mused. “I'm sorry.”

Starlight grinned and flashed her love a naughty wink. “Oh, I know you will be soon.”

* * *

The Next Day...

* * *

“And just then, Daring Do leaped into action and saved us both! It was the coolest thing ever!” Rainbow Dash proclaimed.

Starlight chuckled as she rested on the couch next to her. “Sounds like you had a good time. Even though you were in mortal peril. So did you kiss him?”

“Who, Quibble Pants? Oh, um... well um...”

“You did, didn't you? Oh now this I have to hear,” Starlight said with a grin.

Rainbow blushed fiercely. She averted her eyes. “It was... it was nothing alright! I was just grateful to him for helping get us out of there alive, that's all.”

“Was he cute?” Starlight asked. She loved it when Rainbow got flustered like this. Dash was always so confident in everything, that it was great to knock some wind out of her sails on occasion.

“He... okay, yes. Is that what you want to hear? He was cute. And I kissed him. But that's all that happened,” Rainbow said, sounding highly nervous and looking like she had just given up her first-born foal. Her eyes shifted back and forth several times.

“Wait a tick. You never sound that nervous. Oh. Ohh. You naughty filly you. You did way more than just kiss him, didn't you?” Starlight said.

“I... I...”

“Come on Dash, you can tell me. I won't tell the others, I promise,” Starlight said.

“Okay fine... I asked him up to my room when we got back to the con,” Dash said. “I swear if you mention this, I'll find a way to make you pay.”

“Unlikely,” Starlight said with a smirk. “But it'll be fun to see you try. Continue?”

“Well... I was feeling very, well you know... gracious. I may have well... I gave him a blowjob,” Rainbow said, closing her eyes.

“Oh really? I thought you didn't swing that way, Rainbow?” Starlight asked. “Thought mares were more your style.”

“It was... well... it was totally in the moment,” Rainbow said. “It just... I dunno... felt right.”

“Mmmm.... you enjoyed it, I take it.”

“He was a little surprised at first, but he didn't say no,” Rainbow said. “Just thinking about it is getting me all hot and bothered.”

“I can help with that you know. Tell me about it. Tell me how you sucked his cock,” Starlight said. “I want to hear all about it.”

Rainbow gulped. “And you promise not to tell the others? Not even Twilight?”

“I promise.”

“Okay... well... we were in the room and I was showing him my collection of Daring Do books when I noticed well... he was bulging. I must have been in heat, I guess, because the next thing I knew I was kissing him and throwing him onto the bed,” Rainbow said.

Starlight grinned as her eyes glanced down at Rainbow's backside. Glistening wet leaked from between her legs. “I see. Do me a favor, and continue. I want you to turn and spread your legs for me.”

“Like... like this?” Rainbow said, moving to spread her legs.

Starlight grinned widely as she took in the sight of Rainbow's finely toned ass and pussy. The other mare's flower winked, squirting a little. Starlight breathed in the smell of her lover's sex. She was enjoying this.

“So... anyways... I gave him a longer kiss and decided I wanted more, so I went for it. I made my way down to his cock and started licking and tasting it.”

Starlight stood, her horn glowing, summoning the magical phallus she had grown accustomed to. “Did you make him cum?”

Rainbow nodded nervously. “It didn't take long. I just kept slobbering and sucking up and down until he was ready.”

“Where did he cum?”

“On my face. It was... it was hot. Totally hot.”

“And what did you do after that? That can't have been all you did,” Starlight said, preparing to lunge forth into Rainbow's waiting pussy.

Rainbow's crimson blush deepened. “No... I let him up and I told him I wanted him. I wanted him to fuck me. Like a naughty filly. So he did. I hunched my ass into the air and he gave it to me. Every inch.”

Starlight grinned and plunged the head of her magical cock into Rainbow's folds. The chromatic mare gasped softly as she moved, inserting herself all of the way in.

“Like this? Did he fuck you like I'm fucking you right now?”

“Y-Y-Yes.... yes... he fucked me just like this,” Dash said panting.

“Pretend I'm him. Pretend this is him fucking you. What did you say? What did you want him to do?” Starlight asked. She pulled her magical cock out and waited.

Rainbow squealed and moved herself into position better.

“Fffffuck. Fuck me. Please. I need it. Fuck me, Quibble. Make me your mare,” Rainbow said.

Starlight obliged, thrusting forward with all of her might. Rainbow shouted and shrieked as she went deep and hard. “Is this what you experienced, Rainbow?”

“Oh... oh yes. Please... fuck me hard, Quibble. I need your dick inside me. Please, I'm yours. Keep going,” Rainbow exhaled.

Starlight nodded, pulling out and thrusting back in hard and fast. Rainbow squirmed underneath, taking every thrust in stride like she'd done it for years.

“And what happened next? Did he cum again?”

