Starlight Glimmer's Predicament

Chapter Two: Denial

* * *

One Day Later

* * *

“Hold on. You mean to tell me that Twilight Sparkle... the Princess of Friendship... is... is preggers?”

Starlight grimaced at Trixie. She nodded calmly. Even she still couldn't believe it.

“I just can't believe it,” Trixie said, chuckling loudly. “I didn't even know she was seeing anypony. Who in their right mind would do her?”

Starlight's face reddened. Trixie's eyebrow raised as she caught her friend's blushing face.

“Starlight?”

“Yeah... yeah about that... the thing is... the foal is... well... it's mine.”

Silence. Trixie's jaw dropped. “I... I... I didn't mean...”

“It's okay. It's fine. I know you don't like Twilight, and that's fine,” Starlight said. “I just... I needed to talk to somepony.”

Trixie shuffled over to her friend, laying a hoof on her shoulder. She didn't know what to think. She hadn't even been aware of the fact that Starlight and Twilight had been romantically involved. Another thought crossed her mind.

“Wait... how...? You're a...”

“A mare, I know. There's this spell... well.. it kind of backfired,” Starlight said looking down at her hooves.

“Oh.”

“There's... there's something else too. Twilight's other friends, you know them right?”

“Yeah. Well, I don't know them well enough to be on first name basis, but I know of them,” Trixie said.

Starlight gulped loudly. “They're... they're pregnant too.”

Even more dead silence. Trixie's eyes widened. “You mean...”

“Yeah. Same spell. Same mare,” Starlight said.

“And they all told you about it?” Trixie asked.

“At the same time no less.”

“What did you do?”

“I... I ran. I couldn't believe what I was hearing. Twilight told me it was only natural to be feeling some sort of fear. She isn't sure why the spell did what it did either. She sent a message up to the Crystal Empire to ask Sunburst to come down,” Starlight said. “She didn't say why, just that she needed help deciphering a spell.”

“I... Wow... so you managed to get six mares pregnant, all in the span of a week? Wait... how does that even work? How would they already know?” Trixie said, feeling very confused. “Usually it takes a couple weeks after conception.”

“I don't know, Trix. Probably something to do with the spell itself. I can't even remember all the alterations Twilight and I made to the spell,” Starlight said, groaning. She rested her head against Trixie. “Sorry for laying this all on you. You're a good friend, you know that right?”

“I'm the greatest and most powerful friend you'll ever have, and don't you forget it,” Trixie replied with a snicker. “In all seriousness though... if you need me for anything, don't be afraid to stop by. Now that I have you as a friend, I'm not going anywhere.”

Starlight nodded. “Thanks... I just don't know what I'm going to do.”

“Well, you know... you could always just embrace it and add me to your harem,” Trixie said with a wink. “I know I wouldn't mind taking you for a ride.”

“TRIXIE!” Starlight shouted, her face reddening. “That is NOT funny!”

Trixie chuckled. “I'm just teasing you, Starlight. You know I'm not interested in mares. Although, I guess you're not really a mare with that much virility between your legs, are you?”

Starlight groaned. “Good one, Trix. Very funny. I'll be sure to remember that when I'm surrounded by foals,” she said. “Speaking of, I guess I'd better get going. Sunburst should be arriving later today and I need to be with Twilight when he does.”

Trixie reached out and placed a hoof on her friend's shoulder. “It'll be alright. You'll get through this.”

Starlight sighed. “Thanks. I'll see you later, okay?”

“Good luck!”

* * *

Later that day...

* * *

Starlight waited in anxious anticipation for the train to pull up. She stood next to Twilight, remaining as silent as she could. Twilight hadn't said much to her since she'd returned, and she'd hoped that she wasn't mad at her for running off like she had. She hadn't wanted to, but she wasn't sure what to say about the news. She was scared.

The train pulled into the station several minutes later and stopped. The doors opened and a unicorn stepped out onto the platform. He stroked his beard and adjusted his glasses as he glanced about. His eyes settled on Starlight and Twilight.

