Starlight Glimmer's Predicament

Starlight Glimmer's Predicament

Chapter Four: When Love Comes to Town

Starlight groaned as she awoke. Her head pounded as she tried to recall the events of the night before. She clearly remembered the sex, that part was still fresh in her mind. Her memories came flooding back as she recalled Trixie running off. Why had she done that? She claimed she had something to do, but didn’t say anything about that until she’d mentioned the spell.

The spell! Starlight thought as she shot up into a sitting position. Did Trixie know something about it? How or why would she have known anything about such a spell? It didn’t make sense.

As Starlight glanced about, she realized that she wasn’t in her castle bed. The smell of dust settled around her as she took in the inside of Trixie’s cabin. It was quaint and well kept, with a neat little desk in the corner. Many of Trixie’s magic supplies were well organized into drawers stating what each one was for with a little picture. Starlight groaned and shuffled out of the bed, pulling herself up in front of the mirror on the desk.

She looked hideous. Her mane was matted and sweaty, and she could still vaguely see streaks of dried cum on her snout and face. A quick glance revealed out the window that it was mid-morning. Without any way to cover herself, there was no way to make it to the castle without somepony noticing what she’d been doing the night before.

A knock came at the door to the cart, pulling Starlight out of her thoughts.

“Who’s there?” she ventured, tensing up at the possibility of someone coming to look for Trixie.

“It’s me,” came the voice of her friend. “Can I come in?”

Starlight breathed a sigh of relief and pushed open the door. Trixie entered with a faint smile, placing her cape and hat on the desk.

“How did you sleep?” she asked.

“Well enough. I’ve got a bit of a headache,” Starlight replied. “What happened to you last night, Trixie?”

“I… I had a thought about what you said, about some sort of outside factor causing the malfunction of the spell,” Trixie said softly. “I was… well, I was wrong. It wasn’t him.”

“Him?” Starlight said, trying to puzzle through what Trixie could mean before it hit her. “Oh… you thought it was Discord that did this?”

“I had to be reasonably sure,” Trixie said. “You’re my best friend, Starlight. I wanted to make sure it was true before I made the suggestion. I’m just sorry I had to run off on you. Can you forgive me for that?”

Starlight smiled and nodded. “I know you are,” she said. “Just… in the future talk to me first, alright? Before you run off and do something crazy like that.”

“Noted,” Trixie said.

“So, it wasn’t Discord, then?” Starlight asked. “He told you as much?”

“He, uh… he’s pretty upset about Fluttershy being a part of this, but he told me to tell you that he would never do such a thing that would impact her too, even for a practical joke,” Trixie said with a sigh. “If I were you, I’d maybe try to steer clear of him until he cools down.”

“Great. So now the God of Chaos and Disharmony is mad at me too,” Starlight said. “As if anything else needed to go wrong.”

“Hey, listen. Things will turn out alright, trust me,” Trixie said, placing a hoof on Starlight’s shoulder. “One thing at a time, alright? Let’s get you back home first and get you cleaned up. You feeling alright enough to teleport?”

Starlight sighed, but nodded. Her horn glowed brightly for a brief second and then the two mares reappeared in Starlight’s room in the castle. As Starlight moved to head to her shower, a knock came at the door.

“Starlight, is that you?” she heard Twilight’s voice say.

“Uh, yes? If you’ll excuse me, I need to take a shower. I’ll be right out,” Starlight called out.

“Is everything alright? I kinda… kinda wanted to talk to you.”

“Yeah. It’s fine. Just hold on for a bit and we’ll talk, alright?”

“Okay… Starlight… I love you, you know that right?” Twilight replied, sniffling a little.

Starlight face-hooved. Of course Twilight’s emotions were going to be running high, the pregnancy and all. She wasn’t overly expecting such a public outpouring though. She sighed deeply and composed herself. Trixie on the other hand, looked as if she were ready to burst into full on jovial laughter.

“I… I love you too, Twilight. I’ll talk to you in a second, okay?”

“Okay. I’ll… I’ll be in the throne room, okay?”

“Okay,” Starlight said before turning to Trixie. “Don’t laugh.”

Trixie sniggered softly. “Sorry, it’s just crazy to hear Twilight that way. She really loves you. You can hear it in her voice.”