“Y-Y-Yes....”

“Where did he cum? Where do you want him to cum?”

“He... came... came inside of me...” Rainbow said, grunting.

“Oh, you really are a naughty filly,” Starlight said. “Is that what you want?”

“Yes... yes please... cum inside me. Fill me up with your seed. I want you to overflow my pussy!” Rainbow shouted.

Starlight grinned, thrusting harder and harder, feeling her body tense up with every push. Eventually her tenseness could hold no longer and she shuddered as she felt her cock flare up and begin to spurt hot sticky gobs inside Rainbow's pussy. Rainbow in turn squealed loudly as she reached her own climax, bucking hard back into Starlight's magical cock.

“Fuck fuck fuck!” Rainbow shouted. “Yes... fucking cum inside your mare!”

Starlight kept cumming, feeling herself depositing every drop she had into Rainbow's marehood. She pulled out sloppily, cum oozing from the other mare's love hole. She slumped back onto the couch as Rainbow slumped next to her.

“That was.... that was hot, Rainbow. What happened after that?” Starlight asked, panting loudly.

“Give me a second... ohh... wow...” Rainbow said as she regained her composure. She sat up next to Starlight. “Well... after that we stayed around the hotel room and then went back down to the con for the ending ceremonies. We exchanged addresses and he left.”

* * *

The Next Day...

* * *

“Oh... Starlight... come join us...” Rarity said in a sing-song voice. She grinned over at Fluttershy, who sat next to her in the sauna.

Starlight's eyes widened. “You can't be serious. This is a public place. What if somepony walks in on us?”

Rarity scoffed. “Please, darling. That just makes it more exciting. Besides... if they walk in, they'll be getting a lovely show won't they? How often do you get to take two lovely mares at the same time?”

“Alright... I suppose...”

“Good... now come on darling, bring out your 'friend'. We do have a schedule to keep up with and I need a facial to go with it,” Rarity said with a wink.

* * *

The Next Day...

* * *

“Whee! I just love when we get to have fun together, Glimmy!” Pinkie chirped.

“Me too, Pinkie. Me too,” Starlight said with a grin. “Come on over here though. I've got a friend who want to say hello.”

Pinkie's eyes widened and she nodded excitedly. “I'll make sure to greet him appropriately!”

* * *

The Next Day...

* * *

“Ah... ah...” Applejack huffed and puffed. She slid up and down on Starlight's magical dick, riding her like... well a cowpony. “Keep it going, sugarcube! I'm close!”

Starlight grunted loudly as she came, bucking hard into the apple-bucker's pussy. Cum leaked out from around the lips of AJ's folds, and the orange mare leaned back into Starlight and sighed.

“Wow...”

* * *

The Next Day...

* * *

Starlight sighed as she walked towards the castle. The past week had been crazy. Every day she'd been busy with the others, and every day had devolved from simple and innocent to depraved amounts of sex and debauchery.

She'd fucked Rarity and Fluttershy into abysmal bliss in the middle of the Ponyville Spa's sauna room. It was a small measure of surprise nopony had heard Rarity scream, as loud as she was.

Baking cakes with Pinkie Pie had turned into a suck and fuck fest with chocolate syrup.

Applejack jumped her bones when they got back into the barn after working.

Starlight groaned. She was drained and she felt ridiculously sore. She needed rest and relaxation, the kind that she could usually only find with Twilight. That was the one strange thing about Twilight. For all of their sexual escapades, she spent just as much time in the other mare's company simply enjoying life. She needed some of that.

She slipped into the castle doors, glancing around as she tried to find her love. She wasn't in the dining room. The only possible other place she could be was in the throne room. As he neared it, she heard hushed voices that stopped as she walked in. Her six friends were each sitting around the Cutie Map. They all had worried looks on their faces that started to clear up as they saw her.

“Oh, Starlight, I didn't know you were coming over,” Twilight said.

“Sorry, I should have sent a message. What's going on? Is everything alright? Is there another threat to Equestria? Something I can help with?” Starlight asked.

“Well... it's a little more complicated than that, but yes... you might be able to help out,” Twilight said.

“Anything, you name it. What's the problem?” Starlight said with a smile.

Twilight stood and looked at the others, her face unsure. She sighed deeply and trotted up to Starlight.

“Well... you see, Starlight...” Twilight began. “I'm... I'm pregnant.”

Starlight's eyes widened to pinpricks. How...? How could...? Before she could formulate a thought, Twilight continued.

“And that's... that's not all either,” Twilight said, glancing and motioning at the others.

Starlight's gaze widened further as each of her other friends got up and stood next to Twilight, and as one spoke two words that scared her more than any trip to a post-apocalyptic future where no pony life lived ever could.

“I'm pregnant.”

Author's Note

If you like what you've read here, consider supporting me on Patreon.