“Starlight, Princess,” Sunburst said with a smile.

“Sunburst,” Twilight said. “It's good of you to come on such a short notice. I hope the trip was pleasant?”

“Of course, Princess. It was fine. I’m happy to come, things around the castle have been pretty slow lately, so Cadance and Shining Armor were able to let me go,” Sunburst said. “Shall we go back to your castle and discuss the matter of this spell you're having troubles with?”

“Of course,” Twilight said, smiling.

The three made their way from the train station and began walking back towards the castle. Starlight remained quiet for most of the trip, only speaking to Sunburst when he asked her a question about how her studies were going. She hoped he wouldn't judge her harshly for what had happened. It had taken the Crystal Empire nearly being destroyed to bring them back together as friends, and she didn't want that friendship to die.

They arrived at the castle shortly, where Twilight invited Sunburst in to discuss the matter over dinner. Starlight sat, anxiously fidgeting as Spike entered and served the dinner before leaving them to talk. Starlight nervously ate her soup, watching the conversation unfold.

“So... this spell that you've asked me to come look at, what are the particulars that you need my help on? I mean, you're the Princess of Friendship and the Element of Magic,” Sunburst said. “Forgive me for being so forward, but what can I do that you can't?”

“It's... it's complicated. The spell involves me. You see... Well... I'll just come out and say it,” Twilight said with a sigh. “I'm pregnant. Magically.”

Sunburst's eyes widened. “Oh. Wow, right. Okay. How... how did this happen?”

Starlight's blush deepened as she tried to sink through her seat. Twilight glanced over at her and smiled.

“Well... you see... It's hard to say this, but Starlight and I have been... well... having sex. With the aid of... magic,” she said.

“Oh. I... I see,” Sunburst said. “So I surmise you used some sort of fertility spell?”

Starlight grimaced. “Not exactly,” she said meekly. She stood up and with a red face her horn glowed, activating the spell that had caused her so much trouble. She felt the magical cock sprout forth between her legs. She could see Sunburst's face, his eyes widening.

“You can see our dilemma,” Twilight said. “The spell isn't supposed to provide fertility. It never was supposed to do that.”

“I see,” Sunburst said. “You can... can dismiss that now. It's going to take some time to research this properly. I would need any notes you have about the spell's construction.”

Starlight's horn glowed, dismissing the spell. She sat back down in her chair, the heat on her face deepening.

“Starlight should have everything you need,” Twilight said. “I just... Let me be clear about something. I want to know why this happened. It's probable that there's nothing we can do about this, but I want to research every avenue. It's possible this isn't even real. If it is... well then I guess we'll accept that fact.”

“Understood,” Sunburst said.

“Good. I shall leave you two to your work then. Starlight, I'm going out to see the girls. Make sure they're doing alright. You should go and see them too after you're done with Sunburst, I think,” Twilight said. She stood and exited the room.

Sunburst glanced over at Starlight. “Are you alright? You spent the entirety of that conversation looking like you might vomit,” he asked.

Starlight nodded. “I just... I didn't want you to... you know... see me like that.”

“Ah. I... I guess it was a little strange, but I guess not unexpected. You and Twilight. It's... it's a good match,” Sunburst said. “Regardless of what's going on between you two, I think we can figure the magic side of this out.”

“There's... there's something else that Twilight didn't say,” Starlight said, looking down at her hooves.

“The others are pregnant too, aren't they?” Sunburst asked.

Starlight's eyes widened. “How did...?”

“I gathered as much from her last statement to you,” Sunburst said. “I'm guessing you've been hmmm… Involved with them as well.”

Starlight looked away for a moment. “I'm sorry. I should have told you. I know that... I know you...” She glanced down, tears forming in her eyes. “Sunburst, I don't know what to do. What if this is all real? What if this spell really did what it did?”

