Starlight Glimmer's Predicament

Starlight Glimmer's Predicament

Chapter Three: A Great and Powerful Revelation

Starlight groaned as she awoke next to the sleeping Sunburst. She sighed profoundly as she started to remember the events of the night before. Her loins still ached from the sex, and yet, she didn't feel any better. It only served to remind her of what was to come next.

She sat up and shuffled out of bed and headed towards the bathroom, where she flicked on the shower and stepped inside. As she bathed, her thoughts turned to Twilight and the others. What if they were genuinely pregnant? What was she going to do? After all she'd been through with them, could she be there for them? She didn't know.

Starlight sighed and finished her shower, stepping out of the stall wet and feeling very hot. She stepped up in front of the mirror to brush her mane when she gasped in surprise at two discolored eyeballs staring right back at her.

“Discord!” she shouted. “What are you doing spying on me in the shower?!”

The eyeballs coalesced into the face of the spirit of Chaos and Disharmony, Discord himself. A bemused grin sat upon his face.

“My dear Starlight Glimmer, I was merely popping in to say hello and to ask if you have seen my dear friend Fluttershy around, I cannot seem to locate her anywhere,” he said. “I assure you I was not spying.”

Starlight scowled. “You know darn well where Fluttershy is, so drop the act. What do you want?”

“Fine, you're right. Fluttershy is currently feeding her animals at home like she always does,” Discord said with a sigh. “Is it so hard to believe that I wanted to talk to one of my newest friends?”

Starlight rolled her eyes with a huff as she lifted her brush in the air with her magic. “That's fine, but maybe not when I'm in the shower? You scared the hell out of me.”

“Oh. Oh you thought that I... Oh that is too rich,” Discord said with a chortle as realization dawned on his face. “My dear Starlight, I assure you that I have no interest in you or your body. As Applejack would put it...” his face suddenly transformed into a perfect mimicry of the orange mare. “Mah barn door don't swing that way.”

“Well then what did you want to talk about?” Starlight asked in response.

“Well,” Discord replied, his face returning to normal. “Something's been bothering Fluttershy lately, and I wanted to know if you knew what that was. You are good friends with her as well, surely you've noticed.”

Starlight froze. She couldn't be responsible for telling Discord about what had happened. That would be a betrayal of her friendship with Fluttershy. She sighed deeply.

“Discord, have you maybe tried asking Fluttershy about what's bothering her?” she said.

Discord's eyes lit up, transforming into glimmering light bulbs. “You know, I haven't! That's a great idea, I'll go do that now. You really do have the hang of this friendship thing, Starlight Glimmer.”

A flash of light erupted in the bathroom before Starlight could reply, and the spirit of Chaos was gone from the mirror. Starlight sighed and headed back towards the bedroom where Sunburst had sat up in bed.

“Is everything alright? I thought I heard shouting,” he said groggily.

“It's fine. Just a little visit from our friendly neighborhood Discord,” Starlight said. “How did you sleep?”

“Pretty well, you?” Sunburst asked.

“Well enough,” Starlight replied. “So... what's on the docket for today?”

“Well, today I thought we'd get your friends together and run some tests. See if we can match up the ah... data I collected yesterday with some of their physiological effects and go from there,” Sunburst said.

“I guess then we'd better get downstairs and discuss that with Twilight, eh?” Starlight said nervously.

* * *

Several hours later

* * *

Starlight paced around behind Sunburst and Twilight. The others were on their way to the castle, where Sunburst would finally lay to rest whether or not the spell had indeed impregnated them all. Starlight was nervous, unsure of what to feel. She stopped when Twilight rested her hoof on her shoulder.

“Starlight? Are you alright?” she asked.

“No, I'm not. Not really,” Starlight whispered. “What if it is true? What if I've just ruined everypony's lives with this? Rainbow's a Wonderbolt, you're the Princess, Rarity's got her shops... I just took that all away from you.”

“Starlight...” Twilight said with a sigh. “It's going to be alright. Whatever happens, the girls will understand and if it is true, we all know that you will do your best to be there for each of us. We're a family, and that's all that matters, right?”

Starlight grimaced, but nodded all the same.

“Then just be calm. They're just as scared and nervous as you are. Hell, I'm scared too,” Twilight continued. “But I can't allow my nerves to get to me. We have to approach this in a calm, logical fashion.”

Starlight nodded and sat down next to Twilight until the others arrived. When they did, they were as normal and friendly towards her as they were any other day. None of them seemed to indicate that they were angry in any way. This helped drive down her anxiety a lot.

