Thunderstruck awoke with a terrible headache. He rubbed his head as he slowly opened his eyes.

“Thunderstruck, are you alright?” Sunset asked.

“Yeah, but I had the strangest dream.” Thunderstruck replied. “You and Twilight both grew pony ears and tails, and then you grew wings and began to-” Thunderstruck stopped when he fully opened his eyes, seeing that Sunset and Twilight were still in their magical states.

Thunderstruck raised an eyebrow. “I’m not dreaming, am I?”

Twilight bit her lower lip. “Uhh, no.”

“So, then everything you just told me is real?”

Sunset nodded her head. “Yes.”

Thunderstruck raised himself to a seated position. “I...I need a moment to think.”

Twilight and Sunset returned to their normal forms. “I’ll go get the rest of the girls, then we can figure out what to do together.” Sunset said.

Once everyone had gathered in the music room, they began discussing the situation. “Okay, here’s what we know.” Twilight said. “The sirens have used Thunderstruck to convince principal Celestia to put on a rock concert.”

“But we destroyed their amulets.” Said Rainbow. “They’re just normal teenage girls now. They can’t sing, and have no way to use mind control.”

Applejack thought the situation over. “Maybe the concert is just a cover for somethin’ else?”

Meanwhile, Thunderstruck sat away from the group lost in his own thoughts. Fluttershy noticed this and went over to him. “Is everything alright?” She asked.

Thunderstruck let out a sigh. “I’m still trying to take all of this in. Yesterday I was just a high school guy with a crush. Now I found out that magic is real, the girl I have a crush on is from another dimension, she and her friends once tried to take over the school, and now they might be trying to do it again and I’m stuck right in center of it all.”

“That...that is a lot to take in.” Fluttershy said softly.

“But the thing is, I still like her.” Thunderstruck continued. “She just makes me feel so great. My whole world gets better everytime I’m around her.”

“Have you told her that?” Fluttershy asked.

“No. And I refuse to believe that Sonata is some evil being. I’m going to find her and tell her how I feel.” With that Thunderstruck got up and marched out of the music room.

“Where is he going?” Rainbow asked.

“Um, Thunderstruck said that he was going to confess his feelings to Sonata and prove that she is no longer evil.” Fluttershy replied in a slightly hushed tone.

Sunset face-palmed herself. “This can’t turn out well.”

School had just let out, and all of the students were gathered out front. Some were heading home, while others were just hanging out. Adagio, Aria, and Sonata all stood in front of the school’s statue.

“Alright girls, the plan is in motion.” Adagio said with a confident smirk. “While everyone is distracted by the concert, we sneak into Principal Celestia’s office, get the key, go the library, get the book, and regain our powers. This entire city will be ours.”

“Good, because I’m sick of living as a teenage girl.” Said Aria. She then looked over at Sonata and noticed that she looked depressed. “Why are you so sad? We’re going to be all powerful again.”

Sonata looked over at her fellow Sirens. “I was just thinking...about Thunderstruck.”

“What about him?” Adagio asked. “He did his job. We don’t need him anymore.”

“But he is so nice. Don’t you think it’s wrong to just use him like that.” Said Sonata.

Adagio and Aria both had looks of shock on their faces. Adagio stepped in front of Sonata. “Sonata, do you actually like-” Before Adagio could finish, Thunderstruck ran up to the three.

“Sonata, there is something I need to tell you.” Thunderstruck said.

“What is it?” Sonata asked.

“Sonata, I like you. I mean I really like you. I think this can explain it better.” Thunderstruck then got his guitar and began to perform.

Sonata didn’t know what to say. “Thunderstruck, do you mean it?”

Thunderstruck set down his guitar. “Yes Sonata. I-” Thunderstruck then found himself interrupted by Aria, who grabbed Sonata by the arm and dragged her away.

“We’re leaving. NOW!”

Sonata tried to resist. “But...wait!”