“Then I guess you'll probably have to accept the fact that you're going to be a parent,” Sunburst said solemnly. “We won't know until I've gotten the chance to study the spell's composition. For the record though... I'm not upset with you. I'm in the Crystal Empire, you're here. It would have never worked out distance-wise. Twilight... Twilight is good for you. I can tell. She really loves you.”

Starlight nodded. She knew it was true. She loved Twilight, she really did. She loved the others too in their own ways. Deep down a part of her hoped that this wasn't real, that they weren't pregnant... but then a part of her wished it was. She could raise a family with Twilight. She looked up at Sunburst.

“So... I guess then you'll need my notes on the spell,” she said.

“That, and I'll... uh... need you to activate it again for me so that I can study the composition of the uh...” Sunburst said, his cheeks flushing.

Starlight raised an eyebrow. “Are you asking to see my dick again?”

Sunburst groaned. “Yes, alright. I need to study how it's constructed so that I can make an accurate assessment of the magic involved.”

“Alright, but not here. Spike could wander in, and he doesn't need to see that, nor does anypony else for that matter that might wander. Come with me, we can kill two birds with one stone. My notes are in our room,” Starlight said. She stood, moving towards the hallway.

Sunburst stood and followed behind as they made their way up the stairs towards Starlight and Twilight's shared bedroom. Starlight motioned for Sunburst to take a seat as she went over to the cabinet and pulled out the notes on the spell. A short stack of papers appeared next to Sunburst, who sat on the bed.

“You um... you've researched this subject pretty thoroughly I see,” he said.

Starlight chuckled. “I guess you're right. Perhaps a little too well.”

“Well... the notes I can peruse later at my leisure. Are you... ready to begin to second part of my assessment?” Sunburst asked.

Starlight nodded, taking a seat on the across from him. She lay back on the pillow and her horn glowed. The familiar feeling of her magical appendage springing to life between her legs came to her as easily as it had any other time.

“It's... it's certainly impressive,” Sunburst said with a twitch. “Very... realistic.”

Starlight snickered. “I honestly bet this isn't what you thought you'd be doing when you got here.”

“Well, no, but that's not to say that I'm not intrigued,” Sunburst replied. “I'd be lying if I said I wasn't.”

“Wait. What?” Starlight asked.

Sunburst's cheeks reddened. “I... Well... I've always kind of... wondered... what it feels like.”

Starlight's mind exploded. “You... what, wait... what? Are you...?”

“Oh... oh no. I'm not... well... I don't know. I just... thought maybe...” Sunburst said, grinning sheepishly. “Never mind. I shouldn't have said anything.”

“Sunburst. Out with it. Seriously. It's you and me, you can tell me, whatever it is,” Starlight said.

Sunburst grimaced and nodded. “I just wondered what it would feel like to you know... touch it?”

“Don't you have one of your own?” Starlight asked with a wink.

“It's... not the same and you know it,” Sunburst said, his cheeks flushing. “I shouldn't have brought this up. You have a problem, and I'm here to help fix that problem.”

Starlight rolled her eyes. She glanced down past Sunburst's face between his legs. Something there told a different story than what he was saying. He was getting excited about this. She made her decision.

“Alright. I tell you what,” she said. “Go ahead. You can touch it. Whatever you want to do... or want me to do, you got it. And don't tell me you're not into it. I can see otherwise.”

“But... what about... Twilight?” Sunburst asked.

“Twilight won't be back for a while, and I think you're relatively clear in understanding how she feels about me and other ponies,” Starlight replied casually. “Besides... you know you want to.”

Sunburst glanced away and bit his lip. “Alright. I do need to study the composition of the spell still,” he said hesitantly. He reached out a hoof and placed it along the length of Starlight's member, rubbing along it slowly. “It uh... definitely feels real.”

Starlight moaned softly at his touch. She felt a twitch as her cock started to stiffen.

“It reacts as one would expect,” Sunburst said with a grin. His hooves reached out, grasping the phallus, eliciting another moan from Starlight. The cock stood at attention, hard as a rock. “Normal erectile response to tactile stimuli.”