Sunburst had gathered each of them so that he could individually assess each mare's physiological aftereffects. He brought each mare inside one of the large spare changing rooms and performed his operations, comparing the data to the information he had collected on the spell the day prior. When he had finished, he sent each mare back to the throne room to wait.

Starlight sat in calm anxiety as the last of her friends, Twilight, returned from the changing room. Sunburst walked in behind her, his brow furrowed as he toted along a large binder of papers.

“Alright, I've finished compiling all the data I've collected, and I've come to a conclusion,” he said as he set the papers down on the table containing the map.

“And...? Spit it out darling, we're all wondering,” Rarity said.

Sunburst adjusted his glasses and sighed. “There's no easy way to say this, but you all display all the classic physiological signs of being pregnant. I'm not sure there's any other explanation here, but it appears as if you are all indeed pregnant.”

There was a set of collective gasps and chatter. Sunburst waved his hoof, indicating that he had more to say, quieting down the seven mares.

“There's more. Based on my research of the spell used by Starlight. It's inconclusive as to whether or not the spell actually caused the pregnancies to occur,” he said. “Quite frankly, there doesn't seem to be anything within the spell's composition that replicates fertility.”

“That means that there had to be some other factor that caused this,” Twilight said.

“You mean, somepony else did this?” Rainbow Dash asked, pointing at her belly.

“For lack of a better word... yes,” Sunburst replied. “It's going to take me some more time to isolate the factor that caused it, unfortunately. This is very strong and powerful magic we're dealing with here. In the mean time, I think perhaps you had better start worrying about your physiological health...”

Starlight shrank behind the others as Sunburst talked. She couldn't believe what he was saying. The others were really pregnant? Part of her inside had hoped that this was just one of Rainbow Dash's pranks, or that Sunburst was somehow wrong in his assertion. She didn't know what to do.

“Starlight? Are you alright there, Sugarcube?” Applejack said suddenly from beside her.

Starlight yelped loudly, startling the orange mare and drawing the attention of the others. Before she could even think about what she was doing, she was hurtling out of the throne room and out of the castle. The others stood, eyes wide, and watched as she ran.

“Was it something I said?” Applejack asked.

“I don't think so,” Twilight said. “I'll go find her and talk to her. I suspect that Starlight is feeling a little shocked at this news, moreso than any of us is. Sunburst, you're more than welcome to stay for a few more days and try and isolate this component. I have my own theories, but personally I'd like to know who is responsible for this.”

“Of course, Princess. I'll have Spike send a message to Princess Cadance letting her know of the extend in my stay,” Sunburst replied.

“Excellent, now then... I'll leave you girls to the rest of your day while I go hunt down our friend.”

* * *

Twilight trotted through the town, smiling at the townsponies as she went. She had stopped a few times, inquiring as to whether anypony had seen Starlight Glimmer. Most of them had seen her heading towards the outskirts of town. Twilight knew exactly where she was headed.

Trixie's cart came into view shortly thereafter, but nopony was in sight around it. Twilight stepped up to the side of the cart and knocked with her hoof. After a few seconds, a familiar blue mare popped her head out of the window.

“What do you want, Princess Twilight?” Trixie said.

“Hello, Trixie. I was wondering if you'd seen Starlight around. She was heading this way according to the ponies in town,” Twilight asked.

“No... I haven't seen her, sorry,” Trixie said. “The Great and Powerful Trixie would know if she had seen her best friend.”

Twilight sighed. “Alright then... well, if you see her could you please let me know? It's really important that I speak with her. She's... she's not feeling well, and I would like to do what I can to help her.”

“The Great and Powerful Trixie will consider your request,” Trixie replied casually. “Now if you are finished, the Great and Powerful Trixie must prepare for her show this evening.”

Twilight nodded and trotted away, leaving Trixie by herself. The blue mare turned to her side and sighed.

“You can release the spell now, Starlight. I know you're here,” she said.

Starlight Glimmer breathed a sigh of relief, and let the invisibility spell fade away. She smiled meekly at Trixie.

“Thanks... I really appreciate it,” she said.

“I wouldn't have done it if we weren't such great friends,” Trixie replied. “Besides... I could tell that you weren't interested in speaking to Purple Smart. Something happen between you two?”

Starlight fidgeted and nodded. “I don't really want to talk about it right now. Could we maybe just hang out? I can't quite go back to the castle yet.”

Trixie rolled her eyes and nodded. She pushed open the door to the cart and started locking it up.