“I… I know she does,” Starlight said as she stepped into the shower and turned it on. It just makes what I did last night that much worse, she thought.

Starlight leaned into the water, soaking up as much as she could as she tried to forget what had happened the night before. Why had she let Trixie take her out? True, she had needed to let off some steam, but why did she need the sex to do so? Nothing made any sense anymore.

Freshly cleaned, Starlight stepped out of the shower and dried herself off with a towel. A quick spell righted her mane and tail into a more voluminous nature as she studied herself in the mirror. She glanced over at Trixie.

“Last night never happened, you know that, right?” she said.

“I won’t say a word, you know I would never do such a thing,” Trixie said. She lifted a hoof up to her mouth and made a zipping motion. “My lips are sealed.”

Starlight nodded. “Well. I guess I’d better go talk to Twilight. Maybe after we could get something to eat?”

“That sounds fine. I’ll wait for you at my cart, alright?” Trixie said.

Starlight nodded once more and headed towards her door. She pushed it open and walked down the long hall to the stairs. As she walked, she dreaded what Twilight wanted to talk to her about. Was she upset that the pregnancy was real? Was she going to banish her for making her look like a complete laughingstock in front of the entire kingdom?

Starlight shook her head as she came upon the throne room. Quietly she entered, seeing Twilight sitting by herself on her throne. In front of her the Cutie Map shone brightly, showing every inch of Equestria. How strange it was for Starlight to think back that it was the map that had brought her into contact with Twilight and the others in the first place. Back when she was… worse.

“Twilight?” Starlight said as she trotted up to the throne. “You wanted to see me?”

Twilight glanced up, her eyes appearing fairly red and her cheeks tear-soaked. “Oh, uh… yes, I didn’t see you get in last night, so I was a little… a little worried.”

“Twilight, I’m sorry. I went out with Trixie, and we had a few drinks. Her cart was closer than getting back to the castle, that’s all,” Starlight replied. “You haven’t been… crying this whole time have you?”

“Maybe. I think it has something to do with the hormones,” Twilight said with a sniffle. “I wondered where you went and then the next thing I knew I was bawling my eyes out.”

“Well, I’m here now. I’m sorry I’ve been… overreacting to all of this. This is really hard for me to understand. I feel like I’m ruining your lives,” Starlight said.

“Why would you even think that? You know what someday we were all going to possibly seek out having a foal… having companionship… love,” Twilight said, glancing down at her hooves. “Nopony is going to fault you for this Starlight. Least of all, the others.”

“But the others is what I’m worried about, Twilight!” Starlight exclaimed. “Rainbow’s going to have to stop being a Wonderbolt, Rarity’s life is going to change dramatically… even Fluttershy is going to have a heck of a time with her new animal sanctuary and a foal!”

“That’s… that’s kind of why I wanted to speak to you,” Twilight said with a sigh. “The girls and I… we’ve talked it over, and they all feel that it would make the most sense that since this is real that the others find their own companionship… you know… you raise their foals with.”

Starlight raised an eyebrow. “What do you mean?”

“I mean… the others decided that they don’t want you to feel obligated to raise each individual foal, Starlight,” Twilight said. “After you ran out yesterday, it’s clear that this is hard for you. We came up with this way so that you don’t have to feel as bad about it.”

“So I won’t be involved in their lives?”

“You will, to an extent. They’re going to be family after all,” Twilight replied with a soft smile. “But you won’t have to be their parent.”

Starlight grimaced as she worked it out in her mind. It appeared to be a clean solution, but it meant that she wouldn’t be seen as responsible for potentially ruining her friends lives. She looked up at Twilight.

“Who… who are they going to be with? And do they… do they know?” she asked.

“They know everything. They all agreed up front to this. Applejack selected an old friend, the Wonderbolt Soarin’. I must admit, they go well together,” Twilight said wistfully. “Pinkie Pie selected one of your old village friends, Party Favor. He’s actually moving here to live with her. Rarity on the other hoof… she ended up selecting Fashion Plate, a fashion newpaper editor. He’ll be able to help her keep up the stores while she’s out on leave. Rainbow actually surprised us quite a bit. We had assumed she’d select another athlete, but it was an earth pony named Quibble Pants.”