Starlight closed her eyes, leaning back into the pillow. Sunburst's hooves continued to work up and down her magical appendage, causing her to moan even more. She felt the beginnings of precum leaking from the tip of the cock.

“Mmmm... yes. Emissions normal, and plentiful,” Sunburst said. “Starlight...? Can I...?”

“Goddess, whatever you want, just do it. I'm so fucking horny it's not funny.” Starlight said back breathily.

Sunburst nodded. He reached forward with his mouth, extending his tongue. He rolled it up just below the tip, spreading it over the head of the phallus, taking in some of the precum into his mouth. It tasted surprisingly not bad, kind of salty. He felt Starlight twitch and spasm as he pulled his tongue away. With a grin, he lowered his lips onto the magical cock and took it into his mouth.

“Oh... oh Goddess... wow...” Starlight breathed.

Sunburst lowered himself as far as he thought he could go, taking as much of the dick into his mouth as equinely possible. He thought nothing of it, which was strange. He had always considered maybe asking Shining Armor about this very thing, given the openness of his relationship with Cadance, but he had always feared he would either be fired or rejected. Truth be told, Sunburst thought quite positively of both stallions and mares, he had just been too scared to ask someone to try it. With Starlight he felt comfortable.

He pulled away, the dick slipping out of his mouth in a slippery mess of spit and precum. Starlight grunted and he took the hint, proceeding to go back down again on the massive member. This time he took even more of her into his throat, working his way down until it was buried to the hilt in his mouth. Accomplishing that, he began working his way up and down, feeling Starlight twitch and hearing her moan and groan under his inexpert but passionate blowjob. She was tense, and he could feel that she was close.

He kept going, preparing himself for her inevitable climax. She was squirming and shouting at this point, unable to keep her volume down at all. Still, he kept sucking and slurping the magical stallionhood.

“Oh... oh fuck fuck... I'm cumming... oh Sunburst I'm cumming!” Starlight shouted as she bucked her hips into Sunburst’s face. The head of her massive cock twitched hard, spewing forth gobs of hot sticky cum into Sunburst's throat.

Sunburst pulled off as she came, several stray spurts of semen landing on his face instead of in his mouth. Cum trickled from his lips and he gave Starlight a grin.

“Normal responses all around on the stimuli front,” he said breathily.

“Uh huh....” Starlight said, breathing hard. Her tongue lolled out of the side of her mouth. “That was... wow... I can't even describe.”

“You're... you're welcome,” Sunburst said as he wiped his face clean. “Thank you for... well... you know...”

Starlight recovered herself and looked at him with a grin. “Oh we're not done. Don't you want to be thorough in your study?”

Sunburst's eyes widened. “What do you mean?”

“What I mean to say is that I would like to bend you over and fuck you silly until you can't walk,” Starlight said, narrowing her eyes at Sunburst. “Does that sound like fun to you?”

Sunburst gulped loudly, but he nodded just the same. He shifted onto the bed further as the two started to position themselves. He waited apprehensively, moving so his exposed rump was facing Starlight. He had been hard himself for a good portion of giving the blowjob, and he could feel his own dick stiffening as he kneeled forward.

“I never quite realized, Sunburst,” Starlight said casually. “But you have quite a cute little butthole.”

Sunburst said nothing. Somewhere in the back of his mind, he was scared it was going to hurt, but at the forefront he was excited. He wanted it, every minute of it. He needed it.

Starlight grinned as she watched her oldest friend wait in anticipation. Her magical dick was already getting hard again, soaked in saliva and her own cum. She moved and positioned herself so that the tip of her cock pressed up against Sunburst's entrance. He moaned a little as she pressed forward a little more, sliding her dick into his asshole with little interference.

Sunburst felt his eyes pop open, grunting heavily as the massive dick filled him up. It was an experience that he had never felt before, feeling so full and stuffed. He realized that he loved it. He made a mental note to ask Shining Armor about doing this again when he got back to the Crystal Empire.