“What would you like to do? Trixie doesn't really have a show to do tonight, it was canceled due to friendship emergency,” she said with a wink.

“Won't ponies get mad at you for canceling on such short notice?” Starlight asked, cocking her head in confusion.

“Not particularly. Attendance is way down, anyways. You're more important,” Trixie replied. “Now, where to?”

Starlight grimaced. “I don't know... somewhere Twilight won't think to look for me?”

Trixie's eyes lit up. “I have just the place.”

* * *

“You've got to be kidding me.”

“I know, right? It's great.”

Starlight glanced up at the neon sign and shook her head in disbelief. Since when did Ponyville even have this kind of club? Ponies around the area were always so straight-laced. Granted, the place was deep back in an alley, but wouldn't somepony notice it was here during the day?

“Are you sure about this?” Starlight asked.

“Are you doubting the Great and Powerful Trixie? Twilight will never look for you here. Besides, you look like you needed a drink and to blow some steam off. Here you can do both,” Trixie replied. “Come on, I come here all the time when I'm not performing.”

“Wait, you do? I didn't think you were...”

“I'm not. You'll see,” Trixie said with a wink.

Starlight grimaced as she followed behind Trixie into the club's main entrance. The music thumped loudly the moment they stepped inside. Starlight realized that she couldn't hear it from the outside, likely the result of a sound dampening charm. She followed her friend down a dark hallway that opened up into a large dance floor. At the far end sat a bar where ponies mingled. At the other, a set of stages where both a mare and a stallion danced, their bodies on full display.

Starlight blinked. She hadn't quite realized that even though most ponies walked around completely naked without issue, they weren't always as out there as the two on the stage were. In fact, they seemed to be flaunting every inch of their bodies. Above the stage, a familiar white unicorn with a blazing electric blue mane sat in the DJ booth, her head bobbing along with the music that thumped from the speakers.

“Come on, let's get you something to cool your head,” Trixie shouted, motioning for Starlight to follow.

Starlight nodded and walked closely behind Trixie, moving through the crowd watching the dancers on stage towards the bar. Trixie ordered for both of them, and soon two glasses of fruit colored liquid ended up in front of them.

Starlight inserted her straw and took a drink. The liquid seared as it went down her throat, making her head feel very fuzzy. Still, the taste was good. She could separate out that it had some sort of cherries in it. She happily went back in for more as she and Trixie relaxed at the bar.

“Whoah, slow down there, Starlight. You don't want to ruin your night and get sick,” Trixie said.

Starlight chuckled as she lifted her head from the glass. “Sorry, I just... thank you, Trixie. Really. I really appreciate you doing this for me.”

“No worries. Besides, I figured you would enjoy the show here too,” Trixie said as she motioned towards the stage.

Starlight's eyes drifted up. The mare and the stallion were now on the same stage together, dancing closely to each other. Her eyes widened as the mare hoisted her rump into the air, allowing the stallion maximum angle for penetration. In full view of the crowd, he mounted her, thrusting his cock in and out to the rhythm of the music. The mare screamed in pure delight. As Starlight tried to pull herself away from the spectacle, she noticed that many of the club goers weren't even paying attention, instead they too were engaged in some form of intimate activity, be it passionate kissing or in some cases, oral sex.

“I... Wow...” Starlight started to say. Her loins lit up like fire and she blushed hard.

“Yeah, see. Told you. This is a great place to come hang out, drink a little, and blow off a lot more than just steam,” Trixie said with a grin.

“I can see that,” Starlight replied. She glanced down, realizing her drink was gone and that another completely full glass sat in its place.

“Keep them coming,” Trixie said to the bartender. “Also, have you seen Caramel? He's usually here by now.”

“Think I saw him upstairs in the private rooms. You're more than welcome to go up and find out, Miss Trixie,” the bartender said, winking. “I'll send your drinks up there.”

“Thanks!” Trixie said. She grabbed a hold of Starlight. “Come on. I want you to meet somepony.”

Starlight nodded and followed behind Trixie as the two made their way towards the back stairs. As they made their way to the second floor, Starlight noted that the sound dampening enchantment, likely the work of DJ-PON3, prevented the sound from reaching from below.

Instead, a new set of sounds greeted Starlight's ears. Sounds she was all too familiar with. The sounds of mares crowing and stallions grunting. She could smell the sex in the air. This place got more and more interesting with each moment that passed.

“So... how does Ponyville even have someplace like this?” she whispered to Trixie as they made their way down the hall.

“I dunno. It's been here for a while though. No idea who owns the place,” Trixie replied. “Ah here we are.”