“And Fluttershy?”

“She… she didn’t exactly feel comfortable with the whole arrangement,” Twilight said. “She opted to care for the foal. Discord is apparently going to assist her.”

“Wow… you really thought this whole thing out in just a day didn’t you?” Starlight asked. “Wait… that’s everypony… but you.”

Twilight glanced away, her cheeks reddening. “I… I was sort of hoping that… that you would raise our foal, Starlight.”

Starlight’s eyes widened. “You want me to do it? Why? Won’t that stir up some questions?”

“Sensationalist news we can always quell,” Twilight said, tears forming in her eyes. “The point is… I don’t care about what anypony else says. I… I want to have this foal. And I want you to be there, Starlight. I want you to be there because I love you.”

“It just feels like this moving a little too fast,” Starlight said, looking away. “I mean, what about Sunburst? I thought he was still investigating the spell?”

“Sunburst left for the Crystal Empire this morning,” Twilight replied. “The girls and I discussed everything with him and we all feel this is for the best. I just assumed that you would… you know…”

“Twilight… it’s not that I don’t want this,” Starlight said. “I do love you. I just… there was an outside factor to this spell that we still don’t know anything about. Wouldn’t you at least like to know what that was?”

Twilight grimaced. “Does it really matter? There’s no reversing this. I know that it’s hard to hear this, but it is happening no matter whether we find out who did it or not.”

Starlight sighed. Something felt off. It wasn’t like Twilight to not want to know something. Perhaps she was overreacting after all. She briefly considered that somehow everything had been taken care of. It felt a little too perfectly aligned. It definitely didn’t feel like anything Discord would have done. But if not him, then who?

Starlight glanced back over at Twilight, who appeared to be giving her the puppy dog eyes, watering with tears. She smiled softly. Figuring out the rest of this could be put off until later, she supposed. Twilight needed her right now.

“Okay,” she said finally. “You’re right. And for the record, I do want this with you. You know that I do.”

Twilight smiled brightly. She leaned in and snuggled her snout along Starlight’s neck. “Thank you, Starlight.”

Starlight chuckled as she snuggled back. Twilight felt warm and soft, almost as if she too had recently showered. She felt her shift beneath her and their eyes met. Starlight searched momentarily, seeing nothing but the other mare’s love for her there. Content, she reached in and planted a kiss on her lips.

“Starlight…” Twilight breathed out. “You know… it’s been… been some time…”

“Do you want to go back to the bedroom?” Starlight asked softly.

Twilight’s eyes lit up mischievously. With a flick of her horn the doors to the throne room closed and locked. She shuffled off the throne and seated herself on the edge of the Cutie Map, spreading her legs and exposing her purple pony pussy to Starlight.

“I was thinking maybe you could just take me right here,” she said with a wink. “I have been sorely missing my Glimmer.”

Starlight grinned, her horn glowing as she cast the spell. Beneath her legs she felt the phallus grow in excitement at seeing her lover’s marehood. She lunged at the table, firmly planting her snout in between Twilight’s legs, extending her tongue to lap up the other mare’s slit. Twilight moaned as she spread wider into Starlight’s ministrations.

Starlight responded by diving in deeper, running her tongue up and down her love’s pussy, feeling the hot wetness all over her snout as she gently pulled in Twilight’s clit and suckled on it. Twilight howled in delight, bucking her hips and nearly bumping Starlight away.

“Sorry!” Twilight squealed. “That just… it feels so good…”

“That’s alright… I’m glad you like it, but I think you’re wet enough for the main course,” Starlight purred. “Unless you want to take a taste first?”

Twilight’s eyes widened. “I don’t usually… but if you want me to.”

“Twilight, I want you to come over here and suck this dick,” Starlight said point blank a she slid onto the map and spread her legs. “Now.”

“Yes, ma’am. I thought I was supposed to be your teacher, not the other way around,” Twilight said with a chuckle. She sat up, positioning herself with her mouth hovering over Starlight’s massive erection.