Starlight huffed and puffed, feeling the walls of Sunburst's asshole clenching on her dick like a vice grip. He was incredibly tight, but the extra lubrication he had given her helped immensely. She slid all the way to the hilt, feeling him shudder with delight. With a quick movement, she pulled back and thrust back in hard. Sunburst replied with shouts of pleasure and groans. She responded in kind, pulling out and and thrusting again, harder this time.

She kept up this motion, slamming her magical appendage into his asshole over and over, feeling his body respond with every thrust. She could feel herself welling back up towards a climax again. Sunburst's asshole clenched her cock so hard she was soon unable to contain herself.

“I'm going to cum... Sunburst....” Starlight breathed.

Sunburst grunted. His own cock was throbbing intensely and he was surprised howclose he was to his own climax. He had never really considered that being anally pleasured would provoke him to cum, but here he was getting ready to while being fucked by his best friend.

“Me... me too...” he replied.

Starlight grinned and thrust hard one final time into Sunburst, triggering both of their climaxes at the same time. She yelped in delight as she felt her cock begin to flare and spurt, depositing sticky hot cum into Sunburst's asshole.

Sunburst groaned loudly as the feeling of cum inside him forced his own along. He gasped and breathed as his cock started spouting forth it's own cum all over the sheets and bed.

The two slumped onto the bed as Starlight gently pulled herself out of Sunburst's asshole. They laid there for several long seconds, each of them now covered in their mixed cum, sighing as they rode down the highs of their orgasms.

Sunburst shuffled to face Starlight. “That... was... wow... I... Amazing.”

Starlight giggled. She lowered a hoof to Sunburst's cock, collecting a small amount of cum from its tip. He was already starting to soften. She licked it off of her hoof and smiled. It was warm and salty, and tasted amazing. She glanced up at Sunburst.

“Mmm... yes. That was pretty good,” she said. “Looks like we both really enjoyed that.”

“We made a bit of a mess didn't we?” Sunburst asked.

Starlight nodded. “That's alright though. We can deal with it after we take a shower.”

“Oh?” Sunburst asked.

“Well yeah, we're both covered in cum... and well... I kind of want you to fuck me in the shower, okay?” Starlight replied with a grin.

Sunburst blinked. “Oh. Alright... But after that I really have to get to researching this spell of yours.”

“Don't worry, Sunburst. I'm sure you'll figure something out,” Starlight said. “And... thanks. This made me feel a little better about this whole thing. I needed it, and the talk. Hopefully you don't take what just happened too seriously, right?”

Sunburst grinned and nodded. “Any time. You're my best friend, Starlight. None of this changes that. You'll always be my best friend, and I'll do what I can to help you. Now... about that shower?”

* * *

Twilight sat in the spa next to the other girls, her magical senses tingling. She knew what it meant, that Sunburst and Starlight had gotten a little more than friendly. She smiled, knowing that it was good for her love, it would take her mind off of the more pressing matters for a little while at least.

“I still can't believe this is actually happening,” Rarity said. “I mean... are any of us really ready for motherhood?”

“I know... I've got the Wonderbolts, and flight camp, and everything else going on,” Rainbow replied. “Twi? You said Sunburst was in town to see why this is all happening, right?”

“Correct. Sunburst should be able to figure something out. If this is just a strange side effect of the magic, making us feel like we're pregnant, he should be able to determine what caused it,” Twilight said with a smile.

“But? I'm sensing there's a but in there,” Applejack said.

“Oh there's a big butt alright, and it's mine!” Pinkie Pie exclaimed, proclaimed, paddling the pulchritudinous pink posterior in question.

Twilight sighed. “But we should all be prepared for the fact that this is real. That we really are pregnant, and that well... that we're going to all be moms. If that is the case, we all have to be strong, for Starlight. It's going to be hardest on her out of all of us.”

Author's Note

If you like what you've read here, consider supporting my work on Patreon! I'm currently starting work on an original piece of fiction and the support there would be fantastic!