Trixie stopped and pulled open one of the half-open doorways, revealing a well-lit bedroom. On the bed inside was an earth pony stallion that Starlight felt like she knew, as if she'd seen him around town before. Below him was a mare, and they were deep in the throes of passionate lovemaking. The stallion grunted, pulling out of the mare's pussy, his impressive member even startling Starlight as he circled about and thrust it into the mare's mouth. He grunted even louder as he came, depositing cum all over the mare's face.

The stallion slumped back onto the bed, his eyes flittering up as he noticed them. The mare lay there, quietly licking and cleaning his stallionhood with her tongue.

“Oh, hey Trixie. Been a while,” he said. “And who do you have here? Starlight Glimmer, is that you?”

“How...?” Starlight asked.

“I work at Sweet Apple Acres,” the stallion said. “Name's Caramel.”

“Oh... right, that's how I know you,” Starlight said. “I've seen you at AJ's.”

“That's right. Trix, what's up? What are you here for? You haven't been here in a while,” Caramel replied. He glanced down at the mare below him and reached down caressing her mane. “That's good, sweetie. Why don't you go back downstairs and show off?”

The mare nodded eagerly as she got off the bed. As she passed by Starlight and Trixie, Starlight could still see the streaks of cum on the mare's snout. She had made zero attempt to even clean up. Soon she was gone and it was just the three of them.

“Figured it would be a good idea to hang out, maybe have a little fun,” Trixie said with a wink. “Starlight here could use a good lay. She's down in the dumps.”

“Trixie!” Starlight shouted.

“What? Am I wrong? Do you doubt the wisdom of the Great and Powerful Trixie?” Trixie replied. “I just kind of figured you spend all the time playing the stallion, that maybe you'd like to be the mare for once, and only the mare.”

Starlight stopped and scowled. She thought to her encounter with Sunburst, and of the trouble that had gotten her to this point. She looked down at her hooves and nodded. “I guess you are right about that.”

“And you came to see little old me? Could have been anypony, Trix,” Caramel interjected.

“I... I figured Starlight would be more comfortable with somepony she knows,” Trixie replied.

“That's fair. Why don't you two come over and join me? Get a little more acquainted,” Caramel said.

Starlight sighed, but nodded. In truth, she did need something like this to get her mind off of what had happened. She sauntered over to the bed next to Trixie, who immediately dove in and started kissing Caramel fiercely. Starlight could see that the stallion was greatly enjoying the attention already, as his cock began to stiffen up.

Starlight grinned and grabbed a hold of Caramel's stallionhood with her hooves, caressing it up and down. It almost nearly put her own magically created one to shame. Almost. She reached up and craned her neck, extending her tongue out to lick the stallion's dick from base to tip. She smiled as she felt him shudder a little.

She glanced up, noting that Trixie had at some point removed her robe and hat, and was straddling Caramel's face, grinding her wet pussy into his snout. She huffed and puffed loudly as she rode him.

Starlight returned her attention to Caramel's member, since it seemed that Trixie had him a little occupied up top. Wrapping her lips around the tip, she pulled the giant cock into her mouth and inched downwards, taking more and more of it in as she went. With a grunt she reached the base of the stallionhood. She breathed through her nose as she felt the cock writhe and pulse inside of her mouth. After a few brief seconds she pulled up, letting it slide out stiff as a rock. She continued this for several more minutes as she felt Caramel starting to tense up.

Caramel grunted through Trixie's sopping pussy as he came, cum spurting forth from his cock. Starlight felt it coating the walls of her mouth, sticky and hot and salty. She felt so full of it that she felt some of it trickle up and out of her nose. She pulled away as the rest of the cum slid down her throat. She swallowed deeply and went back down, licking as much of the substance as she could off of Caramel's dick.

Trixie began moaning as Caramel's orgasm intensified his own ministrations. He licked harder and faster, bringing Trixie's orgasm to a head as she began to buck over the stallion's face. With earth-shattering force, she came, expelling her own brand of hot sticky juice from her pussy. Caramel eagerly accepted the load with a smile.

“Wow... I remember that,” Caramel said as Trixie shuffled off onto the bed next to him. “You two are really good, I have to admit.”

“Trixie is glad to oblige,” Trixie said. “But I think it's time for the main course. Starlight, get up here.”

Starlight nodded, still feeling the cum trickling down to her stomach. Caramel grinned and pushed up onto all fours while he waited for her to get into position. With one swift motion, he mounted on her rump and inserted his cock.