Without wasting any time, Twilight wrapped her mouth around the head of her lover’s cock, hungrily working her way down the shaft. There was no possible way for her to take the entire length of it, but she strained herself before stopping a few inches short of it. She quickly released her pressure, moving up and down, using her saliva as lubricant. Starlight sighed happily as she felt her mare greedily doing everything she could to ensure she was giving the best blowjob she could possibly ever give.

“Shit… that’s amazing,” Starlight said as she laid back, enjoying every minute of watching Twilight suck her off.

Twilight responded by letting go of the head of the massive phallus with a *pop* before wrapping her lips around it again and going all the way back down. Starlight squealed as she felt the pressure building inside of her.

“Oh… Twilight, stop. You’re gonna make me cum…” she said.

Twilight let the cock slip out of her mouth and smiled. “Guess that means you’re ready to fuck me then, right?”

“Twilight… you’re so cute when you’re that direct,” Starlight said with a grin. “Get up.”

Twilight nodded, letting Starlight up so that she could move behind her. Twilight leaned against the edge of the map as Starlight positioned the head of her swollen cock at the entrance to her waiting marehood.

Twilight squealed with delight as Starlight plunged deep inside her, her inner walls lubricated enough that they offered no resistance. Starlight yelped as well as she felt Twilight’s pussy clenching around her cock, squeezing hard and just egging her on to cum.

“Starlight… cum inside me. Fill me up with your cum. I want it… I need it…” Twilight cried out as Starlight continued to hammer her.

And then the floodgates opened. Starlight howled as she felt Twilight convulse in her own orgasm beneath her while she felt her own coming to a head. Starlight’s mind exploded as she let loose, spilling every little drop of cum into her lover’s pussy. She stayed there for a moment, her cock twitching as she continued to fill up Twilight. After several long moments of grunting and pulsating she pulled out and landed on the edge of the map next to her lover.

Twilight cooed as she turned back to regard her mare parts. Starlight’s cum leaked down the side of her legs and inner thighs. She sighed as she landed next to her marefriend.

“That was… I’ve never cum like that before,” Starlight said, breathing heavily.

“Just think, you can do that every night to me. Don’t have to worry about getting me pregnant either,” Twilight said, leaning into her love for snuggles. “You can have your way with me however you want.”

“Twilight… are you sure you want… well… me?” Starlight asked softly. “You want me to be mother to our foal?”

“I told you once before, I love you heart and soul, Starlight Glimmer,” Twilight said. “There’s nopony else I’d rather be with.”

Starlight sighed contentedly. “Alright. We’ll do it. I can’t believe I’m saying this, but we’re going to be mothers!” she squealed.

As they lay there, they both heard the soft magical *pop* above them. A letter coalesced in the air above before softly falling down to land on them. Twilight's eyes went wide as she saw the emblem attached to the envelope. It was the cutie mark of a heart.

“Oh… oh no,” she said as her magic opened it. “She can’t have known. Sunburst didn’t tell her, did he? I wanted it to be a surprise!”

“What is it?” Starlight asked. “A letter from Cadance?”

“It’s… it says she’s coming to Ponyville with my brother… to plan our foal shower with us!” Twilight said, planting a hoof in her face. “This is… this isn’t good. I didn’t even tell them yet. How did she know?! Wait. It says they’re due to arrive within the hour?! We have to clean up!”

“Twilight, relax. Sunburst probably just let it slip. Remember, calm, collected?” Starlight said. She glanced down and dispelled the magic between her legs. “Besides, we have plenty of time to clean up before they get here. Just relax. It’ll be alright.”

“You’re… you’re right,” Twilight said, her horn glowing as she washed away the evidence of their sweaty activity from the edge of the Cutie Map. “We should probably take showers… again. See you in a half hour?”

“Twilight, we can shower together, silly,” Starlight teased. “But go on ahead. I’ll be right there.”

Twilight nodded before disappearing in a flash of light. Starlight grinned and picked up the letter. She glanced at the words in it and grimaced. It did seem slightly odd that Cadance had known about the pregnancy. Sunburst didn’t seem like the type to gossip about such a thing.

Starlight’s eyes widened. Wait… fertility… love magic. No. No. That’s not possible! She thought.

There was no denying the evidence and where it all pointed. The outside factor wasn’t Discord, or some aspect of the spell they’d overlooked.

The outside factor was Cadance.