Adagio got in the face of Thunderstruck, poking him in the chest. “Listen here new guy. Stay away from Sonata. I will make bad things happen if you go near her, got it?” Adagio and Aria then walked off with Sonata. She turned her head to look at Thunderstruck, a tear rolling down her cheek.

Thunderstruck fell down to his knees. He felt defeated and alone. Suddenly, Thunderstruck felt a hand on his shoulder. He looked up to see Twilight and the rest of the Rainbooms.

“You really do love her, don’t you?” Twilight asked.

“Yes, I do.” Thunderstruck replied. “I know that you say Sonata is monster from another dimension, but I don’t see that. All I see is the most beautiful girl in the world.”

Pinkie Pie then stepped forward. “Then I say that we need to get you two lovebirds together!”

“But how?” Thunderstruck asked. “Adagio and Aria won’t let me near Sonata.”

“Thunderstruck, we all know what it’s like to be in love.” Sunset said as she sat next to him. “Perhaps with your help, Sonata can even be redeemed.”

“I agree.” Said Twilight. “Come on girls, we’ve got work to do!”

That evening Thunderstruck, along with Rainbow Dash, Applejack, and Twilight waited in the Siren’s backyard while Sunset, Pinkie Pie, Fluttershy, and Rarity approached their front door and rang the bell.

Adagio and Aria both answered. “What do you all want?” Adagio asked, clearly annoyed to see them.

“Oh, we were just in the neighborhood. Carrying an extra pair of these.” Rarity then showed Adagio and Aria a pair of tickets to that nights Feather Bangs concert.

Aria’s eyes went wide and she dashed forward to get a closer look at the tickets. “How did you get those? That concert has been sold out for weeks!”

“Our friend Vinyl Scratch knows a guy.” Sunset said.

“We’re heading out for the concert, and were wondering if you two could join us?” Fluttershy asked.

“What’s the catch?” Adagio asked with a skeptical look.

“There’s no catch. We just want to make amends and welcome you back to the school!” Said Pinkie.

Aria pleaded with Adagio. “Can we go? Please, please,please?”

“Fine. I guess it wouldn’t hurt.” Adagio grabbed the tickets.

“By the way, where’s Sonata?” Sunset asked.

“Lets just say she's grounded.” Said Aria. The six girls then headed out. Applejack watched from a distance to make sure that they were gone.

“Okay, the coast is clear.”

Thunderstruck stepped out of hiding along with Twilight and Rainbow. “Are you sure this will work?” Thunderstruck asked.

“Trust me.” Rainbow said with a smug smile. “Just walk up to her bedroom window and confess your love. It’s guaranteed to work. I read it in a book by Shakespeare.”

Applejack looked at Rainbow with a raised eyebrow. “Rainbow, did you even finish Romeo and Juliet?”

“Not quite. They live happily ever after, don’t they?”

Applejack facepalmed herself and let out a sigh of frustration.

“Don’t worry, just be yourself.” Twilight said reassuringly. “All you have to do is speak from the heart.”

Thunderstruck took a deep breath. He walked up to Sonata’s bedroom window and threw a pebble. Sonata opened the window and stuck out her head.

“Thunderstruck, what are you doing here? If Adagio and Aria see you-”

“They won’t. My friends have made sure that they’ll be gone for a while. Sonata Dusk, I love you. And I want to express it the best way I know how.” Thunderstruck was then handed his guitar by Twilight, and he began to sing.

Sonata looked at Thunderstruck with a smile. Tears of joy were building up in her eyes. Sonata went back into her room and returned with a rope ladder. “Come on up!” she said as the ladder was let down.

Thunderstruck climbed up the ladder into Sonata’s room. He then held her hands and looked into her eyes. “Sonata, I know that you’re a siren from another dimension and that you and your friends tried to take over the school.”

“And...you still love me?” Sonata asked with some confusion.

“I love you for who you are. I don’t care what anybody else sees. And I don’t care about what you did. All I care about is you.”

“Thunderstruck, I don’t know what else to say. I love you too! In fact.”

Thunderstruck and Sonata then kissed each other passionately.

Author's Note

This was a real pain to upload, but I finally got it up.