Starlight gasped at the feeling of being full of stallion cock. This was remarkably different than what she had done with her friends. This felt... real. She groaned as Caramel pounded her hard, her pussy wet and accepting of every thrust. Meanwhile, she found her face full of the image of Trixie, who lay there panting as she watched.

“Trixie.... c'mere,” Starlight said between grunts. “Can't... can't leave you out of the fun.”

Trixie glanced at her skeptically. “Starlight... I don't...”

“Oh it's not like that, now come on. I can only take so much,” Starlight replied.

Trixie sighed and nodded, shuffling herself so that Starlight had full access to her nether regions. She gasped softly as Starlight's horn glowed, making a magic ball that coalesced into a phallic shaped object. With a quick flick of her horn, the object lowered and began inserting itself into her. Trixie grunted as the magical phallus tore into her gaping pussy.

Starlight grunted, her pussy being pounded by the second by Caramel's thick cock, and reached out with her mouth, using her tongue to flick on Trixie's clit while the magic spell did it's work. Trixie too began to groan and writhe.

“I'm gonna cum again soon,” Caramel said with a huff.

Starlight nodded and continued tongue-fucking her best friend while toying her into oblivion with a magical dildo. She felt Caramel speed up, her pussy unable to stand the pressure. Finally, that pressure broke and her own orgasm peaked. Caramel slid out and made his way around to both of them, where his cock burst, spreading his cum everywhere. With a massive grunt, Trixie came at the same time, gushing hot mare juice into Starlight's face and mouth. It mixed with Caramel's cum, creating a salty hot bath of mare and stallion that made Starlight eager for more.

Starlight slumped to the side and grinned. “Okay, you were right, I did need that. I feel a lot better now.”

“Told you,” Trixie said. “And so do I... Caramel you haven't changed a bit.”

“Glad I could be of some service, but the night's still young. What do you say we get some drinks and take a breather. I mean, since I haven't seen you in a while and all, it'd be nice to get some action on you too, Trix,” Caramel said.

Trixie glanced over at Starlight who smiled through the cum staining her face. She shrugged and nodded.

“Sure, I'm up for more.”

“Alright, you got a deal, Caramel.”

* * *

“I look like I dove into the frosting aisle of one of Pinkie Pie's cakes,” Starlight said drunkenly as she and Trixie walked back towards her cart. “Except you know... if the cake was made of semen.”

“You're drunk,” Trixie said with a grin. “Come on let's get you back to the cart. You can rest if off there and then go back to the castle tomorrow.”

Starlight stopped cold. “I don't want to go back, Trix. I... I'm not sure what's gonna happen when I do.”

“Look, I know you didn't want to talk about it, but I feel like we need to. Why were you running from Twilight?” Trixie asked.

“I... I don't...” Starlight said.

“No, Starlight. I tried my best to help you get things off your mind, but you're talking about not going back at all? Abandoning your friends?” Trixie said angrily. “What is it, Starlight? What's wrong? I can't try to even begin to help you if you won't talk to me.”

“It's real, alright!” Starlight shouted. “It's real. All of it. The pregnancies are all real. Sunburst confirmed it. I just... I don't even know... I ruined their lives! I'm taking away their futures from them! What kind of friend does that?!”

Trixie stopped and sighed. “And he's sure? I mean, come on, it was just a magical cock spell. There's no way that it could produce fertility. Even I know that about magic.”

“It wasn't the spell...” Starlight said.

“What?” Trixie said, her eyes widening. “What do you mean?”

“Sunburst said there was no way the spell could have caused this to happen. There was some sort of... of outside factor. Something he's staying an extra couple days to research,” Starlight replied. “Even so... this is my fault, Trixie. I'm the one who chose to have sex with my friends. I'm the one who decided it would be fun. Now because of me, Dash will have to leave the Wonderbolts, Rarity will have to take a break from her fashion career, and Twilight... Twilight will be a laughingstock!”

“Did you... did you just say that there was... was an outside factor?” Trixie said, her eyes still wide.

Starlight glanced at Trixie. “I... I did... why? What does that have to do with anything?”

Trixie suddenly turned on a dime and started walking away from Starlight. “I have to go,” she yelled. “You can stay in the cart overnight, the key's under the mat. I'll see you soon.”

“What...? Where are you going?” Starlight called after her.

“Just... just trust me! I have to do something!” Trixie shouted.

Starlight watched as her best friend in the whole world disappeared into the gloom of the night. With a heavy sigh she hung her head low and started onwards towards Trixie's cart.